7.4 Evolution
Where the first living things came from, what fossils, limbs, embryos and molecules tell us about common descent, how Darwin's natural selection works together with mutation, recombination, gene flow and genetic drift, how the Hardy–Weinberg principle measures evolution, and how our own species arose.
In 1950s England, a hospital could cure almost any staphylococcal infection with penicillin. Within a few decades most strains of Staphylococcus aureus had become resistant, and today doctors need new drugs against bacteria that shrug off old ones. Nobody designed those resistant bacteria. In every population of microbes a few cells happened to carry variants that let them survive the drug; they multiplied, and their descendants took over. That is evolution happening fast enough to watch — the same process that, over billions of years, produced every living thing.
This section tells that longer story. It begins with the origin of life on a young, lifeless Earth; collects the evidence that living things share common ancestors (fossils, comparative anatomy, embryology, molecules, and evolution observed in our own time); follows the ideas of Lamarck, Darwin and de Vries into the modern synthetic theory; and then makes evolution measurable with the Hardy–Weinberg principle, the types of natural selection, gene flow and genetic drift. It ends with the evolution of our own species. The genetics of Section 7.1 and the molecules of Sections 7.2–7.3 are the raw material: mutation and recombination make the variation that evolution works on.
The Origin of Life
According to the Big Bang theory, the universe began with a huge explosion; as it expanded and cooled, galaxies, stars and planets formed. (Older estimates of the age of the universe were about 20 billion years; modern measurements give about 13.8 billion.) Earth formed about 4.5 billion years ago. At first it had no atmosphere. Water vapour, methane, carbon dioxide and ammonia released from the molten mass covered the surface. Ultraviolet rays from the Sun broke water into hydrogen and oxygen; the lighter hydrogen escaped, and oxygen combined with ammonia and methane to form water, carbon dioxide and other gases. The ozone layer formed, and as the Earth cooled the water vapour fell as rain and filled the depressions to form oceans. Life appeared about 500 million years after the Earth formed — almost 4 billion years ago.
- Panspermia. Some early Greek thinkers (and some astronomers still) suggested that units of life called spores were transferred to Earth from other planets.
- Spontaneous generation (abiogenesis, in its old sense). For a long time people believed that life arises from decaying and rotting matter such as straw and mud. Louis Pasteur disproved it: in pre-sterilised flasks, killed yeast gave rise to no new life when the flask was kept closed to air, while a similar flask open to air developed new living organisms. Life comes only from pre-existing life (biogenesis).
- Chemical evolution (Oparin–Haldane theory). A. I. Oparin of Russia and J. B. S. Haldane of England proposed that the first form of life could have come from pre-existing non-living organic molecules (such as RNA and protein), and that the formation of life was preceded by chemical evolution — the formation of diverse organic molecules from inorganic constituents. Conditions on the early Earth were high temperature, volcanic storms and a reducing atmosphere containing CH₄, NH₃ and other gases, without free oxygen.
In 1953 S. L. Miller, an American scientist, created similar conditions on a laboratory scale. He passed an electric discharge (sparks, imitating lightning) through a closed flask containing CH₄, H₂, NH₃ and water vapour at high temperature (NEET questions quote 800 °C), with the products cooled and collected. After about a week he found amino acids in the water.
In similar experiments others obtained sugars, nitrogen bases, pigments and fats. Analysis of meteorites revealed similar compounds, suggesting that such processes occur elsewhere in space too. These results support chemical evolution — but they do not show how the first cell arose.
On this view, the first non-cellular forms of life — giant molecules such as RNA, protein and polysaccharides, able to reproduce themselves — could have arisen about 3 billion years ago. The first cellular forms probably did not appear until about 2000 million years ago; they were single cells, and all life forms were in water at that time. The theory of chemical evolution followed by biological evolution is accepted by the majority, although the step from molecules to the first cell remains a hypothesis that has not been demonstrated.
Which gases did Miller place in the closed flask through which he passed an electric discharge?
Evidence for Evolution
If living things share common ancestors, that history should have left traces: in rocks, in the bodies of living organisms, in their development and in their molecules. It has — and we can also see evolution happening today.
