Equations $F(x,y,y')=0$ that are not solved for $y'$: general and singular solutions, envelopes, the $p$- and $c$-discriminants and the loci they hide, Clairaut's and Lagrange's equations, and orthogonal trajectories.
So far the equation has been handed to us in the form $y'=f(x,y)$. Many equations of geometry and mechanics arrive instead as a relation $F(x,y,y')=0$ that is quadratic, cubic or worse in the slope: "the tangent line cuts off intercepts with constant sum", "the normal has constant length", $(y')^2+y^2=1$. Such an equation prescribes several slopes at each point, and a new phenomenon appears. The circles of radius $1$ centred on the $x$-axis are integral curves of $y^2(1+y'^2)=1$; so are the two lines $y=\pm1$, which touch every one of those circles. Along these lines uniqueness fails — through each of their points two solutions pass with the same slope — and the lines cannot be obtained from the family of circles by choosing the constant. They are singular solutions, and they are envelopes of the family.
This section explains where singular solutions come from and how to find them: they lie where the slope equation has a repeated root (the $p$-discriminant) and where neighbouring members of the family meet (the $c$-discriminant) — but these two loci also contain curves that are not solutions: tac-loci, node-loci and cusp-loci. Clairaut's equation $y=px+f(p)$ is the cleanest example, with straight lines as general solution and their envelope as singular solution; Lagrange's equation generalises it. We end with orthogonal trajectories. CSIR NET asks for singular solutions of Clairaut-type equations, for discriminant loci of a given family, and for orthogonal trajectories, often with options designed around the extraneous loci. Throughout, $p$ denotes $y'=\dfrac{dy}{dx}$.
Equations Not Solved for the Derivative
📘 Definition 1.6 — General, particular and singular solutions
Consider $F(x,y,p)=0$ with $p=y'$, where $F$ is $C^1$; when $F$ is a polynomial of degree $n$ in $p$ we speak of an equation of the first order and degree $n$.
A general solution (complete primitive) is a one-parameter family of curves $\varphi(x,y,c)=0$, each of which is an integral curve, such that (in the region considered) the family supplies integral curves through each point with each of the admissible slopes.
A particular solution is a member of that family, obtained by fixing $c$.
A singular solution is an integral curve that is not a member of the family for any value of $c$, and along which uniqueness fails: at each of its points another integral curve passes with the same slope.
The general solution of an equation of degree $n$ usually splits as a product of $n$ factors, one for each slope branch, or is one equation of degree $n$ in $c$.
🧭 Problem-solving strategy — three ways to solve $F(x,y,p)=0$
Solvable for $p$. Factor $F=(p-f_1(x,y))\cdots(p-f_n(x,y))$; solve each $y'=f_i(x,y)$ as in §1.1, obtaining $\varphi_i(x,y,c)=0$; the general solution is $\varphi_1\varphi_2\cdots\varphi_n=0$ with the same letter $c$ in each factor.
Solvable for $y$: $y=g(x,p)$. Differentiate with respect to $x$: $p=g_x+g_p\,\dfrac{dp}{dx}$, a first-order equation in $x$ and $p$. Solve it as $\Psi(x,p,c)=0$, then eliminate $p$ between $\Psi=0$ and $y=g(x,p)$ — or keep $p$ as a parameter.
Solvable for $x$: $x=h(y,p)$. Differentiate with respect to $y$, using $\dfrac{dx}{dy}=\dfrac1p$: $\dfrac1p=h_y+h_p\,\dfrac{dp}{dy}$; solve for $p$ in terms of $y$ and eliminate.
Watch the factors you divide by. In methods 2 and 3 a factor such as $(1-2x^3p)$ often cancels: setting it equal to zero gives the candidates for singular solutions — check them in the equation.
✏️ Example 1 — Solvable for $p$, and a locus that is not a solution
Solve $p^2-(x+y)p+xy=0$. Show that the line $y=x$ is the locus of points where the two slopes coincide, and decide whether it is a solution.
💡 Show solution▶
Factor $p^2-(x+y)p+xy=(p-x)(p-y)$. So $y'=x$, giving $y=\tfrac{x^2}2+c$, or $y'=y$, giving $y=ce^x$. General solution: $$\left(y-\tfrac{x^2}{2}-c\right)\left(y-ce^x\right)=0.$$
Equal slopes The two roots $p=x$ and $p=y$ coincide exactly on $y=x$; equivalently the discriminant in $p$ is $(x+y)^2-4xy=(x-y)^2$.
Not a solution On $y=x$ we have $p=1$, and $F=1-2x+x^2=(x-1)^2$, which is not identically $0$. So $y=x$ is not an integral curve (it is one only at the single point $(1,1)$).
What it is Through $(t,t)$ pass $y=\tfrac{x^2}2+t-\tfrac{t^2}2$ (slope $t$) and $y=te^{x-t}$ (slope $t$): two different members touch there. Such a locus of contact points of non-neighbouring members is a tac-locus; note that it appears squared in the discriminant.
✏️ Example 2 — Solvable for $y$
Solve $y+px=x^4p^2$ ($x\ne0$) and find any singular solution.
💡 Show solution▶
Differentiate $y=x^4p^2-px$, so $p=4x^3p^2+2x^4p\,p'-p-xp'$, i.e. $2p+xp'=2x^3p\,(2p+xp')$: $$(2p+xp')(1-2x^3p)=0.$$
General solution $2p+xp'=0$ gives $(x^2p)'=0$, $p=\dfrac{c}{x^2}$. Then $y=x^4\dfrac{c^2}{x^4}-\dfrac cx$: $$y=c^2-\frac cx,\quad\text{i.e.}\quad xy=c^2x-c.$$
The other factor $1-2x^3p=0$ gives $p=\dfrac1{2x^3}$ and $y=\dfrac{x^4}{4x^6}-\dfrac{1}{2x^2}=-\dfrac{1}{4x^2}$. Check: for $y=-\tfrac1{4x^2}$, $p=\tfrac1{2x^3}$ and $y+px=\tfrac1{4x^2}=x^4p^2$. It is a solution, not of the form $c^2-c/x$: the singular solution $4x^2y+1=0$.
Cross-check As a quadratic in $c$, $xc^2-c-xy=0$ has discriminant $1+4x^2y$; it vanishes exactly on the singular solution — the members with "double" values of $c$ are where neighbouring curves meet. This is the $c$-discriminant of the next subsection.
Envelopes and the $c$-Discriminant
📘 Definition 1.7 — Envelope of a one-parameter family
Let $\{C_c\}$ be the curves $\varphi(x,y,c)=0$, with $\varphi$ of class $C^1$. A curve $\Gamma$, parametrised as $c\mapsto(x(c),y(c))$ with $(x'(c),y'(c))\ne(0,0)$, is an envelope of the family if for each $c$ the point $(x(c),y(c))$ lies on $C_c$ and $\Gamma$ and $C_c$ have the same tangent line there. In words: $\Gamma$ touches every member, each at its own point.
📘 Definition 1.8 — The $c$- and $p$-discriminants
The $c$-discriminant of the family $\varphi(x,y,c)=0$ is the relation between $x$ and $y$ obtained by eliminating $c$ from $$\varphi(x,y,c)=0,\qquad\frac{\partial\varphi}{\partial c}(x,y,c)=0;$$ its graph is the $c$-discriminant locus. For a polynomial in $c$ it is the ordinary discriminant.
