Chapter 17 ยท Introduction

Chapter 17 โ€” Dual Nature of Matter and Radiation

Light knocks electrons out of metals in a way no wave theory can explain: below a threshold frequency nothing happens however bright the light, and above it the fastest electrons get faster with frequency, not with brightness. Light comes in photons of energy hฮฝ โ€” and, in return, every moving particle has a wavelength h/p.

In 1887 Heinrich Hertz noticed that the spark in his radio-wave receiver jumped more easily when ultraviolet light fell on the metal gap. A few years later Philipp Lenard showed what was happening: light was pulling electrons out of the metal. The details made no sense for a wave. Dim violet light released electrons at once, while blindingly bright red light released none at all; and making the light brighter produced more electrons but never faster ones. In 1905 Einstein explained everything with one bold idea โ€” light delivers its energy in packets, photons, each carrying $h\nu$ โ€” and it was this, not relativity, that won him the Nobel Prize. The same effect counts photons today in every phone camera, light meter, solar panel and night-vision tube.

This chapter follows the idea in both directions. First, the photoelectric effect: the photocell experiment, the saturation current and the stopping potential, the threshold frequency and work function $\phi_0$, Einstein's photoelectric equation $K_{\max}=eV_0=h\nu-\phi_0$, Millikan's straight-line graph of $V_0$ against $\nu$ of slope $h/e$, and photons as particles with energy $h\nu$ and momentum $h/\lambda$ that can be counted and can push. Second, matter waves: if light waves behave like particles, de Broglie argued, particles must behave like waves, with $\lambda=h/p$. An electron accelerated through $V$ volts has $\lambda=1.227/\sqrt V\ \text{nm}$ โ€” about the spacing of atoms in a crystal โ€” which is why electron microscopes can see atoms. NEET usually sets one or two questions on this short chapter, and nearly all of them come down to quick bookkeeping with $h\nu$, $\phi_0$, $K$ and $p$ โ€” marks a well-prepared candidate collects in well under a minute each.

The NEET (UG) syllabus for this unit โ€” the dual nature of radiation; the photoelectric effect, with Hertz's and Lenard's observations; Einstein's photoelectric equation and the particle nature of light; matter waves, the wave nature of particles and the de Broglie relation โ€” is covered completely by the two sections below. The Davissonโ€“Germer experiment, which is no longer in the syllabus, appears only in one optional box in Section 17.2.

Hertz & Lenardโ†’Threshold $\nu_0$, stopping potential $V_0$โ†’$h\nu=\phi_0+K_{\max}$โ†’$V_0$โ€“$\nu$ line, slope $h/e$โ†’Photon: $E=h\nu$, $p=h/\lambda$โ†’$\lambda=h/p$โ†’$\lambda=1.227/\sqrt V$ nmโ†’Thermal neutronsโ†’Particle vs photon
๐ŸŽฏ By the end of this chapter you canโ€ฆ
  • describe the photocell experiment and read its graphs: photocurrent against collector potential, saturation current against intensity, and stopping potential against frequency;
  • state the laws of photoelectric emission and explain why the wave picture cannot account for the threshold frequency, the instantaneous emission and the independence of $K_{\max}$ from intensity;
  • use Einstein's equation $K_{\max}=eV_0=h\nu-\phi_0$ with the work function, threshold frequency $\nu_0=\phi_0/h$ and threshold wavelength $\lambda_0=hc/\phi_0$, working in eV with $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$;
  • find Planck's constant and the work function from the slope and intercept of the $V_0$โ€“$\nu$ line;
  • count photons, $N=P\lambda/hc$, and find saturation photocurrents and the force of a light beam on an absorbing or a reflecting surface;
  • use the de Broglie relation $\lambda=h/p=h/\sqrt{2mK}$, and $\lambda=h/\sqrt{2mqV}$ for a charged particle accelerated through $V$ (electron: $1.227/\sqrt V\ \text{nm}$);
  • find the wavelength of thermal neutrons and gas molecules, $\lambda=h/\sqrt{3mk_BT}$;
  • compare a photon and a particle of the same wavelength or the same energy, and find the de Broglie wavelength of photoelectrons;
  • solve NEET multiple-choice questions on photons, the photoelectric effect and matter waves in every format the paper uses โ€” single answer, statement I / II, assertionโ€“reason, matching lists, "how many are correct" and graph reading โ€” quickly, by eliminating options.

