2.1 Position, Displacement and Instantaneous Velocity
Where a body is, how far it has really moved, and how fast it is moving at one instant: position, displacement and instantaneous velocity โ the slope of the positionโtime graph, $v=\dfrac{dx}{dt}$.
A taxi takes you $24\ \text{km}$ from home to the airport in $40$ minutes, an average of $36\ \text{km/h}$. Yet the speedometer read $0$ at every traffic signal and touched $80\ \text{km/h}$ on the flyover. A speed camera on the flyover does not care about your average: it fines you for how fast you were going at that instant. And if you ended up back home because you forgot your passport, your average velocity for the whole trip would be zero, even though the meter charged you for every kilometre.
These everyday puzzles show that "how far" and "how fast" each have two meanings, and physics needs to keep them apart. In this section we describe straight-line motion by a position that can be positive or negative, separate path length from displacement, and then shrink the time interval until the average velocity becomes the instantaneous velocity โ the number a speedometer shows. That last step is your first use of calculus in physics: velocity is the rate of change of position, $v=\dfrac{dx}{dt}$.
Position, frame of reference and displacement
To say where something is, you need a starting point, a direction and a clock. A motion in a straight line needs only one axis: we place it along the line of motion, call it the $x$-axis, and measure positions from a chosen origin $O$.
A frame of reference is a coordinate system (an origin and axes) together with a clock, fixed to some chosen body โ the ground, a train, the Earth's centre. For motion along a straight line we use one axis, the $x$-axis, along the line.
The position of a point object at time $t$ is its coordinate $x(t)$ on this axis: a distance from the origin with a sign, positive on the side chosen as the positive direction and negative on the other side. The object is at rest in the frame if $x$ does not change with time, and in motion if it does.
Rest and motion are relative: a passenger dozing in a train is at rest in the train's frame and moving at $90\ \text{km/h}$ in the ground's frame. Unless we say otherwise, the frame is fixed to the ground. We also treat the moving body as a point object โ its size is small compared with the distance it moves โ so a single number $x$ fixes where it is.
If an object moves from position $x_1$ at time $t_1$ to position $x_2$ at time $t_2$, its displacement is the change of position $$\Delta x=x_2-x_1 .$$ Displacement has a magnitude and a direction, shown by its sign: $\Delta x\gt0$ means a net shift in the $+x$ direction, $\Delta x\lt0$ in the $-x$ direction.
The path length (distance travelled) is the total length of the path actually covered. It is never negative, and $\text{path length}\ge|\Delta x|$, with equality only when the object never reverses direction.
Displacement depends only on where the motion starts and ends; path length depends on everything in between. Moving the origin changes every position but not any displacement, because both $x_1$ and $x_2$ shift by the same amount.
Average velocity and average speed
Dividing by the time taken turns each kind of "how far" into a kind of "how fast".
Over a time interval $\Delta t=t_2-t_1$, the average velocity and the average speed are
$$\bar v=\frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}=\frac{x_2-x_1}{t_2-t_1},$$ $$\text{average speed}=\frac{\text{path length}}{\Delta t}.$$Both have the SI unit $\text{m/s}$ and dimensions $[\text{L}\,\text{T}^{-1}]$. Average velocity carries a sign (a direction); average speed never does, and $|\bar v|\le$ average speed. On an xโt graph, $\bar v$ is the slope of the chord joining the points $(t_1,x_1)$ and $(t_2,x_2)$.
Instantaneous velocity: the slope of the xโt graph
An average hides what happens inside the interval. To find how fast the jogger is moving at a particular instant $t$, take the average over a shorter and shorter interval $\Delta t$ that starts at $t$. For smooth motion the averages settle down to a definite value. Geometrically, the chord joining $(t,x)$ to $(t+\Delta t,\,x+\Delta x)$ swings round until it lies along the tangent to the xโt curve at $t$.
