Chapter 1 · Money, Time and Returns

1.1 Time Value of Money: Interest, Inflation and Real Returns

Why ₹1 today is worth more than ₹1 next year: simple and compound interest, how often interest is credited, the effective annual rate, continuous compounding as a limit, and what inflation and tax leave of your return.

📍 The situation

Ananya has just started her first job in Pune and received a joining bonus of ₹2,00,000. Her bank's savings account pays an illustrative 3% a year; a five-year fixed deposit (FD) pays an illustrative 7% a year, "compounded quarterly"; another bank advertises 7.10% "compounded annually"; and a colleague forwards a WhatsApp message about a scheme where "your money doubles in 5 years, guaranteed". Her parents add one more piece of advice: "Prices double every ten years or so — whatever you choose must beat that."

To decide sensibly she needs answers to five questions, and they are the five questions of this section. How much will ₹2 lakh become under each option? Which quoted rate is really higher — 7% quarterly or 7.10% annually? What is a future amount worth today? What will her money buy after inflation and tax? And how quickly does money double at a given rate — fast enough to check that "doubles in 5 years" claim in her head? All of them come down to one idea, the time value of money, and one piece of school mathematics, the geometric progression. Along the way we meet the number $e$ as the limit of ever more frequent compounding — the first place where calculus enters finance.

⚠️ About the numbers on this page

All interest, inflation and tax rates on this page are illustrative, chosen to make the arithmetic realistic — they are not current rates, forecasts or recommendations. Bank and small-savings rates, inflation and tax rules change; check your bank's terms, the RBI and the Income Tax Department for the current position. The people and schemes are hypothetical.

Simple Interest, Compound Interest and Present Value

When you deposit money you lend it to the bank; interest is the rent the bank pays for using it. The question is what the rent is calculated on. With simple interest it is always calculated on the original amount. With compound interest each period's interest is added to the balance and itself earns interest in later periods — "interest on interest".

📘 Definition 1.1 — Simple and compound interest

Let $P$ be the principal (amount invested), $r$ the annual rate of interest written as a decimal ($7\%$ means $r=0.07$), and $t$ the time in years.

  • Simple interest: interest is paid on $P$ only, $I=Prt$, so the amount after $t$ years is $A=P(1+rt)$.
  • Compound interest (compounded annually): at the end of each year the year's interest is added to the balance, which then earns interest in the following years.

The amount $A$ at the end is called the future value (FV) or maturity value of $P$.

📐 Theorem 1.1 (Formula) — Growth and discounting

With principal $P$ and annual rate $r\gt0$:

  1. Simple interest: $A_t=P(1+rt)$ — the amounts form an arithmetic progression (they rise by $Pr$ every year).
  2. Compound interest: $A_t=P(1+r)^t$ for $t=0,1,2,\dots$ — the amounts form a geometric progression with ratio $1+r$.
  3. Present value: an amount $A$ due in $t$ years is worth today $$PV=\frac{A}{(1+r)^t}=A\,v^t,\qquad v=\frac{1}{1+r},$$ where $r$ is the rate you could earn meanwhile and $v$ is the one-year discount factor.

Why the formula is true. Write $A_k$ for the balance after $k$ years. Under compounding the balance at the end of year $k+1$ is the old balance plus a year's interest on it: $A_{k+1}=A_k+rA_k=(1+r)A_k$. Starting from $A_0=P$, multiplying by $1+r$ once a year gives $A_t=P(1+r)^t$ (formally, by induction on $t$). Present value just runs this backwards: if $PV$ invested today becomes $PV(1+r)^t=A$, then $PV=A/(1+r)^t$. ∎

This is the time value of money in one line: as long as money can earn a positive rate, ₹1 today is worth more than ₹1 later, because today's rupee can be invested and become $1+r$ rupees in a year. Moving money forward in time we multiply by $(1+r)^t$ (compounding); moving it back we divide by $(1+r)^t$ (discounting). Every chapter of this course uses these two moves — EMIs and SIPs (§1.2), CAGR, NPV and XIRR (§1.3), bond prices (§2.3) and company valuation (§5.1).

✏️ Example 1 — Simple vs compound on ₹2,00,000 at 7%
Ananya invests ₹2,00,000 at an illustrative 7% a year. Compare the amount after 5, 10 and 20 years under simple interest and under annual compounding. How large is the "interest on interest" in each case?
Simple $A=2{,}00{,}000\,(1+0.07t)$: after 5 years ₹2,70,000; after 10 years ₹3,40,000; after 20 years ₹4,80,000. Each year adds the same ₹14,000.
Compound $A=2{,}00{,}000\times1.07^t$: $1.07^5=1.402552$, so ₹2,80,510; $1.07^{10}=1.967151$, so ₹3,93,430; $1.07^{20}=3.869684$, so ₹7,73,937.
Interest on interest The differences are ₹10,510 after 5 years, ₹53,430 after 10 years and ₹2,93,937 after 20 years. In the first few years the two methods are close; over decades compounding dominates, because the geometric progression eventually outruns any arithmetic one.
Check After 20 years the compound amount is $3.87$ times the principal — almost two doublings. That matches the rule of 72 (Theorem 1.5 below): at 7% money doubles in about $72/7\approx10.3$ years.
✏️ Example 2 — What is a promise of ₹5 lakh in 6 years worth today?
An insurance-type plan promises a guaranteed ₹5,00,000 at the end of 6 years in return for a single payment today. If Ananya can earn an illustrative 7.5% a year (compounded annually) on a safe deposit instead, what is the most it makes sense to pay for the promise today?
Idea Discount the promised amount at the rate available elsewhere (the opportunity cost): $PV=A/(1+r)^t$.
Compute $1.075^6=1.543302$, so $$PV=\frac{5{,}00{,}000}{1.543302}\approx3{,}23{,}981.$$
Interpret ₹3,23,981 placed at 7.5% today grows to ₹5,00,000 in 6 years. Paying more than this for the promise means accepting less than 7.5% a year; paying less means earning more. (We are ignoring the credit risk of the promiser — the chance it fails to pay — which would push the fair price lower.)
Answer At most about ₹3.24 lakh.

