Chapter 6 · Derivatives on NSE: Futures and Options

6.2 Options: Payoffs, Strategies and Put–Call Parity

An option is a right without an obligation — and that one asymmetry bends a straight futures payoff into a hockey stick. Read call and put payoffs, build covered calls, protective puts, spreads, straddles and iron condors with their break-evens and maximum profit and loss, and tie call and put prices together with put–call parity.

📍 The situation

Meera holds about ₹11 lakh in a Nifty 50 index ETF — roughly the same exposure as one lot of index futures (§6.1). She is worried about the next month but, unlike Kavya in §6.1, she does not want to give up the upside. A friend suggests "buying a put" as insurance. Her colleague Vikram, meanwhile, says he "earns a steady income" every week by selling options, and her nephew has bought a far out-of-the-money call for "only ₹50" and dreams of a ten-bagger.

Who is taking what risk? What does Meera's insurance cost, and how much does it actually protect? Where does Vikram's income come from, and what is his worst week? How far must the index move before the nephew's call pays anything? Every one of these questions is answered by drawing a payoff diagram — a piecewise linear function of the index at expiry — and finding where it crosses zero and where it is highest and lowest. A single no-arbitrage argument, put–call parity, then ties the price of every call to the price of the matching put.

⚠️ About the numbers on this page

The index level (22,000), option premiums, interest rate and dividend yield are hypothetical. The premiums in our "option chain" were generated by the pricing model of §6.3 with an illustrative volatility of 14%, 30 days to expiry, $r=7\%$ and $q=1.2\%$, then rounded to whole points — real quotes have bid–ask spreads and move every second. Lot sizes, margins for option sellers, expiry days and the number of weekly contracts are set by NSE and SEBI and change; we use an illustrative lot of 50. Check the current NSE contract specifications and SEBI circulars. Costs and taxes are ignored unless stated. Nothing here is investment advice.

Calls, Puts and Moneyness

📘 Definition 6.7 — Call and put options

A call option gives its holder the right, but not the obligation, to buy the underlying at a fixed strike price $K$; a put option gives the right to sell at $K$. A European option can be exercised only at expiry $T$; an American option at any time up to $T$.

The buyer (holder, long side) pays the option premium ($c$ for a call, $p$ for a put, per unit) to the seller (writer, short side) at the start. The holder's loss is limited to the premium; the writer receives the premium and takes on the obligation, so the writer must deposit margin.

On NSE, index options are European and cash-settled; stock options are generally settled by delivery of shares if exercised — check the current rules. One contract covers one lot of $Q$ units, so premiums quoted per unit (per index point) are multiplied by $Q$.

📐 Theorem 6.6 (Formula) — Payoff, profit and break-even at expiry

Per unit, with $S_T$ the underlying's price at expiry, $x^+=\max(x,0)$:

positionpayoff at expiryprofit at expirybreak-evenmax profitmax loss
long call$(S_T-K)^+$$(S_T-K)^+-c$$K+c$unlimited$c$
short call$-(S_T-K)^+$$c-(S_T-K)^+$$K+c$$c$unlimited
long put$(K-S_T)^+$$(K-S_T)^+-p$$K-p$$K-p$$p$
short put$-(K-S_T)^+$$p-(K-S_T)^+$$K-p$$p$$K-p$

(The "max" for a put uses $S_T\ge0$; it ignores the interest that could be earned on the premium.) A holder exercises only when it pays: a call when $S_T\gt K$, a put when $S_T\lt K$.

Why. At expiry a call is worth $S_T-K$ if $S_T\gt K$ (buy at $K$ something worth $S_T$) and nothing otherwise (the holder walks away), which is $(S_T-K)^+$; similarly for the put. Subtract the premium paid for the profit; the seller's numbers are the negatives. Break-even solves "profit $=0$" on the sloping piece. The call payoff grows without bound as $S_T\to\infty$, so a short call can lose without limit; a put's payoff is at most $K$ (when $S_T=0$). ∎

📘 Definition 6.8 — Moneyness, intrinsic value and time value

With the underlying at $S$, a call is in the money (ITM) if $S\gt K$, at the money (ATM) if $S\approx K$, and out of the money (OTM) if $S\lt K$; for a put the inequalities are reversed. These three labels describe the option's moneyness.

The intrinsic value is what immediate exercise would give: $(S-K)^+$ for a call, $(K-S)^+$ for a put. The rest of the premium, $\text{premium}-\text{intrinsic value}$, is the time value: the price of the chance that the option ends up (further) in the money. Time value is largest near the money and shrinks to zero at expiry (§6.4).

