Chapter 4 · Plant Physiology

4.1 Photosynthesis in Higher Plants

How a green leaf turns light, water and carbon dioxide into sugar: the early experiments, the chloroplast, the pigments, the light reaction with its Z-scheme and chemiosmosis, the Calvin cycle, the C₄ pathway, photorespiration and the factors that limit the rate.

Every breath you take, every grain of rice and every page of paper began as a reaction inside a green cell. A wheat field in Punjab, a mangrove in the Sundarbans and the algae floating in the Bay of Bengal all do the same thing: they catch sunlight and use its energy to pull carbon dioxide out of the air and build it into sugar, releasing oxygen as they go. Almost all the food chains on Earth start here, and so does almost all the oxygen in the atmosphere. Fossil fuels are photosynthesis too — sunlight trapped by plants millions of years ago.

Photosynthesis looks simple when written as one equation, but it is really two linked sets of reactions in two parts of one organelle. In this section we follow the story from the first experiments with candles, mice and bell jars to the modern picture: the chloroplast and its pigments; the light reaction, in which two photosystems split water and make ATP and NADPH; the Calvin cycle, which uses them to fix CO₂; the C₄ pathway of plants such as maize; the wasteful side-reaction called photorespiration; and the factors that set the rate. The same ATP reappears in respiration (Section 4.2), and the sugar made here pays for growth (Section 4.3).

Autotrophic Nutrition, Early Experiments and the Site

Green plants are autotrophs: they make their own food from simple inorganic raw materials. All other organisms — animals, fungi, most bacteria — are heterotrophs and depend, directly or indirectly, on the food that plants make. Photosynthesis is therefore important for two reasons: it is the primary source of all food on Earth, and it releases the oxygen that aerobic organisms need.

📘 Definition 4.1 — Photosynthesis

Photosynthesis is a physico-chemical process by which green plants (and some other organisms) use light energy to drive the synthesis of organic compounds (carbohydrates) from carbon dioxide and water, releasing oxygen. Chlorophyll traps the light; the energy ends up stored in the chemical bonds of sugar. The balanced overall equation is

$$6\,\mathrm{CO_2}+12\,\mathrm{H_2O}\xrightarrow[\text{chlorophyll}]{\text{light}}\mathrm{C_6H_{12}O_6}+6\,\mathrm{H_2O}+6\,\mathrm{O_2}$$

Water appears on both sides because the oxygen released comes from water (12 molecules are split), while new water is made from oxygen atoms that came from CO₂. Glucose is usually stored as starch.

Simple experiments done in school laboratories show the conditions needed. A variegated leaf (green and white patches) tested with iodine after a day in light gives starch only in the green parts, so chlorophyll is needed. A leaf partly covered with black paper makes starch only in the exposed part, so light is needed. In the half-leaf experiment, part of a leaf is enclosed in a test tube with cotton soaked in potassium hydroxide (KOH), which absorbs CO₂; that part does not make starch, so CO₂ is needed.

📐 Key fact 4.1 — The early experiments
ScientistExperimentConclusion
Joseph Priestley (1770)A candle burning or a mouse breathing in a closed bell jar soon fails; with a mint plant in the jar, both survive.Plants restore to the air whatever burning candles and breathing animals remove (we now know: oxygen).
Jan IngenhouszRepeated Priestley's set-up in the dark and in sunlight; watched an aquatic plant in bright light.Sunlight is essential, and only the green parts release oxygen — small bubbles form round green parts in light, not in the dark.
Julius von Sachs (1854)Studied where the green pigment lies and what is made.Chlorophyll is located in special bodies (chloroplasts); plants make glucose, usually stored as starch.
T. W. EngelmannSplit light with a prism onto the green alga Cladophora kept in a suspension of aerobic bacteria.Bacteria crowded in the blue and red regions, where most O₂ was released: the first action spectrum, resembling the absorption of chlorophylls a and b.
Cornelius van NielStudied purple and green sulphur bacteria, which use H₂S and release no O₂.Photosynthesis is a light-dependent reaction in which hydrogen from an oxidisable donor reduces CO₂: $2\,\mathrm{H_2A}+\mathrm{CO_2}\to 2\,\mathrm{A}+\mathrm{CH_2O}+\mathrm{H_2O}$. In green plants $\mathrm{H_2A}$ is water, so the O₂ comes from water, not CO₂ — later proved with radioactive isotopes.

By the middle of the nineteenth century the empirical equation $\mathrm{CO_2}+\mathrm{H_2O}\xrightarrow{\text{light}}[\mathrm{CH_2O}]+\mathrm{O_2}$ was accepted; van Niel's work showed why the balanced version needs water on both sides.

📘 Definition 4.2 — Where photosynthesis takes place

Photosynthesis occurs in the green parts of a plant, mainly the leaves, inside the chloroplasts of the mesophyll cells. Chloroplasts usually line the cell walls so that they receive the best light, turning their flat surfaces towards moderate light and their edges towards strong light.