FD payout options. Banks usually offer an FD in two forms. In a cumulative (reinvestment) FD the interest is added to the deposit and paid with the principal at maturity — compound interest. In a non-cumulative (payout) FD the interest is paid out to you every month or quarter, and the deposit itself stays at $P$ — so from the deposit's point of view this is simple interest. Whether you end up with compound growth depends on what you do with the payouts.

✏️ Example 3 — Cumulative FD vs quarterly payout
A retired teacher has ₹5,00,000 to place in a 3-year FD at an illustrative 7.2% a year. Option A: cumulative, compounded quarterly. Option B: quarterly payout. Find the maturity value of A, the quarterly payout of B, and the total interest each produces. What does the difference represent?
A Quarterly rate $0.072/4=0.018$, $3\times4=12$ quarters: $A=5{,}00{,}000\times1.018^{12}\approx6{,}19{,}360$. Interest ₹1,19,360.
B Each quarter the bank pays $5{,}00{,}000\times0.018=$ ₹9,000; over 12 quarters that is ₹1,08,000, and the ₹5,00,000 is returned at maturity.
Difference ₹1,19,360 − ₹1,08,000 = ₹11,360. This is exactly the interest earned on interest: in A every ₹9,000 stays in and earns 1.8% a quarter for the remaining quarters.
Decide Neither option is "better" in itself: B suits someone who needs regular income to spend. If the payouts are spent, they do not compound; if they are reinvested at the same rate, B becomes A.

Compounding Frequency, Effective Rate and Continuous Compounding

Ananya's FD pays "7% compounded quarterly"; the other bank pays "7.10% compounded annually". The quoted rates cannot be compared directly, because interest that is credited more often starts earning interest sooner. We need a common yardstick.

📘 Definition 1.2 — Nominal rate, compounding frequency and effective annual rate

A nominal annual rate $r$ compounded $m$ times a year means that every $1/m$ of a year the balance is multiplied by $1+\frac{r}{m}$ ($m=1$ annually, $2$ half-yearly, $4$ quarterly, $12$ monthly, $365$ daily). The number $r/m$ is the periodic rate.

The effective annual rate (EAR, also called the annual percentage yield or "effective yield") is the rate that, compounded once a year, gives the same growth in one year: $1+\text{EAR}=\left(1+\frac{r}{m}\right)^m$.

📐 Theorem 1.2 (Formula) — Compounding $m$ times a year

A principal $P$ at nominal rate $r$ compounded $m$ times a year grows in $t$ years to $$A=P\left(1+\frac{r}{m}\right)^{mt},$$ and its effective annual rate is $$\text{EAR}=\left(1+\frac{r}{m}\right)^{m}-1.$$ For fixed $r\gt0$ the EAR increases with $m$, and $\text{EAR}\ge r$ with equality only for $m=1$. Conversely, the nominal rate compounded $m$ times a year that gives a target EAR is $r=m\left[(1+\text{EAR})^{1/m}-1\right]$.

Why EAR grows with $m$. In $t$ years there are $mt$ periods, each multiplying by $1+r/m$; that is the formula. Expand with the binomial theorem: $$\left(1+\frac{r}{m}\right)^m=1+r+\frac{m(m-1)}{2!}\,\frac{r^2}{m^2}+\frac{m(m-1)(m-2)}{3!}\,\frac{r^3}{m^3}+\cdots$$ The $k$-th term equals $\frac{r^k}{k!}\left(1-\frac1m\right)\left(1-\frac2m\right)\cdots\left(1-\frac{k-1}{m}\right)$; every bracket grows when $m$ grows, and a larger $m$ also adds more (positive) terms. So the sum increases with $m$, and for $m\ge2$ it is larger than $1+r$. ∎

✏️ Example 4 — Which quote is really the highest?
Four banks quote illustrative one-year deposit rates: Bank P 7.10% compounded annually; Bank Q 7.00% compounded quarterly; Bank R 6.95% compounded monthly; Bank S 6.90% compounded daily. Rank them by effective annual rate.
P $m=1$: EAR $=7.100\%$.
Q $(1+0.07/4)^4-1=1.0175^4-1\approx7.186\%$.
R, S $(1+0.0695/12)^{12}-1\approx7.176\%$; $\ (1+0.069/365)^{365}-1\approx7.143\%$.
Rank Q (7.186%) > R (7.176%) > S (7.143%) > P (7.100%). The lowest quoted rate with compounding beats the highest quoted rate without it — but notice the differences are only a few hundredths of a percent; frequency matters less than the rate itself unless rates are high (see the credit-card case in the ⚠️ box).

What if interest were credited every second? Increasing $m$ forever does not make the money grow without bound. The values $(1+r/m)^m$ increase, but they approach a ceiling. This ceiling is one of the most important numbers in mathematics.