The $p$-discriminant of the equation $F(x,y,p)=0$ is obtained by eliminating $p$ from $F=0$, $\dfrac{\partial F}{\partial p}=0$: the points where two of the slopes $p$ coalesce.
📐 Theorem 1.11 — Envelopes and singular points lie on the $c$-discriminant locus
Let $\varphi$ be $C^1$. (a) If $\Gamma:(x(c),y(c))$ is an envelope of $\varphi(x,y,c)=0$ and the point of contact is a regular point of $C_c$ (that is, $(\varphi_x,\varphi_y)\ne(0,0)$ there), then $\varphi_c(x(c),y(c),c)=0$. (b) If $(x(c),y(c))$ is a singular point of $C_c$ for each $c$ (a node or cusp: $\varphi=\varphi_x=\varphi_y=0$) and depends differentiably on $c$, then also $\varphi_c=0$ along it. Hence both envelopes and loci of singular points (node-loci and cusp-loci) satisfy the $c$-discriminant relation.
Proof. In both cases $\varphi(x(c),y(c),c)=0$ for all $c$. Differentiating with respect to $c$ by the chain rule: $$\varphi_x\,x'(c)+\varphi_y\,y'(c)+\varphi_c=0.$$ (a) The gradient $(\varphi_x,\varphi_y)$ is normal to the level curve $C_c$ at a regular point, and $(x'(c),y'(c))$ is tangent to $\Gamma$, which is tangent to $C_c$; so the first two terms add to $0$ and $\varphi_c=0$. (b) Here $\varphi_x=\varphi_y=0$ at the point, so again $\varphi_c=0$. ∎
The converse is false: the $c$-discriminant locus is only a list of candidates. Geometrically, $\varphi(x,y,c)=0=\varphi(x,y,c+\Delta c)$ describes the intersection of two neighbouring members, and $\varphi_c=0$ is its limit as $\Delta c\to0$; neighbouring members can "meet in the limit" because they touch a common curve (envelope) or because each has a singular point there (node or cusp).
📐 Theorem 1.12 — An envelope of solutions is a solution
Suppose every member of the family $\varphi(x,y,c)=0$ is an integral curve of $F(x,y,p)=0$, and let $\Gamma$ be an envelope of the family that is the graph of a differentiable function $y=s(x)$. Then $s$ is a solution of $F(x,y,y')=0$. If $\Gamma$ is not a member of the family, it is a singular solution: at every point of $\Gamma$ two integral curves ($\Gamma$ and a member) pass with the same slope.
Proof. Let $(x_1,s(x_1))\in\Gamma$ be the point of contact with $C_c$. Near this point $C_c$ is the graph of a solution $y_c$ (its tangent is the non-vertical tangent of $\Gamma$), with $y_c(x_1)=s(x_1)$ and, by tangency, $y_c'(x_1)=s'(x_1)$. Since $F(x_1,y_c(x_1),y_c'(x_1))=0$, we get $F(x_1,s(x_1),s'(x_1))=0$. As $x_1$ was arbitrary, $s$ solves the equation. The last sentence restates tangency. ∎
✏️ Example 3 — Sine curves and their envelope
Solve $p^2+y^2=1$, find the $p$- and $c$-discriminants, and show that $y=\pm1$ are singular solutions. How many solutions does the IVP with $y(0)=1$ have?
💡 Show solution▶
General solution $p=\pm\sqrt{1-y^2}$ (so $|y|\le1$). Where $|y|\lt1$: $\dfrac{dy}{\sqrt{1-y^2}}=\pm dx$, $\arcsin y=\pm x+c'$, which in both cases is $$y=\sin(x+c).$$ Check: $\cos^2(x+c)+\sin^2(x+c)=1$.
Discriminants $p$: $F=p^2+y^2-1$, $F_p=2p=0$ gives $y^2=1$. $c$: $\varphi=y-\sin(x+c)$, $\varphi_c=-\cos(x+c)=0$ gives $\sin(x+c)=\pm1$, so $y=\pm1$. Both loci are $y=\pm1$, each appearing once.
Singular $y\equiv1$: $p=0$ and $0+1=1$ — a solution, and not a sine curve. Each $y=\sin(x+c)$ touches $y=1$ at its maxima, with slope $0$: $y=1$ is the envelope (Theorem 1.12), and similarly $y=-1$.
Non-uniqueness Through $(0,1)$ pass $y\equiv1$, $y=\cos x$ ($c=\tfrac\pi2$), and glued solutions such as $y=1$ for $x\le0$, $\cos x$ for $0\le x\le\pi$, $-1$ for $x\ge\pi$: infinitely many. The equation solved for $p$, $p=\pm\sqrt{1-y^2}$, has a right side that is not Lipschitz at $y=\pm1$ — singular solutions live exactly where §1.1's uniqueness theorem fails.
The $p$-Discriminant, Singular Solutions and the Extraneous Loci
The $c$-discriminant needs the general solution. The $p$-discriminant needs only the equation, and the next theorem explains why it must contain every singular solution.
📐 Theorem 1.13 — Where solutions touch, $\partial F/\partial p=0$
Let $F(x,y,p)$ be $C^1$. Suppose $y_1,y_2$ are solutions of $F(x,y,y')=0$ near $x_1$ with $y_1(x_1)=y_2(x_1)=y_*$ and $y_1'(x_1)=y_2'(x_1)=p_*$, which are different on every neighbourhood of $x_1$. Then $$F(x_1,y_*,p_*)=0\quad\text{and}\quad\frac{\partial F}{\partial p}(x_1,y_*,p_*)=0.$$ Consequently a singular solution (in particular an envelope of the general solution) lies on the $p$-discriminant locus.
Proof. $F(x_1,y_*,p_*)=0$ because $y_1$ is a solution. Suppose $F_p(x_1,y_*,p_*)\ne0$. By the implicit function theorem there are neighbourhoods $U$ of $(x_1,y_*)$ and $V$ of $p_*$ and a $C^1$ function $g$ on $U$ such that for $(x,y)\in U$, $p\in V$: $F(x,y,p)=0\iff p=g(x,y)$. As usual we take solutions to be $C^1$; then for $x$ near $x_1$ the points $(x,y_i(x))$ lie in $U$ and the slopes $y_i'(x)$ lie in $V$. Hence both $y_1$ and $y_2$ solve the explicit IVP $y'=g(x,y)$, $y(x_1)=y_*$. Since $g$ is $C^1$, it is locally Lipschitz in $y$ (Theorem 1.2), and Picard–Lindelöf (Theorem 1.3) forces $y_1=y_2$ near $x_1$ — a contradiction. ∎
The theorem shows that the $p$-discriminant locus is the only place where singular solutions can hide. It may also contain curves that are not solutions at all. For families of curves in general position the possibilities are summarised in the following classical table. It is a guide, not a theorem: always finish by substituting each candidate into the equation.
locus
geometric meaning
in $p$-disc.
in $c$-disc.
solution?
envelope $E$
touches every member
$E$
$E$
yes — singular
tac-locus $T$
two non-neighbouring members touch
$T^2$
absent
no (in general)
node-locus $N$
locus of double points of members
absent
$N^2$
no (in general)
cusp-locus $C$
locus of cusps of members
$C$
$C^3$
no (in general)
Thus, typically, $p$-discriminant $=E\,T^2\,C$ and $c$-discriminant $=E\,N^2\,C^3$: the envelope is the factor that appears once in both. Why squares and cubes? At a tac-point two distinct roots $p$ merge from both sides of the locus (like $(x-y)^2$ in Example 1); at a node two values of $c$ merge; at a cusp both $p$ and $c$ degenerate in a more singular way.