Fossils are remains of hard parts of life forms found in rocks. Rocks form from sediments, and a cross-section of the Earth's crust shows layers of sediment laid one over another during the long history of the Earth. Rock layers of different ages contain different life forms, which probably died during the formation of that sediment. Some fossils resemble modern organisms; many represent extinct organisms (e.g. dinosaurs). The study of fossils in rock layers shows that life forms varied over time and that certain forms are restricted to certain geological time spans; hence new forms of life have arisen at different times. The age of fossils is found by radioactive dating.
Homologous organs have the same basic structure and origin but perform different functions. The forelimbs of whales, bats, cheetahs and humans are all built from the same bones — humerus, radius and ulna, carpals, metacarpals and phalanges — although they are used for swimming, flying, running and grasping. Other examples: the hearts and brains of vertebrates; in plants, the thorn of Bougainvillea and the tendril of Cucurbita (both modified axillary shoots). Homology results from divergent evolution: the same structure developed along different directions in descendants of a common ancestor, as adaptations to different needs. Homology indicates common ancestry.
Analogous organs perform the same function but are not anatomically similar and do not share an origin: the wings of a butterfly and of a bird; the eye of an Octopus and of a mammal; the flippers of penguins and of dolphins; sweet potato (a root modification) and potato (a stem modification) as stores of food. Analogy results from convergent evolution: similar habitats select similar adaptive features in groups of organisms that are not closely related.
- Embryology. Ernst Haeckel proposed embryological support for evolution from features common to all vertebrate embryos but absent in the adults — for example, all vertebrate embryos, including the human embryo, develop a row of vestigial gill slits just behind the head, functional only in fishes. On careful study his proposal was disapproved by Karl Ernst von Baer, who noted that embryos never pass through the adult stages of other animals.
- Molecular (biochemical) evidence. Similarities in proteins and genes performing a given function among diverse organisms point to common ancestry, in the same way as homologous organs. The universality of the genetic code (Section 7.3) is the most striking example.
- Artificial selection. Breeders have produced many breeds of dogs, cattle and crops in a few hundred to a few thousand years, showing that selection on variation can change a population greatly.
- Industrial melanism. In England, in collections of moths made before industrialisation (around 1850) white-winged moths outnumbered dark-winged (melanised) moths on the trees; in collections made in the same area after industrialisation (around 1920) dark-winged moths were more numerous. Industrial smoke and soot killed the lichens and darkened the tree trunks, so white-winged moths could no longer hide and were picked off by predators, while dark moths survived. In rural areas, where trunks stayed covered with lichens, the dark moths remained rare. (Lichens are indicators of air pollution: they do not grow in polluted areas.)
- Anthropogenic action. Excessive use of herbicides and pesticides has selected resistant varieties in a much shorter time; microbes resistant to antibiotics, and eukaryotic cells resistant to drugs, appear on a time scale of months and years, not centuries.
The thorn of Bougainvillea and the tendril of Cucurbita are an example of
Darwin, de Vries and the Modern Synthetic Theory
Before Darwin, the naturalist Lamarck proposed that evolution of life forms occurred through the use and disuse of organs: giraffes, stretching their necks to reach leaves on tall trees, passed the slightly longer necks on to their young, so that over many generations the neck became long. No one believes this conjecture today, because characters acquired during an individual's life are not inherited.
During his sea voyage around the world on the sail ship H.M.S. Beagle, Charles Darwin concluded that existing living forms share similarities to varying degrees among themselves and with life forms that existed millions of years ago, many of them now extinct. Alfred Russel Wallace, a naturalist who worked in the Malay Archipelago, reached similar conclusions at about the same time.
- Variation — individuals of a population differ from one another, and many differences are heritable.
- Over-production and struggle for existence — populations could grow very fast, yet resources are limited, so individuals compete and most offspring do not survive to reproduce.
- Natural selection — individuals with heritable variations that let them use resources better survive and leave more offspring; over generations their characters spread. Darwin called this survival of the fittest, and fitness in his sense means reproductive fitness: those who are better fit in an environment leave more progeny than others.