📐 Theorem 1.3 (Formula) — Continuous compounding

For every real $r$ and $t\ge0$, $$\lim_{m\to\infty}\left(1+\frac{r}{m}\right)^{mt}=e^{rt},$$ where $e=\lim_{m\to\infty}(1+\frac1m)^m=2.71828\ldots$ So a nominal rate $r$ compounded continuously grows $P$ to $A=Pe^{rt}$, has $\text{EAR}=e^{r}-1$, and the present value of $A$ due at time $t$ is $Ae^{-rt}$. Continuous growth is characterised by the differential equation $\dfrac{dA}{dt}=rA$: the balance grows at a rate proportional to itself.

Derivation (the calculus link). Take logarithms and put $h=r/m$, so that $h\to0$ as $m\to\infty$: $$\log\left(1+\frac rm\right)^{mt}=mt\log\left(1+\frac rm\right)=rt\cdot\frac{\log(1+h)}{h}.$$ Now $\dfrac{\log(1+h)-\log 1}{h}\to\dfrac{d}{dx}\log x\Big|_{x=1}=1$ — this limit is the derivative of the natural logarithm at $1$. So the logarithm tends to $rt$, and since $\exp$ is continuous the amount tends to $e^{rt}$. Finally $\frac{d}{dt}(Pe^{rt})=rPe^{rt}$, which is the equation $A'=rA$. ∎

Continuous compounding is not something your bank does, but it is the natural language of finance theory: it makes growth rates add ($e^{r_1t}e^{r_2t}=e^{(r_1+r_2)t}$), which is why the log returns of §1.3, the futures price $Se^{(r-q)T}$ of §6.1 and the Black–Scholes formula of §6.3 are written with $e$.

Interactive 1 — From Quarterly to Continuous: Watching the Staircase Become $e^{rt}$

₹1,00,000 is deposited for one year at the nominal rate you choose. The blue staircase is the balance when interest is credited $m$ times a year: it jumps by the factor $1+r/m$ at every credit. The green curve is continuous compounding $100{,}000\,e^{rt}$ and the grey line is simple interest. Press Play to step through $m=1,2,4,12,52,365$ and "continuous"; raise the rate to see the gaps clearly. (Illustrative rates.)

12.0%
periodic rate r/m—
value after 1 year—
effective annual rate—
continuous limit eʳ − 1—
gap to continuous—
✏️ Example 5 — Monthly, daily and continuous on ₹1 lakh for 10 years
Compute the value of ₹1,00,000 after 10 years at a nominal 8% compounded (a) annually, (b) monthly, (c) daily, (d) continuously. Then find the continuously compounded rate that is equivalent to an effective 7% a year.
(a), (b) $1{,}00{,}000\times1.08^{10}\approx$ ₹2,15,892; $\ 1{,}00{,}000\times(1+0.08/12)^{120}\approx$ ₹2,21,964.
(c), (d) $1{,}00{,}000\times(1+0.08/365)^{3650}\approx$ ₹2,22,535; $\ 1{,}00{,}000\times e^{0.8}\approx$ ₹2,22,554.
Pattern The jump from annual to monthly is worth about ₹6,000; from monthly to continuous only about ₹600 more; daily is within ₹20 of continuous. The sequence increases and levels off at $e^{0.8}$, exactly as Theorem 1.3 says.
Equivalent rate We need $e^{\delta}=1.07$, so $\delta=\log1.07\approx0.06766$, i.e. 6.766% compounded continuously. In general the continuous rate equivalent to an effective rate $R$ is $\log(1+R)$, which is a little below $R$.

Inflation, Purchasing Power and Real Return

An FD can double your rupees and still leave you no richer, if prices have doubled too. What matters for your life is not the number of rupees but what they buy — their purchasing power. Prices are tracked by a price index such as a consumer price index (CPI), which measures the cost of a fixed basket of goods and services relative to a base year; India's official CPI figures are published monthly by the government's statistics office.

📘 Definition 1.3 — Inflation and purchasing power

If a price index has value $I_0$ now and $I_1$ a year later, the inflation rate for that year is $\pi=\dfrac{I_1}{I_0}-1$. (Here $\pi$ is the usual economists' symbol for inflation, not $3.14159\ldots$)

If inflation is $\pi$ a year for $t$ years, something costing $C$ today will cost $C(1+\pi)^t$ — the same formula as compound interest. Equivalently, ₹$X$ received in $t$ years has the purchasing power of $X/(1+\pi)^t$ rupees today; this is the amount "in today's rupees" or in real terms.

📘 Definition 1.4 — Nominal and real rates of return

The nominal return $r_{\text{nom}}$ is the growth of the number of rupees. The real return $r_{\text{real}}$ is the growth of purchasing power: the rate at which the investment grows when measured in today's rupees.

📐 Theorem 1.4 (Formula) — The Fisher relation

Over one period with nominal return $r_{\text{nom}}$ and inflation $\pi\gt-1$, $$1+r_{\text{nom}}=(1+r_{\text{real}})(1+\pi),\qquad\text{so}\qquad r_{\text{real}}=\frac{1+r_{\text{nom}}}{1+\pi}-1=\frac{r_{\text{nom}}-\pi}{1+\pi}.$$ For small rates, $r_{\text{real}}\approx r_{\text{nom}}-\pi$; this shortcut differs from the true real return by exactly the cross term $\pi\,r_{\text{real}}$. If the interest is taxed at a rate $\tau$ each year, the after-tax real return is $$r_{\text{real, after tax}}=\frac{1+r_{\text{nom}}(1-\tau)}{1+\pi}-1.$$

