1.2 EMIs, SIPs and Annuities
Equal payments over time — the EMI on a home loan, a monthly SIP, a pension — are geometric series in disguise. Derive the EMI formula, read an amortisation schedule, decide between prepayment options, size a SIP or step-up SIP for a goal, and see through the flat-rate trap.
📍 The situation
Rohan, 29, has found a flat in Bengaluru and been offered a home loan of ₹40,00,000 for 20 years at an illustrative 8.5% a year on a reducing balance. The bank's letter states an EMI of about ₹34,713. Rohan has three questions. Where does that number come from, and why, after a year of paying almost ₹4.2 lakh, does his loan statement show that the balance has fallen by only about ₹80,000? If he gets a ₹5 lakh bonus in five years, should he ask the bank to reduce his EMI or his tenure — and how much interest does each save? And when his sister starts a ₹5,000 monthly SIP, how much might it grow to, and what difference does raising it by 10% every year make?
Meanwhile a car dealer offers Rohan's sister a car loan at "only 6% flat", which sounds cheaper than the bank's 9%. Is it? All of these are questions about annuities — equal payments at equal intervals — and every one of them is answered by the formula for the sum of a geometric progression, the mathematical engine of this section.
Loan rates, SIP return assumptions, tax rates and prepayment rules on this page are illustrative. An "assumed 12% return" is an input to a calculation, not a forecast or promise — market-linked returns vary from year to year and can be negative. Check current lender terms, RBI rules on prepayment charges and the Income Tax Department's rules on home-loan deductions. People and products are hypothetical; nothing here is investment advice.
Annuities as Geometric Series
An EMI, a SIP, a recurring rent and a monthly pension all have the same shape: an equal amount at equal intervals. To value such a stream we move each payment to a common date with the compounding and discounting of §1.1, then add. The sum is always a geometric progression.
An annuity is a sequence of equal payments $A$ made at equal intervals (periods) for $n$ periods, valued at a periodic rate $i$ (for monthly payments and an annual nominal rate $r$ compounded monthly, $i=r/12$).
- In an ordinary annuity (annuity-immediate) the payments come at the end of each period — loan EMIs, salaries, most pensions.
- In an annuity due the payments come at the start of each period — rent, insurance premiums, and a SIP that is invested at the beginning of each month.
- A perpetuity is an annuity that continues for ever.
For any real $x\ne1$ and integer $n\ge1$, $$1+x+x^2+\cdots+x^{n-1}=\frac{x^n-1}{x-1}.$$ If $|x|\lt1$, then $x^n\to0$ and $\displaystyle\sum_{k=0}^{\infty}x^k=\frac{1}{1-x}$.
Why. Call the sum $S$. Then $xS=x+x^2+\cdots+x^n$, and subtracting, $xS-S=x^n-1$; divide by $x-1\ne0$. ∎ This three-line trick — multiply by the ratio and subtract — is behind every formula in this section.
Payments of $A$ at the end of each of $n$ periods, at periodic rate $i\gt0$, have
future value (at the last payment) $$FV=A\,\frac{(1+i)^n-1}{i},$$
present value (one period before the first payment) $$PV=A\,\frac{1-(1+i)^{-n}}{i}.$$
For an annuity due (payments at the start of each period) multiply both by $(1+i)$: every payment has one more period to grow. A perpetuity of $A$ per period has $PV=A/i$.
Derivation. The payment made at the end of period $k$ grows for $n-k$ more periods, to $A(1+i)^{n-k}$. Adding, $FV=A\left[1+(1+i)+\cdots+(1+i)^{n-1}\right]$, a geometric progression with ratio $x=1+i$; Theorem 1.6 gives $A\frac{(1+i)^n-1}{i}$. Discounting by $(1+i)^n$ gives $PV$. For a perpetuity let $n\to\infty$: $(1+i)^{-n}\to0$. ∎
Loan EMIs and the Amortisation Schedule
A home loan in India is usually a reducing-balance loan: each month interest is charged on what you still owe, and the fixed EMI first pays that interest; the rest reduces the balance.