  • The membrane system — the grana (stacks of flattened sacs called thylakoids) and the stroma lamellae joining them — traps light energy and makes ATP and NADPH: the light reactions.
  • The stroma (the matrix) contains the enzymes that reduce CO₂ to carbohydrate: the biosynthetic phase, often called the dark reactions. The name is misleading — these reactions do not need darkness, but they do not use light directly; they depend on the ATP and NADPH from the light reactions.
✏️ Example 1 — Following the oxygen atoms
Two sets of leaves are given heavy-oxygen (¹⁸O) labels. Set P receives $\mathrm{H_2{}^{18}O}$ with ordinary CO₂; set Q receives $\mathrm{C{}^{18}O_2}$ with ordinary water. (a) In which set is the O₂ released labelled? (b) Using the balanced equation, how many of the oxygen atoms in the 6 O₂ released for each glucose come from water? (c) Where do the 12 oxygen atoms of 6 CO₂ end up? (d) Purple sulphur bacteria use H₂S instead of water. What do they release instead of O₂, and why does this support (a)?
(a) Set P. The O₂ is produced by splitting water, so the label in water appears in the O₂; set Q releases unlabelled O₂.
(b) 6 O₂ contain $12$ oxygen atoms, and all $12$ come from the 12 water molecules split.
(c) Six go into glucose ($\mathrm{C_6H_{12}O_6}$ has 6 O) and six into the 6 new water molecules: $6+6=12$ ✓.
(d) Sulphur (or sulphate), formed by oxidising H₂S: $2\,\mathrm{H_2S}+\mathrm{CO_2}\to 2\,\mathrm{S}+\mathrm{CH_2O}+\mathrm{H_2O}$. The by-product always comes from the hydrogen donor; in green plants the donor is water, so the by-product is O₂.
Check Oxygen atoms balance: left $6\times2+12\times1=24$; right $6+6+12=24$ ✓.
✏️ Example 2 — What did each experiment prove?
State the single most important conclusion of each set-up. (a) A mouse in a sealed bell jar with a mint plant survives; without the plant it does not. (b) The same jar, with the plant, kept in the dark: the mouse dies. (c) Bubbles form round the green parts of a submerged pondweed in bright sunlight, but not round its pale stem base. (d) Aerobic bacteria cluster under the blue and red bands of a spectrum thrown on a filament of Cladophora. (e) Part of a leaf sealed in a tube with KOH-soaked cotton gives a negative starch test.
(a) Plants restore something to the air that breathing removes (Priestley) — oxygen.
(b) Light is essential for the plant to restore the air (Ingenhousz).
(c) Only the green parts release oxygen (Ingenhousz) — chlorophyll is required.
(d) Photosynthesis (O₂ release) is fastest in blue and red light: the first action spectrum (Engelmann).
(e) CO₂ is a raw material: without it no starch is made.

The oxygen released during photosynthesis by a green plant comes from

Pigments and the Light Reaction

If the pigments of a leaf are extracted and separated by paper chromatography, four coloured bands appear. Each pigment absorbs some wavelengths strongly and reflects others — which is why leaves look green: green light is the least absorbed.

📘 Definition 4.3 — Photosynthetic pigments, absorption and action spectra
  • Chlorophyll a — bright or blue-green; the chief pigment, found at the reaction centres and essential for photosynthesis.
  • Chlorophyll b — yellow-green.
  • Xanthophylls — yellow.
  • Carotenoids (carotenes) — yellow to yellow-orange.

Chlorophyll b, xanthophylls and carotenoids are accessory pigments. They absorb light of other wavelengths and pass the energy to chlorophyll a, so they widen the range of wavelengths that can be used; they also protect chlorophyll a from photo-oxidation.

An absorption spectrum shows how much light a pigment absorbs at each wavelength. An action spectrum shows the rate of photosynthesis at each wavelength. Chlorophyll a absorbs most in the blue and red regions, and the rate of photosynthesis is also highest there; because the action spectrum closely follows the absorption of chlorophyll a (helped by the accessory pigments), it shows that chlorophyll a is the chief pigment.

📘 Definition 4.4 — The light reaction: photosystems and reaction centres

The light reactions (photochemical phase) include light absorption, water splitting, oxygen release and the formation of the high-energy chemical intermediates ATP and NADPH.

The pigments are organised into two discrete photochemical light-harvesting complexes (LHC) within Photosystem I (PS I) and Photosystem II (PS II), named in the order of their discovery, not the order in which they work. Each LHC is made of hundreds of pigment molecules bound to proteins and forms an antenna: it absorbs light of different wavelengths and funnels the energy inward. Each photosystem has all the pigments except one molecule of chlorophyll a, which forms the reaction centre.

  • PS I reaction centre: chlorophyll a with its absorption peak at 700 nm — P700.
  • PS II reaction centre: chlorophyll a with its absorption peak at 680 nm — P680.
📐 Principle 4.2 — Electron transport, the Z-scheme and the splitting of water
  1. Red light of 680 nm absorbed by PS II excites electrons of P680 to a higher energy level; they are accepted by an electron acceptor, which passes them on to an electron transport system of carriers (including cytochromes). The electrons move downhill in terms of redox potential and reach PS I.
  2. At the same time, light of 700 nm excites electrons of P700 in PS I. They are taken by another acceptor of greater redox potential and passed downhill to NADP⁺, reducing it to NADPH + H⁺. The electrons that came from PS II fill the gap left in P700.
  3. PS II replaces its lost electrons by splitting water. The water-splitting complex is associated with PS II and is located on the inner side of the thylakoid membrane (facing the lumen): $$2\,\mathrm{H_2O}\longrightarrow 4\,\mathrm{H^+}+\mathrm{O_2}+4\,e^-$$ The protons and the oxygen are released; O₂ is a by-product of photosynthesis.

Drawn on a scale of redox potential, the path from water through PS II and PS I to NADP⁺ has the shape of a sideways letter Z: the Z-scheme. Each electron is boosted twice, once at each photosystem.

📘 Definition 4.5 — Photophosphorylation: non-cyclic and cyclic

Making ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate using light energy in chloroplasts is photophosphorylation.

  • Non-cyclic photophosphorylation — the two photosystems work in series (PS II, then PS I), joined by the electron transport chain. Electrons flow one way from water to NADP⁺; ATP and NADPH + H⁺ are both made, and O₂ is released.
  • Cyclic photophosphorylation — only PS I works. The excited electron is not passed to NADP⁺ but cycled back to PS I through the electron transport chain; only ATP is made (no NADPH, no O₂). It takes place in the stroma lamellae: the grana membranes have PS I and PS II, but the stroma lamellae lack PS II and NADP reductase. It also occurs when only light of wavelengths beyond 680 nm is available.
FeatureNon-cyclicCyclic
photosystemsPS II and PS IPS I only
electron pathwater → PS II → PS I → NADP⁺ (open)PS I → carriers → back to PS I (closed loop)
water split, O₂ releasedyesno
productsATP + NADPH + H⁺ATP only
wheregrana thylakoidsstroma lamellae (and grana, in far-red light)
✏️ Example 3 — Counting electrons and photons
In non-cyclic photophosphorylation each electron is excited once at PS II and once at PS I. (a) How many electrons must be removed from water to release one O₂? (b) How many NADPH can these electrons make? (c) How many photons are absorbed in releasing one O₂? (d) The Calvin cycle needs 12 NADPH to make one glucose. How many O₂ molecules are released, and how many photons absorbed, while these 12 NADPH are being made?
Find (c), the photons absorbed per O₂ released, before you open the solution:
(a) $2\,\mathrm{H_2O}\to4\,\mathrm{H^+}+\mathrm{O_2}+4e^-$: 4 electrons per O₂.
(b) NADP⁺ + 2e⁻ + H⁺ → NADPH: 4 electrons make 2 NADPH.
(c) Each electron absorbs one photon at PS II and one at PS I: $4\times2=8$ photons.
(d) 12 NADPH need $24$ electrons, which come from splitting $12$ H₂O: $24/4=6$ O₂, and $24\times2=48$ photons.
Check 6 O₂ per glucose and 12 H₂O split per glucose — exactly the numbers in the balanced equation of Definition 4.1 ✓.