✏️ Example 4 — A cusp-locus that is not a solution
Show that $(y-c)^2=x^3$ is the general solution of $4p^2=9x$, compute both discriminants, and decide whether $x=0$ is a singular solution.
💡 Show solution▶
Solve $p=\pm\tfrac32\sqrt x$ ($x\ge0$), so $y=c\pm x^{3/2}$, i.e. $(y-c)^2=x^3$: semicubical parabolas, each with a cusp at $(0,c)$. Check: $4\left(\tfrac32\sqrt x\right)^2=9x$.
$p$-discriminant As a quadratic in $p$, $4p^2-9x$ has discriminant $144x$: the locus $x=0$, appearing once.
$c$-discriminant $\varphi=(y-c)^2-x^3$, $\varphi_c=-2(y-c)=0$ gives $y=c$ and then $x^3=0$: the locus $x=0$, appearing cubed (the discriminant in $c$ is $4x^3$).
Verdict $x=0$ is the cusp-locus, $C$ in the $p$-discriminant and $C^3$ in the $c$-discriminant, exactly as in the table. It is not a solution — it is not even the graph of a function of $x$. Theorem 1.11(b) explains its presence in the $c$-discriminant: the cusps $(0,c)$ are singular points of the members.
Interactive 1 — Envelope, Tac-Locus, Node-Locus, Cusp-Locus: Seeing the Discriminants
Grey curves are members of a one-parameter family of solutions; the red member moves as $c$ changes. Lines drawn in green are envelopes (singular solutions), amber dashed are tac-loci, purple dashed are node- or cusp-loci — they belong to a discriminant but are not solutions. Watch how the red member meets each locus: touching, touching another member, crossing itself, or forming a cusp.
c—
p-discriminant—
c-discriminant—
singular solutions—
Clairaut's and Lagrange's Equations
📘 Definition 1.9 — Clairaut's and Lagrange's (d'Alembert's) equations
Let $f,g$ be $C^1$ (or $C^2$ where stated) on an interval $J$ of $p$-values. The equation
$$y=px+f(p)$$
is Clairaut's equation. The more general equation
$$y=x\,g(p)+f(p),\qquad g(p)\not\equiv p,$$
is Lagrange's (or d'Alembert's) equation. Both are linear in $x$ and $y$ for fixed $p$.
📐 Theorem 1.14 — Solutions of Clairaut's equation
Let $f\in C^2(J)$ with $f''(p)\ne0$ on $J$.
For each $c\in J$, the straight line $y=cx+f(c)$ is a solution: the general solution is obtained by replacing $p$ by $c$.
The curve $$\Gamma:\quad x=-f'(p),\qquad y=f(p)-pf'(p)\qquad(p\in J)$$ is the graph of a $C^1$ function that solves the equation; it is not one of the lines, and it is the envelope of the family of lines. It is the singular solution, obtained by eliminating $p$ from $y=px+f(p)$ and $x+f'(p)=0$.
Differentiating the equation gives $\big(x+f'(p)\big)\dfrac{dp}{dx}=0$: on any interval, a $C^2$ solution satisfies either $p'=0$ (a line) or $x+f'(p)=0$ (a piece of $\Gamma$).
Proof. (1) For $y=cx+f(c)$, $p=c$ and $px+f(p)=cx+f(c)=y$. (3) If $y$ is $C^2$, differentiating $y=px+f(p)$ gives $p=p+xp'+f'(p)p'$, i.e. $(x+f'(p))p'=0$. (2) Since $f''\ne0$ on the interval $J$, $f''$ has one sign and $p\mapsto x=-f'(p)$ is strictly monotone and $C^1$ with nonzero derivative, so it has a $C^1$ inverse $p=P(x)$ with $P'(x)=-1/f''(P)$. Along $\Gamma$, $y(x)=f(P)-Pf'(P)$, so $$\frac{dy}{dx}=\big(f'(P)-f'(P)-Pf''(P)\big)P'(x)=-Pf''(P)\cdot\frac{-1}{f''(P)}=P.$$ Hence the slope of $\Gamma$ at the point with parameter $p$ is $p$ itself, and $px+f(p)=-pf'(p)+f(p)=y$: $\Gamma$ solves the equation. The line with $c=p$ passes through the same point (its value at $x=-f'(p)$ is $-pf'(p)+f(p)=y$) with the same slope $p$: it is tangent to $\Gamma$ there, so $\Gamma$ is the envelope. $\Gamma$ is not a line because its slope $P(x)$ is strictly monotone. ∎
Part (3) does not exclude glued solutions that are only $C^1$: follow $\Gamma$ up to a point, then continue along the tangent line there. The slope is continuous at the junction, but $p'$ jumps from $-1/f''$ to $0$ (Exercise IV.6). Clairaut's equation is the purest example of the non-uniqueness described in Theorem 1.13: on $\Gamma$, $F_p=x+f'(p)=0$.
✏️ Example 5 — Tangent lines to a circle
Solve $y=px+\sqrt{1+p^2}$. Identify the singular solution geometrically, and describe a solution through $(0,1)$ that is neither a line nor the singular solution.
💡 Show solution▶
General $y=cx+\sqrt{1+c^2}$, $c\in\mathbb{R}$. The distance from the origin to this line is $\dfrac{\sqrt{1+c^2}}{\sqrt{1+c^2}}=1$: every member is tangent to the unit circle.
Singular $f(p)=\sqrt{1+p^2}$, $f'=\dfrac{p}{\sqrt{1+p^2}}$, $f''=(1+p^2)^{-3/2}\gt0$. So $x=-\dfrac{p}{\sqrt{1+p^2}}$, $y=\sqrt{1+p^2}-\dfrac{p^2}{\sqrt{1+p^2}}=\dfrac1{\sqrt{1+p^2}}$. Then $x^2+y^2=1$ with $y\gt0$: the upper semicircle $y=\sqrt{1-x^2}$, $|x|\lt1$.
Check For $y=\sqrt{1-x^2}$: $p=-\dfrac{x}{\sqrt{1-x^2}}$, $1+p^2=\dfrac1{1-x^2}$, and $px+\sqrt{1+p^2}=\dfrac{-x^2+1}{\sqrt{1-x^2}}=\sqrt{1-x^2}=y$.
A glued solution Through $(0,1)$ pass the line $y=1$ ($c=0$) and the semicircle. The function equal to $1$ for $x\le0$ and $\sqrt{1-x^2}$ for $0\le x\le\tfrac35$, then continuing along the tangent at $\left(\tfrac35,\tfrac45\right)$, namely $y=-\tfrac34x+\tfrac54$ for $x\ge\tfrac35$, is $C^1$ and solves the equation everywhere: three pieces, two junctions. Through $(0,1)$ there are infinitely many solutions.
