Chapter 10 ยท Oscillations and Waves

10.4 Superposition, Standing Waves and Beats

When waves meet, their displacements simply add. A wave and its reflection add up to a standing wave, $y=2a\sin kx\cos\omega t$, so a string or an air column can ring only at its harmonics โ€” $\nu_n=nv/2L$ for a string or an open pipe, odd multiples of $v/4L$ for a closed pipe โ€” and two close frequencies give beats at $|\nu_1-\nu_2|$.

Pluck a guitar string and it does not sound every frequency: it sounds one clear note, plus fainter notes at exactly two, three, fourโ€ฆ times that frequency, and nothing in between. Blow across the mouth of an empty bottle and you hear a single deep hum; pour in some water and the hum rises. A tabla player taps the drum skin and tightens its straps until two notes stop "wobbling" against each other. All of this is the physics of waves meeting other waves.

The key is one simple rule: when two waves pass through the same place, the displacement there is just the sum of the displacements each wave would cause on its own. In this section we use that rule to combine two waves of the same frequency (interference), to see what happens when a wave is reflected from a fixed or a free end, to build standing waves from a wave and its reflection, to find the normal modes โ€” fundamental and harmonics โ€” of strings and of open and closed organ pipes (including the resonance tube of the NEET experiment on the speed of sound), and finally to explain beats. Everything rests on the progressive-wave relation $y=a\sin(kx-\omega t+\phi)$ of Section 10.3. NEET asks about this section every year: the harmonics of strings and of open and closed pipes (and which ones are missing), overtones counted correctly, distances between nodes and antinodes, the resonance tube, and beats with the wax-and-file reasoning.

The principle of superposition

Send a hump along a stretched rope from each end. The two pulses run towards each other, overlap for a moment โ€” the rope then has the shape you get by adding the two humps point by point โ€” and then emerge from the meeting place exactly as they went in, each continuing on its way as if the other had never been there. Waves do not bounce off or damage each other; they pass through each other.

๐Ÿ“ Principle 10.20 โ€” Principle of superposition of waves

When two or more waves travel through the same region of a medium, the resultant displacement of any particle at any instant is the (vector) sum of the displacements that the individual waves would produce there:

$$y(x,t)=y_1(x,t)+y_2(x,t)+\cdots$$

Each wave continues unaffected after the waves have crossed. The principle holds when the restoring force is proportional to the displacement (a linear medium) โ€” true for waves of small amplitude, which is the case in all NEET problems.

The most important case is two waves of the same frequency (and wavelength) travelling the same way, with amplitudes $a_1$ and $a_2$ and a phase difference $\phi$ between them: $y_1=a_1\sin(kx-\omega t)$ and $y_2=a_2\sin(kx-\omega t+\phi)$. At each point both are SHMs of the same frequency, and adding two such SHMs is like adding two vectors (phasors) of lengths $a_1$ and $a_2$ at an angle $\phi$.

๐Ÿ“ Result 10.21 โ€” Superposition of two waves of the same frequency

The resultant is a wave of the same frequency and wavelength, $y=A\sin(kx-\omega t+\delta)$, with

$$A=\sqrt{a_1^2+a_2^2+2a_1a_2\cos\phi},\qquad \tan\delta=\frac{a_2\sin\phi}{a_1+a_2\cos\phi}.$$

Since the energy carried (the intensity) is proportional to the square of the amplitude, $I=I_1+I_2+2\sqrt{I_1I_2}\cos\phi$.

  • Constructive: $\phi=0,2\pi,4\pi,\dots$ (path difference $0,\lambda,2\lambda,\dots$): $A_\text{max}=a_1+a_2$.
  • Destructive: $\phi=\pi,3\pi,\dots$ (path difference $\lambda/2,3\lambda/2,\dots$): $A_\text{min}=|a_1-a_2|$.

So $\dfrac{I_\text{max}}{I_\text{min}}=\left(\dfrac{a_1+a_2}{a_1-a_2}\right)^2$. A path difference $\Delta x$ gives a phase difference $\phi=\dfrac{2\pi}{\lambda}\Delta x$.

๐Ÿ“˜ Definition 10.10 โ€” Interference

Interference is the redistribution of energy that occurs when two waves of the same frequency with a constant phase difference superpose: where they arrive in phase the resultant is large (constructive interference), where they arrive in opposite phase it is small or zero (destructive interference). Energy is not destroyed; it is moved from the places of destructive interference to those of constructive interference.

Two loudspeakers driven by the same amplifier are a good example: walking across the room in front of them, you pass through loud and quiet spots, according to whether the path difference from the two speakers is a whole number of wavelengths or an odd number of half-wavelengths. Noise-cancelling headphones do the same deliberately โ€” they play the incoming noise back with its phase reversed, so that the two cancel at your ear.

โœ๏ธ Example 1 โ€” Adding two waves
Two waves $y_1=(4.0\ \text{mm})\sin(kx-\omega t)$ and $y_2=(3.0\ \text{mm})\sin(kx-\omega t+\phi)$ travel together along a string. Find the amplitude of the resultant when (a) $\phi=\pi/2$, (b) $\phi=\pi/3$, (c) $\phi=\pi$. (d) Find the ratio of the greatest to the least possible intensity of the resultant. (e) For $\phi=\pi/2$, by what angle does the resultant lead $y_1$?
(a) $\cos\dfrac{\pi}{2}=0$: $A=\sqrt{16+9}=5.0\ \text{mm}$.
(b) $A=\sqrt{16+9+2\times4\times3\times0.5}=\sqrt{37}=6.08\ \text{mm}$.
(c) Opposite phase: $A=4.0-3.0=1.0\ \text{mm}$.
(d) $\dfrac{I_\text{max}}{I_\text{min}}=\left(\dfrac{4+3}{4-3}\right)^2=49$.
(e) $\tan\delta=\dfrac{3\sin90^\circ}{4+3\cos90^\circ}=\dfrac34$, so $\delta=36.9^\circ$ โ€” the familiar 3โ€“4โ€“5 triangle of phasors.
Check Every answer lies between $|a_1-a_2|=1$ and $a_1+a_2=7\ \text{mm}$ โœ“, and $A$ falls steadily as $\phi$ grows from $0$ to $\pi$.

Two waves of the same frequency and the same amplitude $a$ travel together with a phase difference of $2\pi/3$. The amplitude of the resultant wave is

Reflection of waves and standing waves

A wave reaching the end of a string, or the end of a pipe, is reflected. What comes back depends on the end.