Why. ₹1 grows to $1+r_{\text{nom}}$ rupees in a year. Deflating by the price level, that is $\frac{1+r_{\text{nom}}}{1+\pi}$ rupees of today's purchasing power, so the growth of purchasing power is $\frac{1+r_{\text{nom}}}{1+\pi}-1$. Multiplying out $(1+r_{\text{real}})(1+\pi)=1+r_{\text{real}}+\pi+r_{\text{real}}\pi$ shows that $r_{\text{nom}}=r_{\text{real}}+\pi+r_{\text{real}}\pi$: the simple subtraction $r_{\text{nom}}-\pi$ leaves the small cross term $r_{\text{real}}\pi$ in. With tax, only $r_{\text{nom}}(1-\tau)$ of each rupee's interest is kept, and the same deflation applies. ∎

About tax. In India, interest from bank deposits is generally added to your income and taxed at your income-tax slab rate, and the bank may deduct tax at source (TDS) above a threshold; equity and debt mutual funds have their own rules (§8.2). Rates, thresholds and rules change with each Budget — check the Income Tax Department's current rules. On this page $\tau$ is always an illustrative rate, and we use the simplification that each year's interest is taxed in that year.

✏️ Example 6 — Is a 7% FD beating 5.5% inflation?
An FD pays an illustrative 7% a year (take it as the effective annual rate); inflation is an illustrative 5.5% a year. (a) Find the exact and approximate real return. (b) With an illustrative 30% tax on interest, find the after-tax real return. (c) What is ₹1,00,000 in this FD worth after 10 years in today's rupees, before and after tax?
(a) $r_{\text{real}}=\dfrac{1.07}{1.055}-1\approx1.422\%$. The shortcut $7-5.5=1.5\%$ is slightly too high.
(b) After tax the FD grows at $0.07\times0.7=4.9\%$ a year, so $$r_{\text{real, after tax}}=\frac{1.049}{1.055}-1\approx-0.569\%.$$ The depositor's purchasing power shrinks by about 0.57% a year.
(c) Before tax: $1{,}00{,}000\times1.07^{10}\approx$ ₹1,96,715 in rupees, worth $1{,}96{,}715/1.055^{10}\approx$ ₹1,15,163 today. After tax: $1{,}00{,}000\times1.049^{10}/1.055^{10}\approx$ ₹94,456 today.
Interpret The passbook shows the money nearly doubling, but after tax and inflation it buys about 5.5% less than at the start. A "safe" deposit protects the number of rupees, not their purchasing power.
Interactive 2 — The Inflation Eraser: Rupees vs Purchasing Power

₹1,00,000 goes into a deposit compounded annually at the rate you choose. The blue curve is the passbook balance, the purple curve the balance after an illustrative tax on each year's interest, and the green curve that after-tax balance in today's rupees. The red curve is ₹1,00,000 kept as cash, in today's rupees. The dashed line is the starting purchasing power. Press Play to move through 30 years. (All rates are illustrative assumptions.)

7.0%6.0%
year—
passbook balance—
after tax—
after tax, in today's ₹—
cash, in today's ₹—
real after-tax rate—
✏️ Example 7 — What will a college education cost?
A four-year engineering degree costs ₹10,00,000 today. If education costs rise at an illustrative 6% a year, what will the same degree cost when a child who is 3 today turns 18? What is today's ₹10 lakh worth in 15 years' purchasing power if general inflation is also 6%?
Future cost $t=15$ years: $10{,}00{,}000\times1.06^{15}=10{,}00{,}000\times2.396558\approx$ ₹23,96,558 — about ₹24 lakh.
Purchasing power ₹10 lakh received in 15 years buys what $10{,}00{,}000/1.06^{15}\approx$ ₹4,17,265 buys today.
Planning lesson A goal must be stated in future rupees before you compute the saving needed for it. §1.2 shows how to turn ₹24 lakh in 15 years into a monthly SIP, and §8.1 builds full goal plans. Education costs often rise faster than general prices; the 6% here is only an illustration.

Doubling Time: Logarithms and the Rules of 72 and 70

"At what rate does money double in 5 years?" and "how long until prices double?" are questions about the exponent $t$ in $(1+r)^t$. Exponents are found with logarithms.

📐 Theorem 1.5 (Formula) — Doubling time and the rules of 72 and 70

At an annual rate $r\gt0$ compounded annually, an amount is multiplied by $k\gt1$ after $$T_k=\frac{\log k}{\log(1+r)}\ \text{years};\qquad\text{in particular}\qquad T_2=\frac{\log2}{\log(1+r)}.$$ With continuous compounding $T_2=\dfrac{\log 2}{r}=\dfrac{0.6931}{r}$ exactly. For annual compounding and rates of a few percent up to about 20%, $$T_2\approx\frac{72}{100r}\qquad\text{(rule of 72)},$$ while $T_2\approx 70/(100r)$ (rule of 70, or 69.3) is better for low rates and for continuous growth. The same formulas give the time for prices to double, or purchasing power to halve, at inflation $\pi$.

Why 72? Solving $(1+r)^T=2$ by taking natural logs gives $T\log(1+r)=\log2$. Near $r=0$ the Taylor expansion $\log(1+r)=r-\frac{r^2}{2}+\cdots$ gives $\dfrac{r}{\log(1+r)}\approx1+\dfrac r2$, so $$T_2=\frac{\log 2}{r}\cdot\frac{r}{\log(1+r)}\approx\frac{0.693}{r}\left(1+\frac r2\right).$$ At $r=8\%$ the correction factor is $1.04$ and $0.693\times1.04\approx0.72$ — hence "72", which also has the convenience of many divisors (2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 9, 12). At small $r$ the correction disappears and 69.3 (or the rounder 70) is more accurate. ∎