Interactive 2 — Clairaut's Equation: Lines Sweeping Out Their Envelope
For $y=px+f(p)$ every line $y=cx+f(c)$ is a solution. As $c$ moves, the red line touches the green singular solution at $\left(-f'(c),\,f(c)-cf'(c)\right)$, and the grey trail of earlier lines outlines it. Press Glued solution to see a $C^1$ solution made of a piece of the envelope followed by a tangent line.
c—
line y = cx + f(c)—
contact point—
slope of envelope there—
📐 Theorem 1.15 — Lagrange's equation
Let $f,g\in C^1(J)$, and consider $y=xg(p)+f(p)$. (a) On an interval where $p'\ne0$, a $C^2$ solution satisfies, with $p$ as independent variable, the linear equation $$\big(p-g(p)\big)\frac{dx}{dp}-g'(p)\,x=f'(p).$$ Its general solution $x=X(p,C)$, together with $y=X(p,C)g(p)+f(p)$, gives the general solution in parametric form. (b) For every root $p_0$ of $g(p_0)=p_0$, the line $y=p_0x+f(p_0)$ is a solution; such lines may be particular or singular solutions.
Proof. (a) Differentiating, $p=g(p)+\big(xg'(p)+f'(p)\big)p'$. Where $p'\ne0$, $x$ is locally a $C^1$ function of $p$ with $\tfrac{dx}{dp}=1/p'$; multiplying by $\tfrac{dx}{dp}$ gives $\big(p-g(p)\big)\tfrac{dx}{dp}=xg'(p)+f'(p)$. (b) For $y=p_0x+f(p_0)$, $p\equiv p_0$ and $xg(p_0)+f(p_0)=p_0x+f(p_0)=y$. ∎ When $g(p)=p$ the linear equation degenerates and we are back in Clairaut's case.
✏️ Example 6 — A Lagrange equation with one particular and one singular line
Solve $y=(x+1)p^2$ for $x\gt-1$. The roots of $g(p)=p^2=p$ give two lines; classify them.
💡 Show solution▶
Linear equation Here $g=f=p^2$. Theorem 1.15(a): $(p-p^2)\tfrac{dx}{dp}-2px=2p$; for $p\ne0$, $(1-p)\tfrac{dx}{dp}=2(x+1)$, so $\dfrac{d(x+1)}{x+1}=\dfrac{2\,dp}{1-p}$ and $x+1=\dfrac{K}{(1-p)^2}$.
Eliminate $p$ $1-p=\dfrac{k}{\sqrt{x+1}}$ (with $k^2=K$, sign absorbed into $k$), so $p=1-\dfrac k{\sqrt{x+1}}$ and $y=(x+1)p^2$: $$y=\left(\sqrt{x+1}-k\right)^2.$$ Check: $p=1-\tfrac{k}{\sqrt{x+1}}=\tfrac{\sqrt{x+1}-k}{\sqrt{x+1}}$ and $(x+1)p^2=(\sqrt{x+1}-k)^2$.
The lines $p^2=p$ gives $p_0=1$: $y=x+1$, and $p_0=0$: $y=0$. The line $y=x+1$ is the member $k=0$ — a particular solution. The line $y=0$ is not a member, and each member with $k\gt0$ touches it at $x=k^2-1$ (a double zero of $(\sqrt{x+1}-k)^2$): it is the envelope, a singular solution.
Discriminant check $F=y-(x+1)p^2$, $F_p=-2(x+1)p=0$ gives $p=0$ and then $y=0$: the $p$-discriminant locus is $y=0$, as Theorem 1.13 requires.
Orthogonal Trajectories
📘 Definition 1.10 — Orthogonal trajectories
An orthogonal trajectory of a one-parameter family of curves is a curve that cuts every member it meets at a right angle. Examples: lines of force and equipotentials of a planar electric field, streamlines and velocity-potential curves of a planar flow, heat-flow lines and isotherms. A family is self-orthogonal if its orthogonal trajectories form the same family.
📐 Theorem 1.16 — Finding orthogonal trajectories
(a) If the family $\varphi(x,y,c)=0$ has differential equation $F(x,y,p)=0$ (obtained by eliminating $c$), then its orthogonal trajectories satisfy $$F\!\left(x,y,-\frac1p\right)=0.$$ (b) In polar coordinates, if the family satisfies $G\!\left(r,\theta,\tfrac{dr}{d\theta}\right)=0$, the orthogonal trajectories satisfy $$G\!\left(r,\theta,-r^2\frac{d\theta}{dr}\right)=0.$$
Proof. (a) Two curves through a point with slopes $m_1,m_2$ (neither vertical nor horizontal) are perpendicular iff $m_1m_2=-1$. The member through $(x,y)$ has a slope $p_1$ with $F(x,y,p_1)=0$; the trajectory's slope $p$ must equal $-1/p_1$, i.e. $p_1=-1/p$. (b) The angle $\psi$ between the radius vector and the tangent satisfies $\tan\psi=r\dfrac{d\theta}{dr}=\dfrac{r}{r'}$ with $r'=\tfrac{dr}{d\theta}$. Two curves are orthogonal at a point iff their angles differ by $\tfrac\pi2$, i.e. $\tan\psi_1\tan\psi_2=-1$: $\dfrac{r}{r_1'}\cdot\dfrac{r}{r_2'}=-1$, so $r_1'=-\dfrac{r^2}{r_2'}=-r^2\dfrac{d\theta}{dr}$ along the trajectory. ∎
✏️ Example 7 — Circles through the origin
Find the orthogonal trajectories of the circles $x^2+y^2=2cx$ (centres on the $x$-axis, through the origin), first in Cartesian and then in polar coordinates.
💡 Show solution▶
Eliminate $c$ Differentiate: $2x+2yp=2c=\dfrac{x^2+y^2}{x}$. So $2xyp=y^2-x^2$, i.e. $p=\dfrac{y^2-x^2}{2xy}$.
Replace $p$ by $-1/p$ $-\dfrac1p=\dfrac{y^2-x^2}{2xy}$, i.e. $p=\dfrac{2xy}{x^2-y^2}$. This is the same equation with $x$ and $y$ interchanged ($\tfrac{dx}{dy}=\tfrac{x^2-y^2}{2xy}$), so the solutions are the circles $$x^2+y^2=2ky$$ (centres on the $y$-axis). Check: differentiating gives $p=\dfrac{x}{k-y}$ with $k-y=\dfrac{x^2-y^2}{2y}$, i.e. $p=\dfrac{2xy}{x^2-y^2}$.
Polar route $r=2c\cos\theta$, so $\dfrac{r'}{r}=-\tan\theta$. Replace $r'$ by $-r^2\dfrac{d\theta}{dr}$: $-r\dfrac{d\theta}{dr}=-\tan\theta$, i.e. $\dfrac{dr}{r}=\cot\theta\,d\theta$, $r=2k\sin\theta$ — the same circles.
Physics These two families are the field lines and equipotentials of a planar dipole at the origin (the real and imaginary parts of $1/z$, up to sign): orthogonal families of circles appear whenever the curves are level sets of the two parts of an analytic function.