๐Ÿ“ Result 10.22 โ€” Reflection at rigid and free boundaries
  • Rigid (fixed) end โ€” a string tied to a wall: the end cannot move, so the reflected wave must cancel the incident wave there. The reflected wave is inverted (a crest returns as a trough): a phase change of $\pi$.
  • Free end โ€” a string ending in a light ring that slides on a smooth rod: the end can move freely and the slope there is zero. The reflected wave returns upright: no phase change.
  • Joint of two strings: a wave going from a lighter to a heavier string (into a slower medium) is partly reflected inverted, like a fixed end; from heavier to lighter it is reflected upright, like a free end. The transmitted wave is never inverted. The frequency is the same for all three waves.
  • Sound in a pipe: at a closed end the air cannot move (a displacement node, where the pressure varies most); at an open end the air moves freely and the pressure stays at atmospheric (a displacement antinode, a pressure node).

Take an incident wave travelling towards $-x$, $y_i=a\sin(kx+\omega t)$, and a rigid end at $x=0$. The reflected wave travels towards $+x$ with the same amplitude and must make $y_i+y_r=0$ at $x=0$ for all $t$; that is $y_r=a\sin(kx-\omega t)$, since $\sin(\omega t)+\sin(-\omega t)=0$. (Compared with the incident wave written as $a\sin(\omega t+kx)$, the reflected wave $-a\sin(\omega t-kx)$ carries the minus sign of the phase change $\pi$.) Adding them with $\sin A+\sin B=2\sin\dfrac{A+B}{2}\cos\dfrac{A-B}{2}$:

$$y=a\sin(kx+\omega t)+a\sin(kx-\omega t)=2a\sin kx\cos\omega t .$$

This is no longer a travelling wave: $x$ and $t$ appear in separate factors. Every particle performs SHM, $\cos\omega t$, with its own fixed amplitude $2a\sin kx$; the shape swells and shrinks in place without moving along the string.

๐Ÿ“ Result 10.23 โ€” Standing wave

Two waves of equal amplitude $a$ and equal frequency travelling in opposite directions superpose to give a standing wave. With a displacement node at $x=0$ (rigid end),

$$y=2a\sin kx\cos\omega t ,$$

and with a displacement antinode at $x=0$ (free end), $y=2a\cos kx\cos\omega t$. The amplitude at position $x$ is $|2a\sin kx|$ (or $|2a\cos kx|$).

  • Nodes (zero amplitude) for $\sin kx=0$: $x=0,\ \dfrac{\lambda}{2},\ \lambda,\ \dfrac{3\lambda}{2},\dots$
  • Antinodes (amplitude $2a$) for $\sin kx=\pm1$: $x=\dfrac{\lambda}{4},\ \dfrac{3\lambda}{4},\ \dfrac{5\lambda}{4},\dots$
  • Adjacent nodes (or antinodes) are $\lambda/2$ apart; a node and the next antinode are $\lambda/4$ apart.
  • All particles between two adjacent nodes move in phase; particles in neighbouring loops move in opposite phase.
๐Ÿ“˜ Definition 10.11 โ€” Standing wave, node and antinode

A standing (or stationary) wave is the pattern of vibration formed by two identical waves travelling in opposite directions: the waveform does not travel and no energy is transported past any node. A node is a point that is permanently at rest; an antinode is a point where the amplitude is greatest. Between nodes, energy surges back and forth between kinetic (all particles passing the mean position together) and elastic potential (all at their extremes together).

Compare the two kinds of wave carefully. In a progressive wave all particles have the same amplitude and their phases change steadily along $x$; energy flows. In a standing wave the amplitude changes with position (from $0$ at nodes to $2a$ at antinodes), the phase is the same within a loop and jumps by $\pi$ at each node, and there is no net flow of energy. In a sound standing wave, the displacement nodes are pressure antinodes and vice versa: where the air does not move, it is squeezed and stretched the most.

โœ๏ธ Example 2 โ€” A wave meets a fixed end
A wave $y_i=(2.0\ \text{mm})\sin(5\pi x+200\pi t)$ ($x$ in m, $t$ in s) travels along a long string towards a rigid support at $x=0$ and is completely reflected. (a) Write the reflected wave and the resulting standing wave. (b) Find the wavelength, frequency and wave speed, and the positions of the first three nodes and antinodes. (c) Find the amplitude of the particle at $x=0.05\ \text{m}$ and the greatest speed of a particle at an antinode. (d) The same standing wave is set up on a string $1.0\ \text{m}$ long fixed at both ends, of linear mass density $5.0\ \text{g/m}$. Which harmonic is it, what is the fundamental frequency, and what is the tension?
Find the amplitude at $x=0.05\ \text{m}$ in (c) before you open the solution:
(a) Inverted reflection: $y_r=(2.0\ \text{mm})\sin(5\pi x-200\pi t)$ (check: $y_i+y_r=0$ at $x=0$ for all $t$). Sum: $y=(4.0\ \text{mm})\sin(5\pi x)\cos(200\pi t)$.
(b) $\lambda=\dfrac{2\pi}{5\pi}=0.40\ \text{m}$, $\nu=100\ \text{Hz}$, $v=\dfrac{\omega}{k}=40\ \text{m/s}$. Nodes at $x=0,\ 0.20,\ 0.40\ \text{m}$; antinodes at $0.10,\ 0.30,\ 0.50\ \text{m}$.
(c) $A=4.0\left|\sin\dfrac{\pi}{4}\right|=2.83\ \text{mm}$. At an antinode $v_\text{max}=2a\,\omega=4.0\times10^{-3}\times200\pi=2.51\ \text{m/s}$.
(d) $L=n\dfrac{\lambda}{2}$ gives $n=\dfrac{2\times1.0}{0.40}=5$: the fifth harmonic (five loops). Fundamental $\dfrac{100}{5}=20\ \text{Hz}$. $T=\mu v^2=5.0\times10^{-3}\times40^2=8.0\ \text{N}$.
โฑ Shortcut Read a standing wave $y=A_0\sin kx\cos\omega t$ exactly like a travelling one: $\lambda=2\pi/k$, $\nu=\omega/2\pi$, $v=\omega/k$ โ€” the speed of the component waves โ€” and each component has amplitude $A_0/2$.

In a standing wave of wavelength $\lambda$, the distance between a node and the nearest antinode is

Normal modes of strings and organ pipes

On a string of length $L$ fixed at both ends, waves bounce back and forth. A standing wave can survive only if both ends are nodes, i.e. if a whole number of half-wavelengths fits exactly into the length: $L=n\dfrac{\lambda}{2}$. Any other frequency is quickly killed by the reflections cancelling each other. The allowed patterns are the natural ways the string can vibrate.