rate $r$exact $T_2$ (years)rule of 72rule of 70
2%35.0036.035.0
4%17.6718.017.5
6%11.9012.011.7
8%9.019.08.75
12%6.126.05.83
24%3.223.02.92
✏️ Example 8 — Checking three claims in your head
(a) The WhatsApp scheme says "money doubles in 5 years". (b) Ananya's parents say "prices double every 10 years". (c) A finfluencer says "₹1 lakh becomes ₹1 crore at 12%". Find the rate implied in (a) and (b), and the time needed in (c) — first with the rule of 72, then exactly.
(a) Rule of 72: $72/5=14.4\%$ a year. Exactly: $2^{1/5}-1\approx14.87\%$ a year, every year, "guaranteed". That is roughly double the illustrative FD rate with no risk — a classic red flag (see the checklist in §8.2).
(b) Rule of 72: $72/10=7.2\%$; rule of 70: $7\%$. Exactly $2^{1/10}-1\approx7.18\%$ inflation a year.
(c) ₹1 crore is $100$ times ₹1 lakh, and $100\approx2^{6.64}$, so about $6.64$ doublings of $72/12=6$ years each: about $39.9$ years. Exactly: $T=\log100/\log1.12\approx40.6$ years.
Moral The claims are arithmetically possible, but (a) needs an unusually high guaranteed rate and (c) needs 40 years of an assumed 12% — and ₹1 crore in 40 years will buy far less than ₹1 crore today.
⚠️ Common mistakes and myths
  1. "2% a month is 24% a year." Only as a nominal rate. Compounded monthly, 2% a month is $1.02^{12}-1\approx26.8\%$ effective; an illustrative 3.5% a month on an unpaid credit-card balance is $1.035^{12}-1\approx51\%$ a year. Always convert to the effective annual rate before comparing.
  2. Comparing quoted rates with different compounding. 7% quarterly beats 7.10% annually (Example 4). Compare EARs.
  3. "My money doubled, so I am twice as rich." Doubling in rupees over 10 years at 7% inflation leaves your purchasing power unchanged. Always ask what the money will buy.
  4. Using $r_{\text{nom}}-\pi$ at high rates. At 20% nominal and 15% inflation the shortcut gives 5%, the truth is $1.20/1.15-1\approx4.35\%$.
  5. Forgetting tax. A 7% FD taxed at an illustrative 30% earns 4.9%; at 5.5% inflation that is a negative real return (Example 6). Compare investments after tax.
  6. Expecting payouts to compound. A payout FD pays simple interest on the deposit; only reinvested interest compounds (Example 3).
  7. "Continuous compounding means unlimited growth." The limit is finite: at 12% nominal the most frequent compounding can achieve is $e^{0.12}-1\approx12.75\%$.
  8. Treating the rule of 72 as exact. It is an approximation for moderate rates; at 1% use 70 (exact 69.7 years), at 36% the exact doubling time is 2.25 years, not 2.
  9. "A 20% fall followed by a 20% rise gets me back." Growth factors multiply: $0.8\times1.2=0.96$, a 4% loss. (Returns over several periods are studied in §1.3.)
  10. Treating a past rate as a promise. An FD rate is fixed only for the deposit you have booked; rates on new deposits, inflation and tax rules change. Plans should be checked against several assumptions, not one.
📈 Market case — Ananya's ₹2 lakh after five years

Ananya compares three places to keep ₹2,00,000 for five years, using illustrative assumptions: a savings account at 3% compounded quarterly, a cumulative FD at 7% compounded quarterly, and cash in a locker. She assumes inflation of 5% a year and tax of 20% on each year's interest (a simplification of the slab system — her actual rate depends on her income).

  1. Effective rates. Savings: $1.0075^4-1\approx3.034\%$; FD: $1.0175^4-1\approx7.186\%$.
  2. Passbook values after 5 years. Savings $2{,}00{,}000\times1.0075^{20}\approx$ ₹2,32,237; FD $2{,}00{,}000\times1.0175^{20}\approx$ ₹2,82,956; cash ₹2,00,000.
  3. After tax. Each year keeps $(1-\tau)$ of the interest, so the after-tax annual growth rates are $3.034\%\times0.8\approx2.427\%$ and $7.186\%\times0.8\approx5.749\%$: values ₹2,25,478 and ₹2,64,488.
  4. In today's rupees. Prices rise by the factor $1.05^5\approx1.27628$. Dividing: savings ₹1,76,668, FD ₹2,07,233, cash ₹1,56,705.
  5. Real after-tax rates (Fisher): savings $1.02427/1.05-1\approx-2.45\%$ a year; FD $1.05749/1.05-1\approx+0.71\%$ a year; cash $1/1.05-1\approx-4.76\%$ a year.
optionpassbook (₹)after tax (₹)today's ₹real after-tax rate
savings 3% q2,32,2372,25,4781,76,668−2.45%
FD 7% q2,82,9562,64,4882,07,233+0.71%
cash2,00,0002,00,0001,56,705−4.76%

The scheme. "Doubles in 5 years, guaranteed" means $14.87\%$ a year (Example 8) with no risk, about twice the FD. A genuine risk-free rate that high would be offered by every bank; when someone offers it privately, the most likely explanation is that the money is at serious risk. The mathematics cannot tell her where to invest, but it tells her exactly what each claim implies.

What she learns. Under these assumptions only the FD keeps purchasing power roughly intact, and only just. Changing any assumption — a higher tax slab, higher inflation — can flip the sign of the real return. Interactive 2 lets you test such changes. Getting a real return meaningfully above zero usually means accepting risk (equity, Chapter 3), which is a separate decision.

Exercises

All rates are illustrative. Unless stated otherwise, "compounded annually"; give rupee answers to the nearest rupee and rates to two decimals.