✏️ Example 1 — What has to happen for a call buyer to profit?
With the index at 22,000, a 30-day 22,000 call costs 406 points (lot 50). Find the premium per lot, the break-even, and the profit per lot if the index expires at 21,500, 22,000, 22,406 and 22,800. What return on the premium does each represent?
Premium $406\times50=$ ₹20,300 per lot, paid upfront. Break-even $K+c=22{,}406$: the index must rise 1.85% just to get the money back.
Table
$S_T$payoff (points)profit (points)profit per lot (₹)on premium
21,5000−406−20,300−100%
22,0000−406−20,300−100%
22,406406000%
22,800800+394+19,700+97%
Reading it The buyer's loss is capped at ₹20,300, but that whole amount is lost whenever the index does not rise. A 3.6% rise roughly doubles the money; anything below 1.85% loses money even though the "view" (index up) was right. Leverage again — in a different shape from §6.1.
✏️ Example 2 — The put seller's side, and splitting premiums
(a) Vikram sells one lot of the 21,800 put at 219. Find his maximum profit, his break-even and his result if the index expires at 21,000 and at 20,000. (b) With the index at 22,000, split each premium into intrinsic and time value: 21,800 call at 522; 22,200 put at 402; 22,300 call at 265.
(a) Best case If $S_T\ge21{,}800$ the put expires worthless and he keeps $219\times50=$ ₹10,950. Break-even $K-p=21{,}581$.
(a) Bad cases At 21,000: $(219-800)\times50=-$₹29,050. At 20,000: $(219-1{,}800)\times50=-$₹79,050. A 9% fall costs him more than seven times what the trade could ever earn.
(b) 21,800 call: ITM, intrinsic $200$, time value $322$. 22,200 put: ITM, intrinsic $200$, time value $202$. 22,300 call: OTM, intrinsic $0$, all 265 points are time value.
Meaning The seller of an OTM option is selling time value: if nothing much happens, it decays to zero and becomes his profit. If something big happens, he pays — that is the insurance business, with its rare large claims.

Strategies: Building Payoffs from Pieces

Real positions combine several options, sometimes with the underlying. Because every leg's payoff is a straight line with one kink at its strike, any combination is a piecewise linear function of $S_T$ — and that makes the analysis mechanical.

📘 Definition 6.9 — Common option strategies
  • Covered call: own the underlying, sell a call. Protective put: own the underlying, buy a put. Collar: both — own, buy a put below, sell a call above.
  • Bull call spread: buy a call at $K_1$, sell a call at $K_2\gt K_1$. Bear put spread: buy a put at $K_2$, sell a put at $K_1\lt K_2$.
  • Straddle: a call and a put at the same strike; strangle: an OTM put and an OTM call. "Long" means bought, "short" means sold.
  • Iron condor: sell an OTM put spread and an OTM call spread: buy put $K_1$, sell put $K_2$, sell call $K_3$, buy call $K_4$ with $K_1\lt K_2\lt K_3\lt K_4$.
  • Butterfly (calls): buy $K_1$, sell two $K_2$, buy $K_3$, with equally spaced strikes.
📐 Theorem 6.7 — The slope rule for payoff diagrams

For a position of long and short calls and puts with the same expiry (plus possibly $u$ units of the underlying), the profit at expiry $\Pi(S_T)$ is continuous and linear between consecutive strikes. Its slope just above a level $S_T$ is $$u+\sum_{\text{calls},\,K\lt S_T}n_K-\sum_{\text{puts},\,K\gt S_T}n_K,$$ where $n_K$ is the number bought ($+$) or sold ($-$) at strike $K$. Consequently the maximum profit and maximum loss occur at a strike or at an end ($S_T=0$ or $S_T\to\infty$); they are unlimited exactly when the slope beyond the highest strike is positive (profit) or negative (loss).

Why. $(S_T-K)^+$ has slope $0$ below $K$ and $1$ above; $(K-S_T)^+$ has slope $-1$ below $K$ and $0$ above; the underlying has slope $1$ everywhere. Slopes add, so each call bought adds $+1$ to the slope above its strike and each put bought adds $-1$ below its strike (signs flip for options sold). A piecewise linear continuous function on $[0,\infty)$ attains its extremes at a kink or at an end. ∎

🧭 Analysing any option strategy in five steps
  1. Net premium. Add premiums paid and subtract premiums received: a net debit (you pay) or credit (you receive).
  2. Kinks. List the strikes in order; compute the profit at each strike and at $S_T=0$.
  3. Tails. Find the slope above the highest strike (Theorem 6.7): positive means unlimited profit, negative unlimited loss.
  4. Break-evens. On each piece where the profit changes sign, solve the linear equation $\Pi(S_T)=0$.
  5. Multiply by the lot size and compare the maximum loss with the money you can actually afford to lose — and with the margin a seller must post.
📐 Theorem 6.8 (Formula) — Break-evens and extremes of standard strategies

Per unit, at expiry; $c_K$, $p_K$ are premiums; $S_0$ is the purchase price of the underlying; $D$ is a net debit and $C$ a net credit.

strategybreak-even(s)max profitmax loss
covered call ($S_0$, short $K$)$S_0-c_K$$K-S_0+c_K$$S_0-c_K$ (if $S_T\to0$)
protective put ($S_0$, long $K$)$S_0+p_K$unlimited$S_0-K+p_K$
bull call spread $K_1\lt K_2$, $D=c_{K_1}-c_{K_2}$$K_1+D$$K_2-K_1-D$$D$
bear put spread $K_1\lt K_2$, $D=p_{K_2}-p_{K_1}$$K_2-D$$K_2-K_1-D$$D$
long straddle at $K$, $D=c_K+p_K$$K\pm D$unlimited$D$
long strangle $K_1\lt K_2$, $D=p_{K_1}+c_{K_2}$$K_1-D,\ K_2+D$unlimited$D$
short straddle / strangle (credit $C$)same as long$C$unlimited
iron condor, wings $w=K_2-K_1=K_4-K_3$, credit $C$$K_2-C,\ K_3+C$$C$$w-C$

Derivation (two rows; the rest are exercises). Bull call spread: below $K_1$ both calls are worthless, profit $-D$; above $K_2$ the payoff is $(S_T-K_1)-(S_T-K_2)=K_2-K_1$, profit $K_2-K_1-D$; in between the slope is $+1$, so $\Pi=S_T-K_1-D$, zero at $K_1+D$. Iron condor: between $K_2$ and $K_3$ every option expires worthless and the credit $C$ is kept; beyond $K_4$ (or below $K_1$) the call (put) spread pays out its full width $w$, so the loss is $w-C$; on $[K_3,K_4]$ the profit is $C-(S_T-K_3)$, zero at $K_3+C$, and symmetrically $K_2-C$ on the left. ∎