A loan of $L$ at annual rate $r$ on a monthly reducing balance has periodic rate $i=r/12$. If $B_k$ is the balance after the $k$-th monthly payment $E$ (with $B_0=L$), then $$B_k=(1+i)B_{k-1}-E.$$ The equated monthly instalment (EMI) is the constant $E$ for which $B_n=0$ after $n$ payments. In month $k$ the interest component is $iB_{k-1}$ and the principal component is $E-iB_{k-1}$. The table of these numbers, month by month, is the amortisation schedule.
For a loan $L$, periodic rate $i\gt0$ and $n$ monthly payments:
- $$E=\frac{L\,i\,(1+i)^n}{(1+i)^n-1}=\frac{L\,i}{1-(1+i)^{-n}}.$$
- The balance after $k$ payments is the present value of the remaining payments: $$B_k=E\,\frac{1-(1+i)^{-(n-k)}}{i}.$$
- The principal component of payment $k$ is $(E-iL)(1+i)^{k-1}$: it grows geometrically, so the interest component $E-(E-iL)(1+i)^{k-1}$ shrinks. Total interest paid is $nE-L$.
Derivation. Unwinding the recursion, $$B_k=L(1+i)^k-E\left[(1+i)^{k-1}+\cdots+1\right],$$ and by Theorem 1.6 the bracket is $\frac{(1+i)^k-1}{i}$, so $$B_k=L(1+i)^k-E\,\frac{(1+i)^k-1}{i}.$$ Setting $B_n=0$ and solving for $E$ gives (1); equivalently, the loan is the present value of the $n$ EMIs (Theorem 1.7). Substituting (1) back gives (2). For (3), the principal component is $P_k=E-iB_{k-1}$, and $P_{k+1}-P_k=-i(B_k-B_{k-1})=iP_k$, so $P_{k+1}=(1+i)P_k$ with $P_1=E-iL$. ∎
Prepayment, Rate Changes and the Length of a Loan
A part-prepayment is an extra payment that reduces the outstanding balance at once. Afterwards the lender either keeps the EMI and reduces the tenure, or keeps the end date and reduces the EMI (recomputed by Theorem 1.8 for the new balance and the remaining months).
In a floating-rate loan the interest rate is linked to a benchmark and can change during the loan. When the rate changes, lenders often keep the EMI and change the remaining tenure, or change the EMI, or both. Prepayment charges and the options offered depend on the loan agreement and on RBI rules — check the current position.
A balance $B$ repaid by EMIs $E$ at periodic rate $i\gt0$ is cleared after $$n=\frac{-\log\left(1-\dfrac{iB}{E}\right)}{\log(1+i)}$$ payments (round up; the last payment is smaller), provided $E\gt iB$. If $E\le iB$ the EMI does not even cover the month's interest, and the balance never decreases (for $E\lt iB$ it grows — negative amortisation).
Why. Solve $B=E\,\frac{1-(1+i)^{-n}}{i}$ for $n$: $(1+i)^{-n}=1-\frac{iB}{E}$, then take logarithms. The right side is positive only if $E\gt iB$. If $E\le iB$, the recursion gives $B_1=(1+i)B-E\ge B$, so the balance can never fall. ∎
After 60 EMIs Rohan's balance is ₹35,25,087 (rate unchanged at an illustrative 8.5%, 180 EMIs of ₹34,713 left; remaining interest $180\times34{,}712.93-35{,}25{,}087\approx$ ₹27,23,240). He prepays ₹5,00,000, leaving $B=$ ₹30,25,087.
- Reduce tenure. Theorem 1.9: $iB/E=0.0070833\times30{,}25{,}087/34{,}712.93\approx0.6173$, $n=-\log(0.3827)/\log(1.0070833)\approx136.07$: 136 full EMIs and a final payment of about ₹2,575. Interest from now on ≈ ₹16,98,446, so interest saved ≈ ₹10,24,793, and the last payment falls 43 months (3 years 7 months) earlier than planned.