The two key concepts of Darwinian theory are branching descent (all organisms are descended from common ancestors, the lines branching over time) and natural selection.
Adaptive radiation is the evolution of different species in a given geographical area, starting from one point and literally radiating to other areas of geography (habitats). Examples:
- Darwin's finches of the Galapagos Islands. From the original seed-eating finches, many other forms with altered beaks arose, enabling them to become insectivorous and vegetarian finches.
- Australian marsupials. A number of marsupials, each different from the others, evolved from an ancestral stock, all within the Australian island continent.
- The placental mammals of Australia also show adaptive radiation.
When more than one adaptive radiation occurs in an isolated geographical area (representing different habitats), the result is convergent evolution: placental mammals and Australian marsupials that live in similar ways look alike — placental wolf and Tasmanian wolf (marsupial); flying squirrel and flying phalanger; mole and marsupial mole; anteater and numbat (banded anteater); mouse and marsupial mouse; lemur and spotted cuscus; bobcat and Tasmanian tiger cat.
Working on the evening primrose, Oenothera lamarckiana, Hugo de Vries concluded that it is mutation that causes evolution, and not the minor heritable variations that Darwin talked about. Mutations are random and directionless, while Darwinian variations are small and directional. De Vries believed that a single-step large mutation could cause speciation, and called it saltation. Evolution for Darwin was gradual; for de Vries it was by jumps.
The modern synthetic theory of evolution combines Darwin's natural selection with Mendelian and population genetics. Variation arises by mutation and genetic recombination (crossing over and independent assortment in meiosis, and fertilisation); allele frequencies also change by gene flow and genetic drift; natural selection favours the variants that leave more offspring; and reproductive isolation lets the changed populations become separate species. The origin of species is therefore based on heritable variation and natural selection acting on a population over many generations.
Which statement correctly contrasts de Vries with Darwin?
The Mechanism of Evolution: Hardy–Weinberg, Selection, Gene Flow and Drift
To see evolution happening, we need a baseline: what does a population look like when it is not evolving? The answer, found independently by the English mathematician G. H. Hardy and the German physician Wilhelm Weinberg in 1908, is the Hardy–Weinberg principle.
- The gene pool is the total set of genes and their alleles in a population.
- The allele (gene) frequency is the fraction of all copies of a gene in the gene pool that are of one allele. For two alleles A and a with frequencies $p$ and $q$: $p+q=1$.
- Gene flow (gene migration). When individuals move from one place to another and breed there, alleles are added to (or lost from) the gene pool and allele frequencies change in both the old and the new population. If gene migration happens many times, there is gene flow.
- Genetic drift. If the same kind of change in allele frequencies happens by chance, it is called genetic drift. It is strongest in small populations. Sometimes the change is so great that a new sample of a population becomes a different species; the original drifted population becomes the founders, and the effect is called the founder effect.
In a population, allele frequencies are stable and constant from generation to generation — the gene pool remains constant — as long as no disturbing factor acts. This is genetic equilibrium. With random mating, two alleles of frequencies $p$ and $q$ combine at random, so the genotype frequencies are given by the binomial expansion of $(p+q)^2$:
$$p^{2}+2pq+q^{2}=1$$where $p^{2}$ is the frequency of AA, $2pq$ of Aa and $q^{2}$ of aa. (The equilibrium holds for a large, randomly mating population.)
Five factors disturb the equilibrium: gene migration (gene flow), genetic drift, mutation, genetic recombination and natural selection. When the frequency measured differs from the expected value, the difference indicates the extent of evolutionary change: disturbance of Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium = evolution.
- Find $q^{2}$ first if you can. The recessive phenotype shows only in aa, so the fraction showing it is $q^{2}$. Then $q=\sqrt{q^{2}}$ and $p=1-q$. (You cannot start from the dominant phenotype, which mixes AA and Aa.)
- From genotype counts, count alleles: $p=\tfrac{2(\text{AA})+(\text{Aa})}{2N}$.
- Carriers are heterozygotes: $2pq$. Multiply frequencies by the population size to get numbers.