The instantaneous velocity at time $t$ is the limit of the average velocity as the interval shrinks to zero:
$$v=\lim_{\Delta t\to0}\frac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}=\frac{dx}{dt}.$$$\dfrac{dx}{dt}$ is read "the derivative of $x$ with respect to $t$", or simply "the rate of change of position". It equals the slope of the tangent to the xโt graph at that instant. Its sign gives the direction of motion. The instantaneous speed is its magnitude, $|v|$.
From now on, "velocity" and "speed" without the word "average" always mean the instantaneous values. For motion in one direction at a steady rate โ uniform motion โ the xโt graph is a straight line, every chord has the same slope, and the instantaneous and average velocities are equal.
Repeating the algebra of Example 3 at a general time $t$ gives $\dfrac{\Delta x}{\Delta t}=8.0\,t+4.0\,\Delta t\to8.0\,t$, so $v=8.0\,t$. You do not have to redo the limit every time: a few rules, which you will prove in Class 11 Mathematics, cover all the motions in this chapter.
For constants $c$, $A$, $B$ and a whole number $n\ge1$ (you will prove these in maths):
$$\frac{d}{dt}(c)=0,\qquad \frac{d}{dt}\left(t^{n}\right)=n\,t^{\,n-1},$$ $$\frac{d}{dt}\big(A\,f+B\,g\big)=A\frac{df}{dt}+B\frac{dg}{dt}.$$So for $x=x_0+bt+ct^2+dt^3$, the velocity is $v=\dfrac{dx}{dt}=b+2ct+3dt^2$. The initial position $x_0$ drops out: moving the origin never changes a velocity.
Reading xโt graphs
Because velocity is the slope of the xโt graph, the shape of the graph tells the whole story of the motion at a glance.
| Feature of the xโt graph | What the object is doing |
|---|---|
| horizontal line | at rest ($v=0$) |
| straight line sloping up / down | uniform motion in the $+x$ / $-x$ direction; steeper means faster |
| curve getting steeper | speeding up |
| curve getting flatter | slowing down |
| peak or valley (horizontal tangent) | momentarily at rest and turning back |
| crossing the $t$-axis | passing through the origin (says nothing about the velocity) |
1. Path length is not displacement. Split the motion at every turning point (where $v=0$) before adding distances; Example 4 gives $12\ \text{m}$, not $4\ \text{m}$.
2. Average speed is not the average of the speeds. Divide total path length by total time; equal distances at $40$ and $60\ \text{km/h}$ average $48\ \text{km/h}$, not $50$.
3. Velocity is the slope, not the height, of the xโt graph. A body at $x=500\ \text{m}$ may be at rest; a body at $x=0$ may be moving fast.
4. An xโt graph is not a picture of the path. The motion is along a straight line; the curve only shows how $x$ changes with $t$.
5. Impossible graphs. A real xโt graph cannot have a vertical segment (infinite speed), cannot go backwards in time, and cannot have two values of $x$ at one $t$.
Exercises
- 1 A cyclist starts at $x=-120\ \text{m}$ and rides to $x=+380\ \text{m}$. Find her displacement.
- 2 She then rides back to $x=+80\ \text{m}$. Find the displacement and the path length for the whole ride.
- 3 Repeat part 2 with the origin moved to the old $x=+200\ \text{m}$. Which answers change?
- 4 A lift starts at a floor $8.0\ \text{m}$ above the ground floor, rises to $28.0\ \text{m}$, then comes down to the ground floor. Taking $+$ upwards from the ground floor, find its displacement and path length.
- 5 A swimmer swims four lengths of a $50\ \text{m}$ pool (there and back twice). Find the displacement and path length.
- 6 A ball dropped from $5.0\ \text{m}$ above the floor bounces up to $3.0\ \text{m}$ and is caught there. Taking $+$ upwards from the floor, find its displacement and path length.
- 7 Can the magnitude of a displacement ever exceed the path length? When are they equal?