๐Ÿ“ Result 10.24 โ€” Normal modes of a string fixed at both ends

A string of length $L$, tension $T$ and linear mass density $\mu$, fixed at both ends, can vibrate in standing waves with

$$\lambda_n=\frac{2L}{n},\qquad \nu_n=\frac{nv}{2L}=\frac{n}{2L}\sqrt{\frac{T}{\mu}},\qquad n=1,2,3,\dots$$

The $n$-th mode has $n$ loops, $n+1$ nodes (counting the ends) and $n$ antinodes. All whole-number multiples of the lowest frequency $\nu_1=\dfrac{1}{2L}\sqrt{\dfrac{T}{\mu}}$ occur. For the fundamental: $\nu\propto\dfrac1L$ (at fixed $T,\mu$), $\nu\propto\sqrt T$, $\nu\propto\dfrac{1}{\sqrt\mu}$ โ€” the "laws of vibrating strings" used with a sonometer.

๐Ÿ“˜ Definition 10.12 โ€” Normal modes, fundamental, harmonics and overtones

The normal modes of a vibrating system are the patterns in which every part oscillates with the same frequency; their frequencies are its natural frequencies. The lowest is the fundamental mode (first harmonic), of frequency $\nu_1$. A natural frequency equal to $n\nu_1$ is the $n$-th harmonic. The natural frequencies above the fundamental, in order, are the first, second, โ€ฆ overtones. For a string, the first overtone is the second harmonic; in general the $(n-1)$-th overtone is the $n$-th harmonic. A system that has only odd harmonics (a closed pipe, below) has first overtone $=$ third harmonic.

A plucked or bowed string usually vibrates in several modes at once; the mixture of harmonics gives an instrument its tone quality (timbre), while the fundamental fixes the pitch. A guitarist touching a string lightly at its midpoint kills every mode that does not have a node there, leaving only the even harmonics โ€” a "harmonic" an octave up. In a sonometer a wire is stretched over two bridges by a hanging mass; when its fundamental equals the frequency of a tuning fork held on the box, the wire vibrates strongly (resonance) and a paper rider placed on it jumps off.

Organ pipes. Air columns have normal modes too. At a closed end the air is held still (displacement node); at an open end it moves most (displacement antinode). Draw the displacement pattern of each mode and count quarter-wavelengths.

๐Ÿ“ Result 10.25 โ€” Normal modes of air columns (organ pipes)

With $v$ the speed of sound and $L$ the length of the pipe:

  • Closed pipe (closed at one end, open at the other): node at the closed end, antinode at the open end, so $L=(2n-1)\dfrac{\lambda}{4}$ and $$\nu=\frac{(2n-1)\,v}{4L},\qquad n=1,2,3,\dots$$ Only odd harmonics occur: $\nu_1,\ 3\nu_1,\ 5\nu_1,\dots$ with $\nu_1=\dfrac{v}{4L}$.
  • Open pipe (open at both ends): antinodes at both ends, so $L=n\dfrac{\lambda}{2}$ and $$\nu=\frac{nv}{2L},\qquad n=1,2,3,\dots$$ All harmonics occur, with $\nu_1=\dfrac{v}{2L}$ โ€” twice the fundamental of a closed pipe of the same length.

End correction. The antinode at an open end lies slightly outside the pipe, at about $e\approx0.3d$ beyond it ($d$ the internal diameter, so $e\approx0.6r$). Then a closed pipe has $\nu_1=\dfrac{v}{4(L+e)}$ and an open pipe $\nu_1=\dfrac{v}{2(L+2e)}$.

The resonance tube. The NEET experiment on the speed of sound in air at room temperature (Chapter 20, Experimental Skills) uses a closed pipe of adjustable length: a glass tube whose lower end dips into water, the water level set by a reservoir. A tuning fork of frequency $\nu$ is held over the open end and the air column is lengthened from zero. The sound swells loudly at a length $l_1$ (first resonance) and again at $l_2$ (second resonance). With the end correction $e$,

$$l_1+e=\frac{\lambda}{4},\qquad l_2+e=\frac{3\lambda}{4}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad \lambda=2(l_2-l_1),\quad v=2\nu(l_2-l_1),\quad e=\frac{l_2-3l_1}{2}.$$

Using the difference of the two lengths removes the end correction from the result โ€” the reason the experiment needs two resonances.

๐Ÿงญ Problem-solving strategy โ€” Strings and pipes
  1. Decide the ends: fixed string end or closed pipe end = displacement node; open pipe end = antinode (plus the end correction if the diameter is given).
  2. Sketch the mode and count: node to node or antinode to antinode $=\lambda/2$; node to antinode $=\lambda/4$. Express $L$ in terms of $\lambda$.
  3. Find $v$: $\sqrt{T/\mu}$ on a string, the given speed of sound (or $\sqrt{\gamma RT/M}$) in a pipe. Then $\nu=v/\lambda$.
  4. Two consecutive natural frequencies: their difference is $\nu_1$ for a string or open pipe and $2\nu_1$ for a closed pipe. If the ratios are $1:2:3$ it is a string or open pipe; $1:3:5$ means a closed pipe.
  5. "Unison" means equal frequencies; "first overtone" of a closed pipe is the third harmonic, $3v/4L$.
โœ๏ธ Example 3 โ€” Tuning a guitar string
The vibrating length of a guitar string is $65\ \text{cm}$ and its linear mass density is $1.2\ \text{g/m}$. Its fundamental is to be $330\ \text{Hz}$. (a) Find the wave speed and the tension needed. (b) Find the frequencies of the next two harmonics. (c) Where must the player press the string against a fret to sound $440\ \text{Hz}$? (d) If the tension is $4\%$ too high, what fundamental does the string give?
(a) $v=2L\nu_1=2\times0.65\times330=429\ \text{m/s}$; $T=\mu v^2=1.2\times10^{-3}\times429^2=221\ \text{N}$.
(b) All harmonics occur: $660\ \text{Hz}$ and $990\ \text{Hz}$.
(c) Same $v$: $L'=\dfrac{v}{2\nu}=\dfrac{429}{880}=0.488\ \text{m}$, i.e. a vibrating length of $48.8\ \text{cm}$ (pressing $16.2\ \text{cm}$ from the top end).
(d) $\nu\propto\sqrt T$: $330\sqrt{1.04}=337\ \text{Hz}$ โ€” about $2\%$ sharp, easily heard against a correctly tuned string (Interactive 2).
Check $\dfrac{\nu'}{\nu}=\dfrac{L}{L'}=\dfrac{65}{48.8}=1.33=\dfrac{440}{330}$ โœ“.
โœ๏ธ Example 4 โ€” Open and closed pipes
Take the speed of sound as $340\ \text{m/s}$ and ignore end corrections. (a) Find the first three natural frequencies of a pipe $85\ \text{cm}$ long closed at one end, and (b) of an open pipe of the same length. (c) The first overtone of the closed pipe is in unison with the fundamental of an open pipe. Find the length of the open pipe.
(a) $\nu_1=\dfrac{v}{4L}=\dfrac{340}{3.4}=100\ \text{Hz}$; then the odd harmonics $300\ \text{Hz}$ and $500\ \text{Hz}$.
(b) $\nu_1=\dfrac{v}{2L}=200\ \text{Hz}$; then $400\ \text{Hz}$ and $600\ \text{Hz}$.
(c) First overtone of the closed pipe $=3\times100=300\ \text{Hz}=\dfrac{v}{2L'}$, so $L'=\dfrac{340}{600}=0.567\ \text{m}=56.7\ \text{cm}$.
โฑ Shortcut $\dfrac{3v}{4L}=\dfrac{v}{2L'}$ gives $L'=\dfrac{2L}{3}$ directly; $v$ cancels.
โœ๏ธ Example 5 โ€” The resonance tube
In a resonance-tube experiment with a tuning fork of frequency $512\ \text{Hz}$, the first resonance is found with an air column of $16.0\ \text{cm}$ and the second with $49.5\ \text{cm}$. (a) Find the speed of sound in the air. (b) Find the end correction and estimate the internal diameter of the tube. (c) At what length of air column would the third resonance occur?
Find the speed of sound in (a) first:
(a) $\lambda=2(49.5-16.0)=67.0\ \text{cm}$; $v=512\times0.670=343\ \text{m/s}$.
(b) $e=\dfrac{l_2-3l_1}{2}=\dfrac{49.5-48.0}{2}=0.75\ \text{cm}$; with $e\approx0.3d$, $d\approx2.5\ \text{cm}$.
(c) $l_3+e=\dfrac{5\lambda}{4}=83.75\ \text{cm}$, so $l_3=83.0\ \text{cm}$ (each resonance is $\lambda/2=33.5\ \text{cm}$ beyond the last).
Check Without the end correction, $4l_1=64.0\ \text{cm}$ would give $v=328\ \text{m/s}$ โ€” about $4\%$ low. That is why the experiment uses $l_2-l_1$.