Light of wavelength $400\ \text{nm}$ falls on potassium ($\phi_0=2.30\ \text{eV}$). The wavelength is now halved to $200\ \text{nm}$, so each photon carries twice the energy. What happens to the stopping potential?

Choose potassium and set $\lambda=400\ \text{nm}$: the readouts show $h\nu=3.10\ \text{eV}$, $K_{\max}=0.80\ \text{eV}$, so $V_0=0.80\ \text{V}$, and the fastest electrons have a de Broglie wavelength of $1.37\ \text{nm}$. Now set $\lambda=200\ \text{nm}$: $h\nu=6.20\ \text{eV}$, $K_{\max}=6.20-2.30=3.90\ \text{eV}$, $V_0=3.90\ \text{V}$, and the faster electrons have the shorter wavelength $0.62\ \text{nm}$. Einstein's equation $eV_0=h\nu-\phi_0$ (Section 17.1) is a straight line in $\nu$ that does not pass through the origin, so doubling $\nu$ more than doubles $V_0$. Move the intensity slider: the number of electrons changes, their speed does not. Finally try zinc at $400\ \text{nm}$ โ€” no electrons at all, however bright the light.
Teaser โ€” Photons In, Electrons Out

Light of the chosen wavelength and brightness falls on a clean metal plate. Each photon gives all of its energy $h\nu$ to one electron: the work function $\phi_0$ is spent getting out, and the rest is the kinetic energy of the fastest electrons. The bar on the right splits each photon's energy into these two parts; each escaping electron carries a little wave of its de Broglie wavelength $h/p$. Press Play to see the electrons stream out.

400 nm2
photon energy hฮฝโ€”
K_max and stopping potentialโ€”
de Broglie ฮป of fastest electronsโ€”
photocurrentโ€”

Sections in this chapter

๐ŸŽฏ Chapter mixed test NEET ยท MCQ

Eight NEET-style questions drawn from both sections and shuffled, as the paper does โ€” three of them need the photoelectric equation and the de Broglie relation together. Answer each one and press Submit (NEET marking: $+4$ correct, $-1$ wrong, $0$ unanswered), or press โฑ Take as a timed test. The test clock is generous: at real NEET pace โ€” about a minute per question โ€” you should finish all eight in ten minutes, so try to beat it comfortably. Take $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$, $h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $e=1.6\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}$, $m_e=9.1\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}$ and, for an electron of kinetic energy $K$ electronvolts, $\lambda=1.227/\sqrt K\ \text{nm}$.

E1. NEET ยท MCQ Ultraviolet light of wavelength $200\ \text{nm}$ falls on a metal of work function $2.2\ \text{eV}$. The de Broglie wavelength of the fastest photoelectrons is about (A) $0.49\ \text{nm}$ (B) $0.61\ \text{nm}$ (C) $0.87\ \text{nm}$ (D) $1.23\ \text{nm}$

Photoelectric $h\nu=\dfrac{1240}{200}=6.2\ \text{eV}$, so $K_{\max}=6.2-2.2=4.0\ \text{eV}$ (Section 17.1).
de Broglie The fastest electrons have the shortest wavelength: $\lambda=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt{4.0}}=0.61\ \text{nm}$ (Section 17.2).
Answer (B) $0.61\ \text{nm}$.
โฑ Shortcut $4.0$ is a perfect square โ€” the numbers were chosen for it. (A) uses the photon energy $6.2\ \text{eV}$ and forgets the work function.

E2. NEET ยท MCQ Statement I: For a given photosensitive surface and a fixed frequency above the threshold, the stopping potential does not depend on the intensity of the incident light. Statement II: The slope of the graph of stopping potential against frequency is different for different metals. In the light of these statements, choose the correct option. (A) Both Statement I and Statement II are correct (B) Both Statement I and Statement II are incorrect (C) Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect (D) Statement I is incorrect but Statement II is correct

Statement I $eV_0=h\nu-\phi_0$ contains the frequency and the metal only (Section 17.1). Correct.
Statement II The slope is $h/e$, a ratio of two universal constants โ€” the same for every metal; only the intercepts differ. Incorrect.
Answer (C).
โฑ Shortcut Different metals give parallel $V_0$โ€“$\nu$ lines โ€” remember the picture and Statement II falls at once.