In Interactive 1, keep the granal thylakoid but switch the light to far-red only (beyond 680 nm). When the electron counter reaches 20, what will the O₂ and NADPH readouts show?

In white light, at electrons transferred: 20 the readouts show photons absorbed: 40, O₂ released: 5, NADPH formed: 10 (4 e⁻ per O₂, 2 e⁻ per NADPH). With far-red only, P680 cannot be excited, so no water is split; the electrons from P700 run round the loop back to PS I. At 20 electrons the readouts are photons 20, O₂ 0, NADPH 0 — cyclic photophosphorylation, ATP only. Switching the membrane to stroma lamella gives the same result even in white light, because PS II and NADP reductase are missing there.
Interactive 1 — Z-Scheme Electron Tracer

Electrons (dots) are drawn on a scale of redox potential — higher means more energetic. Choose the light and the part of the thylakoid system, then watch the path: in non-cyclic flow electrons travel from water through PS II and PS I to NADP⁺; in cyclic flow they loop from PS I back to the cytochrome complex. The counters show what the electrons have produced.

pathway—
electrons transferred—
photons absorbed—
O₂ released—
NADPH formed—

Which statement about cyclic photophosphorylation is correct?

Chemiosmosis and the Calvin Cycle

The Z-scheme explains how NADPH is made, but not ATP. The answer, worked out by Peter Mitchell, is that the electron transport chain is really a proton pump: it builds up a difference in H⁺ concentration across the thylakoid membrane, and the flow of protons back through an enzyme turns the enzyme like a mill-wheel.

📐 Principle 4.3 — The chemiosmotic hypothesis

ATP synthesis is linked to the development of a proton gradient across the thylakoid membrane. Protons accumulate inside the membrane, in the lumen of the thylakoid, for three reasons:

  1. Water is split on the inner side of the membrane, so its H⁺ are released into the lumen.
  2. As electrons pass through the photosystems, the primary acceptor (towards the outer side) hands its electron to an H carrier rather than an electron carrier. The H carrier picks up a proton from the stroma and, when it passes its electron on to a carrier on the inner side, releases the proton into the lumen.
  3. NADP reductase is on the stroma side; reducing NADP⁺ to NADPH + H⁺ removes protons from the stroma.

So H⁺ falls in the stroma and rises in the lumen — the pH of the lumen drops. The gradient breaks down when protons move back to the stroma through ATP synthase, which has two parts: CF₀, embedded in the membrane, forming a transmembrane channel for facilitated diffusion of protons; and CF₁, protruding on the outer surface of the thylakoid membrane facing the stroma. Proton flow causes a conformational change in CF₁ that makes ATP from ADP and Pi.

Chemiosmosis therefore needs a membrane, a proton pump, a proton gradient and ATP synthase. Light energy is used to pump the protons; the energy stored in the gradient is what makes ATP. ATP and NADPH are then used immediately in the stroma.

With ATP and NADPH in hand, the stroma can fix CO₂. Melvin Calvin and his colleagues fed radioactive ¹⁴CO₂ to algae and stopped the reaction after a few seconds: the first labelled product was a 3-carbon acid, 3-phosphoglyceric acid (PGA). Plants whose first stable product is PGA are C₃ plants. Later another group of plants was found whose first stable product is the 4-carbon oxaloacetic acid (OAA) — the C₄ plants of the next subsection. The Calvin cycle runs in all photosynthetic plants, whether they have C₃ or C₄ (or other) pathways.

📘 Definition 4.6 — The Calvin cycle (C₃ cycle)

The primary CO₂ acceptor is a 5-carbon ketose sugar, ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate (RuBP). The cycle has three stages:

  1. Carboxylation — fixation of CO₂ into a stable organic intermediate. The enzyme RuBisCO (RuBP carboxylase-oxygenase) adds CO₂ to RuBP, giving two molecules of 3-PGA: $\mathrm{RuBP}\,(5\mathrm{C})+\mathrm{CO_2}\to2\times\text{3-PGA}\,(3\mathrm{C})$.
  2. Reduction — a series of reactions that lead to glucose. Per CO₂ fixed, 2 ATP are used for phosphorylation and 2 NADPH for reduction, producing triose phosphate (glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate).
  3. Regeneration — RuBP must be regenerated for the cycle to continue, using 1 ATP per CO₂ for phosphorylation.

The cycle turns once for each CO₂ fixed. Six turns fix 6 CO₂ — enough carbon for one molecule of glucose.

📐 Rule 4.4 — The Calvin-cycle balance sheet

For every CO₂ fixed: 3 ATP and 2 NADPH. For one glucose (6 CO₂, 6 turns):

InOut
6 CO₂1 glucose
18 ATP18 ADP
12 NADPH12 NADP

In general, fixing $n$ CO₂ needs $3n$ ATP and $2n$ NADPH; $n$ carbon atoms of sugar need $n$ turns.