- Reduce EMI. New EMI over 180 months: $E'=30{,}25{,}087\times0.0070833/(1-1.0070833^{-180})\approx$ ₹29,789, i.e. ₹4,924 a month less. Interest from now on $=180\times29{,}789.23-30{,}25{,}087\approx$ ₹23,36,974, so interest saved ≈ ₹3,86,266.
- Is "reduce tenure" really ₹6.4 lakh better? Not quite. With "reduce EMI", Rohan keeps ₹4,924 a month. If he invested exactly that at 8.5% (compounded monthly) for 136 months, the fund (about ₹11.20 lakh), topped up by the ₹2,575 that "reduce tenure" would still pay in month 137, would exactly cover his remaining 44 EMIs of ₹29,789 — both plans have the same present value at the loan rate. "Reduce tenure" saves more interest because it repays the bank faster; the real question is what return Rohan could earn on the money he does not prepay.
- Prepay or invest? Prepaying "earns" the loan rate, 8.5%, with certainty. If the ₹5 lakh were invested instead for 15 years, an assumed 6% would give about ₹11.98 lakh, 8.5% about ₹17.00 lakh and 10% about ₹20.89 lakh — but market returns are uncertain and taxed, and home-loan interest may carry tax deductions that change the comparison (check the current rules).
| option | EMI (₹) | EMIs left | future interest (₹) | saved (₹) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| no prepayment | 34,713 | 180 | 27,23,240 | — |
| reduce tenure | 34,713 | 137 (last ≈ 2,575) | 16,98,446 | 10,24,793 |
| reduce EMI | 29,789 | 180 | 23,36,974 | 3,86,266 |
The mathematics, not a recommendation. The arithmetic shows (i) prepayment early in a loan has a large effect, (ii) "reduce tenure" maximises interest saved, (iii) "reduce EMI" gives monthly cash-flow flexibility, and (iv) the honest comparison is with the after-tax, risk-adjusted return available elsewhere. Which matters most depends on Rohan's job security, emergency fund (§8.1) and other goals.
SIPs, Step-up SIPs and the Flat-Rate Trap
A Systematic Investment Plan is an annuity in the other direction: instead of repaying a loan you build a corpus. Mutual-fund SIPs buy units at the day's NAV (§2.2); here we only need the growth arithmetic, under an assumed constant annual return $R$ — a planning assumption, never a promise.
A SIP invests a fixed amount $A$ every month. A step-up (top-up) SIP raises the monthly amount by a fixed percentage $g$ once a year: $A$ a month in year 1, $A(1+g)$ in year 2, $A(1+g)^2$ in year 3, and so on.
Monthly rate convention. An annual return $R$ corresponds to the monthly rate $i=(1+R)^{1/12}-1$ (compounding twelve months reproduces $R$). Many online calculators instead use $i=R/12$, which corresponds to the higher effective rate $(1+R/12)^{12}-1$. Always state which you use.
A SIP of $A$ at the start of each month for $n$ months, at monthly rate $i\gt0$, is worth at the end of month $n$ $$FV=A\,\frac{(1+i)^n-1}{i}\,(1+i).$$ With an annual step-up $g$ for $Y$ years, write $s=\frac{(1+i)^{12}-1}{i}(1+i)$ (one year of ₹1-a-month SIP) and $R_1=(1+i)^{12}$. Then $$FV=A\,s\,\frac{R_1^{\,Y}-(1+g)^Y}{R_1-(1+g)}\quad(R_1\ne1+g),$$ and $FV=A\,s\,Y R_1^{\,Y-1}$ when $R_1=1+g$.
Derivation. The first formula is the annuity-due future value of Theorem 1.7. For the step-up SIP, year $j$'s twelve instalments are worth $A(1+g)^{j-1}s$ at the end of year $j$, and then grow for $Y-j$ more years: the total is $As\sum_{j=1}^{Y}(1+g)^{j-1}R_1^{\,Y-j}=As\,R_1^{\,Y-1}\sum_{j=0}^{Y-1}x^j$ with $x=\frac{1+g}{R_1}$. Theorem 1.6 sums it; if $x=1$ every term is $1$. ∎
Flat rates. Some consumer loans — for vehicles, gadgets or personal loans from non-bank lenders — are quoted at a "flat" rate, which sounds much lower than a bank's reducing-balance rate. It is not the same kind of number.