E3. NEET ยท MCQ Assertion (A): An electron microscope can resolve much finer detail than an optical microscope. Reason (R): Electrons accelerated through a few kilovolts have de Broglie wavelengths far shorter than the wavelength of visible light. Choose the correct option. (A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A (B) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A (C) A is true but R is false (D) A is false but R is true

Reason At $5\ \text{kV}$, $\lambda=1.227/\sqrt{5000}=0.017\ \text{nm}$, against about $500\ \text{nm}$ for visible light (Section 17.2). True.
Assertion True โ€” and the smallest detail any microscope can resolve is of the order of the wavelength it uses, so R is exactly the reason.
Answer (A).
โฑ Shortcut Read "A, because R": "finer detail, because a much shorter wavelength" is a complete explanation.

E4. NEET ยท MCQ Match each quantity in List-I with the way it varies in List-II.
List-I: (a) the energy of a photon, as its wavelength $\lambda$ changes (b) the de Broglie wavelength of an electron accelerated from rest, as the accelerating voltage $V$ changes (c) the number of photons emitted per second by a source of fixed power, as its wavelength $\lambda$ changes (d) the maximum kinetic energy of photoelectrons, as the intensity $I$ of the light changes at fixed frequency
List-II: (i) $\propto\lambda$ (ii) independent of $I$ (iii) $\propto1/\sqrt V$ (iv) $\propto1/\lambda$
Choose the correct answer: (A) a-iv, b-iii, c-i, d-ii (B) a-i, b-iii, c-iv, d-ii (C) a-iv, b-ii, c-i, d-iii (D) a-iii, b-iv, c-i, d-ii

Match (a) $E=hc/\lambda$: iv. (b) $\lambda=h/\sqrt{2meV}$: iii. (c) $N=P\lambda/hc$: i. (d) $K_{\max}=h\nu-\phi_0$: ii (Section 17.1 for a, c, d; Section 17.2 for b).
Answer (A) a-iv, b-iii, c-i, d-ii.
โฑ Shortcut Only (iii) contains $V$ and only (ii) contains $I$, so b-iii and d-ii โ€” that leaves (A) and (B). Shorter wavelength means a more energetic photon, so a-iv.

E5. NEET ยท MCQ Two beams of monochromatic light, 1 and 2, fall in turn on the same emitter, and the photocurrent $I$ is plotted against the collector potential $V$. The photons of beam 1 have energy $3.5\ \text{eV}$. The work function of the emitter and the photon energy of beam 2 are (A) $1.0\ \text{eV}$ and $2.5\ \text{eV}$ (B) $2.5\ \text{eV}$ and $3.5\ \text{eV}$ (C) $3.5\ \text{eV}$ and $6.0\ \text{eV}$ (D) $2.5\ \text{eV}$ and $5.0\ \text{eV}$
โˆ’3โˆ’2โˆ’112336V (volt)I (ฮผA)12

Read the graph The currents fall to zero at $-1.0\ \text{V}$ (beam 1) and $-2.5\ \text{V}$ (beam 2): $V_{0,1}=1.0\ \text{V}$, $V_{0,2}=2.5\ \text{V}$. The saturation currents ($6$ and $3\ \mu\text{A}$) are not needed.
Work function $\phi_0=h\nu_1-eV_{0,1}=3.5-1.0=2.5\ \text{eV}$ (Section 17.1).
Beam 2 $h\nu_2=\phi_0+eV_{0,2}=2.5+2.5=5.0\ \text{eV}$.
Answer (D).
โฑ Shortcut Beam 2 stops at the more negative potential, so its photons are more energetic than $3.5\ \text{eV}$ โ€” (A) and (B) are out. (C) adds the stopping potential to $3.5$ as if the work function were $3.5\ \text{eV}$. The lower curve of beam 2 only means fewer photons per second.