✏️ Example 4 — Paying for a molecule of sucrose
Sucrose ($\mathrm{C_{12}H_{22}O_{11}}$) is the form in which sugar is exported from leaves. To make one sucrose molecule from CO₂: (a) how many turns of the Calvin cycle are needed? (b) how many ATP and (c) how many NADPH? (d) In the carboxylation step of these turns, how many 3-PGA molecules are formed? (e) How many O₂ molecules are released by the light reaction in making the NADPH?
Find (b), the ATP needed for one sucrose, before you open the solution:
(a) 12 carbon atoms → 12 turns (12 CO₂ fixed).
(b) $3\times12=36$ ATP.
(c) $2\times12=24$ NADPH.
(d) Each carboxylation gives 2 PGA: $2\times12=24$ 3-PGA.
(e) 24 NADPH need 48 electrons; 4 electrons per O₂ (Example 3): $48/4=12$ O₂.
Check Sucrose is two hexoses: twice the glucose numbers ($2\times18=36$ ATP, $2\times12=24$ NADPH) ✓.

For every molecule of CO₂ fixed in the Calvin cycle, the cycle uses

The C₄ Pathway, Photorespiration and Limiting Factors

RuBisCO is the most abundant enzyme in the world — and a strangely imperfect one. Its active site can bind both CO₂ and O₂. In hot, dry, bright conditions, when stomata partly close and O₂ builds up inside the leaf, a C₃ plant loses part of its hard-won carbon. Some plants of dry tropical regions have evolved a way round the problem.

📘 Definition 4.7 — Photorespiration

RuBisCO has a much greater affinity for CO₂ than for O₂ when the two are present in nearly equal concentrations; the binding is competitive, so their relative concentrations decide which one binds. In C₃ plants some O₂ does bind to RuBisCO, and CO₂ fixation falls. Instead of forming two PGA, RuBP combines with O₂ to give

$$\mathrm{RuBP}+\mathrm{O_2}\longrightarrow\text{1 PGA}+\text{1 phosphoglycolate (2C)}$$

This pathway is photorespiration. In it there is no synthesis of sugars, ATP or NADPH; instead, CO₂ is released with the use of ATP — it is a wasteful process. (The phosphoglycolate is processed through three organelles — chloroplast, peroxisome and mitochondrion — where the CO₂ is lost.) Photorespiration occurs in C₃ plants and does not occur in C₄ plants.

📘 Definition 4.8 — Kranz anatomy and the C₄ (Hatch–Slack) pathway

C₄ plants — for example maize, sorghum and sugarcane — are adapted to dry tropical regions. Their leaves have Kranz anatomy ("Kranz" means wreath): the vascular bundles are surrounded by a wreath of large bundle sheath cells that have many chloroplasts, thick walls impervious to gaseous exchange, and no intercellular spaces. Mesophyll cells lie outside them.

  1. In the mesophyll cells the primary CO₂ acceptor is the 3-carbon phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP); the enzyme is PEP carboxylase (PEPcase). Mesophyll cells lack RuBisCO.
  2. The product is the 4-carbon oxaloacetic acid (OAA), which forms other 4-carbon acids such as malic acid or aspartic acid; these are transported into the bundle sheath cells.
  3. In the bundle sheath the C₄ acid is broken down to release CO₂ and a 3-carbon molecule (pyruvate), which returns to the mesophyll and is converted back to PEP.
  4. The CO₂ released in the bundle sheath enters the Calvin cycle. Bundle sheath cells are rich in RuBisCO but lack PEPcase.

The basic pathway that makes sugar — the Calvin cycle — is therefore common to C₃ and C₄ plants; the C₄ cycle is a pump that delivers CO₂ to it.

📐 Key fact 4.5 — C₃ and C₄ plants compared
FeatureC₃ plants (wheat, rice, mango)C₄ plants (maize, sorghum, sugarcane)
leaf anatomyno Kranz anatomyKranz anatomy: large bundle sheath cells
primary CO₂ acceptorRuBP (5C)PEP (3C) in mesophyll; RuBP in bundle sheath
first stable product3-PGA (3C)OAA (4C)
enzyme of first carboxylationRuBisCOPEPcase
Calvin cycle inmesophyll cellsbundle sheath cells
photorespirationpresentabsent
temperature optimumlowerhigher — tolerate high temperature
response to high lightsaturate at lower lightrespond to high light intensities
CO₂ saturationonly beyond about 450 µL L⁻¹about 360 µL L⁻¹
biomass productivitylowergreater

Why no photorespiration in C₄? Breaking down the C₄ acid in the bundle sheath raises the CO₂ concentration around RuBisCO, so the enzyme works as a carboxylase and its oxygenase activity is minimised. This is also why C₄ plants are more productive and tolerate higher temperatures.

✏️ Example 5 — C₃ or C₄?
Leaves of two grasses, X and Y, are fed ¹⁴CO₂ for 2 seconds in bright light at 35 °C. In X the radioactivity is first found in a 4-carbon acid; in Y, in a 3-carbon acid. When the O₂ in the air around the leaves is lowered from 21% to 2%, the rate of photosynthesis of Y rises by about a third, while that of X hardly changes. (a) Which grass is C₄? (b) Where in X would you find RuBisCO? (c) Explain the effect of lowering O₂ on Y. (d) Which grass would you expect to show Kranz anatomy, and which to grow better on a hot, dry plain?
(a) X — its first stable product is a C₄ acid (OAA).
(b) In the bundle sheath cells only; its mesophyll cells have PEPcase and lack RuBisCO.
(c) Y is C₃. O₂ competes with CO₂ for RuBisCO; at 21% O₂ some RuBP is oxygenated (photorespiration) and carbon is lost. Lowering O₂ removes the competition, so net fixation rises.
(d) X shows Kranz anatomy and suits the hot, dry plain: no photorespiration, higher temperature optimum, high-light response. X is unaffected by O₂ because the CO₂ concentration at its RuBisCO is already high.

Whatever the pathway, the rate of photosynthesis depends on many factors. Internal (plant) factors include the number, size, age and orientation of leaves, the mesophyll cells and chloroplasts, the internal CO₂ concentration and the amount of chlorophyll. External factors include the availability of sunlight, temperature, CO₂ concentration and water. Several of these act together; at any moment, one of them sets the pace.