- 1 A train covers $150\ \text{km}$ along a straight track in $2.5\ \text{h}$. Find its average speed in $\text{km/h}$ and in $\text{m/s}$.
- 2 The cyclist of Card I takes $50\ \text{s}$ to ride from $-120\ \text{m}$ to $+380\ \text{m}$ and $40\ \text{s}$ to return to $+80\ \text{m}$. Find her average velocity and average speed for the whole ride.
- 3 A car covers $30\ \text{km}$ at $60\ \text{km/h}$ and the next $30\ \text{km}$, in the same direction, at $40\ \text{km/h}$. Find its average speed.
- 4 Another car drives for $1\ \text{h}$ at $60\ \text{km/h}$ and then for $1\ \text{h}$ at $40\ \text{km/h}$ in the same direction. Find its average speed, and explain why it differs from part 3.
- 5 A jogger runs $3.0\ \text{km}$ east in $15\ \text{min}$, then walks $1.0\ \text{km}$ west in $15\ \text{min}$. Find her average velocity and average speed in $\text{km/h}$.
- 6 Show that the magnitude of the average velocity over any interval is never greater than the average speed.
- 7 A boy walks to a shop at speed $v_1$ and returns along the same road at $v_2$. Show that his average speed is $\dfrac{2v_1v_2}{v_1+v_2}$, and evaluate it for $v_1=1.2\ \text{m/s}$, $v_2=1.8\ \text{m/s}$.
- 1 $x=5.0\,t^2$. Find $v$ at $t=3.0\ \text{s}$.
- 2 $x=3.0+4.0\,t$. Find $v$ at any time. What kind of motion is this?
- 3 $x=12t-3.0\,t^2$. Find $v(t)$, the time at which the body is momentarily at rest, and its position then.
- 4 $x=2.0\,t^3$. Find the average velocity between $t=1.0\ \text{s}$ and $t=3.0\ \text{s}$ and the instantaneous velocity at $t=2.0\ \text{s}$. Why are they different?
- 5 $x=t^2$. Find the average velocity over $[3,\,3.1]$ and $[3,\,3.01]$ and guess $v(3)$. Confirm with Result 2.1.
- 6 $x=40-5.0\,t^2$. Find the velocity and the speed at $t=2.0\ \text{s}$, and the direction of motion.
- 7 $x=t^3-9t^2+24t$. At what times is the particle momentarily at rest, and where is it then?
- 8 For the particle of part 7, find the displacement and path length between $t=0$ and $t=5\ \text{s}$.
- 9 In $x=At+Bt^3$, find the SI units of $A$ and $B$, and write $v(t)$. Check that every term of $v$ has the unit $\text{m/s}$.
- 1 Find the velocity in each of the four segments.
- 2 When is the body at rest? In which segment is it fastest?
- 3 Find the displacement and path length over the whole $50\ \text{s}$.
- 4 Find the average velocity and average speed over the whole $50\ \text{s}$, and the average velocity from $t=0$ to $t=30\ \text{s}$.
- 5 Explain why an xโt graph can never contain a vertical segment.
- 6 A car moves with $x=0.80\,t^2$ for $0\le t\le10\ \text{s}$. Find its average velocity over these $10\ \text{s}$ and the instant at which its velocity equals that average.
- 7 A phone logs a cyclist's position every $2.0\ \text{s}$: $t=0,2,4,6,8\ \text{s}$; $x=0,\ 9.0,\ 20.0,\ 33.0,\ 48.0\ \text{m}$. Estimate her velocity at $t=4.0\ \text{s}$ and at $t=6.0\ \text{s}$ using the average over the interval centred on each instant.
- 8 (Modelling) Two cameras $10.5\ \text{km}$ apart on an expressway with a $100\ \text{km/h}$ limit record a car at 10:02:10 and 10:07:55. Find its average speed. Must it have been over the limit at some instant? Explain.
E1. Board ยท 2 marks Distinguish between displacement and path length. Give an example in which the path length is non-zero but the displacement is zero.