In Interactive 1 choose the closed pipe, set $L=0.85\ \text{m}$ and select mode $2$. What frequency does the pipe sound, and what is this mode called?

With the closed pipe, $L=0.85\ \text{m}$ and mode $2$ the readouts show $\lambda=4L/3=1.13\ \text{m}$, $\nu=3v/4L=300\ \text{Hz}$, "3rd harmonic = 1st overtone", and 2 displacement nodes with 2 antinodes (a node at the closed end, an antinode at the open end). The frequency ladder under the pipe shows only $100,300,500,\dots\ \text{Hz}$: a closed pipe has no even harmonics, so its second mode is the third harmonic. Switch to the open pipe of the same length and mode $2$: $400\ \text{Hz}$, the second harmonic.
Interactive 1 โ€” Standing Waves: Strings, Closed Pipes and Open Pipes

Choose a string fixed at both ends ($v=120\ \text{m/s}$) or a pipe ($v=340\ \text{m/s}$, no end correction), its length and the mode number. The black curve is the standing wave (slowed down; for a pipe it is the displacement of the air along the pipe, drawn sideways), the dashed curves its envelope, N and A the nodes and antinodes. Show the two travelling waves to see the standing wave being built from a wave and its reflection. The ladder at the bottom marks all the frequencies this system allows.

0.85 m2
wavelength $\lambda$โ€”
frequency $\nu$โ€”
which modeโ€”
nodes / antinodesโ€”

Which of these frequencies can a pipe of length $L$ closed at one end not produce? ($v$ is the speed of sound; ignore end correction.)

Beats

Strike two tuning forks of nearly the same frequency โ€” say $256\ \text{Hz}$ and $260\ \text{Hz}$ โ€” together. You do not hear two notes; you hear one note, of about $258\ \text{Hz}$, whose loudness swells and fades four times a second: wahโ€“wahโ€“wahโ€“wah. This waxing and waning of loudness is called beats. It is superposition again, but now in time at one place, between two waves of slightly different frequencies.

At the listener's position let the two waves give $y_1=a\cos2\pi\nu_1t$ and $y_2=a\cos2\pi\nu_2t$, with $\nu_1\gt\nu_2$. Using $\cos A+\cos B=2\cos\dfrac{A-B}{2}\cos\dfrac{A+B}{2}$,

$$y=\underbrace{2a\cos\left(2\pi\,\frac{\nu_1-\nu_2}{2}\,t\right)}_{\text{slowly varying amplitude}}\ \cos\left(2\pi\,\frac{\nu_1+\nu_2}{2}\,t\right).$$

The ear hears a tone of the average frequency $\dfrac{\nu_1+\nu_2}{2}$ whose amplitude $\left|2a\cos\pi(\nu_1-\nu_2)t\right|$ rises and falls slowly. The amplitude is greatest ($2a$) whenever $\cos\pi(\nu_1-\nu_2)t=\pm1$, i.e. at $t=0,\ \dfrac{1}{\nu_1-\nu_2},\ \dfrac{2}{\nu_1-\nu_2},\dots$ โ€” the two vibrations are back in step โ€” and zero half-way between, when they are in opposite phase.

๐Ÿ“˜ Definition 10.13 โ€” Beats

Beats are the periodic rise and fall in the loudness of sound heard when two sound waves of slightly different frequencies (and similar amplitudes) superpose at a point. One beat is one cycle from loud to faint and back to loud.

๐Ÿ“ Result 10.26 โ€” Beat frequency
$$\nu_\text{beat}=|\nu_1-\nu_2|,\qquad T_\text{beat}=\frac{1}{|\nu_1-\nu_2|}.$$

The ear can count beats only when $|\nu_1-\nu_2|$ is small โ€” up to about $10$ per second; for larger differences the two notes are heard separately (or as a rough sound). If the amplitudes are unequal, the loudness varies between $(a_1+a_2)^2$ and $(a_1-a_2)^2$ but never falls to zero.

Finding an unknown frequency. Beats tell you the size of the difference, not its sign: a fork giving $4$ beats/s with a $256\ \text{Hz}$ fork is at $252$ or $260\ \text{Hz}$. To decide, change the unknown fork slightly and watch the beats. Loading a prong with a little wax lowers its frequency; filing a prong (removing metal from its end) raises it. If loading the unknown fork increases the beats, it moves away from $256$: so it was already below, at $252\ \text{Hz}$. If loading decreases the beats, it was above. For strings, tightening raises the frequency. Musicians use exactly this to tune: they adjust until the beats slow down and vanish.