A loan $L$ for $n$ months at a flat rate $f$ a year charges interest on the original amount for the whole term, $I=Lf\,\tfrac{n}{12}$, and divides principal plus interest equally: $E=\dfrac{L\left(1+f\,\frac{n}{12}\right)}{n}$. The equivalent reducing-balance rate is the annual rate $r$ for which Theorem 1.8 gives the same EMI.
For $n\ge2$ and $f\gt0$, the equivalent reducing-balance rate is strictly greater than $f$; it is the unique root $r$ of $$\frac{L\,(r/12)}{1-(1+r/12)^{-n}}=\frac{L\left(1+f\,\frac n{12}\right)}{n},$$ found numerically. A rough estimate is the constant-ratio formula $r\approx\dfrac{2nf}{n+1}$ — close to double the flat rate (it slightly overstates $r$).
Why the flat rate understates the cost. Under a flat rate you pay interest on the full $L$ for the whole term, although on average you owe only about half of it (the balance falls roughly linearly from $L$ to $0$). Interest $Lf\frac{n}{12}$ on an average balance of about $L\frac{n+1}{2n}$ is a rate of about $f\cdot\frac{2n}{n+1}$. For uniqueness: the reducing-balance EMI increases strictly with $r$, from $L/n$ at $r=0$ to $\infty$, and the flat EMI exceeds $L/n$; and at $r=f$ the reducing-balance EMI is less than the flat one because it charges interest only on the falling balance. ∎
- "My EMI mostly repays the loan." Early on it mostly pays interest: 82% of Rohan's first EMI, and principal overtakes interest only in month 143 (Example 3).
- "Total interest is just rate × years × loan." That is the flat-rate formula; on a reducing balance the total is $nE-L$ (₹43.3 lakh for Rohan, not $0.085\times20\times40$ lakh = ₹68 lakh).
- Comparing a flat rate with a reducing rate. 6% flat is about 11% reducing (Example 7).
- "Reduce tenure always beats reduce EMI." It saves more interest, but the two are equivalent at the loan rate if the EMI saving is invested; the choice is about cash flow and alternatives (Market case).
- Ignoring a rate rise. A one-point rise on a long loan can add years (Example 4); if the EMI falls below the month's interest, the balance grows.
- Treating an assumed SIP return as a promise. "12% a year" is an input. Real returns vary, can be negative for years, and their order matters (§3.3).
- Mixing conventions. $R/12$ and $(1+R)^{1/12}-1$ give different answers — ₹1.43 lakh apart in Example 5.
- Forgetting timing. Start-of-month (annuity due) and end-of-month (ordinary) values differ by the factor $1+i$.
- "Doubling the SIP tenure doubles the corpus." It does far more: compounding makes later years much larger (try 15 vs 30 years in Interactive 2).
- Rent vs buy by EMI vs rent. The EMI includes saving (principal); the economic comparison is interest + opportunity cost + upkeep − appreciation (Example 8).
Exercises
All rates are illustrative. Loans: monthly reducing balance with $i=r/12$, EMIs at month-end. SIPs: invested at the start of each month with $i=(1+R)^{1/12}-1$ unless stated otherwise. Round rupee answers to the nearest rupee.
- 1 Evaluate $1+1.01+1.01^2+\cdots+1.01^{59}$.
- 2 ₹2,000 is deposited at the end of every month for 5 years at 9% a year compounded monthly. Find the future value.
- 3 Repeat part 2 with deposits at the start of each month.
- 4 Find the present value of ₹15,000 a month for 10 years (end of month) at 6% a year compounded monthly.
- 5 A prize offers ₹50 lakh now or ₹6 lakh at the end of each year for 12 years. At 7% a year, which is worth more today?