- Test equilibrium by comparing observed genotype numbers with $p^{2}N$, $2pqN$, $q^{2}N$.
In the Hardy–Weinberg lab below, choose set % showing the recessive trait and set it to 1 %. What percentage of the population are carriers (Aa)?
Variation arises from mutation, recombination during gametogenesis, and gene flow and genetic drift. Natural selection is a process in which heritable variations enabling better survival allow their bearers to reproduce and leave a greater number of progeny. For a character that varies continuously (size, beak depth, birth weight), selection can act in three ways:
- Stabilising selection — individuals with the mean character value are favoured; both extremes are removed. More individuals acquire the mean value, so the peak becomes higher and narrower (e.g. human birth weight: very light and very heavy babies have lower survival).
- Directional selection — individuals at one extreme are favoured. More individuals acquire a value other than the mean, and the peak shifts in one direction (e.g. dark moths in industrial areas; antibiotic-resistant bacteria; deeper beaks in finches after a drought).
- Disruptive selection — individuals at both extremes are favoured over the mean. More individuals acquire peripheral values at both ends, and the distribution develops two peaks (e.g. a seed-eating bird population where only very small and very large seeds are available).
In the selection lab below, choose stabilising selection and run it for 20 generations. What happens to the mean beak depth (starting at 10.0 mm) and the spread (starting SD 1.50 mm)?
In a population in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium, the frequency of the recessive allele is 0.4. What fraction of the population is homozygous dominant?
The Origin and Evolution of Humans
Human evolution is one branch of the primate story, pieced together from fossil skulls, teeth and limb bones, and from the tools and art our ancestors left behind. The figures below are the ones used in the NEET syllabus; new fossils keep adding detail.
| When (approx.) | Form | Key features |
|---|---|---|
| about 15 mya | Dryopithecus and Ramapithecus | primates; hairy, walked like gorillas and chimpanzees; Ramapithecus was more man-like, Dryopithecus more ape-like |
| 3–4 mya | man-like primates of eastern Africa | probably not taller than 4 feet, but walked upright; a few man-like bones found in Ethiopia and Tanzania |
| about 2 mya | Australopithecines | lived in East African grasslands; hunted with stone weapons but essentially ate fruit |
| about 2 mya | Homo habilis | the first human-like being; brain capacity 650–800 cc; probably did not eat meat |
| about 1.5 mya | Homo erectus | fossils discovered in Java in 1891; large brain, about 900 cc; probably ate meat |
| 1,00,000–40,000 years ago | Neanderthal man | brain size 1400 cc; lived in the Near East and Central Asian countries; used hides to protect their bodies and buried their dead |
| 75,000–10,000 years ago | Homo sapiens (modern humans) | arose in Africa and moved across continents, developing into distinct races; modern H. sapiens arose during the ice age between 75,000 and 10,000 years ago |
| about 18,000 years ago | pre-historic cave art | e.g. the Bhimbetka rock shelters in Raisen district, Madhya Pradesh |
| about 10,000 years ago | agriculture | human settlements began |
Which hominid had a brain capacity of about 1400 cc, used hides to protect the body and buried its dead?
1. Miller's gases. CH₄, H₂, NH₃ and water vapour — no free O₂. Products: amino acids (others later found sugars, nitrogen bases, pigments, fats). Miller did not make a cell.
2. Pasteur disproved spontaneous generation; Oparin and Haldane proposed chemical evolution. Don't swap them.
3. Homologous = same origin, different function = divergent evolution. Analogous = same function, different origin = convergent evolution. Thorn of Bougainvillea / tendril of Cucurbita are homologous; potato / sweet potato are analogous.
4. Haeckel proposed, von Baer disapproved. Embryos do not pass through the adult stages of other animals.
5. Industrial melanism is selection, not mutation caused by soot. The dark form already existed; pollution changed which form survived.
6. Darwin's fitness = reproductive fitness, not physical strength. De Vries: mutation, saltation, Oenothera; Lamarck: use and disuse, giraffe.
7. Adaptive radiation vs convergent evolution. Darwin's finches and Australian marsupials are adaptive radiation; a placental wolf resembling the Tasmanian wolf is convergent evolution.