⚠️ Counterexamples and pitfalls
A discriminant locus need not be a solution. For $(y-c)^2=x^3$ the cusp-locus $x=0$ is in both discriminants and is not a solution (Example 4); for $(x-c)^2=y^2(3-y)$ the node-locus $y=0$ is in the $c$-discriminant only (Exercise II.2). Always substitute.
Appearing in both discriminants is not enough. The cusp-locus also appears in both; the envelope is the factor that appears to the first power in both — and even this is only the typical behaviour.
The $p$-discriminant contains tac-loci. $y=x$ for $(p-x)(p-y)=0$ (Example 1) and $y=2$ for $9(2-y)^2p^2=4(3-y)$: they appear squared and are not solutions.
A solution on the $p$-discriminant locus need not be singular. For $p^2=y^2(1-y)$ the locus is $y^2(1-y)=0$; $y=0$ is a solution, but $p=\pm y\sqrt{1-y}$ is Lipschitz near $y=0$, so uniqueness holds there: $y=0$ is not singular. $y=1$ is singular (Exercise II.3).
An envelope may cross the members. $y=0$ is the envelope of $y=(x-c)^3$: each cubic is tangent to the axis at its inflection point and crosses it. Tangency, not "lying on one side", is the definition.
No envelope when $f''\equiv0$. For $y=px+ap+b$ (with $f$ linear) the general solution $y-b=c(x+a)$ is a pencil of lines through $(-a,b)$; the "envelope" degenerates to a point and there is no singular solution.
Clairaut solutions need not be lines or the envelope. $C^1$ glued solutions exist (Example 5); only $C^2$ solutions are forced to be one or the other.
Orthogonal trajectories: eliminate $c$ first. Replacing $p$ by $-1/p$ in an equation that still contains $c$ (for instance $p=2cx$ for $y=cx^2$) gives a different, wrong answer; first write $p=2y/x$, then replace.
Polar orthogonal trajectories. The replacement is $\tfrac{dr}{d\theta}\mapsto-r^2\tfrac{d\theta}{dr}$, not $\tfrac{dr}{d\theta}\mapsto-\tfrac{d\theta}{dr}$: the angle condition involves $\tan\psi=r\,\tfrac{d\theta}{dr}$.
Exercises
I
Equations of higher degree; envelopes.
1 Solve $p^2-5p+6=0$.
2 Solve $p^2-2p\cosh x+1=0$.
3 Solve $x=y+\log p$ (solvable for $x$).
4 Solve $y=(1+p)x+p^2$ in parametric form.
5 Solve $p^2-4xp+4y=0$ and find its singular solution.
6 Solve $xp^2-2yp+4x=0$ and show that $y=\pm2x$ are singular solutions.
7 Find the envelopes of (a) the circles $(x-c)^2+y^2=4$; (b) the lines $y=cx+\tfrac1c$.
8 Find the $c$-discriminant of $y=c(x-c)^2$ and decide which of its components are envelopes.
💡 Show solutions▶
1 $(p-2)(p-3)=0$: $y=2x+c$ or $y=3x+c$; general solution $(y-2x-c)(y-3x-c)=0$. No singular solution (the two slopes never coincide).
2 $p=\cosh x\pm\sqrt{\cosh^2x-1}=\cosh x\pm\sinh x=e^{\pm x}$. So $(y-e^x-c)(y+e^{-x}-c)=0$. The $p$-discriminant $4\cosh^2x-4=4\sinh^2x$ vanishes on $x=0$ (squared): a tac-locus, where $y=e^x+c_1$ and $y=-e^{-x}+c_2$ both have slope $1$; it is not a solution (a vertical line).
3 Differentiate with respect to $y$: $\tfrac1p=1+\tfrac1p\tfrac{dp}{dy}$, so $\tfrac{dp}{dy}=1-p$, $p=1-ke^{-y}$. Then $x=y+\log(1-ke^{-y})$, $e^x=e^y-k$: $$y=\log(e^x+k).$$ Check: $p=\tfrac{e^x}{e^x+k}$, $y+\log p=x$.
4 Lagrange with $g=1+p$, $f=p^2$: differentiating, $p=1+p+(x+2p)p'$, so $\tfrac{dx}{dp}=-(x+2p)$, $(xe^p)'=-2pe^p$, $xe^p=-2(p-1)e^p+C$: $$x=2(1-p)+Ce^{-p},\qquad y=(1+p)x+p^2.$$ ($g(p)=p$ has no root, so there are no extra lines.)
5 $y=xp-\tfrac{p^2}{4}$ is Clairaut's equation with $f(p)=-\tfrac{p^2}4$. General: $y=cx-\tfrac{c^2}{4}$. Singular: $x=-f'(p)=\tfrac p2$, $y=\tfrac{p^2}{2}-\tfrac{p^2}{4}=\tfrac{p^2}4$, i.e. $y=x^2$. Check: $p=2x$, $4x^2-8x^2+4x^2=0$.
6 Solvable for $y$: $y=\tfrac x2\left(p+\tfrac4p\right)$. Differentiating, $(p^2-4)(p-xp')=0$. $p=cx$ gives $y=\tfrac{c}{2}x^2+\tfrac2c$; $p=\pm2$ gives $y=\pm2x$. Check $y=2x$: $4x-8x+4x=0$. The $c$-discriminant of $x^2c^2-2yc+4=0$ is $4y^2-16x^2$, i.e. $y=\pm2x$: envelopes, hence singular.
7 (a) $\varphi_c=-2(x-c)=0$ gives $y^2=4$: the envelopes $y=\pm2$. (b) $c^2x-cy+1=0$ has discriminant $y^2-4x$: the parabola $y^2=4x$ (each line touches it at $\left(\tfrac1{c^2},\tfrac2c\right)$).
8 $\tfrac{\partial}{\partial c}\left[c(x-c)^2\right]=(x-c)^2-2c(x-c)=(x-c)(x-3c)$. $c=x$ gives $y=0$; $c=\tfrac x3$ gives $y=\tfrac{4x^3}{27}$. The $c$-discriminant is $y(27y-4x^3)$. Both are envelopes: the member touches $y=0$ at $(c,0)$ (double root) and touches $27y=4x^3$ at $x=3c$, where both slopes equal $\tfrac{4x^2}{9}$.
II
Discriminants and singular solutions.
1 Solve $p^2+2xp=y$ (parametrically), find its $p$-discriminant, and show that it is not a solution.
2 Show that $(x-c)^2=y^2(3-y)$ is the general solution of $9(2-y)^2p^2=4(3-y)$. Compute both discriminants and classify every locus.
3 For $p^2=y^2(1-y)$, find the $p$-discriminant locus. Which of its components are solutions, and which are singular solutions?
4 Find the differential equation of the family $y=(x-c)^2+c$ and its singular solution.
5 Show that $y=(x-c)^3$ is the general solution of $p^3=27y^2$ and that $y=0$ is a singular solution, although every member crosses it.
6 For $p^2=4y$: find the general and singular solutions, and show that through $(x_0,y_0)$ with $y_0\gt0$ pass exactly two members of the general solution, while through $(x_0,0)$ pass infinitely many solutions.