โœ๏ธ Example 6 โ€” Beats and wax
A tuning fork A of frequency $256\ \text{Hz}$ is sounded with another fork B, and $4$ beats per second are heard. When a little wax is stuck on a prong of B, the number of beats rises to $6$ per second. (a) Find the frequency of B. (b) What would you hear if, instead, a prong of B were filed slightly so that its frequency rose by $2\ \text{Hz}$? (c) At one point two sound waves arrive as $y_1=a\sin(680\pi t)$ and $y_2=a\sin(672\pi t)$. Find the beat frequency, the time between successive loud sounds, and the frequency of the tone heard.
Find the frequency of B before you open the solution:
(a) $\nu_B=256\pm4=260$ or $252\ \text{Hz}$. Wax lowers $\nu_B$. From $260$ it would move towards $256$ and the beats would fall; from $252$ it moves away and the beats rise (to $6$ when $\nu_B=250\ \text{Hz}$). So $\nu_B=252\ \text{Hz}$.
(b) Filing raises $\nu_B$ from $252$ to $254\ \text{Hz}$: the beats slow to $2$ per second โ€” a second, consistent test.
(c) $\nu_1=\dfrac{680\pi}{2\pi}=340\ \text{Hz}$, $\nu_2=336\ \text{Hz}$: $\nu_\text{beat}=4\ \text{Hz}$, loud sounds every $\dfrac14=0.25\ \text{s}$, heard tone $\dfrac{340+336}{2}=338\ \text{Hz}$.
โฑ Shortcut Wax (or a looser string): $\nu$ down. If the beats go up, the unknown was below the standard; if they go down, it was above. Filing (or a tighter string) reverses the rule.

In Interactive 2 set $\nu_1=25\ \text{Hz}$, $\nu_2=22\ \text{Hz}$ and equal amplitudes ($a_2/a_1=1.0$). How often does the loudness reach a maximum?

With $25$ and $22\ \text{Hz}$ the readouts show a beat frequency of $3\ \text{Hz}$, a beat period of $0.333\ \text{s}$ and a tone at the average frequency $23.5\ \text{Hz}$; in the $2\ \text{s}$ window a loud swelling comes every $0.333\ \text{s}$, and with equal amplitudes it falls right to zero between them ($I_\max/I_\min$ reads "โˆž"). The envelope $2a\cos\pi\Delta\nu t$ itself has frequency $1.5\ \text{Hz}$, but the loudness peaks at both its $+$ and $-$ extremes โ€” hence $3$ beats per second, not $1.5$. Now set $a_2/a_1=0.5$: the minima no longer reach zero and $I_\max/I_\min=(1.5/0.5)^2=9$.
Interactive 2 โ€” Beats: Two Close Frequencies

Two vibrations reach your ear (low frequencies are used so that each oscillation can be seen). The top two strips show each one alone; the large graph shows their sum over $2\ \text{s}$ with its envelope dashed. Press Play: the cursor sweeps the time axis and the bar on the right shows the loudness ($\propto$ amplitudeยฒ) at that moment. Move $\nu_2$ towards $\nu_1$ and watch the beats slow down โ€” this is how a musician tunes.

25.0 Hz22.0 Hz1.0
beat frequency $|\nu_1-\nu_2|$โ€”
beat periodโ€”
tone heard $\tfrac{\nu_1+\nu_2}{2}$โ€”
$I_\max/I_\min$โ€”
โœ๏ธ Example 7 โ€” NEET-style: missing harmonics and beats by elimination
(a) A pipe $50\ \text{cm}$ long is closed at one end. Taking the speed of sound as $340\ \text{m/s}$ and neglecting the end correction, which of the following frequencies can the pipe not produce? (A) $170\ \text{Hz}$ (B) $510\ \text{Hz}$ (C) $680\ \text{Hz}$ (D) $850\ \text{Hz}$.
(b) Two sound waves $y_1=a\sin(500\pi t)$ and $y_2=a\sin(506\pi t)$ reach the same point. The number of beats heard per second is (A) $6$ (B) $3$ (C) $1.5$ (D) $251.5$.
(a) Fundamental $\nu_1=\dfrac{v}{4L}=\dfrac{340}{4\times0.50}=170\ \text{Hz}$ (Result 10.25).
(a) Harmonics A closed pipe has only odd harmonics: $170,\ 510,\ 850,\ 1190,\dots\ \text{Hz}$. $680\ \text{Hz}=4\times170\ \text{Hz}$ is an even harmonic.
Answer (a) (C) $680\ \text{Hz}$.
(b) Frequencies $\nu_1=\dfrac{500\pi}{2\pi}=250\ \text{Hz}$ and $\nu_2=\dfrac{506\pi}{2\pi}=253\ \text{Hz}$, so $\nu_\text{beat}=|\nu_1-\nu_2|=3$ per second (Result 10.26).
Answer (b) (B) $3$. (A) takes the difference of the coefficients, $6$, as if it were a frequency in hertz; (C) is the frequency of the envelope $\cos\pi(\nu_2-\nu_1)t$, which gives two loud moments per cycle; (D) is the frequency of the tone heard.
โฑ Shortcut (a) Divide each option by the fundamental: $1,\ 3,\ 4,\ 5$ โ€” the even one is the odd one out. (b) The coefficient of $t$ is $2\pi\nu$, so $\nu_\text{beat}=\dfrac{506\pi-500\pi}{2\pi}=3$ in one line.
๐Ÿš€ Beyond NEET โ€” the Doppler effect

The Doppler effect is not in the NMC NEET (UG) syllabus list for this unit (it is listed for JEE Advanced, and it is not in the CBSE syllabus). This box is for interest only; nothing here is used in the exercises, the Exam corner or the quiz.

When a source of sound and a listener move towards each other, the listener hears a higher frequency than the source emits; when they move apart, a lower one โ€” the rise and fall in pitch of a passing ambulance siren. For motion along the line joining them, in still air with speed of sound $v$, a source of frequency $\nu$ moving at $v_s$ and a listener moving at $v_o$ give $\nu'=\nu\,\dfrac{v+v_o}{v-v_s}$, with $v_o$ positive when the listener moves towards the source and $v_s$ positive when the source moves towards the listener. A $700\ \text{Hz}$ siren approaching at $20\ \text{m/s}$ ($v=340\ \text{m/s}$) is heard at $744\ \text{Hz}$, and at $661\ \text{Hz}$ once it has passed. Sound reflected from a moving object and mixed with the original gives beats at the frequency shift โ€” the principle of Doppler radar and of Doppler ultrasound scans of blood flow, which let a doctor see how fast blood moves through the heart and the arteries.