8. Hardy–Weinberg. Start from $q^{2}$ (recessive phenotype). The five disturbing factors: gene flow, genetic drift, mutation, recombination, natural selection. Founder effect is a kind of drift.
9. Brain sizes. H. habilis 650–800 cc; H. erectus 900 cc; Neanderthal 1400 cc. Ramapithecus more man-like, Dryopithecus more ape-like.
Not in the NMC NEET (UG) syllabus; optional background.
A population bottleneck is a sharp, temporary fall in population size — after a disaster, a disease or hunting. Like the founder effect, it is genetic drift: the few survivors carry only a chance sample of the old gene pool, and much variation is lost for good even if numbers recover. Cheetahs are thought to have passed through at least one severe bottleneck; today they are so genetically uniform that skin grafts between unrelated cheetahs are often accepted. Conservation programmes, including the reintroduction of cheetahs to India, therefore try to bring in animals from several different source populations to rebuild genetic variation.
Exercises
- 1 State the theory of panspermia and the theory of spontaneous generation. Who disproved the latter, and how?
- 2 What were the main ideas of Oparin and Haldane? What conditions did they assume on the early Earth?
- 3 Name the four substances Miller placed in his apparatus, the source of energy he used, and the products he obtained.
- 4 How long after the formation of the Earth did life appear? When did the first non-cellular and the first cellular forms of life arise?
- 5 Why was the early atmosphere called "reducing"? How did the ozone layer form?
- 6 Why do organic compounds found in meteorites support the theory of chemical evolution?
- 1 What are fossils, and how does the arrangement of fossils in rock layers support evolution? How is their age found?
- 2 Name the bones common to the forelimbs of whale, bat, cheetah and human. What does this similarity indicate?
- 3 Give two plant and two animal examples of analogous organs.
- 4 Distinguish divergent from convergent evolution.
- 5 What did Haeckel propose from vertebrate embryos, and why was it rejected?
- 6 How do similarities in proteins and genes provide evidence for evolution?
- 7 (Illustrative data.) In a wood, 64 of 400 moths caught were dark in 1860, and 348 of 400 in 1910. Find the percentage of dark moths in each year.
- 1 How did Lamarck explain the long neck of the giraffe? Why is his explanation rejected?
- 2 State the two key concepts of Darwin's theory. What did Darwin mean by fitness?
- 3 Which naturalist reached conclusions similar to Darwin's, and where did he work?
- 4 On which plant did de Vries work? Contrast his mutations with Darwinian variations. What is saltation?
- 5 Define adaptive radiation and give two examples.
- 6 Give the placental counterparts of: Tasmanian wolf, flying phalanger, numbat, spotted cuscus, marsupial mole. What do these pairs illustrate?
- 7 List the factors that the modern synthetic theory combines to explain the origin of species.
- 1 State the Hardy–Weinberg principle and name the five factors that disturb the equilibrium.
- 2 In a population in equilibrium, 25 % of individuals are recessive homozygotes. Find $q$ and the percentage of heterozygotes.
- 3 In a population of 2000 with $p=0.7$, how many individuals are AA, Aa and aa?
- 4 A recessive disorder affects 1 in 2500 newborns. Find $q$ and the percentage of carriers (to one decimal place).
- 5 A sample of 800 snails contains 288 AA, 384 Aa and 128 aa. Find $p$, and decide whether the sample is in equilibrium.
- 6 Match each type of selection with the change in the distribution curve: stabilising, directional, disruptive.
- 7 Distinguish gene flow from genetic drift. Why is drift stronger in small populations? What is the founder effect?
- 8 In Interactive 2, choose genetic drift with population size 10 and then 500. What difference do you see, and why?
- 1 Arrange in order of appearance: Homo erectus, Neanderthal man, Dryopithecus, Homo habilis, Australopithecines.
- 2 Give the brain capacities of Homo habilis, Homo erectus and Neanderthal man.
- 3 Which of Dryopithecus and Ramapithecus was more man-like? When did they live?
- 4 Where and when were fossils of Homo erectus discovered? Which hominids probably ate meat, and which probably did not?