I
Simple interest, compound interest and present value.
  • 1 Find the simple interest and the amount on ₹75,000 at 8% a year for 4 years.
  • 2 Find the amount on ₹75,000 at 8% compounded annually for 4 years. How much more is it than in part 1?
  • 3 A relative lends you ₹50,000 and asks for ₹62,000 back after 2 years. What simple interest rate is this? What compound annual rate?
  • 4 How much must be deposited today at 7.5% to have ₹3,00,000 in 4 years?
  • 5 At 8%, which is worth more today: ₹1,00,000 now, or ₹1,50,000 in 5 years? By how much?
  • 6 ₹10,00,000 is placed for 2 years at 7.2% in (a) a quarterly-payout FD, (b) a cumulative FD compounded quarterly. Find the quarterly payout in (a), the maturity value in (b), and the extra interest in (b).
  • 7 Show that for $0\lt t\lt1$, $(1+r)^t\lt1+rt$ (compare at $r=8\%$, $t=\tfrac12$). Why might a bank compute interest for a part of a year at simple interest?
1 $I=75{,}000\times0.08\times4=$ ₹24,000; amount ₹99,000.
2 $75{,}000\times1.08^4=75{,}000\times1.36049\approx$ ₹1,02,037; ₹3,037 more than simple interest.
3 Simple: $12{,}000=50{,}000\times r\times2$ gives $r=12\%$. Compound: $(1+r)^2=1.24$, $r=\sqrt{1.24}-1\approx11.36\%$. The compound rate is lower because the second year's interest is also charged on the first year's interest.
4 $PV=3{,}00{,}000/1.075^4=3{,}00{,}000/1.335469\approx$ ₹2,24,640.
5 $PV$ of ₹1,50,000 $=1{,}50{,}000/1.08^5\approx$ ₹1,02,087, so the later amount is worth about ₹2,087 more today.
6 (a) $10{,}00{,}000\times0.018=$ ₹18,000 a quarter, ₹1,44,000 in 8 quarters. (b) $10{,}00{,}000\times1.018^8\approx$ ₹11,53,406, interest ₹1,53,406. Extra: ₹9,406, the interest on reinvested interest.
7 $1.08^{0.5}\approx1.03923\lt1.04$. In general $f(t)=(1+r)^t$ is convex and agrees with the line $1+rt$ at $t=0$ and $t=1$, so it lies below the line between them. Simple interest for a broken period therefore pays the depositor slightly more than compounding would — and it is easier to compute.
II
Compounding frequency, effective rate and continuous compounding.
  • 1 Find the effective annual rate of 9% compounded monthly.
  • 2 Find the EAR of 12% compounded daily (365 days) and compounded continuously.
  • 3 What nominal rate compounded quarterly gives an effective 8% a year?
  • 4 Find the maturity value of ₹2,50,000 at 6.5% compounded quarterly for 3 years.
  • 5 Find the value of ₹1,00,000 after 10 years at 7% compounded continuously. What continuous rate turns ₹1 lakh into ₹2 lakh in 9 years?
  • 6 An informal lender charges "only 2% a month", which he calls 24% a year. Find the effective annual rate.
  • 7 For $r=10\%$ compute $(1+r/m)^m$ for $m=1,2,4,12$ and compare with $e^{0.1}$. Explain, with the binomial expansion, why the values increase.
1 $(1+0.09/12)^{12}-1=1.0075^{12}-1\approx9.38\%$.
2 Daily: $(1+0.12/365)^{365}-1\approx12.747\%$; continuous: $e^{0.12}-1\approx12.750\%$. Daily is within 0.003 percentage points of the limit.
3 $r=4\left(1.08^{1/4}-1\right)\approx4\times0.019427\approx7.77\%$ compounded quarterly.
4 $2{,}50{,}000\times(1.01625)^{12}\approx$ ₹3,03,352.
5 $1{,}00{,}000\,e^{0.7}\approx$ ₹2,01,375. For doubling in 9 years: $e^{9\delta}=2$, $\delta=\log2/9\approx7.70\%$.
6 $1.02^{12}-1\approx26.82\%$ a year effective.
7 $1.1$, $1.1025$, $1.103813$, $1.104713$, against $e^{0.1}\approx1.105171$. The $k$-th binomial term is $\frac{r^k}{k!}\prod_{j\lt k}\left(1-\frac jm\right)$, which increases with $m$, and larger $m$ adds more positive terms; the terms tend to $r^k/k!$, whose sum is $e^r$.
III
Inflation, purchasing power and real return.
  • 1 At 6% inflation, what will ₹50,000 of today's monthly household spending cost in 8 years?
  • 2 At 5% inflation, what is the purchasing power (in today's rupees) of ₹1,00,000 received in 12 years?
  • 3 An FD pays 7.25% effective and inflation is 6.5%. Find the exact real return and the approximate one.
  • 4 In part 3, interest is taxed at 30%. Find the after-tax real return. Interpret its sign.
  • 5 What nominal annual return gives a real return of 2% when inflation is 5.5%?
  • 6 A price index rose from 120 to 150 in 4 years. Find the average annual inflation rate and the percentage fall in the purchasing power of ₹1 over the 4 years.
1 $50{,}000\times1.06^8\approx$ ₹79,692 a month.
2 $1{,}00{,}000/1.05^{12}\approx$ ₹55,684.
3 Exact $1.0725/1.065-1\approx0.70\%$; approximate $0.75\%$.
4 After tax the nominal rate is $7.25\%\times0.7=5.075\%$; real $1.05075/1.065-1\approx-1.34\%$. Negative: the deposit loses purchasing power each year, even though its rupee balance grows.
5 $1+r_{\text{nom}}=1.02\times1.055=1.0761$, so $r_{\text{nom}}=7.61\%$ (not $7.5\%$).
6 $(150/120)^{1/4}-1=1.25^{1/4}-1\approx5.74\%$ a year. ₹1 now buys $120/150=0.8$ of what it bought 4 years ago: a 20% fall (not 25%).
IV
Doubling time and decisions.
  • 1 Find the exact doubling time at 7.5% compounded annually and compare it with the rule of 72.
  • 2 At 6% inflation, in how many years does the purchasing power of a fixed pension halve? Use the rule of 70, then compute exactly.
  • 3 How long does money take to triple at 9% compounded annually? Compare with a "rule of 114": $T_3\approx114/(100r)$.
  • 4 A scheme says "₹1 lakh becomes ₹3 lakh in 3 years". Find the implied annual rate and say what it suggests.
  • 5 Show that under continuous compounding the doubling time is exactly $\log2/r$, and evaluate it at $r=5\%$.
  • 6 Deposit A pays 7.6% compounded annually, deposit B pays 7.4% compounded monthly. Which is better, and by how much on ₹5,00,000 over 5 years?
1 $\log2/\log1.075\approx9.58$ years; rule of 72: $72/7.5=9.6$ years — excellent agreement.
2 Rule of 70: $70/6\approx11.7$ years. Exact: $\log2/\log1.06\approx11.90$ years.
3 $\log3/\log1.09\approx12.75$ years; rule of 114 gives $114/9\approx12.67$ years. (114 comes from $100\log3\approx109.9$ times the correction factor $1+r/2=1.04$ at $r=8\%$, exactly as 72 comes from 69.3.)
4 $3^{1/3}-1\approx44.2\%$ a year. A "safe" 44% a year is far beyond any deposit rate; it suggests either very high risk or a fraud.
5 $e^{rT}=2\iff rT=\log2\iff T=\log2/r$. At $5\%$: $0.693147/0.05\approx13.86$ years.
6 EAR of B $=(1+0.074/12)^{12}-1\approx7.656\%\gt7.6\%$, so B is better. On ₹5,00,000 for 5 years: A gives $5{,}00{,}000\times1.076^5\approx$ ₹7,21,160, B gives $5{,}00{,}000\times(1+0.074/12)^{60}\approx$ ₹7,23,045 — ₹1,886 more.
🎯 Practice corner NISM-styleCase studyInterview