📐 Law 4.6 — Blackman's law of limiting factors (1905)

If a chemical process is affected by more than one factor, its rate is determined by the factor that is nearest to its minimal value: it is the factor that directly affects the process if its quantity is changed. A green leaf in bright light with plenty of CO₂ but at low temperature is limited by temperature; the same leaf in dim light is limited by light, and adding CO₂ will not help it.

📘 Definition 4.9 — The external factors
  • Light — quality, intensity and duration matter. At low intensities the rate rises linearly with light; at higher intensities it stops rising, as other factors become limiting. Light saturation occurs at about 10 per cent of full sunlight, so except for plants in shade or in dense forests, light is rarely limiting in nature. Very high intensity can break down chlorophyll and lower the rate.
  • Carbon dioxide — the major limiting factor, because its concentration in air is very low (0.03–0.04 per cent). An increase up to about 0.05 per cent can raise CO₂ fixation; higher levels can be damaging over long periods. At low light neither C₃ nor C₄ plants respond to extra CO₂; at high light both do. C₄ plants saturate at about 360 µL L⁻¹, whereas C₃ plants keep responding and saturate only beyond 450 µL L⁻¹ — so present CO₂ levels limit C₃ plants. Greenhouse crops such as tomatoes and bell peppers are grown in CO₂-enriched air for higher yields.
  • Temperature — the dark reactions are enzymatic and therefore temperature-controlled; the light reactions are also temperature-sensitive, but much less so. C₄ plants respond to higher temperatures and have a higher optimum than C₃ plants; tropical plants have higher optima than temperate ones.
  • Water — although a reactant in the light reaction, water acts mainly through its effect on the plant: water stress closes stomata, reducing CO₂ supply, and makes leaves wilt, reducing their surface area and metabolic activity.
✏️ Example 6 — Which factor is limiting?
A greenhouse grower measures the photosynthesis of tomato leaves (C₃) at 25 °C (relative units):
lightCO₂ 0.03%CO₂ 0.05%
dim1010
bright2538
(a) What limits the rate in dim light? (b) What limits it in bright light at 0.03% CO₂? (c) By what percentage does enrichment to 0.05% raise the rate in bright light? (d) Should the grower enrich CO₂ on dull winter days? (e) Why should she not raise CO₂ far beyond 0.05% for weeks on end?
(a) Light: raising CO₂ in dim light has no effect (10 → 10), so light is the factor nearest its minimum.
(b) CO₂: in bright light, adding CO₂ raises the rate (25 → 38).
(c) $\dfrac{38-25}{25}\times100=52\%$.
(d) Little point: on dull days light limits, and extra CO₂ is wasted unless supplementary lighting is used.
(e) Beyond about 0.05%, CO₂ gives little further gain and can damage the plants over longer periods.

In Interactive 2 a C₃ leaf is at 25 °C, light 40% and CO₂ 400 µL L⁻¹. Which single change raises its rate the most?

At the starting settings the readouts show rate 27.2 and limiting factor: CO₂. Light 80%: still 27.2 — the leaf is light-saturated. Temperature 35 °C: the rate falls to 19.4, because the C₃ enzymes are past their optimum. CO₂ 800 µL L⁻¹: the rate rises to 34.0 (the C₃ curve saturates beyond about 450–500 µL L⁻¹, and the limit becomes the enzymes' capacity). Switch to C₄ at the starting settings: the rate is 29.9 and the limiting factor is temperature — 400 µL L⁻¹ already saturates a C₄ leaf (Key fact 4.5), but 25 °C is below its optimum.
Interactive 2 — Limiting Factors Lab (C₃ and C₄)

A simple Blackman-style model of a leaf. The graph shows the rate of photosynthesis against light intensity at the CO₂ level and temperature you choose; the bold curve is the selected plant, the dashed curve the other type. Press ▶ Play to sweep the light from darkness to full sun, then change CO₂ or temperature and see which factor is "nearest its minimum". (Model units; shapes follow the facts in this section, not data from one species.)

40%400
25 °C
rate—
limiting factor—
light at saturation—
other type, same conditions—

In a C₄ plant such as maize, the enzyme RuBisCO is found

⚠️ NEET traps — photosynthesis

1. O₂ comes from water. Not from CO₂. Twelve water molecules are split per glucose, and six new ones are made — that is why H₂O is on both sides of the balanced equation.

2. "Dark reaction" does not mean "in the dark". The biosynthetic phase does not use light directly, but it stops soon after the light goes off because it needs ATP and NADPH from the light reaction.

3. PS I = P700, PS II = P680. The photosystems are numbered by discovery, but in the Z-scheme PS II acts first. Water splitting is linked to PS II and happens on the inner (lumen) side of the thylakoid membrane.

4. Stroma lamellae lack PS II and NADP reductase. So only cyclic photophosphorylation (ATP only, no O₂, no NADPH) happens there.

5. Protons pile up in the lumen (low pH inside the thylakoid), and flow out to the stroma through CF₀; CF₁ faces the stroma and is where ATP is made.

6. Acceptor vs first product. C₃: acceptor RuBP (5C), first product 3-PGA (3C). C₄: acceptor PEP (3C), first product OAA (4C). Do not call RuBP "the first product".

7. Per CO₂: 3 ATP + 2 NADPH; per glucose: 18 ATP + 12 NADPH. The 2 + 2 in the reduction step alone is a common distractor.

8. In C₄ leaves, RuBisCO is in the bundle sheath, PEPcase in the mesophyll. Bundle sheath walls are thick and impervious to gases, with no intercellular spaces. C₄ plants still use the Calvin cycle.

9. Photorespiration makes 1 PGA + 1 phosphoglycolate, and no ATP, NADPH or sugar; it occurs in C₃ plants only. RuBisCO is the most abundant enzyme in the world.

10. Light saturation at about 10% of full sunlight; CO₂ is the major limiting factor (0.03–0.04% in air; enrichment useful up to about 0.05%). C₄ saturates at about 360 µL L⁻¹, C₃ only beyond 450 µL L⁻¹.

🚀 Beyond NEET — CAM plants and a C₄ rice

Not in the NMC NEET (UG) syllabus; optional background.

