4.4 Circular Motion and Solving Problems in Mechanics
Turning needs a net force towards the centre, $mv^2/r$, supplied by friction, tension or the tilt of a banked road. Then the full method: free-body diagrams for every body, linked by strings, pulleys and lifts.
A car takes a bend on a wet road a little too fast. The driver turns the wheel, but the car carries straight on towards the outside of the curve. What went wrong? Section 3.4 showed that anything moving on a circle has an acceleration $v^2/r$ towards the centre. Newton's second law now adds the missing piece: that acceleration needs a net force towards the centre, of size $mv^2/r$. On a level road the only thing that can supply it is friction between the tyres and the road โ and friction has a limit. Above a certain speed the road simply cannot push the car sideways hard enough. That is why race tracks and highway curves are tilted, or banked: tilting the road lets the normal force help to turn the car.
The second half of this section puts the whole chapter to work. Real problems often involve several bodies at once โ two blocks tied by a string over a pulley, a lift and its passenger, a train of wagons. The method is always the same: one free-body diagram for each body, Newton's second law for each, and the conditions that link them (the same string, the same acceleration). With that method you can solve almost any problem in Class 11 mechanics.
Dynamics of circular motion
The centripetal force on a body moving in a circle is the net force on it directed towards the centre of the circle. It is not a new kind of force: it is the resultant of the real forces acting (tension, gravity, friction, normal force, โฆ), or of their components towards the centre.
A body of mass $m$ moving uniformly in a circle of radius $r$ with speed $v$ (angular speed $\omega$) needs a net force towards the centre
$$F_c=\frac{mv^2}{r}=m\omega^2r .$$This follows from $\mathbf{F}_\text{net}=m\mathbf{a}$ with the centripetal acceleration of Result 3.11. If the available inward force becomes smaller than $mv^2/r$, the body moves off along a wider path; if the inward force vanishes, it moves off along the tangent (first law).
So in a circular-motion problem, do not add an extra force called "centripetal force" to the free-body diagram. Draw the real forces, choose one axis pointing towards the centre, and write $\sum F_\text{towards centre}=\dfrac{mv^2}{r}$. Nor is there an outward "centrifugal force" in the ground frame: the feeling of being thrown outward on a bend is your body's inertia โ it tends to go straight on while the car turns under it.
Cars on level and banked curves
Level road. On a flat curve the forces on a car are its weight $mg$ down, the normal force $N=mg$ up, and friction from the road on the tyres. Only friction is horizontal, so friction must provide $mv^2/r$. The tyres are not sliding sideways, so this is static friction, at most $\mu_sN=\mu_smg$. The car can follow the curve only if $\dfrac{mv^2}{r}\le\mu_smg$.
Banked road. Now let the road be tilted at angle $\theta$, with its outer edge higher. The normal force is perpendicular to the road, so it leans towards the centre and its horizontal component $N\sin\theta$ helps to turn the car. At one particular speed this is enough on its own and no friction is needed at all. Above that speed friction acts down the slope (the car tends to slide outward and up); below it, friction acts up the slope.
To find the greatest speed, take friction at its limit, $\mu_sN$, down the slope. Resolve horizontally (towards the centre) and vertically:
$$N\sin\theta+\mu_sN\cos\theta=\frac{mv^2}{r},$$ $$N\cos\theta-\mu_sN\sin\theta=mg .$$Dividing the first equation by the second removes $N$ and $m$: $\dfrac{v^2}{rg}=\dfrac{\sin\theta+\mu_s\cos\theta}{\cos\theta-\mu_s\sin\theta}=\dfrac{\tan\theta+\mu_s}{1-\mu_s\tan\theta}$.