E1. NISM-style A deposit earns 8% a year compounded quarterly. Its effective annual yield is closest to (A) 8.00% (B) 8.16% (C) 8.24% (D) 8.30%.

Idea EAR $=(1+r/m)^m-1$ with $m=4$.
Compute $1.02^4-1=0.082432$, i.e. 8.24%. (A) ignores compounding; (B) is half-yearly compounding, $1.04^2-1$.
Answer (C).

E2. NISM-style An investment earns a nominal 9% in a year in which inflation is 6%. The real rate of return is (A) 3.00% (B) 2.83% (C) 15.54% (D) 1.50%.

Idea Fisher: $r_{\text{real}}=\dfrac{1.09}{1.06}-1$.
Compute $1.09/1.06=1.028302$, so 2.83%. (A) is the approximation $9-6$; (C) is $1.09\times1.06-1$, multiplying instead of dividing; (D) divides the difference by 2 for no reason.
Answer (B).

E3. NISM-style By the rule of 72, an investment that doubles in 6 years earns about (A) 6% (B) 10% (C) 12% (D) 14.4% a year.

Compute $72/6=12\%$. The exact rate is $2^{1/6}-1\approx12.25\%$, so the rule is close.
Answer (C).

E4. Case study Mr Iyer retires with ₹20,00,000 and places it in a quarterly-payout FD at an illustrative 7.4% a year, renewing at the same rate. Assume inflation of 6% a year. (a) What is his quarterly income? (b) After 10 years, what is one quarterly payment worth in today's rupees? (c) How large would the deposit need to be in 10 years to give the same real income? (d) What part of each quarter's interest could he spend if he reinvested the rest so that the principal keeps pace with inflation?

(a) $20{,}00{,}000\times0.074/4=$ ₹37,000 a quarter (₹1,48,000 a year).
(b) The payout stays ₹37,000 in rupees, but its purchasing power falls: $37{,}000/1.06^{10}\approx$ ₹20,661 of today's money — about 44% less.
(c) The deposit must grow with prices: $20{,}00{,}000\times1.06^{10}\approx$ ₹35,81,695.
(d) For the principal to grow at 6% a year it must grow by $1.06^{1/4}-1\approx1.4674\%$ a quarter. The quarterly interest is $1.85\%$, so he can spend $1.85\%-1.4674\%\approx0.3826\%$ of the principal: about ₹7,652 in the first quarter, rising with inflation. Keeping capital "intact in real terms" leaves very little to spend — a key reason retirement plans in §8.1 also use growth assets and planned withdrawals.

E5. Case study Two hypothetical offers for ₹3,00,000 for 3 years: (A) a company deposit at 8.4% compounded annually; (B) a bank FD at 8.1% compounded quarterly. (a) Find both maturity values and effective rates. (b) With interest taxed at an illustrative 20% each year and inflation 5.5%, find each real after-tax rate. (c) What is the extra amount at maturity the company deposit offers, and what does it pay for?