✏️ Example 3 — Meera's insurance: a protective put, and a covered call
Meera's ETF holding behaves like 50 units of the index bought at 22,000 (₹11,00,000). (a) She buys one lot of the 21,500 put at 126. Find the cost, the floor on her holding, the maximum loss and the break-even. (b) Alternatively she sells one lot of the 22,300 call at 265 (a covered call). Find the income, the maximum profit and the break-even. What does she give up?
(a) Cost $126\times50=$ ₹6,300, about 0.57% of the holding for one month.
(a) Floor Below 21,500 every point lost on the ETF is gained on the put, so holding + put is worth at least $50\times21{,}500=$ ₹10,75,000. Max loss $=(22{,}000-21{,}500+126)\times50=$ ₹31,300 (2.85%), however far the index falls. Break-even $S_0+p=22{,}126$; above it she keeps every gain, less the ₹6,300.
(b) Covered call Income $265\times50=$ ₹13,250. Max profit $(22{,}300-22{,}000+265)\times50=$ ₹28,250, reached for any $S_T\ge22{,}300$. Break-even $S_0-c=21{,}735$.
Trade-off The put buys protection and keeps the upside, for a fee. The covered call is not protection: it cushions a fall by only 265 points and caps the gain — she has sold her upside for ₹13,250. Below 21,735 she loses almost as much as if she had done nothing.
✏️ Example 4 — A bull call spread and a bear put spread
Using the chain (22,000 call 406, 22,300 call 265; 22,000 put 301, 21,700 put 184), analyse per lot (a) the bull call spread 22,000/22,300; (b) the bear put spread 22,000/21,700. Compare the bull spread with buying the 22,000 call alone.
(a) Debit $D=406-265=141$ (₹7,050 per lot). Max profit $300-141=159$ points (₹7,950) for $S_T\ge22{,}300$; max loss ₹7,050 for $S_T\le22{,}000$; break-even 22,141.
(b) Debit $301-184=117$ (₹5,850). Max profit $300-117=183$ points (₹9,150) for $S_T\le21{,}700$; max loss ₹5,850; break-even 21,883.
Compare Selling the 22,300 call cuts the cost from 406 to 141 points and the break-even from 22,406 to 22,141, at the price of capping the profit at ₹7,950. If the index ends at 22,300 the spread makes ₹7,950 while the lone call makes $(300-406)\times50=-$₹5,300; above 22,565 (where $S_T-22{,}406=159$) the lone call does better.
Interactive 1 — Option Strategy Builder: Payoffs, Break-evens, Maximum Profit and Loss

Choose a strategy. The thick line is the profit per lot (lot 50, illustrative) at expiry against the index level $S_T$; green shading is profit, red is loss; thin dashed lines are the individual legs. Premiums come from the model of §6.3 with the volatility and days you choose (14% and 30 days reproduce this page's chain). Play sweeps the expiry level; dots mark break-evens.

22,600
legs (premium, points)—
net premium per lot—
max profit per lot—
max loss per lot—
break-even(s)—
P&L at chosen $S_T$—
✏️ Example 5 — Straddles and strangles: betting on (or against) a big move
(a) Find the cost and break-evens of a long 22,000 straddle (call 406, put 301). By what percentage must the index move? (b) Vikram sells this straddle. Find his maximum profit and his result if the index expires at 23,500. (c) Compare with a long strangle: 21,700 put (184) and 22,300 call (265).
(a) $D=406+301=707$ points (₹35,350 per lot). Break-evens $22{,}000\pm707$: 21,293 and 22,707 — a move of about 3.2% either way within the month just to break even.
(b) Max profit ₹35,350, only if the index expires exactly at 22,000. At 23,500: $(707-1{,}500)\times50=-$₹39,650 — and the loss keeps growing by ₹50 per point. His "steady income" is the premium for carrying that tail.
(c) $D=184+265=449$ (₹22,450). Break-evens $21{,}700-449=21{,}251$ and $22{,}300+449=22{,}749$. Cheaper than the straddle, but needs a slightly larger move to profit, and loses everything anywhere between 21,700 and 22,300.
✏️ Example 6 — An iron condor: limited reward, limited risk
Sell the 21,700 put (184), buy the 21,500 put (126), sell the 22,300 call (265), buy the 22,500 call (193). Find the credit, the maximum profit and loss per lot and the break-evens. Then compare the worst case with a short strangle (sell only the 21,700 put and 22,300 call).
Credit Put spread $184-126=58$, call spread $265-193=72$: $C=130$ points, ₹6,500 per lot.
Extremes Max profit ₹6,500 if $21{,}700\le S_T\le22{,}300$. Wings $w=200$, so max loss $(200-130)\times50=$ ₹3,500, below 21,500 or above 22,500.
Break-evens $21{,}700-130=21{,}570$ and $22{,}300+130=22{,}430$ (Theorem 6.8).
Compare The short strangle collects $184+265=449$ points (₹22,450) but its loss is unlimited: at 23,000, $(449-700)\times50=-$₹12,550, at 24,000 $-$₹62,550. The bought wings cost 319 points of premium and turn an open-ended risk into a known ₹3,500. Whether either has a positive expected profit depends on the probabilities of the index ending in each zone (§6.3) and on costs — a high chance of a small gain is not the same as a good bet (§7.2).