โš ๏ธ NEET traps

1. Closed pipes have only odd harmonics. Their natural frequencies are $\nu_1,3\nu_1,5\nu_1,\dots$; two consecutive ones differ by $2\nu_1$. Strings and open pipes have all harmonics, differing by $\nu_1$. Opening the closed end of a pipe doubles its fundamental; closing one end of an open pipe halves it.

2. Harmonic or overtone? The $n$-th harmonic has frequency $n\nu_1$; overtones are counted from the first frequency above the fundamental. For a string or an open pipe the first overtone is the second harmonic; for a closed pipe it is the third harmonic, and the second overtone the fifth.

3. Node/antinode spacing. Node to node $=\lambda/2$, node to antinode $=\lambda/4$. A string in its $n$-th mode has $n$ loops, $n+1$ nodes and $n$ antinodes. In a pipe, displacement nodes are pressure antinodes โ€” read which one the question asks for.

4. Standing versus progressive waves. In a standing wave the amplitude changes from point to point, all particles between two adjacent nodes move in phase, and no energy is carried past a node. In a progressive wave every particle has the same amplitude, the phase changes steadily along the wave, and energy flows. Statements that swap these are a favourite.

5. End correction and the resonance tube. When a diameter is given, the effective length is $L+0.3d$ (closed) or $L+0.6d$ (open). In the resonance tube, $\lambda=2(l_2-l_1)$ is free of end correction, while $4l_1$ is not.

6. Beats: the sign of the difference. Beats give only $|\nu_1-\nu_2|$. Wax lowers a fork's frequency, filing raises it; a tighter string goes up. Decide the sign from whether the beats increase or decrease. And intensities do not add simply: $\dfrac{I_\max}{I_\min}=\left(\dfrac{a_1+a_2}{a_1-a_2}\right)^2$ uses the amplitudes.

A tuning fork of unknown frequency gives $5$ beats per second with a fork of $300\ \text{Hz}$. When the unknown fork is filed slightly, the beats fall to $3$ per second. The unknown frequency was

Exercises

Take the speed of sound in air as $340\ \text{m/s}$ and neglect end corrections unless told otherwise.