(a) (A) $3{,}00{,}000\times1.084^3\approx$ ₹3,82,128, EAR 8.400%. (B) $3{,}00{,}000\times1.02025^{12}\approx$ ₹3,81,593, EAR $1.02025^4-1\approx8.349\%$.
(b) After tax: (A) $8.4\%\times0.8=6.72\%$, real $1.0672/1.055-1\approx1.16\%$; (B) $8.349\%\times0.8\approx6.680\%$, real $\approx1.12\%$.
(c) Only ₹3,82,128 − ₹3,81,593 = ₹535 more over three years. This is the whole reward for accepting the company's credit risk — the chance it delays or fails to repay — which bank deposits carry to a much smaller degree. Whether ₹535 is enough is a judgement about risk, not arithmetic; the arithmetic shows how small the reward is. (Credit spreads are studied in §2.3.)

E6. Interview Without a calculator, roughly how long does it take money to grow tenfold at 8% a year compounded annually? You may use $\log_2 10\approx3.32$.

Idea Tenfold $=2^{3.32}$, i.e. $3.32$ doublings; each doubling takes $72/8=9$ years.
Estimate $3.32\times9\approx30$ years.
Check Exactly $\log10/\log1.08=2.302585/0.076961\approx29.92$ years. A good interview answer also says what the estimate assumes: a constant 8% every year, no tax and no withdrawals.
🧑‍🏫 For the teacher

Suggested plan — 2 lectures × 60 min.

  1. Growth and discounting. Open with the 📍 situation and ask the class to rank Ananya's options before any calculation. Simple vs compound (Definition 1.1, Theorem 1.1) with Example 1 on the board; present value as "running the film backwards" (Example 2); FD payout options (Example 3). Then compounding frequency and EAR (Theorem 1.2, Example 4). Project Interactive 1 at 36% so the staircase is obvious, then lower the rate to a realistic 7% and ask why the curves almost coincide. Derive $e^{rt}$ as a limit (Theorem 1.3).
  2. Inflation and doubling. Inflation and purchasing power (Definitions 1.3–1.4), Fisher (Theorem 1.4) with Example 6. Project Interactive 2, set tax to 30% and ask students to find the deposit rate at which the green curve stays flat. Doubling times and the rules of 72/70 (Theorem 1.5) and Example 8; finish with the 📈 Market case and Practice corner E4.

Class activity. Each student picks a real expense (a phone, a two-wheeler, a year's fees), assumes an inflation rate, and computes its cost in 10 years and the deposit needed today to pay for it at an assumed FD rate. Compare answers under two inflation assumptions to show sensitivity.

Misconceptions to watch for. "2% a month = 24% a year"; confusing the nominal and effective rates; subtracting inflation instead of dividing at high rates; thinking a payout FD compounds; reading the rule of 72 as exact; believing that more rupees means more wealth.

Suggested homework. I(2, 3, 5, 6), II(1, 3, 6, 7), III(3, 4, 5, 6), IV(1, 4, 6); Practice corner E1, E2, E5.

🛠️ Do it yourselfSpreadsheet mini-project · about 45 minutes

Project. Build a "deposit vs inflation" sheet that compares any deposit offer with inflation, after tax, year by year — and check the rules of 72 and 70 against the exact formula.

Why it matters. Deposit advertisements quote nominal rates with different compounding; news reports quote inflation; your tax depends on your slab. A sheet that puts the three together answers the only question that matters: what will this money buy?

What to do.

  1. Inputs in cells B1:B5: principal (B1), nominal rate (B2), compounding periods per year (B3), tax rate on interest (B4, illustrative), inflation (B5).
  2. Effective rate in B6: =EFFECT(B2,B3) (or =(1+B2/B3)^B3-1); after-tax rate =B6*(1-B4) in B7; real after-tax rate =(1+B7)/(1+B5)-1 in B8.
  3. In A12:A42 put the years 0 to 30; in B12 (and copy down): =$B$1*(1+$B$6)^A12 (passbook), C: =$B$1*(1+$B$7)^A12 (after tax), D: =C12/(1+$B$5)^A12 (today's rupees). Chart the three columns.
  4. In a second block, for rates 1%, 2%, …, 30%, compute =LN(2)/LN(1+r), =72/(100*r) and =70/(100*r). Plot the percentage error of each rule against $r$.
  5. Download a few years of the official all-India CPI from the government's statistics website and compute each year's inflation as =I1/I0-1; replace the constant inflation in B5 by the actual year-by-year values.

Python version: import math; ear=(1+r/m)**m-1; real=(1+ear*(1-tau))/(1+pi)-1; T2=math.log(2)/math.log(1+r).

Hand in: the chart, the deposit rate at which the real after-tax return is exactly zero for your chosen tax and inflation (use Goal Seek on B8), and the range of rates where the rule of 72 is within 1% of the exact doubling time.

Going further. Use the NOMINAL function to convert an EAR back to a nominal rate; extend the sheet with a monthly-payout FD whose payouts are reinvested in a savings account at a lower rate.

Instructor note: the break-even deposit rate solves $1+r(1-\tau)=1+\pi$, i.e. $r=\pi/(1-\tau)$: at $\pi=6\%$ and $\tau=30\%$ it is $8.57\%$ effective. The rule of 72 is within 1% of the exact doubling time for rates from about 5.75% to 10% (it is exact near 7.85%); the rule of 70 is within 1% for rates up to about 4% and exact near 2%.

🧪 Self-check quiz

0/5 correct

Q1. Which illustrative quote has the highest effective annual rate?

Q2. A deposit earns 8% and inflation is 6%. The exact real return is about

Q3. As the number $m$ of compounding periods per year tends to infinity, $(1+r/m)^m$

Q4. With inflation at 7% a year, ₹1,00,000 received in 10 years has the purchasing power today of about

Q5. In a quarterly-payout FD whose payouts are spent, the deposit grows