Put–Call Parity, Arbitrage and Expiry Cycles

Look at the chain: the 22,000 call (406) costs 105 points more than the 22,000 put (301), and the 22,100 call and put cost almost the same. That is no coincidence. A call and a put with the same strike and expiry are tied together so tightly that knowing one price (and the futures price) tells you the other.

📐 Theorem 6.9 — Put–call parity (European options)

For European call and put options on the same underlying with the same strike $K$ and expiry $T$, with risk-free rate $r$, dividend yield $q$, futures price $F_0=S_0e^{(r-q)T}$, and no arbitrage:

$$c-p=S_0e^{-qT}-Ke^{-rT}$$

$$c-p=(F_0-K)\,e^{-rT}.$$

In particular $c\gt p$ when $K\lt F_0$, $c\lt p$ when $K\gt F_0$, and $c=p$ exactly when $K=F_0$ (the at-the-money-forward strike).

Proof (no arbitrage). Compare two portfolios. A: one call plus cash $Ke^{-rT}$ invested at $r$. B: one put plus $e^{-qT}$ units of the index, dividends reinvested so that it grows to one unit by $T$. At expiry, $$A:\ (S_T-K)^++K=\max(S_T,K),$$ $$B:\ (K-S_T)^++S_T=\max(S_T,K).$$ The two portfolios pay exactly the same in every outcome and nothing before $T$, so they must cost the same today: $c+Ke^{-rT}=p+S_0e^{-qT}$. If not, buy the cheaper portfolio and sell the dearer one: you collect the difference now and owe nothing at expiry. The second form substitutes $S_0e^{-qT}=F_0e^{-rT}$ (Theorem 6.2). ∎ The proof uses no model of how prices move — no volatility, no probabilities — which is why parity holds in real markets up to costs, while the level of option prices needs the model of §6.3.

📘 Definition 6.10 — Synthetic positions, conversion and reversal

Rearranging parity, a long call plus a short put (same $K$, $T$) has the payoff $S_T-K$ of a synthetic long future at price $K$; a long call plus a short future is a synthetic long put; a long put plus a long future is a synthetic long call. A conversion (long future, long put, short call) and a reversal (short future, short put, long call) lock in a fixed amount at expiry; traders use them to capture parity violations.

📐 Theorem 6.10 — No-arbitrage bounds for European options

Under the assumptions of Theorem 6.9,

$$\left(S_0e^{-qT}-Ke^{-rT}\right)^+\le c\le S_0e^{-qT},$$

$$\left(Ke^{-rT}-S_0e^{-qT}\right)^+\le p\le Ke^{-rT}.$$

Why. Option prices are non-negative because the payoffs are. From parity, $c=p+S_0e^{-qT}-Ke^{-rT}\ge S_0e^{-qT}-Ke^{-rT}$, and symmetrically for $p$. A call can never pay more than one unit of the index ($(S_T-K)^+\le S_T$), so $c\le S_0e^{-qT}$; a put never pays more than $K$, so $p\le Ke^{-rT}$. ∎

✏️ Example 7 — Checking parity and capturing a violation
For $K=22{,}000$, 30 days, $S_0=22{,}000$, $r=7\%$, $q=1.2\%$ (fair future 22,105.1): (a) check parity for the chain prices 406 and 301. (b) Suppose the put were quoted at 280 with the call still at 406 and the future at 22,105. Describe the arbitrage and the amount locked in per lot at expiry, before costs.
(a) $(F_0-K)e^{-rT}=105.13\times0.99426\approx104.5$; chain $c-p=406-301=105$. Parity holds to within rounding.
(b) Diagnose Now $c-p=126$, more than 104.5: the call is rich relative to the put (equivalently, the put is cheap). Sell the rich side, buy the cheap side.
(b) Trade Conversion: sell the call (+406), buy the put (−280), buy the future at 22,105. Receive 126 points now and invest them: $126e^{0.07\times30/365}\approx126.73$ at expiry. At expiry the three legs pay $-(S_T-K)^++(K-S_T)^+$ $+(S_T-22{,}105)$ $=K-22{,}105=-105$, whatever $S_T$ is.
(b) Result $126.73-105\approx21.7$ points, ₹1,086 per lot, riskless before costs. But three legs of brokerage, taxes and bid–ask spreads, plus margin on the short call and the future, can easily cost more than that: real parity violations are small and short-lived.
✏️ Example 8 — Using parity: implied futures prices and missing quotes
(a) A long 22,000 call and a short 22,000 put cost $406-301=105$ points. What futures price is this synthetic position equivalent to? (b) The 22,300 call trades at 265. What should the 22,300 put cost? (c) Is a 21,500 call at 590 possible?
(a) The synthetic pays $S_T-K$ at expiry; paying 105 now (worth $105e^{rT}\approx105.6$ at expiry) is like buying a future at $K+105.6\approx22{,}105.6$ — the implied futures price. Traders read implied futures (and implied interest rates) off option chains this way.
(b) $p=c-S_0e^{-qT}+Ke^{-rT}$ $=265-21{,}978.3+22{,}172.1\approx458.8$, matching the chain's 459.
(c) Lower bound (Theorem 6.10): $S_0e^{-qT}-Ke^{-rT}=21{,}978.3-21{,}376.7\approx601.7$. A call at 590 is below it: buy the call and sell the future at 22,105.1. At expiry the pair pays $(S_T-21{,}500)^+-(S_T-22{,}105.1)\ge605.1$, worth $601.7$ today, for an outlay of 590 — an arbitrage of about 11.7 points before costs. So 590 should not last.
Interactive 2 — Put–Call Parity: Three Legs, One Flat Line

The call is priced fairly; nudge the put quote away from its parity value. The widget picks the arbitrage (conversion or reversal) and plots, per index point, the profit at expiry of its three legs — the call (red), the put (blue), the future (amber) — and their sum (green). However $S_T$ ends, the sum is flat: a locked-in amount. The bars below compare it, per lot (50, illustrative), with an illustrative cost for trading three legs. Play sweeps the mispricing.