For a car on a curve of radius $r$ with coefficient of static friction $\mu_s$ between tyres and road:
Level road:
$$v_\text{max}=\sqrt{\mu_s\,r\,g}.$$Road banked at angle $\theta$: the ideal (optimum) speed, needing no friction, is
$$v_0=\sqrt{r\,g\tan\theta},$$and the safe range of speeds is $v_\text{min}\le v\le v_\text{max}$ with
$$v_\text{max}=\sqrt{r\,g\,\frac{\mu_s+\tan\theta}{1-\mu_s\tan\theta}},\qquad v_\text{min}=\sqrt{r\,g\,\frac{\tan\theta-\mu_s}{1+\mu_s\tan\theta}}\ \ (v_\text{min}=0\text{ if }\tan\theta\le\mu_s).$$None of these depends on the mass of the car. (If $\mu_s\tan\theta\ge1$ there is no upper limit.)
Solving problems: connected bodies, pulleys and lifts
- Draw a separate free-body diagram for each body (or for any group of bodies that moves together). A string's tension appears on both bodies it connects, pulling each towards the string.
- Write the constraints. Bodies joined by a taut, inextensible string have accelerations of equal size; over an ideal pulley the tension is the same on both sides.
- Choose a positive direction for each body consistent with the motion โ for example, "down" for the heavier hanging mass and "up" for the lighter one โ so that one symbol $a$ serves for all.
- Apply $\sum F=ma$ to each body along its direction of motion, giving as many equations as unknowns. Add them to eliminate the tension.
- Check a special case (equal masses, zero friction, $\theta=0$) and that tensions come out positive.
The simplest pulley system is the Atwood machine: two masses $m_1\gt m_2$ hung on either side of an ideal pulley. Taking $m_1$ moving down: $m_1g-T=m_1a$ and $T-m_2g=m_2a$. Adding eliminates $T$.
For masses $m_1\gt m_2$ connected by an ideal string over an ideal pulley, the heavier mass descends with acceleration
$$a=\frac{m_1-m_2}{m_1+m_2}\,g,$$and the tension in the string is
$$T=\frac{2m_1m_2}{m_1+m_2}\,g .$$$T$ lies between $m_2g$ and $m_1g$: less than the weight of the falling mass (so it accelerates down) and more than that of the rising one (so it accelerates up).
1. Adding a "centripetal force" or "centrifugal force" to the diagram. The centripetal force is the net inward force of the real forces; in the ground frame there is no outward force on a body going round.
2. Using $N=mg$ on a banked road. On a banked curve $N$ is found from the two equations together; it is larger than $mg\cos\theta$ when friction acts down the slope.
3. Taking the tension equal to the hanging weight. $T=mg$ only if the hanging mass is not accelerating. In an Atwood machine $T$ lies strictly between the two weights.
4. Inconsistent signs for connected bodies. Choose each body's positive direction along the way the system moves, so one $a$ serves for all; a negative answer then means the system moves the other way.
5. Confusing velocity and acceleration in lifts. The scale reading depends only on the acceleration: $N=m(g+a)$ with $a$ measured upward.
Exercises
Take $g=9.8\ \text{m/s}^2$. Strings and pulleys are light and frictionless unless stated otherwise.
- 1 A $0.20\ \text{kg}$ ball on a string moves in a horizontal circle of radius $0.80\ \text{m}$ on a smooth table at $4.0\ \text{m/s}$. Find the tension.
- 2 A string breaks at a tension of $50\ \text{N}$. What is the greatest speed at which a $0.50\ \text{kg}$ mass can be whirled on it in a horizontal circle of radius $1.0\ \text{m}$ (smooth table)?
- 3 A $1000\ \text{kg}$ car rounds a level curve of radius $40\ \text{m}$ at $12\ \text{m/s}$. Find the friction force needed and the least $\mu_s$ that provides it.
- 4 Find the greatest safe speed on a level curve of radius $80\ \text{m}$ with $\mu_s=0.50$.
- 5 A coin lies on a turntable $10\ \text{cm}$ from the axis; $\mu_s=0.30$. Find the greatest angular speed (in rad/s and rpm) at which it does not slide.
- 6 Passengers in a car taking a sharp left bend feel pushed to the right. Explain this in terms of inertia.
- 7 A $1500\ \text{kg}$ car goes over the top of a hump-backed bridge (a circular arc of radius $20\ \text{m}$) at $10\ \text{m/s}$. Find the normal force on it at the top, and the speed at which it would just lose contact.