E6. NEET ยท MCQ How many of the following statements are correct?
(i) The photoelectric effect shows the particle nature of light, and the diffraction of electrons by crystals shows the wave nature of matter.
(ii) The work function of a metal is the maximum energy needed to remove an electron from its surface.
(iii) A photon of wavelength $1240\ \text{nm}$ has an energy of $1\ \text{eV}$.
(iv) If the speed of a free electron is doubled (still far below $c$), its de Broglie wavelength is halved.
(v) The electrons emitted in the photoelectric effect have kinetic energies ranging from zero up to $K_{\max}$.
(vi) Light of any frequency can eject photoelectrons if it is intense enough.
(A) Three (B) Four (C) Five (D) Two

Check each (i) โœ“ (Sections 17.1 and 17.2). (ii) โœ— โ€” it is the minimum energy. (iii) โœ“ $1240/1240=1\ \text{eV}$. (iv) โœ“ $\lambda=h/mv$. (v) โœ“ โ€” Einstein's equation gives only the largest value. (vi) โœ— โ€” below the threshold frequency nothing is emitted, however intense the light.
Answer (B) four statements: (i), (iii), (iv) and (v).
โฑ Shortcut The word to watch in (ii) is "maximum": the work function is the price of the least tightly held electron.

E7. NEET ยท MCQ A photon has the same momentum as an electron moving at $1.0\times10^6\ \text{m/s}$. The wavelength and the energy of the photon are about (A) $0.73\ \text{nm}$ and $2.8\ \text{eV}$ (B) $1.46\ \text{nm}$ and $0.85\ \text{keV}$ (C) $0.73\ \text{nm}$ and $1.7\ \text{keV}$ (D) $0.36\ \text{nm}$ and $3.4\ \text{keV}$

Same momentum, same wavelength $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{m_ev}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{9.1\times10^{-31}\times1.0\times10^6}=7.3\times10^{-10}\ \text{m}=0.73\ \text{nm}$ (Section 17.2).
Photon energy $E=\dfrac{hc}{\lambda}=\dfrac{1240}{0.729}\approx1.7\times10^3\ \text{eV}=1.7\ \text{keV}$ (Section 17.1).
Answer (C).
โฑ Shortcut (A) gives the photon the electron's kinetic energy, $\tfrac12m_ev^2=2.8\ \text{eV}$ โ€” equal momenta never mean equal energies; the photon's $pc$ is far larger than the electron's $pv/2$. Once $\lambda=0.73\ \text{nm}$ is found, only (A) and (C) remain.

E8. NEET ยท MCQ A $2.0\ \text{mW}$ laser beam of wavelength $620\ \text{nm}$ falls on the emitter of a photocell, and one photon in every hundred releases an electron. The saturation photocurrent is about (A) $0.10\ \mu\text{A}$ (B) $1.0\ \text{mA}$ (C) $20\ \mu\text{A}$ (D) $10\ \mu\text{A}$

Photons Each photon has $\dfrac{1240}{620}=2.0\ \text{eV}=3.2\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}$, so $N=\dfrac{2.0\times10^{-3}}{3.2\times10^{-19}}=6.25\times10^{15}$ per second (Section 17.1).
Current $I=\eta Ne=0.01\times6.25\times10^{15}\times1.6\times10^{-19}=1.0\times10^{-5}\ \text{A}=10\ \mu\text{A}$.
Answer (D) $10\ \mu\text{A}$.
โฑ Shortcut $I=\eta\dfrac{P}{E(\text{in eV})}=0.01\times\dfrac{2.0\times10^{-3}}{2.0}=1.0\times10^{-5}\ \text{A}$ โ€” the $e$ cancels. (B) forgets the factor $0.01$, (A) applies it twice, and (C) halves the photon energy.
โœ… Before you start
You will measure energies in electronvolts, so recall that a charge $q$ moved through a potential difference $V$ gains energy $qV$ (Section 11.3), and that current is charge per second (Section 12.1). Kinetic energy and momentum, and $K=p^2/2m$, come from Section 3.1 and Section 4.1. Light is an electromagnetic wave with $c=\nu\lambda$ (Section 15.1, Section 15.2), and the evidence that it is a wave โ€” interference and diffraction โ€” is in Section 16.4 and Section 16.5. For thermal neutrons you need the average kinetic energy $\tfrac32k_BT$ of a gas molecule (Section 9.1).