−21 pts
₹600
fair c − p = (F − K)e^(−rT)—
call / put quotes—
quoted c − p—
trade—
locked in per lot—
after costs—

Weekly and monthly expiries. NSE lists option contracts with several expiry dates at once: monthly contracts, and on some indices weekly ones. Which indices have weekly options, and on which weekday contracts expire, are decided by the exchange within SEBI's rules and have changed more than once in recent years — check the current NSE circulars. The mathematics does not change: for the same strike, a shorter time to expiry means less time value. In the model of §6.3 the time value of an at-the-money option grows roughly like $\sqrt{T}$, so a 7-day ATM option costs about half as much as a 30-day one (183 vs 406 points for our 22,000 call) but loses its value about twice as fast per day, and near expiry small index moves swing its price sharply (gamma risk, §6.4). Cheap short-dated options are cheap because they usually expire worthless.

📈 Market case — Meera protects her ₹11 lakh for a month: futures, put or collar?

Meera's ETF behaves like 50 index units bought at 22,000. Three ways to protect it for one month, using the chain (and the future at 22,105 from §6.1):

  1. Sell 1 lot of futures at 22,105 (§6.1): no premium, but margin and daily MTM. Result: ETF $+$ futures $=50(S_T-22{,}000)+50(22{,}105-S_T)=+$₹5,250 in every scenario — the carry. Downside gone, upside gone.
  2. Buy the 21,500 put at 126: pay ₹6,300 now. Floor at a loss of ₹31,300; upside kept.
  3. Collar: buy the 21,500 put (126) and sell the 22,300 call (265): receive a net 139 points (₹6,950). Loss limited to $(500-139)\times50=$ ₹18,050; gain capped at $(300+139)\times50=$ ₹21,950.
index at expiryETF alone+ short future+ 21,500 putcollar
20,000−1,00,000+5,250−31,300−18,050
21,500−25,000+5,250−31,300−18,050
22,0000+5,250−6,300+6,950
22,500+25,000+5,250+18,700+21,950
24,000+1,00,000+5,250+93,700+21,950

Reading the table. The future removes all risk and earns roughly the risk-free carry (₹5,250 ≈ 0.48% for the month, with the ETF's dividends on top). The put is insurance: it costs ₹6,300 in the quiet scenarios and saves ₹68,700 in the crash. The collar pays for the insurance by selling the upside above 22,300. In the middle row the index does not move, yet the results differ: the future earns its carry, the put costs its premium, the collar keeps its net credit. None is free — each gives up upside, premium or both for what it gets.

The mathematics, not a recommendation. Which is "best" depends on Meera's view, horizon, taxes and how much a 9% fall would actually hurt her. Note also what none of them protects against: a fall that happens after expiry, and the ETF's tracking difference from the index (§2.2).

⚠️ Common mistakes and myths
  1. "Option selling is steady income." An option seller's profit is capped at the premium; the loss is not (a short call) or is very large (a short put). Many small wins followed by one large loss is the normal pattern, not bad luck (Examples 2, 5).
  2. "Option buying is safe because the loss is limited." Limited to 100% of the premium — and that full loss is the most common outcome for far OTM and short-dated options. Buying many lots of "limited-risk" options is not limited risk.
  3. "A ₹50 option is cheap." Price per point says nothing about value. The nephew's 23,200 call needs a rise of more than 5.6% in a month just to break even.
  4. Break-even at expiry ≠ profit today. Before expiry the option's price depends on time and volatility (§6.3–6.4); the hockey stick is only the final picture.
  5. "High probability of profit" means a good strategy. An iron condor that wins ₹6,500 most months and loses ₹3,500 otherwise can still have negative expectancy after costs; compute expectancy, not hit rate (§7.2).
  6. Forgetting the lot size. "Only 130 points of credit" is ₹6,500 per lot; "max loss 70 points" is ₹3,500 per lot — multiply before deciding.
  7. "The covered call protects my shares." It cushions a fall only by the premium and caps the gain (Example 3).
  8. Parity "arbitrage" ignoring costs. Three legs, spreads, taxes and margin usually eat a 20-point gap (Example 7, Interactive 2).
  9. Comparing call and put prices directly. A call above the put at the same strike just means $K\lt F_0$ (Theorem 6.9), not that the market is bullish.
  10. All the warnings about leverage and individual traders in the ⚠️ box of §6.1 apply to options too — with a short-option position you can lose far more than the margin you posted.