E2. NEET A body goes from town A to town B at $20\ \text{m/s}$ and returns along the same road at $30\ \text{m/s}$. Its average velocity and average speed for the round trip are (a) $0$ and $24\ \text{m/s}$ (b) $25\ \text{m/s}$ and $25\ \text{m/s}$ (c) $0$ and $25\ \text{m/s}$ (d) $24\ \text{m/s}$ and $0$
E3. NEET JEE Main The position of a particle is $x=4.0+6.0\,t-0.50\,t^3$ ($x$ in m, $t$ in s). At $t=2.0\ \text{s}$ its velocity is (a) $0$ (b) $6.0\ \text{m/s}$ (c) $12\ \text{m/s}$ (d) $-6.0\ \text{m/s}$
E4. JEE Main (Numerical value) A particle moves along the $x$-axis with $x=2t^3-15t^2+36t$ ($x$ in m, $t$ in s). Find the distance (path length) it covers between $t=0$ and $t=4\ \text{s}$.
E5. JEE Advanced (One or more correct) A particle moves with $x=10+8t-t^2$ ($x$ in m, $t$ in s) for $0\le t\le8\ \text{s}$. Which statements are correct? (A) It is momentarily at rest at $t=4\ \text{s}$. (B) Its average velocity over the $8\ \text{s}$ is zero. (C) The path length over the $8\ \text{s}$ is $32\ \text{m}$. (D) Its average speed over the $8\ \text{s}$ is $2\ \text{m/s}$.
E6. Board ยท 3 marks A car travels the first half of a straight journey at $40\ \text{km/h}$ and the second half at $60\ \text{km/h}$. (a) Find its average speed. (b) Find its average speed if instead it travels for the first half of the time at $40\ \text{km/h}$ and the second half at $60\ \text{km/h}$. (c) Why are the answers different?
Research question. Can an average-speed camera prove that a driver broke the speed limit at some instant โ and how do road authorities choose the distance between the two cameras?
Why it matters. Point-to-point ("section control") speed enforcement is used on motorways in the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, Austria, Australia and on several Indian expressways. Instead of catching a car at one spot, it times the car between two cameras kilometres apart. Road-safety studies report that it smooths traffic and reduces serious crashes along the whole section, not just near the camera. Its legal basis is exactly the link between average and instantaneous velocity in this section.
What to do.
- Explain, using an xโt graph, why a car whose average speed over a section exceeds the limit must have exceeded the limit at some instant (compare Card IV, part 8).
- Is the converse true? Sketch an xโt graph for a car that exceeds the limit briefly but still averages below it.
- Clocks at the two cameras are synchronised to within $\pm0.1\ \text{s}$. For sections of $0.5\ \text{km}$, $2\ \text{km}$ and $10\ \text{km}$, find the uncertainty in a measured average speed near $100\ \text{km/h}$. Which spacing gives the fairest fine?
- Record a short journey (as a passenger) with a phone GPS-logging app. Compare the speed it shows at a few instants with the average over the whole trip.
Tools: Graph paper or a spreadsheet; a phone with a free GPS logger (optional).
Hand in: Your two sketches, a table of timing uncertainties for the three section lengths, and a paragraph recommending a section length with reasons.
Going further. The statement in step 1 is a version of the mean value theorem, which you will meet in Class 12 Mathematics. Find out what condition on the motion it needs.
๐งช Self-check quiz
Q1. A runner completes exactly two laps of a straight out-and-back course of length $200\ \text{m}$ each way, finishing at the start. Her displacement and path length are
Q2. On an xโt graph, the instantaneous velocity at time $t$ is
Q3. For $x=3t^2-2t+5$ (SI units), the velocity at $t=2\ \text{s}$ is
Q4. Which of the following can never be the xโt graph of a real body?
Q5. A car covers equal distances at $30\ \text{km/h}$ and $60\ \text{km/h}$ in the same direction. Its average speed is