7 Show that $p^3+p=y$ has no singular solutions.
💡 Show solutions▶
1 $y=p^2+2xp$; differentiating, $p=2pp'+2p+2xp'$, so $\tfrac{dx}{dp}+\tfrac{2x}{p}=-2$, $(p^2x)'=-2p^2$: $$x=-\tfrac{2p}{3}+\tfrac{C}{p^2},\qquad y=-\tfrac{p^2}{3}+\tfrac{2C}{p}.$$ $p$-discriminant: $4x^2+4y=0$, i.e. $y=-x^2$. On it $p=-2x$ and $p^2+2xp-y=x^2\ne0$: not a solution. It is a cusp-locus: along a member $dy/dp=p\,dx/dp$, and $dx/dp=-\tfrac23-\tfrac{2C}{p^3}$ vanishes exactly when $C=-\tfrac{p^3}3$, i.e. when $x=-p$ — so each member has a cusp where it meets $y=-x^2$.
2 On a member, $x=c\pm y\sqrt{3-y}$, so $\tfrac{dx}{dy}=\pm\tfrac{6-3y}{2\sqrt{3-y}}$ and $p^2=\tfrac{4(3-y)}{9(2-y)^2}$: the equation holds. $c$-discriminant: as a quadratic in $c$, discriminant $4y^2(3-y)$: $y=0$ (squared, node-locus: the loop crosses itself at $(c,0)$ with slopes $\pm\tfrac1{\sqrt3}$) and $y=3$ (once). $p$-discriminant: $144(2-y)^2(3-y)$: $y=2$ (squared, tac-locus: members $c$ and $c+4$ touch at $(c+2,2)$ with vertical tangents) and $y=3$ (once). $y=3$: $p=0$, $0=0$ — the envelope, singular solution. $y=0$ and $y=2$ are not solutions ($F=-12$ and $F=-4$ with $p=0$).
3 Discriminant $4y^2(1-y)$: components $y=0$ and $y=1$, both solutions ($p=0$). Near $y=0$, $p=\pm y\sqrt{1-y}$ is Lipschitz, so solutions are unique there: $y=0$ is not singular (no other solution touches it; the others approach it only as $x\to\pm\infty$). Near $y=1$, $\sqrt{1-y}$ is not Lipschitz: with $u=\sqrt{1-y}$ the nonconstant solutions satisfy $\log\tfrac{1+u}{1-u}=\pm(x-c)$, reach $u=0$ (i.e. $y=1$) at $x=c$ with slope $0$ and touch the line: $y=1$ is singular.
4 $p=2(x-c)$, so $c=x-\tfrac p2$ and $y=\tfrac{p^2}4+x-\tfrac p2$. $F_p=\tfrac p2-\tfrac12=0$ gives $p=1$ and $y=x-\tfrac14$; check: $p=1$, $\tfrac14+x-\tfrac12=x-\tfrac14$. Singular solution $y=x-\tfrac14$ (the $c$-discriminant is $4y-4x+1=0$ too; each parabola touches it at $x=c+\tfrac12$).
5 $p=3(x-c)^2$ and $p^3=27(x-c)^6=27y^2$. $y\equiv0$ solves the equation and is not a member. Each cubic has $y=0$, $p=0$ at $x=c$: tangent to the axis, so $y=0$ is the envelope; through each $(c,0)$ pass two solutions with the same slope — singular. The cubic crosses the axis because $(c,0)$ is an inflection point.
6 $p=\pm2\sqrt y$: $\sqrt y=\pm(x-c)$, so $y=(x-c)^2$; singular $y=0$ ($p$- and $c$-discriminant $y=0$). Through $(x_0,y_0)$, $y_0\gt0$: $c=x_0\pm\sqrt{y_0}$ — two members. Through $(x_0,0)$: $y\equiv0$, $y=(x-x_0)^2$, and all glued functions $(x-d)^2$ for $x\le d$, $0$ on $[d,e]$, $(x-e)^2$ for $x\ge e$ with $d\le x_0\le e$.
7 $F_p=3p^2+1\gt0$ everywhere, so the $p$-discriminant locus is empty; by Theorem 1.13 no two solutions can touch, and there is no singular solution. (Indeed $p=h(y)$ with $h$ the smooth inverse of $p\mapsto p^3+p$, and $y'=h(y)$ has unique solutions.)
III
Clairaut and Lagrange.
1 Solve $y=px+p^2$.
2 Solve $y=px-e^p$.
3 Solve $y=px+\dfrac ap$ ($a\gt0$).
4 Solve $(y-px)^2=1+p^2$.
5 Using $X=x^2$, $Y=y^2$, reduce $x^2y^2=x^3yp-y^2p^2$ to Clairaut's form and solve it.
6 Solve the Lagrange equation $y=2xp-p^2$ parametrically and find the extra solution given by Theorem 1.15(b).
7 For $y=px+p^2$, show that $(2,-1)$ lies on the singular solution and find at least four different $C^1$ solutions through it.
8 Find the curves in the first quadrant whose tangent lines cut off intercepts on the axes with constant sum $a\gt0$.
2 $y=cx-e^c$; singular: $x=e^p$, $y=pe^p-e^p$, so $p=\log x$ and $y=x\log x-x$ ($x\gt0$). Check: $p=\log x$, $px-e^p=x\log x-x$.
3 $y=cx+\tfrac ac$; singular: $x=\tfrac{a}{p^2}$, $y=\tfrac{2a}{p}$, so $y^2=4ax$.
4 $y=px\pm\sqrt{1+p^2}$: two Clairaut equations. General: $(y-cx)^2=1+c^2$ (the tangent lines of the unit circle). Singular: $x^2+y^2=1$ (upper and lower semicircles).
5 $P=\tfrac{dY}{dX}=\tfrac{2yp}{2x}=\tfrac{yp}{x}$. Dividing the equation by $x^2$: $y^2=xyp-\tfrac{y^2p^2}{x^2}$, i.e. $Y=PX-P^2$. General: $Y=cX-c^2$, i.e. $y^2=cx^2-c^2$. Singular: $X=2P$, $Y=P^2$, $Y=\tfrac{X^2}4$: $y=\pm\tfrac{x^2}2$. Check $y=\tfrac{x^2}2$: $p=x$, RHS $=\tfrac{x^6}{2}-\tfrac{x^6}{4}=\tfrac{x^6}4=x^2y^2$.
6 Differentiating: $p=2p+2(x-p)p'$, so $\tfrac{dx}{dp}+\tfrac{2x}{p}=2$, $(p^2x)'=2p^2$: $$x=\tfrac{2p}3+\tfrac{C}{p^2},\qquad y=2xp-p^2=\tfrac{p^2}{3}+\tfrac{2C}{p}.$$ $g(p)=2p=p$ gives $p_0=0$: the line $y=0$ (check: $0=0$).
7 $-\tfrac{2^2}{4}=-1$: on $y=-\tfrac{x^2}4$, with slope $-1$. Lines through it: $-1=2c+c^2$, $c=-1$ (double): only $y=-x+1$, the tangent. $C^1$ solutions: (i) the parabola; (ii) the tangent line; (iii) the line for $x\le2$, parabola for $x\ge2$; (iv) parabola for $x\le2$, line for $x\ge2$ — and more, by leaving the parabola again along other tangents.