Exercises

Use the chain below (index 22,000, 30 days, $r=7\%$, $q=1.2\%$, generated by the Black–Scholes model of §6.3 with $\sigma=14\%$ and rounded to whole points; so $S_0e^{-qT}\approx21{,}978.3$, $e^{-rT}\approx0.994263$, $F_0\approx22{,}105.1$), lot 50 (illustrative), and ignore costs unless stated.

strike21,50021,70021,80021,90022,00022,10022,20022,30022,500
call728586522462406354307265193
put126184219258301349402459585
I
Payoffs and moneyness.
  • 1 For a long 22,200 call, find the profit per unit at $S_T=21{,}900$, $22{,}200$ and $22{,}700$, and the break-even.
  • 2 For a long 22,000 put, find the break-even and the profit per lot at $S_T=21{,}400$.
  • 3 For a short 22,300 call, find the maximum profit per lot and the result per lot at $S_T=23{,}000$.
  • 4 With the index at 22,000, classify as ITM, ATM or OTM: the 21,800 call, the 22,200 call, the 21,800 put, the 22,000 put.
  • 5 Split the 21,700 call and the 22,300 put into intrinsic and time value.
  • 6 Can a call buyer lose money even though the option expires in the money? Give an example from the chain.
  • 7 A buyer of the 22,500 call sees the index at 22,900 at expiry. Find the profit and the return on the premium. What is the return if the index ends at 22,400?
1 Premium 307: $-307$, $-307$, $500-307=+193$ points; break-even 22,507.
2 Break-even $22{,}000-301=21{,}699$; at 21,400: $(600-301)\times50=$ ₹14,950.
3 Max profit $265\times50=$ ₹13,250; at 23,000: $(265-700)\times50=-$₹21,750.
4 21,800 call ITM; 22,200 call OTM; 21,800 put OTM; 22,000 put ATM.
5 21,700 call: intrinsic 300, time value 286. 22,300 put: intrinsic 300, time value 159.
6 Yes: whenever $K\lt S_T\lt K+c$. The 22,000 call (406) expiring at 22,200 pays 200 but cost 406: a loss of 206 points (₹10,300 per lot).
7 $400-193=207$ points (₹10,350 per lot), +107% on the premium; at 22,400 the call expires worthless: −100%.
II
Strategies. For each, find the net premium per lot, the maximum profit and loss per lot, and the break-even(s).
  • 1 Covered call: own 50 units at 22,000, sell the 22,200 call.
  • 2 Protective put: own 50 units at 22,000, buy the 21,800 put.
  • 3 Bull put spread (a credit spread): sell the 22,000 put, buy the 21,700 put.
  • 4 Bear call spread: sell the 22,000 call, buy the 22,300 call.
  • 5 Long strangle: buy the 21,500 put and the 22,500 call.
  • 6 Short straddle at 22,100: also find the result per lot at 22,400 and at 23,200.
  • 7 Iron condor 21,500/21,800/22,200/22,500.
  • 8 Call butterfly: buy 21,800, sell two 22,000, buy 22,200.
1 Credit 307 (₹15,350). Max profit $(200+307)\times50=$ ₹25,350 for $S_T\ge22{,}200$; break-even 21,693; max loss $(22{,}000-307)\times50$ only if the index went to zero — in practice "almost the whole fall below 21,693".
2 Debit 219 (₹10,950). Floor: holding + put worth at least $50\times21{,}800$; max loss $(200+219)\times50=$ ₹20,950; break-even 22,219; upside unlimited.
3 Credit $301-184=117$ (₹5,850) = max profit for $S_T\ge22{,}000$; max loss $(300-117)\times50=$ ₹9,150 for $S_T\le21{,}700$; break-even 21,883.
4 Credit $406-265=141$ (₹7,050) = max profit for $S_T\le22{,}000$; max loss $(300-141)\times50=$ ₹7,950; break-even 22,141.
5 Debit $126+193=319$ (₹15,950) = max loss; profit unlimited; break-evens 21,181 and 22,819.
6 Credit $354+349=703$ (₹35,150) = max profit at 22,100; loss unlimited; break-evens 21,397 and 22,803. At 22,400: $(703-300)\times50=+$₹20,150; at 23,200: $(703-1{,}100)\times50=-$₹19,850.
7 Credit $(219-126)+(307-193)=207$ (₹10,350) = max profit for $21{,}800\le S_T\le22{,}200$; wings 300, max loss $(300-207)\times50=$ ₹4,650; break-evens 21,593 and 22,407.
8 Debit $522-2\times406+307=17$ (₹850) = max loss (outside 21,800–22,200); max profit $(200-17)\times50=$ ₹9,150 at exactly 22,000; break-evens 21,817 and 22,183.
III
Put–call parity, bounds and expiries.
  • 1 Verify put–call parity for the 22,200 strike.
  • 2 If the 22,100 call is 354, what should the 22,100 put cost?
  • 3 Find the futures price implied by the 21,900 call and put.
  • 4 The 22,300 put is quoted at 430 (call 265, future 22,105.1). Describe the arbitrage and the amount locked in per lot.
  • 5 Find the no-arbitrage lower bound for the 21,500 call and the upper bound for the 22,500 put. Do the chain prices respect them?
  • 6 Which combination of a future and an option is a synthetic long call? Explain with payoffs.
  • 7 In the model of §6.3 the 7-day 22,000 call is worth about 183 points and the 30-day one 406. Compare the ratio with $\sqrt{7/30}$ and the average time-value decay per day of each.
1 $c-p=307-402=-95$; $S_0e^{-qT}-Ke^{-rT}$ $=21{,}978.3-22{,}072.6\approx-94.3$: equal to within rounding.
2 $p=354-21{,}978.3$ $+22{,}100\times0.994263\approx348.9$, i.e. 349.
3 $F=K+(c-p)e^{rT}$ $=21{,}900+204\times1.00577\approx22{,}105.2$.
4 Fair put 459, quote 430: the put is cheap. Conversion: buy the put, sell the call, buy the future. Pay $430-265=165$ now (owe $165e^{rT}\approx165.95$ at expiry); the legs pay $K-F=22{,}300-22{,}105.1=194.9$. Locked: $\approx28.9$ points, ₹1,446 per lot before costs.
5 Call 21,500: $\ge21{,}978.3-21{,}376.7\approx601.7$; chain 728 ✓. Put 22,500: $\le22{,}500e^{-rT}\approx22{,}370.9$ (and $\ge22{,}370.9-21{,}978.3\approx392.6$); chain 585 ✓.
6 Long future + long put: $(S_T-F)+(K-S_T)^+$ $=\max(S_T,K)-F$ $=(S_T-K)^++(K-F)$ — a call plus a constant. Hence the name "synthetic call" (Definition 6.10).
7 $183/406\approx0.45$, close to $\sqrt{7/30}\approx0.48$. Average decay: about $406/30\approx13.5$ points a day for the monthly, $183/7\approx26$ a day for the weekly — roughly twice as fast. (These ATM premiums are almost all time value.)
IV
Explain and decide.
  • 1 A friend says: "Option buying has limited risk, so I can buy as many lots as I like." Respond with numbers from the chain.
  • 2 Why must the seller of an uncovered call deposit a large margin while the buyer pays only the premium?
  • 3 Simplify the iron condor of Example 6 to two outcomes: +₹6,500 with probability $\pi$ and −₹3,500 otherwise. For which $\pi$ is the expected profit positive? Why is the real calculation harder?
  • 4 Match each view to a strategy from this section and justify: (a) "the index will stay in a range"; (b) "mildly bullish, small budget"; (c) "a big move is coming but I don't know which way"; (d) "I own the index and fear a crash but want to keep the upside".
1 Each lot of the 22,000 call risks ₹20,300; ten lots risk ₹2,03,000, all lost if the index does not rise — which a buyer of short-dated OTM options experiences often. The risk is limited per lot, not in total; size it by the money you can afford to lose (§7.2).
2 The buyer's maximum loss is the premium, already paid. The call seller's loss is unlimited ($c-(S_T-K)^+$), so the clearing corporation needs collateral to cover large moves and charges MTM-style margins as prices move.
3 $6{,}500\pi-3{,}500(1-\pi)\gt0\iff\pi\gt0.35$. In reality there are intermediate outcomes between the break-evens and the wings, the probabilities are uncertain (and model-dependent, §6.3), and costs reduce the gain; and the sizes of rare large moves matter (fat tails, §3.1).
4 (a) Iron condor or short strangle (condor if you want the loss capped). (b) Bull call spread — cheaper than a lone call, capped profit. (c) Long straddle or strangle — profits from a large move either way, loses the premium if nothing happens. (d) Protective put (or a collar if you will give up some upside to pay for it).
🎯 Practice corner NISM-styleCase studyInterview