Cacti, pineapple and many succulents use a third arrangement, crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM). They open their stomata only at night, fix CO₂ with PEPcase into malic acid stored in large vacuoles, and keep the stomata shut in the heat of the day while the malate releases CO₂ to the Calvin cycle in the same cells. C₄ plants separate the two carboxylations in space (two cell types); CAM plants separate them in time (night and day), saving a great deal of water. Because C₄ crops are so productive, an international research consortium is trying to engineer Kranz anatomy and the C₄ enzymes into rice, a C₃ plant that feeds half the world.

Exercises

I
Early experiments, the site and the pigments.
  • 1 Describe Priestley's bell-jar experiment and its conclusion. Which essential condition for photosynthesis did it not reveal?
  • 2 State two conclusions of Jan Ingenhousz's experiments.
  • 3 What did Julius von Sachs show in 1854?
  • 4 Write van Niel's general equation of photosynthesis. Explain how his work on sulphur bacteria showed that the O₂ released by green plants comes from water.
  • 5 In Engelmann's experiment, why did the aerobic bacteria collect in two regions of the spectrum? What is an action spectrum?
  • 6 Name the exact site of: (a) the light reactions; (b) the Calvin cycle; (c) the splitting of water; (d) cyclic photophosphorylation.
  • 7 Name the four pigments separated by paper chromatography of a leaf extract, with the colour of each. Which is the chief pigment, and what are the two roles of the others?
  • 8 In the balanced equation for one glucose: (a) how many of the oxygen atoms in the released O₂ come from water? (b) how many oxygen atoms from CO₂ end up in the water formed?
1 A burning candle or a mouse in a closed bell jar soon fails; with a mint plant inside, the candle burns and the mouse lives. Plants restore to the air what burning and breathing remove. He did not realise that light is essential.
2 Sunlight is essential for plants to purify the air; only the green parts of plants release oxygen (bubbles round green parts of an aquatic plant in light).
3 Chlorophyll is located in special bodies (chloroplasts) in plant cells, and the plant makes glucose, usually stored as starch.
4 $2\,\mathrm{H_2A}+\mathrm{CO_2}\xrightarrow{\text{light}}2\,\mathrm{A}+\mathrm{CH_2O}+\mathrm{H_2O}$. With H₂S as donor, the bacteria release sulphur, not O₂: the by-product comes from the hydrogen donor. In green plants the donor is water, so O₂ comes from water.
5 Most O₂ was released where the alga absorbed light most strongly — the blue and red regions — and aerobic bacteria gather where O₂ is highest. An action spectrum is a graph of the rate of photosynthesis against wavelength.
6 (a) The thylakoid membranes (grana and stroma lamellae); (b) the stroma; (c) the inner (lumen) side of the thylakoid membrane, at PS II; (d) the stroma lamellae.
7 Chlorophyll a (bright or blue-green), chlorophyll b (yellow-green), xanthophylls (yellow), carotenoids (yellow to yellow-orange). Chlorophyll a is the chief pigment. Accessory pigments widen the range of wavelengths used and protect chlorophyll a from photo-oxidation.
8 (a) All $12$ (6 O₂ from 12 H₂O). (b) $12-6=6$: glucose takes 6 of CO₂'s 12 oxygen atoms, and the 6 water molecules take the other $6$.
II
The light reaction and chemiosmosis.
  • 1 What is a light-harvesting complex? Why is it called an antenna, and what is its reaction centre?
  • 2 Why are the reaction centres of the two photosystems called P700 and P680?
  • 3 Trace the path of an electron in non-cyclic photophosphorylation from water to NADP⁺, naming each component in order.
  • 4 Write the equation for the splitting of water. With which photosystem is it associated, and on which side of the membrane does it occur?
  • 5 Give four differences between cyclic and non-cyclic photophosphorylation.
  • 6 Give the three reasons why protons accumulate in the thylakoid lumen.
  • 7 Name the two parts of ATP synthase in the chloroplast and state where each lies. What makes ATP form?
  • 8 In non-cyclic flow, how many electrons must pass from water to NADP⁺ to (a) release 3 O₂; (b) reduce 9 NADP⁺? (c) How many photons are absorbed in (b)?
1 A complex of hundreds of pigment molecules bound to proteins within a photosystem. Like an antenna it collects light of many wavelengths over a large area and funnels the energy to one molecule of chlorophyll a, the reaction centre, which gives up an electron.
2 Their chlorophyll a absorbs maximally at 700 nm (PS I) and 680 nm (PS II); P stands for pigment.
3 Water → PS II (P680, excited by light) → electron acceptor → electron transport chain (plastoquinone, cytochrome b₆f complex, plastocyanin) → PS I (P700, excited again) → acceptor → ferredoxin → NADP reductase → NADP⁺, forming NADPH + H⁺.
4 $2\,\mathrm{H_2O}\to4\,\mathrm{H^+}+\mathrm{O_2}+4e^-$; associated with PS II; on the inner (lumen) side of the thylakoid membrane.
5 Non-cyclic: PS II and PS I; open electron path; water split and O₂ released; ATP and NADPH; grana. Cyclic: PS I only; electrons return to PS I; no water split or O₂; ATP only; stroma lamellae (or when only light beyond 680 nm is available).
6 Water is split on the lumen side; the H carrier (plastoquinone) takes H⁺ from the stroma and releases it into the lumen; NADP reductase on the stroma side uses up stromal H⁺.