8 The tangent at $(x,y)$ has intercepts $x-\tfrac yp$ and $y-px$. Their sum: $(y-px)\left(1-\tfrac1p\right)=a$, so $y=px+\tfrac{ap}{p-1}$ — Clairaut. The lines are trivial solutions; the curve is the singular solution: $f'(p)=-\tfrac{a}{(p-1)^2}$, $x=\tfrac{a}{(p-1)^2}$, $y=\tfrac{ap^2}{(p-1)^2}$, and for $p\lt0$, $\sqrt x+\sqrt y=\tfrac{\sqrt a(1-p)}{1-p}$: $$\sqrt x+\sqrt y=\sqrt a$$ (an arc of a parabola). Check with $a=4$, $p=-2$: $x=\tfrac49$, $y=\tfrac{16}9$, $\tfrac23+\tfrac43=2$.
IV
Orthogonal trajectories and proofs.
1 Find the orthogonal trajectories of $y=cx^3$.
2 Find the orthogonal trajectories of the hyperbolas $x^2-y^2=c$.
3 Find the orthogonal trajectories of the cardioids $r=c(1+\cos\theta)$.
4 Show that the orthogonal trajectories of the coaxal circles $x^2+y^2-2gx+1=0$ ($g$ the parameter) are the circles $x^2+y^2-2fy-1=0$.
5 Find the curves that cut every line through the origin at an angle of $45^\circ$.
6 Let $f\in C^2(J)$ with $f''\ne0$. Prove that every $C^2$ solution of $y=px+f(p)$ on an interval is either a line $y=cx+f(c)$ or a piece of the singular solution, and that the glued solutions of Example 5 are not $C^2$.
2 $p=\tfrac xy$; trajectories $p=-\tfrac yx$: $xy=k$ (the other family of rectangular hyperbolas; together they are the level curves of $\operatorname{Re}z^2$ and $\operatorname{Im}z^2$).
3 $\tfrac{r'}{r}=-\tfrac{\sin\theta}{1+\cos\theta}$. Replace $r'$ by $-r^2\tfrac{d\theta}{dr}$: $\tfrac1r\tfrac{dr}{d\theta}=\tfrac{1+\cos\theta}{\sin\theta}=\operatorname{cosec}\theta+\cot\theta$. Integrating, $\log r=\log\left|\tan\tfrac\theta2\right|+\log|\sin\theta|+C=\log(1-\cos\theta)+C$ (since $\tan\tfrac\theta2\sin\theta=2\sin^2\tfrac\theta2$): $r=k(1-\cos\theta)$, the reflected cardioids.
4 First family: $2g=\tfrac{x^2+y^2+1}{x}$; differentiating $x^2+y^2-2gx+1=0$, $p=\tfrac{g-x}{y}=\tfrac{y^2-x^2+1}{2xy}$. Second family: $2f=\tfrac{x^2+y^2-1}{y}$ and $p=\tfrac{x}{f-y}=\tfrac{2xy}{x^2-y^2-1}$. The product of the two slopes is $\tfrac{y^2-x^2+1}{x^2-y^2-1}=-1$.
5 The line through $(x,y)$ has slope $m=\tfrac yx$; the curve's slope $p$ satisfies $\tfrac{p-m}{1+pm}=\pm1$. With $+1$: $p=\tfrac{x+y}{x-y}$, homogeneous. In polar form the condition is simply $\tan\psi=r\tfrac{d\theta}{dr}=\pm1$: $r=ke^{\pm\theta}$, logarithmic (equiangular) spirals.
6 Let $y$ be a $C^2$ solution on an interval $I$. By Theorem 1.14(3), $(x+f'(p))p'=0$ on $I$. The set $U=\{x\in I:p'(x)\ne0\}$ is open. On $U$, $x=-f'(p(x))$; differentiating, $1=-f''(p)p'$, so $p'=-1/f''(p)$ on $U$. If $x_1\in I$ is a limit of points of $U$, continuity of $p'$ and of $f''(p)$ gives $p'(x_1)=-1/f''(p(x_1))\ne0$, so $x_1\in U$: $U$ is also closed in $I$. Since $I$ is connected, $U=\varnothing$ (then $p$ is constant and $y$ is a line $y=cx+f(c)$) or $U=I$ (then $x=-f'(p)$ throughout, a piece of $\Gamma$). In Example 5 the glued solution has $p'=0$ on the line and $p'=-1/f''(0)=-1$ on the circle at $x=0$: $p'$ jumps, so it is $C^1$ but not $C^2$.
🎯 Exam corner CSIR Part BCSIR Part CGATE MA
E1.CSIR Part BGATE MA The singular solution of $y=px+p^2-p$ is (A) $4y=-(x-1)^2$; (B) $4y=(x-1)^2$; (C) $4y=-x^2$; (D) the equation has no singular solution.
💡 Show solution▶
Idea Clairaut with $f(p)=p^2-p$, $f''=2\ne0$: eliminate $p$ from $y=px+f(p)$ and $x+f'(p)=0$.
Compute $x=1-2p$, $y=p(1-2p)+p^2-p=-p^2$, and $p=\tfrac{1-x}2$: $y=-\tfrac{(1-x)^2}{4}$. Check: $p=\tfrac{1-x}{2}$, $px+p^2-p=p(x+p-1)=\tfrac{1-x}2\cdot\tfrac{x-1}{2}$. (C) is the envelope for $f=p^2$; the extra $-p$ shifts it.
Answer (A).
E2.CSIR Part B For the equation $(y')^2=4(1-y)$, which of the following is a singular solution? (A) $y=0$; (B) $y=1$; (C) $y=1-x^2$; (D) there is none.
💡 Show solution▶
General $p=\pm2\sqrt{1-y}$, $\sqrt{1-y}=\mp(x-c)$: $y=1-(x-c)^2$, downward parabolas with vertex on $y=1$.
Options (A) $p=0$ but $4(1-0)\ne0$: not a solution. (B) $p=0=4(1-1)$: a solution, the envelope of the vertices: singular. (C) is the member $c=0$ — particular. Hence (D) is false.
Answer (B).
E3.CSIR Part B The orthogonal trajectories of the family $y^2=cx^3$ are (A) $2x^2+3y^2=k$; (B) $3x^2+2y^2=k$; (C) $x^2y^3=k$; (D) $y^2=kx^2$.
💡 Show solution▶
Family $2yp=3cx^2=\tfrac{3y^2}{x}$, so $p=\tfrac{3y}{2x}$.
Trajectories $p=-\tfrac{2x}{3y}$: $3y\,dy=-2x\,dx$, $\tfrac32y^2=-x^2+C$, i.e. $2x^2+3y^2=k$. (B) results from forgetting to replace $p$ correctly.
Answer (A).
E4.CSIR Part C Consider $y=px-\dfrac1p$. Which of the following are true? (One or more options may be correct.) (A) The general solution is $y=cx-\tfrac1c$. (B) The singular solution is $y^2=4x$. (C) Exactly two members of the general solution pass through $(1,0)$. (D) The singular solution is obtained from the general solution for a suitable value of $c$.
💡 Show solution▶
(A) True Clairaut: replace $p$ by $c$ ($c\ne0$).