- 6 Find the present value of a perpetuity of ₹12,000 a year (end of year) at 8%, and explain it as a limit of Theorem 1.7.
- 7 How many end-of-month deposits of ₹10,000 at 8% a year compounded monthly are needed to reach ₹10,00,000?
- 1 Find the EMI on a car loan of ₹8,00,000 at 9.5% for 5 years.
- 2 Find the total interest on the loan of part 1.
- 3 Split the first EMI of part 1 into interest and principal.
- 4 Find the balance of the part 1 loan after 2 years.
- 5 For ₹30,00,000 at 8.75%, find the EMI and total interest for tenures of 25 and 15 years.
- 6 A borrower can afford an EMI of ₹25,000. What is the largest loan at 9% for 20 years?
- 7 For the 25-year loan of part 5, in which month does the principal component first exceed the interest component?
- 1 Verify the EMI and the balance. After the 36th EMI the borrower prepays ₹3,00,000. If the EMI is unchanged, how many more EMIs are needed?
- 2 If instead the remaining 144-month tenure is kept, what is the new EMI?
- 3 Find the interest saved in parts 1 and 2 compared with no prepayment.
- 4 Without the prepayment, the rate rises to 10% after the 36th EMI and the EMI is unchanged. How many EMIs remain?
- 5 Explain what would happen in part 4 if the rate rose so much that $iB\ge E$, and what a lender must then do.
- 1 A SIP of ₹3,000 a month for 10 years at an assumed 10% a year. Find the monthly rate and the corpus.
- 2 Recompute part 1 with $i=R/12$. How large is the difference?
- 3 What monthly SIP reaches ₹50,00,000 in 20 years at an assumed 11% a year?
- 4 A SIP starts at ₹4,000 a month and steps up 8% a year for 10 years, at an assumed 10% a year. Find the corpus and the total invested.
- 5 A personal loan of ₹2,00,000 for 2 years at 7% flat: find the EMI and the equivalent reducing-balance rate.
- 6 In one or two sentences, explain to a friend why "7% flat" is not cheaper than "11% reducing".
- 7 A ₹50 lakh flat; 20% down; loan at 9%; down payment could earn 7%; upkeep 1% a year; assumed appreciation 3%; rent ₹15,000 a month. Compare first-year owning cost (use interest ≈ loan × rate) with rent, and find the break-even appreciation.
E1. NISM-style An investor puts ₹10,000 at the beginning of each year for 3 years into a deposit earning 10% compounded annually. Its value at the end of the third year is (A) ₹33,100 (B) ₹36,410 (C) ₹30,000 (D) ₹39,930.
E2. NISM-style In a reducing-balance loan repaid by a fixed EMI, as the loan progresses the interest component of each EMI (A) increases (B) decreases (C) stays the same (D) first increases, then decreases.
E3. NISM-style A SIP of ₹5,000 is invested at the start of each month for 2 years and earns 1% a month. Its value at the end of 2 years is closest to (A) ₹1,20,000 (B) ₹1,34,867 (C) ₹1,36,216 (D) ₹1,52,368.
E4. Case study For a ₹7,00,000 car loan over 4 years, a dealer offers 5.5% flat and a bank offers an illustrative 9.25% on a reducing balance. (a) Find both EMIs and total interest. (b) Find the dealer loan's equivalent reducing rate. (c) Which is cheaper, and by how much in total?
E5. Case study Priya, 30, wants ₹1 crore at 50. Assume (as a planning input) 10% a year, $i=1.1^{1/12}-1$, investments at the start of each month. (a) What flat monthly SIP is needed? (b) If she steps up her SIP by 10% every year, what starting SIP is needed? (c) If she delays and starts a flat SIP at 35, what is needed?
E6. Interview A friend says: "Pay half your EMI every two weeks instead of the full EMI monthly, and your 20-year home loan finishes years early — banks hate this trick." What is really going on? Estimate the effect for ₹40 lakh at 8.5% over 20 years.
Suggested plan — 2 lectures × 60 min.