7 CF₀, embedded in the thylakoid membrane, forms a proton channel; CF₁ protrudes on the stroma side. Protons flowing down their gradient through CF₀ cause a conformational change in CF₁ that synthesises ATP from ADP and Pi.
8 (a) $3\times4=12$ electrons. (b) $9\times2=18$ electrons. (c) $18\times2=36$ photons.
III
The Calvin cycle, the C₄ pathway and photorespiration.
  • 1 Name the three stages of the Calvin cycle and the ATP and NADPH used in each, per CO₂ fixed.
  • 2 Why is the Calvin cycle called the C₃ pathway? Name its primary CO₂ acceptor and the enzyme that fixes CO₂.
  • 3 To make 3 molecules of glucose, how many (a) turns of the Calvin cycle, (b) ATP, (c) NADPH are required?
  • 4 A chloroplast fixes 24 CO₂ by the Calvin cycle. (a) How many molecules of 3-PGA are formed in carboxylation? (b) How many hexose molecules could be exported?
  • 5 Describe Kranz anatomy, giving three features of the bundle sheath cells.
  • 6 Outline the C₄ (Hatch–Slack) pathway in four steps, naming the cell in which each occurs.
  • 7 Which enzyme is absent from (a) the mesophyll cells and (b) the bundle sheath cells of a C₄ leaf?
  • 8 What is photorespiration? Give its products when RuBP combines with O₂, and two reasons why it is called wasteful.
  • 9 Explain why C₄ plants show no photorespiration and tolerate higher temperatures. Name two C₄ crops.
1 Carboxylation (no ATP or NADPH; RuBisCO adds CO₂ to RuBP); reduction (2 ATP + 2 NADPH); regeneration of RuBP (1 ATP). Total 3 ATP + 2 NADPH per CO₂.
2 Its first stable product, 3-PGA, has three carbon atoms. Acceptor: RuBP (5C). Enzyme: RuBisCO.
3 (a) $6\times3=18$ turns; (b) $18\times3=54$ ATP; (c) $18\times2=36$ NADPH.
4 (a) $2\times24=48$ PGA. (b) $24/6=4$ hexoses.
5 Large bundle sheath cells form a wreath ("Kranz") round each vascular bundle, often in several layers; they have many chloroplasts, thick walls impervious to gaseous exchange, and no intercellular spaces.
6 Mesophyll: PEP + CO₂ → OAA (PEPcase). Mesophyll: OAA → malic or aspartic acid, transported to the bundle sheath. Bundle sheath: C₄ acid → CO₂ + 3-carbon molecule (pyruvate); CO₂ enters the Calvin cycle (RuBisCO). Mesophyll: pyruvate → PEP, ready for the next CO₂.
7 (a) RuBisCO; (b) PEPcase.
8 The oxygenation of RuBP by RuBisCO in light, in C₃ plants: RuBP + O₂ → 1 PGA + 1 phosphoglycolate. Wasteful because it makes no sugar, ATP or NADPH, and it releases fixed carbon as CO₂ while using ATP.
9 Decarboxylation of C₄ acids in the sealed bundle sheath raises the CO₂ concentration at RuBisCO, so the enzyme acts as a carboxylase and its oxygenase activity is minimised; without photorespiratory losses they keep fixing carbon efficiently at high temperatures, where their optimum lies. Examples: maize, sorghum (also sugarcane).
IV
Factors affecting photosynthesis.
  • 1 State Blackman's law of limiting factors.
  • 2 List four internal (plant) factors and four external factors that affect photosynthesis.
  • 3 At what fraction of full sunlight does light saturation usually occur? Why, then, is light rarely limiting in nature, and what happens at very high intensities?
  • 4 Compare the responses of C₃ and C₄ plants to rising CO₂ concentration at high light, giving the saturation levels.
  • 5 Why are greenhouse tomatoes and bell peppers grown in CO₂-enriched air? Up to roughly what concentration is enrichment useful?
  • 6 Why is the biosynthetic phase more sensitive to temperature than the light reactions? Compare the temperature optima of C₃ and C₄ plants, and of tropical and temperate plants.
  • 7 Only a tiny fraction of the water a plant absorbs is split in photosynthesis. How, then, does water shortage reduce photosynthesis?
  • 8 Applied. In the model of Interactive 2, a C₃ leaf at 25 °C and 60% light photosynthesises at 27.2 units in 400 µL L⁻¹ CO₂ and at 34.0 units in 800 µL L⁻¹. By what percentage does doubling the CO₂ raise the rate? Would doubling the light at 400 µL L⁻¹ help?
1 If a chemical process is affected by more than one factor, its rate is determined by the factor nearest to its minimal value — the factor that directly affects the process if its quantity is changed.
2 Internal: number, size, age and orientation of leaves; mesophyll cells and chloroplasts; internal CO₂ concentration; amount of chlorophyll. External: sunlight, temperature, CO₂ concentration, water.
3 About 10% of full sunlight. Most leaves receive far more than that, so only plants in shade or in dense forest are light-limited. Very high intensity can break down chlorophyll and lower the rate.
4 At high light both respond to more CO₂. C₄ plants saturate at about 360 µL L⁻¹; C₃ plants keep responding and saturate only beyond about 450 µL L⁻¹, so present air limits C₃ plants more.
5 CO₂ is the major limiting factor for these C₃ crops in bright greenhouses; enrichment raises fixation and yield. Up to about 0.05% (500 µL L⁻¹); much higher levels can be damaging over long periods.
6 The biosynthetic phase is a chain of enzyme-catalysed reactions, and enzyme activity depends strongly on temperature; the photochemical steps are much less temperature-sensitive. C₄ plants have higher optima than C₃; tropical plants higher than temperate ones.
7 Indirectly, through the plant: water stress closes the stomata, cutting the supply of CO₂, and wilting reduces the leaf surface area and metabolic activity.
8 $\dfrac{34.0-27.2}{27.2}\times100=25\%$. No: at 400 µL L⁻¹ the leaf is light-saturated (above about 11% light in the model), so CO₂ — not light — is the factor nearest its minimum.
🎯 Exam corner NEET · MCQ