(B) False $f(p)=-\tfrac1p$, $f'=\tfrac1{p^2}$: $x=-\tfrac{1}{p^2}$, $y=-\tfrac1p-\tfrac1p=-\tfrac2p$, so $y^2=\tfrac4{p^2}=-4x$. The singular solution is $y^2=-4x$ (in $x\lt0$).
(C) True $0=c-\tfrac1c$ gives $c=\pm1$: the lines $y=x-1$ and $y=-x+1$. (A point on the envelope, such as $(-1,2)$, has just one.)
(D) False The members are lines; the singular solution is a parabola.
Answer (A) and (C).
E5.CSIR Part C Let $\varphi(x,y,c)=0$ be a general solution of $F(x,y,p)=0$, with $F$ and $\varphi$ smooth. Which of the following are true? (A) An envelope of the family that is the graph of a differentiable function is a solution of the equation. (B) Every component of the $c$-discriminant locus is a solution. (C) At each point of an envelope that is a singular solution, the IVP through that point has more than one solution. (D) A curve appearing in both the $p$-discriminant and the $c$-discriminant must be a singular solution.
💡 Show solution▶
(A) True Theorem 1.12.
(B) False The node-locus $y=0$ of $(x-c)^2=y^2(3-y)$, or the cusp-locus $x=0$ of $(y-c)^2=x^3$.
(C) True The envelope and the member touching it at that point both pass through it (with the same slope).
(D) False The cusp-locus $x=0$ of $4p^2=9x$ appears in both ($x$ and $x^3$) and is not a solution (Example 4).
Answer (A) and (C).
E6.CSIR Part C Consider the family of parabolas $y^2=4a(x+a)$, $a\in\mathbb{R}\setminus\{0\}$. Which of the following are true? (A) Every member satisfies $y=2xp+yp^2$. (B) The family is self-orthogonal. (C) The family has a real envelope. (D) Through every point not on the $x$-axis pass exactly two members of the family.
💡 Show solution▶
(A) True $2yp=4a$, so $a=\tfrac{yp}2$; substituting, $y^2=2xyp+y^2p^2$, i.e. $y=2xp+yp^2$ for $y\ne0$.
(B) True Replace $p$ by $-\tfrac1p$: $y=-\tfrac{2x}p+\tfrac{y}{p^2}$; multiplying by $p^2$, $yp^2=-2xp+y$, i.e. $y=2xp+yp^2$ — the same equation. (These are the confocal parabolas with focus at the origin.)
(C) False As a quadratic in $a$, $4a^2+4xa-y^2=0$ has discriminant $16(x^2+y^2)$, which vanishes only at the origin: no real envelope.
(D) True For $y\ne0$ the discriminant $16(x^2+y^2)\gt0$ gives two distinct real roots $a$, whose product $-\tfrac{y^2}4\lt0$ shows both are nonzero (one of each sign).
Answer (A), (B) and (D).
🧑🏫 For the teacher
Suggested plan — 2 lectures × 60 min.
Singular solutions and discriminants. Start with $p^2+y^2=1$ (Example 3) drawn on the board: the class finds $y=\sin(x+c)$ and then notices $y=\pm1$. Definitions 1.6–1.8, Theorems 1.11–1.13 with proofs (the implicit-function argument of Theorem 1.13 links back to §1.1). Examples 1, 2 and 4; project Interactive 1, all four modes, and fill the loci table together from what is seen on screen.
Clairaut, Lagrange, trajectories. Theorem 1.14 with proof; Interactive 2 (envelope being swept out, then the glued solution); Example 5, Theorem 1.15 and Example 6; Theorem 1.16 and Example 7. Finish with Exam-corner E4 and E5 done live, insisting that every option is decided.
Discussion questions. (1) Why must a singular solution live where $\partial F/\partial p=0$? What would Picard's theorem say otherwise? (2) The $c$-discriminant and the $p$-discriminant are computed from different data (the family and the equation). Why should they share the envelope but not the other loci? (3) Is there a Clairaut equation whose singular solution is a straight line? (Think about $f''$.)
Misconceptions to watch for. "Every curve in a discriminant locus is a singular solution"; "a singular solution is the member with a special value of $c$"; "the envelope lies on one side of the curves"; forgetting the extra lines $p=g(p)$ in Lagrange's equation; replacing $p$ by $-1/p$ before eliminating $c$; using $-1/r'$ in polar coordinates.
🔬 Research–Teaching NexusResearch-tutored · optional, about 45 minutes
Research question. A fountain nozzle, a fireworks mortar or a garden sprinkler launches water or fragments at a fixed speed in every direction of a vertical plane. Which points can be reached at all — and what is the boundary of the "danger zone"?
Why it matters. Safety distances for fireworks displays and for demolition blasting, the coverage of agricultural sprinklers, and the design of decorative water jets all rest on the envelope of a family of trajectories, sometimes called the parabola of safety. The same mathematics describes caustics in optics (the bright curve in a coffee cup) and the wavefronts of sound in a stadium.
What to do.
Ignoring air resistance, a projectile launched from the origin with speed $v$ at angle $\theta$ follows $y=cx-\dfrac{gx^2}{2v^2}(1+c^2)$ with $c=\tan\theta$. Compute the $c$-discriminant of this family and show that the envelope is $y=\dfrac{v^2}{2g}-\dfrac{gx^2}{2v^2}$.
Find the differential equation $F(x,y,p)=0$ of the family and check, using Theorem 1.13, that the envelope lies on its $p$-discriminant.
For $v=20\ \text{m/s}$ and $g=9.81\ \text{m/s}^2$, find the maximum height and maximum horizontal range on the safety parabola, and plot 15 trajectories with the envelope.
Add linear air resistance numerically (solve the equations of motion with a small drag coefficient) and estimate the new envelope from many trajectories. Is it still a parabola?
Tools: Pen and paper for the discriminant; Python or a graphing tool for the plots and the numerical trajectories.
Hand in: A one-page note: your derivation of the envelope, the plot, the two numbers for $v=20\ \text{m/s}$, and one sentence on how drag changes the danger zone.
Going further. Every trajectory touches the safety parabola once: show that the point of contact is at $x=\dfrac{v^2}{g\tan\theta}$, and interpret the singular-solution property — a point on the boundary is reached by exactly one launch angle, a point inside by two.
Instructor note: with $v=20\ \text{m/s}$, $g=9.81\ \text{m/s}^2$ the safety parabola has height $v^2/(2g)\approx20.39\ \text{m}$ at $x=0$ and meets the ground at $x=v^2/g\approx40.77\ \text{m}$ (the maximal range, at $45^\circ$). With drag the envelope shrinks and becomes asymmetric; it is no longer a conic.
🧪 Self-check quiz
0/5 correct
Q1. For Clairaut's equation $y=px+f(p)$ with $f''\ne0$, the singular solution is found by eliminating $p$ between $y=px+f(p)$ and
Q2. The general solution of $y=px+p^3$ is
Q3. Which locus typically appears squared in the $p$-discriminant and does not appear in the $c$-discriminant?
Q4. The singular solutions of $(y')^2+y^2=1$ are
Q5. The orthogonal trajectories of the hyperbolas $xy=c$ are