- Annuities and EMIs. Start from the 📍 situation: show Rohan's EMI and ask the class to guess how much of the first EMI is interest (most guess under 50%). Derive Theorem 1.6 on the board ("multiply by the ratio and subtract"), then Theorem 1.7 and Example 1. Derive the EMI from the balance recursion (Theorem 1.8) and do Examples 2–3. Project Interactive 1 with no prepayment; ask when the blue part of the bars overtakes the red.
- Decisions. Theorem 1.9 and Example 4 (a rate rise), then the 📈 Market case with Interactive 1 switching between "reduce tenure" and "reduce EMI". SIPs and step-ups (Theorem 1.10, Examples 5–6) with Interactive 2 — switch the monthly-rate convention live. Finish with the flat-rate trap (Example 7) and the rent-vs-buy discussion (Example 8).
Class activity. Each student picks a goal (a two-wheeler in 3 years, higher studies in 6, a down payment in 10), states it in future rupees with an assumed inflation (§1.1), and computes the flat and step-up SIP needed under two return assumptions. Pairs then check each other's numbers with Interactive 2.
Misconceptions to watch for. EMI = interest + equal principal; flat rate = reducing rate; total interest = rate × years × loan; an assumed return is a promise; reduce-tenure is "free money" compared with reduce-EMI; start- vs end-of-month makes no difference.
Suggested homework. I(2, 4, 5, 7), II(1, 4, 5, 6), III(1–3), IV(1, 3, 5, 7); Practice corner E1, E4, E5.
Project. Build a full amortisation schedule for a loan, with a prepayment switch, and check it against the closed-form formulas of this section.
Why it matters. A schedule you have built yourself lets you test any offer — a rate change, a prepayment, a top-up loan — instead of relying on a lender's summary, and it shows the geometric growth of the principal component with your own eyes.
What to do.
- Inputs: loan in B1, annual rate in B2, years in B3. Monthly rate
=B2/12in B4, months=B3*12in B5, EMI=PMT(B4,B5,-B1)in B6. Check it against Theorem 1.8:=B1*B4/(1-(1+B4)^-B5). - Schedule from row 10: month
kin A, opening balance in B (B10=B1), interest C10=B10*$B$4, principal D10=MIN($B$6-C10,B10), prepayment E10 (type amounts by hand), closing balance F10=B10-D10-E10; then B11=F10. Copy down 360 rows. - Check three formulas: the closing balance after month
kequals=PV($B$4,$B$5-k,-$B$6)when there is no prepayment; the principal column grows by the factor1+B4each month; total interest=SUM(C:C)equalsn*EMI − L. - Enter a prepayment in month 60 and find the new payoff month (first row with closing balance ≤ 0); compare with Theorem 1.9 and
=NPER(B4,-B6,balance). - Second sheet: a SIP schedule with a yearly step-up — monthly amount
=A*(1+g)^INT((k-1)/12), value=(previous value + amount)*(1+i)— and check the total against Theorem 1.10; then use=RATE(n,-EMI,L)*12to find the reducing rate of any flat-rate offer.
Python version: B=L; for k in range(1,n+1): I=B*i; P=E-I; B=B-P — store I, P, B in lists and plot them.
Hand in: the yearly totals of interest and principal (a chart like Interactive 1), the month in which principal first exceeds interest, and the interest saved by your chosen prepayment under both options.
Going further. Add a rate-change column so that the rate can differ month by month (a floating-rate loan), and keep the EMI fixed: watch the tenure stretch, and find the rate at which the balance stops falling.
🧪 Self-check quiz
Q1. The EMI formula $E=\dfrac{Li}{1-(1+i)^{-n}}$ comes from
Q2. For ₹10,00,000 at 12% for 10 years (EMI ₹14,347), the total interest paid is about
Q3. After a part-prepayment, compared with keeping the tenure and reducing the EMI, keeping the EMI and reducing the tenure
Q4. A SIP invested at the start of each month is an example of
Q5. A 3-year loan at 6% flat has an equivalent reducing-balance rate of about