E1. NISM-style The maximum loss for the buyer of a put option is (A) the strike price (B) the premium paid (C) unlimited (D) the strike price minus the premium.

Reason A holder can always let the option lapse, so the loss is at most the premium. (D) is the put buyer's maximum profit (and the put seller's maximum loss).
Answer (B).

E2. NISM-style A trader buys a call with strike ₹500 for a premium of ₹20. Ignoring costs, at expiry the trader breaks even when the underlying is at (A) ₹480 (B) ₹500 (C) ₹520 (D) ₹540.

Compute $K+c=500+20=520$. (A) is the put buyer's break-even; (B) is where the call starts to pay; (D) double-counts the premium.
Answer (C).

E3. NISM-style A stock pays no dividends and trades at ₹100. A European call with strike ₹100 costs ₹8, and the present value of ₹100 payable at expiry is ₹98. By put–call parity the matching put should cost (A) ₹6 (B) ₹8 (C) ₹10 (D) ₹2.

Compute $p=c-S_0+Ke^{-rT}=8-100+98=6$. (B) assumes $c=p$, true only at the forward strike; (C) adds the interest instead of subtracting it.
Answer (A).

E4. Case study A trader expects the index (now 22,000) to stay between 21,600 and 22,400 for a month. Chain: 22,400 call 227, 21,600 put 153, 22,700 call 136, 21,300 put 83; lot 50. (a) Analyse the short strangle (sell 22,400 C and 21,600 P): credit, break-evens, maximum profit and loss. (b) Analyse the iron condor that also buys the 22,700 call and the 21,300 put. (c) Find each strategy's result if the index jumps to 23,200 at expiry, and comment.

(a) Credit $227+153=380$ (₹19,000) = max profit between 21,600 and 22,400; break-evens 21,220 and 22,780; loss unlimited above, very large below.
(b) Wings cost $136+83=219$; credit $380-219=161$ (₹8,050) = max profit; wings $w=300$, max loss $(300-161)\times50=$ ₹6,950; break-evens 21,439 and 22,561.
(c) Strangle: $(380-800)\times50=-$₹21,000. Condor: capped at $-$₹6,950. The condor gives up 219 points of premium (₹10,950 in every quiet month) to cap the disaster; the strangle keeps more in quiet months and loses three times as much here — and more in a larger move.

E5. Case study For the 22,000 strike, 30 days, the market shows call 420, put 300 and the future at 22,105 ($r=7\%$, lot 50). (a) Is parity violated? By how much? (b) Set up the arbitrage and find the amount locked in per lot. (c) If brokerage, taxes and spreads for the three legs cost ₹600 per lot, is it still worth doing? What else would the trader need?