I
Superposition and reflection.
  • 1 Two waves of the same frequency with amplitudes $5.0\ \text{mm}$ and $12\ \text{mm}$ travel together with a phase difference of $\pi/2$. Find the resultant amplitude.
  • 2 For the two waves of part 1, find the largest and smallest possible resultant amplitudes and the ratio $I_\max/I_\min$.
  • 3 Two identical waves of amplitude $a$ superpose and the resultant also has amplitude $a$. Find their phase difference in degrees.
  • 4 Two waves of the same frequency have intensities in the ratio $9:4$. Find the ratio of the greatest to the least intensity they can produce together.
  • 5 Two loudspeakers in phase emit $1000\ \text{Hz}$ sound. A listener is $0.85\ \text{m}$ further from one than from the other. Is the sound loud or quiet there? (Take $\lambda=0.34\ \text{m}$.)
  • 6 Describe the reflected pulse when a crest reaches (a) a string's end tied to a wall; (b) an end tied to a light ring that slides freely on a smooth vertical rod.
  • 7 The wave $y_i=3.0\sin(4\pi x+100\pi t)$ (cm, with $x$ in m, $t$ in s) is reflected without loss at $x=0$. Write the reflected wave if $x=0$ is (a) a rigid support, (b) a free end.
  • 8 A light string is joined to a heavy string. A pulse travels from the light string towards the joint. Which of the reflected and transmitted pulses is inverted? Which travels faster?
1 $A=\sqrt{5^2+12^2}=13\ \text{mm}$.
2 $A_\max=17\ \text{mm}$, $A_\min=7.0\ \text{mm}$; $\dfrac{I_\max}{I_\min}=\left(\dfrac{17}{7}\right)^2=5.90$.
3 $a^2=2a^2(1+\cos\phi)$ gives $\cos\phi=-\tfrac12$: $\phi=120^\circ$ $(2\pi/3)$.
4 $a_1:a_2=3:2$, so $\dfrac{I_\max}{I_\min}=\left(\dfrac{3+2}{3-2}\right)^2=25$.
5 $\dfrac{0.85}{0.34}=2.5$ wavelengths, so $\phi=5\pi$: opposite phase โ€” destructive interference, a quiet spot.
6 (a) Rigid end: the pulse comes back inverted, as a trough (phase change $\pi$). (b) Free end: it comes back upright, as a crest.
7 (a) $y_r=3.0\sin(4\pi x-100\pi t)$, so that $y_i+y_r=0$ at $x=0$. (b) $y_r=3.0\sin(100\pi t-4\pi x)$, so that the slope $\partial(y_i+y_r)/\partial x=0$ at $x=0$; the sum is $6.0\cos(4\pi x)\sin(100\pi t)$, with an antinode at the free end.
8 The reflected pulse is inverted (light to heavy is like a fixed end); the transmitted pulse is upright. The pulse on the light string is faster: $v=\sqrt{T/\mu}$ with the same $T$ and smaller $\mu$.
II
Standing waves on strings. Parts 1โ€“3 use $y=(0.50\ \text{cm})\sin\left(\dfrac{\pi x}{4}\right)\cos(100\pi t)$ with $x$ in cm and $t$ in s.
  • 1 Find the wavelength and the distance between adjacent nodes.
  • 2 Find the amplitude and the speed of the two travelling waves that make up this standing wave.
  • 3 Find the amplitude of the particle at $x=1.0\ \text{cm}$.
  • 4 A string $1.2\ \text{m}$ long with linear mass density $6.0\ \text{g/m}$ is fixed at both ends under a tension of $96\ \text{N}$. Find its fundamental frequency.
  • 5 For the string of part 4, find the frequency of the third harmonic and the number of nodes (including the ends) in that mode.
  • 6 A string fixed at both ends has two consecutive natural frequencies $375\ \text{Hz}$ and $450\ \text{Hz}$. Find its fundamental frequency and the harmonic numbers of the two given frequencies.
  • 7 A sonometer wire $50\ \text{cm}$ long resonates in its fundamental with a $256\ \text{Hz}$ fork. At what length (same tension) will it resonate with a $384\ \text{Hz}$ fork?
  • 8 By what percentage must the tension in a string be increased to raise its fundamental frequency by $10\%$?
  • 9 A sonometer wire is stretched by a metal block hanging from it, and its fundamental is $300\ \text{Hz}$. The block (density $9.0\times10^3\ \text{kg/m}^3$) is then completely immersed in water. Find the new fundamental frequency.
1 $k=\dfrac{\pi}{4}\ \text{rad/cm}$: $\lambda=8.0\ \text{cm}$; adjacent nodes $\lambda/2=4.0\ \text{cm}$ apart.
2 Each component has amplitude $0.25\ \text{cm}$; $\nu=50\ \text{Hz}$, so $v=\nu\lambda=400\ \text{cm/s}=4.0\ \text{m/s}$.
3 $A=0.50\sin\dfrac{\pi}{4}=0.354\ \text{cm}$.
4 $v=\sqrt{\dfrac{96}{6.0\times10^{-3}}}=126.5\ \text{m/s}$; $\nu_1=\dfrac{v}{2L}=\dfrac{126.5}{2.4}=52.7\ \text{Hz}$.
5 $\nu_3=3\times52.7=158\ \text{Hz}$; three loops, so $4$ nodes.
6 $\nu_1=450-375=75\ \text{Hz}$; $375=5\times75$ and $450=6\times75$: the 5th and 6th harmonics.
7 $\nu\propto\dfrac1L$: $L=50\times\dfrac{256}{384}=33.3\ \text{cm}$.
8 $\nu\propto\sqrt T$: $T'=1.10^2\,T=1.21\,T$, an increase of $21\%$.
9 $T'=T\left(1-\dfrac{1000}{9000}\right)=\dfrac89\,T$, so $\nu'=300\sqrt{\dfrac89}=283\ \text{Hz}$.
III
Organ pipes and the resonance tube.
  • 1 An open pipe has a fundamental of $425\ \text{Hz}$. Find its length in cm.
  • 2 Find the fundamental and the first two overtones of a pipe $25\ \text{cm}$ long closed at one end.
  • 3 A closed pipe has a fundamental of $170\ \text{Hz}$. Find its length and the frequency of its second overtone.
  • 4 An open pipe and a closed pipe have the same fundamental frequency. Find the ratio of their lengths, $L_\text{open}/L_\text{closed}$.
  • 5 A pipe resonates at $375$, $625$ and $875\ \text{Hz}$, and at no frequency in between. Is it open or closed? Find its fundamental and its length in cm.
  • 6 A pipe $32\ \text{cm}$ long and $5.0\ \text{cm}$ in diameter is closed at one end. Using the end correction $0.3d$, find its fundamental frequency.
  • 7 In a resonance tube experiment with a $480\ \text{Hz}$ fork the first two resonances occur at $17.0\ \text{cm}$ and $52.5\ \text{cm}$. Find the speed of sound and the end correction.
  • 8 In the fundamental mode of a closed pipe, where is the pressure variation greatest and where is it zero? Explain.
1 $L=\dfrac{v}{2\nu_1}=\dfrac{340}{850}=0.40\ \text{m}=40\ \text{cm}$.
2 $\nu_1=\dfrac{340}{4\times0.25}=340\ \text{Hz}$; overtones $3\nu_1=1020\ \text{Hz}$ and $5\nu_1=1700\ \text{Hz}$.
3 $L=\dfrac{340}{4\times170}=0.50\ \text{m}$; second overtone $=5\nu_1=850\ \text{Hz}$.
4 $\dfrac{v}{2L_o}=\dfrac{v}{4L_c}$, so $\dfrac{L_o}{L_c}=2$.
5 Consecutive frequencies differ by $250\ \text{Hz}$ and are in the ratio $3:5:7$, so the pipe is closed with $\nu_1=125\ \text{Hz}$; $L=\dfrac{340}{4\times125}=0.68\ \text{m}=68\ \text{cm}$.
6 $e=0.3\times5.0=1.5\ \text{cm}$; $\nu_1=\dfrac{340}{4\times0.335}=254\ \text{Hz}$ (without the correction, $266\ \text{Hz}$).
7 $\lambda=2(52.5-17.0)=71.0\ \text{cm}$, $v=480\times0.710=341\ \text{m/s}$; $e=\dfrac{52.5-3\times17.0}{2}=0.75\ \text{cm}$.
8 At the closed end the air cannot move (displacement node), so it is squeezed and stretched most: the pressure variation is greatest there. At the open end the air is in contact with the atmosphere, so the pressure stays atmospheric (pressure node) while the displacement is greatest.
IV
Beats and mixed problems.
  • 1 Forks of $384\ \text{Hz}$ and $380\ \text{Hz}$ are sounded together. Find the beat frequency and the time between successive maxima of loudness.
  • 2 A fork P gives $6$ beats per second with a $400\ \text{Hz}$ fork. When P is loaded with a little wax the beats fall to $4$ per second. Find the frequency of P before loading.
  • 3 A tuning fork gives $5$ beats per second with a sonometer wire when the vibrating length is $95\ \text{cm}$, and again $5$ beats per second when it is $100\ \text{cm}$ (tension unchanged, fundamental mode). Find the frequency of the fork.
  • 4 Two open pipes, $50\ \text{cm}$ and $51\ \text{cm}$ long, sound their fundamentals together. Find the beat frequency.
  • 5 Two identical strings are both tuned to $300\ \text{Hz}$. The tension in one is increased by $2\%$. How many beats per second are heard when both sound their fundamentals?
  • 6 A string $1.5\ \text{m}$ long, fixed at both ends, vibrates in four loops at $120\ \text{Hz}$. Find the speed of waves on it.
  • 7 Why can we not hear beats between a $256\ \text{Hz}$ fork and a $300\ \text{Hz}$ fork?
  • 8 A wire $1.0\ \text{m}$ long with linear mass density $1.0\ \text{g/m}$, vibrating in its fundamental mode, is in unison with the fundamental of a $25\ \text{cm}$ pipe closed at one end. Find the tension in the wire.
1 $\nu_\text{beat}=4\ \text{Hz}$; maxima every $0.25\ \text{s}$.
2 $\nu_P=406$ or $394\ \text{Hz}$. Wax lowers $\nu_P$; the beats fall only if $\nu_P$ moves towards $400$, so $\nu_P=406\ \text{Hz}$ (after loading, $404\ \text{Hz}$).
3 $\nu_\text{wire}=K/L$. The $95\ \text{cm}$ wire is $5\ \text{Hz}$ above the fork and the $100\ \text{cm}$ wire $5\ \text{Hz}$ below: $K\left(\dfrac{1}{0.95}-\dfrac{1}{1.00}\right)=10$, $K=190\ \text{Hz m}$, so $\nu=\dfrac{190}{1.00}+5=195\ \text{Hz}$.
4 $\dfrac{340}{1.00}-\dfrac{340}{1.02}=340-333.3=6.67\ \text{beats/s}$.
5 $\nu'=300\sqrt{1.02}=303.0\ \text{Hz}$: about $3$ beats per second (to first order, $300\times\tfrac12\times2\%=3$).
6 Four loops: $L=4\cdot\dfrac{\lambda}{2}$, $\lambda=0.75\ \text{m}$; $v=120\times0.75=90\ \text{m/s}$.
7 The difference is $44\ \text{Hz}$: the loudness would rise and fall $44$ times a second, far too fast for the ear to follow as beats (the limit is about $10$ per second). We hear two separate notes.
8 Pipe: $\nu=\dfrac{340}{4\times0.25}=340\ \text{Hz}$. Wire: $v=2L\nu=680\ \text{m/s}$, so $T=\mu v^2=1.0\times10^{-3}\times680^2=462\ \text{N}$.
๐ŸŽฏ Exam corner NEET ยท MCQ