- 5 Where did Homo sapiens arise? Name an Indian site of prehistoric cave art and state roughly when agriculture began.
E1. NEET · MCQ Statement I: Ernst Haeckel proposed embryological support for evolution from the gill slits that develop in all vertebrate embryos. Statement II: Karl Ernst von Baer observed that embryos never pass through the adult stages of other animals. (A) Both statements I and II are correct (B) Both statements I and II are incorrect (C) Statement I is correct but statement II is incorrect (D) Statement I is incorrect but statement II is correct
E2. NEET · MCQ Assertion (A): The thorn of Bougainvillea and the tendril of Cucurbita are homologous organs. Reason (R): Homologous organs perform the same function. (A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A (B) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A (C) A is true but R is false (D) A is false but R is true
E3. NEET · MCQ Match List-I with List-II. List-I: (a) Homo habilis (b) Homo erectus (c) Neanderthal man (d) Ramapithecus. List-II: (i) about 900 cc; fossils found in Java (ii) man-like primate of about 15 mya (iii) 650–800 cc; probably did not eat meat (iv) 1400 cc; buried their dead. (A) a-iii, b-i, c-iv, d-ii (B) a-i, b-iii, c-iv, d-ii (C) a-iii, b-iv, c-i, d-ii (D) a-iv, b-i, c-iii, d-ii
E4. NEET · MCQ How many of the following pairs are analogous organs? (i) wings of a butterfly and of a bird (ii) forelimbs of a whale and of a bat (iii) eye of an Octopus and of a mammal (iv) flippers of a penguin and of a dolphin (v) sweet potato and potato (vi) thorn of Bougainvillea and tendril of Cucurbita (A) three (B) four (C) five (D) two
E5. NEET · MCQ The graph shows the distribution of a character in a population before (dashed) and several generations after (solid) a change in the environment. Which type of natural selection does it show?(A) stabilising (B) directional (C) genetic drift (D) disruptive
E6. NEET · MCQ In a large population in Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium, the frequency of the recessive allele a is 0.2. The frequency of homozygous dominant individuals is (A) 0.04 (B) 0.32 (C) 0.64 (D) 0.80
Research question. Can we predict how much a population will evolve in one generation after a drought?
Why it matters. On the Galapagos island of Daphne Major, the biologists Peter and Rosemary Grant measured almost every finch for decades. In a severe drought, small soft seeds ran out; birds with deeper beaks could crack the remaining large, hard seeds and survived better. The next generation had measurably deeper beaks — natural selection seen within a few years. Plant and animal breeders, fisheries scientists and conservationists use the same arithmetic to predict how populations respond to selection, whether it comes from a breeder, a fishing net or a warming climate.
What to do.
- (Illustrative data, constructed for this exercise.) Before a drought, the mean beak depth of a finch population was 9.4 mm. The birds that survived the drought and bred had a mean beak depth of 10.0 mm. Find the selection differential $S$ = (mean of breeders) − (mean of the whole population).
- Only part of the variation in beak depth is inherited. Its heritability $h^{2}$, measured by comparing parents and offspring, is 0.8. Predict the response in the next generation, $R=h^{2}S$, and the mean beak depth of the offspring.
- Express the response as a percentage of the original mean.
- Name the type of selection, and explain why the response $R$ is smaller than $S$.
- After the rains return, small seeds are abundant again. Predict what will happen to beak depth over the next few generations.
Tools: a calculator; Definition 7.41 and Interactive 2 (directional selection).
Hand in: your values of $S$, $R$ and the predicted mean with units, and a paragraph linking your numbers to Darwin's idea of reproductive fitness.
Going further. Find out how the Grants showed that a new population of finches on Daphne Major began from a single immigrant bird — and which of the forces in this section that illustrates.
🧪 Self-check quiz
Q1. Who disproved the theory of spontaneous generation?
Q2. The founder effect is a special case of
Q3. Hugo de Vries based his mutation theory on observations of
Q4. The resemblance between the Tasmanian wolf (a marsupial) and the placental wolf is an example of
Q5. Which factor does not disturb Hardy–Weinberg equilibrium?