(a) Quoted $c-p=120$; fair $(22{,}105-22{,}000)e^{-rT}\approx104.4$: the call is about 15.6 points rich relative to the put.
(b) Conversion: sell the call, buy the put, buy the future. Receive 120 now, $\approx120.69$ at expiry; the legs pay $K-F=-105$. Locked $\approx15.7$ points, ₹785 per lot.
(c) Net ≈ ₹185 per lot — and only if all three legs are filled at these prices at once. The trader also needs margin for the short call and the future (capital tied up for a month for a tiny return) and fast execution. That is why such gaps are rare and short-lived.

E6. Interview "A European call and a European put on the same index, same strike, same expiry, trade at exactly the same price. What can you say about the strike?" Then: "What position is long the call and short the put?"

Key step Parity: $c-p=(F_0-K)e^{-rT}$. If $c=p$ then $F_0=K$: the strike equals the futures (forward) price — not the spot. In our chain that is about 22,105, which is why the 22,100 call and put (354 vs 349) are nearly equal.
Second part Long call + short put pays $(S_T-K)^+-(K-S_T)^+=S_T-K$: a synthetic long forward at $K$. With $K=F_0$ it costs nothing, exactly like entering a futures contract.
Interview answer "The strike is at-the-money-forward; long call short put is a synthetic forward." Interviewers like candidates who say "forward", not "spot", and who can derive it from the two-portfolio argument.
🧑‍🏫 For the teacher

Suggested plan — 2 lectures × 60 min.

  1. Payoffs. Start with the 📍 situation and ask the class who is taking the most risk: Meera, Vikram or the nephew. Draw the four basic hockey sticks (Theorem 6.6) on the board, do Examples 1–2, and state the slope rule (Theorem 6.7). Project Interactive 1 and step through long call → short call → covered call → protective put, asking students to predict each shape before you switch.
  2. Strategies and parity. Examples 3–6 with the five-step strategy box; in Interactive 1 change the volatility to show how straddles become expensive in nervous markets. Then the two-portfolio proof of parity, Examples 7–8 and Interactive 2 ("why is the green line flat?"). Finish with the 📈 Market case and the myths box.

Class activity. "Strategy auction": each group receives a market view (range, mild rise, big move, crash fear) and a budget, picks a strategy from the chain, and presents its break-evens and worst case. The class then reveals a random expiry level (roll dice for a simulated move) and every group computes its result.

Misconceptions to watch for. Limited loss = low risk; selling options = income; cheap = good value; the payoff diagram is the price today; call price above put price = bullish market; parity uses spot rather than the forward.

Suggested homework. I(1, 2, 5, 6), II(1, 3, 6, 7, 8), III(1, 2, 4, 5), IV(3, 4); Practice corner E2, E4, E6.

🛠️ Do it yourselfSpreadsheet mini-project · about 60 minutes

Project. Build a general payoff-diagram sheet for any combination of up to six option legs, then test put–call parity on a real option chain.

Why it matters. Brokers' strategy tools show pretty pictures; a sheet you built yourself shows exactly where every number comes from, and lets you check a "strategy" someone is selling you before you risk money on it.

What to do.

  1. Legs table (rows 2–7): type in A (C, P or U for the underlying), strike in B, quantity in C (negative = sold), premium in D. Lot size in G1.
  2. Price grid: in column F from row 10, expiry levels from 0.85×spot to 1.15×spot in steps of 10 points. One column per leg (H to M for legs 1–6), e.g. for leg 1 in H10: =IF($A$2="C",$C$2*(MAX(0,$F10-$B$2)-$D$2),IF($A$2="P",$C$2*(MAX(0,$B$2-$F10)-$D$2),$C$2*($F10-$B$2))) (for the underlying, put its purchase price in B). Total in G10: =SUM(H10:M10)*$G$1. Chart F against G.
  3. Break-evens: a helper column N10 =IF(SIGN(G10)<>SIGN(G11), F10-G10*(F11-F10)/(G11-G10), "") (linear interpolation, Theorem 6.7). Max profit and loss: =MAX(G:G), =MIN(G:G), plus a check of the slope in the last two rows for "unlimited".
  4. Parity: download an index option chain for one expiry from the NSE website (it publishes option chains with last prices, bids and asks). For each strike compute =(call−put) and =K+(call−put)*EXP(r*T), the implied futures price, using mid prices; plot it against $K$. It should be nearly flat, close to the quoted future.
  5. Python version: pnl = sum(n*(max(S-K,0)-prem) if t=='C' else n*(max(K-S,0)-prem) for t,K,n,prem in legs) over a NumPy grid of S.

Hand in: payoff charts for three strategies of your choice with break-evens and extremes, and the implied-futures plot with a short comment: how far from flat is it, and could the deviations be traded after realistic costs (use an illustrative cost per leg)?

Going further. Use the bid for options you sell and the ask for options you buy instead of mid prices, and watch most apparent parity "arbitrages" disappear.

Instructor note: the most common spreadsheet error is applying MAX to a whole range (it returns one number), which is why each leg gets its own column. Real chains are noisy for far OTM strikes with few trades; tell students to use strikes near the money and bid/ask rather than last-traded prices.

🧪 Self-check quiz

0/5 correct

Q1. A put with strike 21,800 is bought for 219 points. At expiry the buyer breaks even when the index is at

Q2. The seller of an uncovered (naked) call option has

Q3. A bull call spread buys the 22,000 call at 406 and sells the 22,300 call at 265. Its maximum profit per unit is

Q4. By put–call parity, for a strike above the futures price ($K\gt F_0$), the call is

Q5. A long straddle (buy a call and a put at the same strike) makes money at expiry when