- 1 A curve of radius $60\ \text{m}$ is banked at $12^\circ$. Find the speed at which no friction is needed.
- 2 At what angle should a curve of radius $100\ \text{m}$ be banked for an ideal speed of $20\ \text{m/s}$?
- 3 A curve of radius $80\ \text{m}$ is banked at $10^\circ$ with $\mu_s=0.25$. Find the greatest safe speed.
- 4 For the curve in part 3, find the least safe speed.
- 5 Give two reasons why highway curves are banked instead of relying on friction alone.
- 6 On a railway curve of radius $500\ \text{m}$ the outer rail is raised so that a train at $20\ \text{m/s}$ needs no sideways push from the rails. The rails are $1.5\ \text{m}$ apart. By how much is the outer rail raised?
- 1 Masses of $5.0\ \text{kg}$ and $3.0\ \text{kg}$ hang over a pulley (Atwood machine). Find the acceleration and the tension.
- 2 In part 1, starting from rest, find the speed of the masses after $2.0\ \text{s}$ and the distance each has moved.
- 3 Blocks of $2.0\ \text{kg}$ and $3.0\ \text{kg}$ on a smooth table are joined by a string. A $10\ \text{N}$ horizontal force pulls the $3.0\ \text{kg}$ block. Find the acceleration and the tension.
- 4 A $6.0\ \text{kg}$ block on a smooth table is tied over a pulley at the edge to a $2.0\ \text{kg}$ hanging mass. Find the acceleration and the tension.
- 5 Repeat part 4 with $\mu_k=0.10$ between block and table (the system moves).
- 6 A $50\ \text{kg}$ person stands on a scale in a lift accelerating downward at $1.8\ \text{m/s}^2$. What does the scale read?
- 7 An $800\ \text{kg}$ lift accelerates upward at $1.2\ \text{m/s}^2$. Find the tension in its cable.
- 8 A $2.0\ \text{kg}$ block on a smooth $30^\circ$ incline is tied by a string, parallel to the incline and over a pulley at its top, to a $3.0\ \text{kg}$ mass hanging vertically. Find the acceleration and the tension.
- 1 In an Atwood machine one mass is twice the other. Show that the acceleration is $g/3$ and the tension is $\tfrac43$ of the weight of the lighter mass.
- 2 Three blocks of $1.0$, $2.0$ and $3.0\ \text{kg}$ lie in a row on a smooth table, joined by strings. A $12\ \text{N}$ force pulls the $3.0\ \text{kg}$ block along the line. Find the acceleration and the tension in each string.
- 3 A uniform rope of mass $2.0\ \text{kg}$ pulls an $8.0\ \text{kg}$ block across a smooth floor; the free end is pulled with $20\ \text{N}$. Find the acceleration and the tension at the middle of the rope.
- 4 A $60\ \text{kg}$ climber goes up a rope with an acceleration of $1.0\ \text{m/s}^2$. Find the tension. If the rope can bear at most $700\ \text{N}$, what is the greatest upward acceleration she can safely have?
- 5 A $1200\ \text{kg}$ car takes the curve of Example 3 at $22\ \text{m/s}$. Find the normal force and the friction (magnitude and direction), and check that it does not slide.
- 6 (Modelling) A jet pulls out of a dive along a vertical circle of radius $500\ \text{m}$ at $100\ \text{m/s}$. At the lowest point, how many times her normal weight does the $60\ \text{kg}$ pilot's seat push on her?
E1. Board ยท 5 marks A car moves on a road banked at angle $\theta$, round a curve of radius $r$; the coefficient of static friction is $\mu_s$. Draw the free-body diagram of the car moving at its greatest safe speed and derive an expression for that speed. Deduce the speed at which no friction is needed.