E1. NEET · MCQ Statement I: Only cyclic photophosphorylation can take place in the stroma lamellae of a chloroplast. Statement II: Cyclic photophosphorylation produces both ATP and NADPH + H⁺. Choose the correct option. (A) Both statements I and II are correct (B) Both statements I and II are incorrect (C) Statement I is correct but statement II is incorrect (D) Statement I is incorrect but statement II is correct

Idea Stroma lamellae lack PS II and NADP reductase, so only the cyclic path is possible there — statement I is correct. In the cyclic path the electron returns to PS I and NADP⁺ is never reduced: ATP only — statement II is incorrect.
Answer (C).

E2. NEET · MCQ Assertion (A): Photorespiration does not occur in C₄ plants. Reason (R): Decarboxylation of C₄ acids in the bundle sheath cells raises the CO₂ concentration around RuBisCO, so that it acts mainly as a carboxylase. (A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A (B) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A (C) A is true but R is false (D) A is false but R is true

A True (Definition 4.7).
R True, and it is the mechanism: O₂ and CO₂ compete for RuBisCO, and a high CO₂ concentration wins.
Answer (A).

E3. NEET · MCQ Match List-I with List-II. List-I: (a) P700 (b) 3-PGA (c) PEP (d) PEP carboxylase. List-II: (i) primary CO₂ acceptor in C₄ plants (ii) reaction centre of PS I (iii) enzyme that fixes CO₂ in the mesophyll of C₄ plants (iv) first stable product of the Calvin cycle. (A) a-iv, b-ii, c-iii, d-i (B) a-ii, b-i, c-iv, d-iii (C) a-iii, b-iv, c-i, d-ii (D) a-ii, b-iv, c-i, d-iii

Recall P700 — PS I reaction centre; 3-PGA — first stable product of the C₃ cycle; PEP — the C₄ acceptor; PEPcase — the mesophyll enzyme.
Answer (D).
⏱ Shortcut a-ii is the easiest pair; only (B) and (D) have it, and (B) makes 3-PGA the C₄ acceptor.

E4. NEET · MCQ How many of the following statements are correct? (i) The splitting of water is associated with PS II. (ii) The water-splitting complex lies on the stroma side of the thylakoid membrane. (iii) NADP reductase is located on the stroma side of the membrane. (iv) CF₁ of ATP synthase is embedded in the thylakoid membrane. (v) The proton gradient forms because H⁺ accumulate in the thylakoid lumen. (A) two (B) three (C) four (D) five

Check (i) ✓; (ii) ✗ — it is on the inner (lumen) side; (iii) ✓; (iv) ✗ — CF₀ is embedded, CF₁ protrudes into the stroma; (v) ✓.
Answer Three: (B).

E5. NEET · MCQ The graph shows how the rate of photosynthesis of two plants, X and Y, changes with CO₂ concentration in bright light at a warm temperature. Which statement is correct?present airXY0360500800CO₂ (µL L⁻¹)rate(A) X is a C₃ plant such as wheat, and present CO₂ levels limit X more than Y. (B) Y is a C₄ plant, because it saturates only at a high CO₂ concentration. (C) Both curves show that light is the limiting factor beyond saturation. (D) X is a C₄ plant such as maize; at present CO₂ levels it is near saturation, while Y would still gain from more CO₂.

Read the graph X saturates at about 360 µL L⁻¹ — the C₄ value; Y keeps rising past 450 µL L⁻¹ — the C₃ pattern. At the dashed line X is already flat, Y is not. Beyond saturation the limit is the enzymes' capacity (and temperature), not light, which is bright here.
Answer (D).
⏱ Shortcut "Saturates early and higher" = C₄; (A) and (B) swap the two types.

E6. NEET · MCQ How many molecules of ATP and NADPH does the Calvin cycle use to fix enough CO₂ for two molecules of glucose? (A) 36 ATP and 24 NADPH (B) 18 ATP and 12 NADPH (C) 24 ATP and 36 NADPH (D) 36 ATP and 36 NADPH

Count Two glucose need 12 CO₂: $12\times3=36$ ATP and $12\times2=24$ NADPH.
Answer (A).
⏱ Shortcut ATP : NADPH is always 3 : 2 in the Calvin cycle — only (A) has that ratio at the right size.
🔬 Research–Teaching NexusResearch-tutored · optional, about 30 minutes

Research question. Does adding CO₂ to a greenhouse help a C₃ crop as much as a C₄ crop — and is it worth paying for?

Why it matters. Greenhouse growers in the Netherlands, Canada, Spain and increasingly India burn natural gas or pipe in captured CO₂ to raise yields of tomatoes, peppers and cucumbers. Plant scientists use the same experiments to predict how crops will respond as the CO₂ in the atmosphere keeps rising. The answer depends on the photosynthetic pathway — exactly the C₃/C₄ difference of this section.

What to do.

  1. (Illustrative data, constructed for this exercise.) Leaf photosynthesis in bright light at 28 °C, in µmol CO₂ m⁻² s⁻¹: tomato — 14.0 at 300 µL L⁻¹, 17.5 at 400, 22.0 at 600, 24.0 at 800; maize — 30.0, 32.5, 33.0, 33.0 at the same levels. Plot both on one graph.
  2. For each crop find the percentage increase in rate from 400 to 800 µL L⁻¹, and from 300 to 400 µL L⁻¹.
  3. Estimate roughly where each curve saturates and compare with Key fact 4.5.
  4. A grower can afford enrichment to 800 µL L⁻¹ for one crop only. Which should it be? Give two other factors (think of Blackman's law) that must be right before enrichment pays off.

Tools: graph paper or a spreadsheet; Interactive 2 (change CO₂ at full light for C₃ and C₄).

Hand in: the graph, the four percentages, your recommendation and the two conditions.

Going further. Find out what a FACE (free-air CO₂ enrichment) experiment is, and what such experiments in fields of rice and wheat have shown about grain yield and grain protein.

Instructor note (illustrative data): tomato 400→800: $(24.0-17.5)/17.5\approx37\%$; 300→400: $25\%$. Maize 400→800: $(33.0-32.5)/32.5\approx1.5\%$; 300→400: $\approx8.3\%$. Maize saturates near 400 µL L⁻¹ (C₄, about 360 in theory); tomato is still rising at 600–800 (C₃, saturating beyond 450). Enrich the tomato house. Light must be high (on dull days light limits) and temperature near the optimum; water and nutrients must not be limiting, and stomata must be open.

🧪 Self-check quiz

0/5 correct

Q1. The first stable product of CO₂ fixation in sorghum is

Q2. The reaction centre of Photosystem II is

Q3. During photorespiration, RuBP combines with O₂ to form

Q4. Light saturation of photosynthesis in most plants occurs at about

Q5. The rate of photosynthesis of a wheat leaf does not change when the light is doubled, but rises when CO₂ is increased. According to Blackman's law, the limiting factor was