E2. NEET The greatest speed at which a car can round a level curve of radius $20\ \text{m}$ if $\mu_s=0.50$ ($g=9.8\ \text{m/s}^2$) is (a) $7.0\ \text{m/s}$ (b) $9.9\ \text{m/s}$ (c) $14\ \text{m/s}$ (d) $98\ \text{m/s}$
E3. JEE Main NEET Masses of $5\ \text{kg}$ and $3\ \text{kg}$ are tied to the ends of a light string passing over a light frictionless pulley. Taking $g=10\ \text{m/s}^2$, the acceleration of the masses and the tension in the string are (a) $2.5\ \text{m/s}^2$, $37.5\ \text{N}$ (b) $2.5\ \text{m/s}^2$, $50\ \text{N}$ (c) $5.0\ \text{m/s}^2$, $37.5\ \text{N}$ (d) $2.5\ \text{m/s}^2$, $30\ \text{N}$
E4. JEE Main (Numerical value) A $60\ \text{kg}$ man stands on a weighing machine in a lift that is moving downward and speeding up at $2.0\ \text{m/s}^2$. Taking $g=10\ \text{m/s}^2$, find the reading of the machine in newtons.
E5. JEE Advanced (One or more correct) A curve of radius $100\ \text{m}$ is banked with $\tan\theta=0.20$, and $\mu_s=0.20$ between tyres and road. Take $g=10\ \text{m/s}^2$. Which statements are correct? (A) At about $14\ \text{m/s}$ a car needs no friction to take the curve. (B) A car can stand still on the curve without sliding down. (C) The greatest safe speed is about $20\ \text{m/s}$. (D) At speeds above the ideal speed, friction on the tyres acts up the slope.
E6. Board ยท Case study A $4.0\ \text{kg}$ block on a rough horizontal table ($\mu_k=0.20$) is connected by a light string over a smooth pulley at the edge of the table to a $2.0\ \text{kg}$ mass hanging freely. The system is released and moves. (i) Find the acceleration. (2 marks) (ii) Find the tension in the string. (1 mark) (iii) What is the least coefficient of static friction for which the system would stay at rest? (1 mark)
Research question. How tight can a highway curve be for a given speed limit โ and why do road engineers never rely on all the friction a tyre can give?
Why it matters. Highway design codes around the world (for example those used by national road agencies in India, Europe and North America) set a minimum curve radius for each design speed. They combine the bank angle โ written as the "superelevation" $e=\tan\theta$, usually capped at about $0.07$ so that slow vehicles and trucks do not slide inward on icy or wet days โ with a "side-friction factor" $f$ of only about $0.12$โ$0.16$, far below a dry tyre's $\mu_s\approx0.8$. The margin keeps curves safe on wet roads, with worn tyres and for drivers who brake while turning.
What to do.
- For small angles, Result 4.10 gives approximately $\dfrac{v^2}{rg}=e+f$. Show this by putting $\mu_s\tan\theta\approx0$ in the formula for $v_\text{max}$.
- Find the minimum radius for design speeds of $50$, $80$ and $100\ \text{km/h}$, with $e=0.07$ and $f=0.14$.
- Recalculate the $80\ \text{km/h}$ radius using a dry-road $\mu_s=0.80$ instead of $f$. By what factor is the code more cautious?
- Find a sharp curve near you (on an online map, measure the radius by fitting a circle to three points). What speed does the formula allow? Compare with the posted limit.
Tools: Spreadsheet; an online map with a distance-measuring tool.
Hand in: A table of design speed against minimum radius, your check on a real curve, and a paragraph explaining to a town council why the speed limit on that curve is (or is not) appropriate.
Going further. Racing circuits bank some curves at over $30^\circ$. Use Interactive 1 to find how fast a car can go on a $30^\circ$ curve of radius $100\ \text{m}$ with racing tyres ($\mu_s=1.0$). What happens to the formula when $\mu_s\tan\theta\ge1$?
๐งช Self-check quiz
Q1. A car rounds a level curve at constant speed. The force towards the centre of the curve is provided by
Q2. A road of radius $r$ is banked so that a car at speed $v$ needs no friction. The bank angle satisfies
Q3. In an Atwood machine the two masses are equal. If the system is given a small push, the masses
Q4. A person stands on a scale in a lift whose cable has snapped, so that the lift falls freely. The scale reads
Q5. A car's speed on a level curve is doubled. The friction force needed to keep it on the curve becomes