E1. NEET ยท MCQ The fundamental frequency of a pipe closed at one end is $220\ \text{Hz}$. The pipe is held vertically with its closed end at the bottom, and one quarter of its length is filled with water. Neglecting the end correction, the frequency of the first overtone of the pipe is now (A) $880\ \text{Hz}$ (B) $660\ \text{Hz}$ (C) $293\ \text{Hz}$ (D) $440\ \text{Hz}$

New length The water surface acts as the closed end, so the air column is a closed pipe of length $\tfrac34L$. Its fundamental is $\dfrac{v}{4\left(\tfrac34L\right)}=\dfrac43\times220=293.3\ \text{Hz}$ (Result 10.25).
Overtone A closed pipe has only odd harmonics, so its first overtone is the third harmonic: $3\times293.3=880\ \text{Hz}$.
Answer (A) $880\ \text{Hz}$.
โฑ Shortcut (B) is the first overtone of the original pipe, $3\times220$; (C) is the new fundamental; (D) is $2\times220$, a second harmonic, which a closed pipe cannot produce at all. Every natural frequency of the new column is an odd multiple of $293.3\ \text{Hz}$, and only (A) is one besides the fundamental.

E2. NEET ยท MCQ Statement I: In a standing wave on a string, all the particles between two adjacent nodes vibrate in phase. Statement II: A standing wave on a string carries energy along the string from one end to the other. In the light of these statements, choose the correct option. (A) Both Statement I and Statement II are correct (B) Both Statement I and Statement II are incorrect (C) Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect (D) Statement I is incorrect but Statement II is correct

Statement I In $y=2a\sin kx\cos\omega t$ every particle moves as $\cos\omega t$; within one loop $\sin kx$ keeps its sign, so they all reach their extremes together (Result 10.23). Correct.
Statement II The nodes never move, so no work is done across them and no energy is transported past them; the energy only surges back and forth within each loop (Definition 10.11). Incorrect.
Answer (C).
โฑ Shortcut "Standing" means the pattern โ€” and the energy โ€” stays put. Energy transport belongs to progressive waves.

E3. NEET ยท MCQ Assertion (A): The first overtone of a pipe closed at one end is its second harmonic. Reason (R): A pipe closed at one end produces only the odd harmonics of its fundamental frequency. Choose the correct option. (A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A (B) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A (C) A is true but R is false (D) A is false but R is true

Reason With a node at the closed end and an antinode at the open end, $L=(2n-1)\tfrac{\lambda}{4}$, so only $\nu_1,3\nu_1,5\nu_1,\dots$ occur (Result 10.25). True.
Assertion The first frequency above the fundamental is therefore $3\nu_1$, the third harmonic (Definition 10.12); the second harmonic does not exist for this pipe. False.
Answer (D).
โฑ Shortcut "First overtone = second harmonic" is true for strings and open pipes only. The reason itself rules it out for a closed pipe.

E4. NEET ยท MCQ Match each mode of vibration in List-I with its wavelength in List-II ($L$ is the length of the string or pipe; end corrections neglected).
List-I: (a) a string fixed at both ends, third harmonic (b) an open pipe, second harmonic (c) a closed pipe, first overtone (d) a closed pipe, fundamental
List-II: (i) $4L$ (ii) $\dfrac{4L}{3}$ (iii) $\dfrac{2L}{3}$ (iv) $L$
Choose the correct answer: (A) a-iii, b-iv, c-i, d-ii (B) a-iii, b-iv, c-ii, d-i (C) a-iv, b-iii, c-ii, d-i (D) a-ii, b-iv, c-iii, d-i

Match (a) $L=3\cdot\tfrac{\lambda}{2}$, $\lambda=\tfrac{2L}{3}$ โ€” iii (Result 10.24). (b) $L=2\cdot\tfrac{\lambda}{2}$, $\lambda=L$ โ€” iv. (c) The first overtone is the third harmonic: $L=\tfrac{3\lambda}{4}$, $\lambda=\tfrac{4L}{3}$ โ€” ii. (d) $L=\tfrac{\lambda}{4}$, $\lambda=4L$ โ€” i (Result 10.25).
Answer (B) a-iii, b-iv, c-ii, d-i.
โฑ Shortcut The closed-pipe fundamental is the longest wavelength of all, $4L$: d-i removes (A). The string's third harmonic has three loops of $\tfrac{\lambda}{2}$: a-iii removes (C) and (D).

E5. NEET ยท MCQ The figure shows the displacement envelope of a standing wave in a pipe $85\ \text{cm}$ long, closed at its left end (N: displacement node, A: displacement antinode). The speed of sound is $340\ \text{m/s}$ and the end correction is negligible. The frequency of this mode, and its name, are (A) $500\ \text{Hz}$, the second overtone (B) $500\ \text{Hz}$, the fifth overtone (C) $400\ \text{Hz}$, the fourth harmonic (D) $300\ \text{Hz}$, the first overtone
NNNAAAclosed endopen endL = 85 cm

Count From the closed end to the open end there are five node-to-antinode stretches, each $\tfrac{\lambda}{4}$: $L=\dfrac{5\lambda}{4}$, so $\lambda=\dfrac{4\times0.85}{5}=0.68\ \text{m}$.
Frequency $\nu=\dfrac{v}{\lambda}=\dfrac{340}{0.68}=500\ \text{Hz}=5\times\dfrac{v}{4L}$ โ€” the fifth harmonic. The closed pipe's natural frequencies are $100,\ 300,\ 500,\dots\ \text{Hz}$, so $500\ \text{Hz}$ is the second frequency above the fundamental: the second overtone (Definition 10.12).
Answer (A).
โฑ Shortcut A closed pipe has no fourth harmonic, so (C) is impossible. "Fifth harmonic" is not "fifth overtone": for a closed pipe the $(2n-1)$-th harmonic is the $(n-1)$-th overtone.

E6. NEET ยท MCQ How many of the following statements are correct?
(i) The beat frequency of two sounds equals the difference of their frequencies.
(ii) Loading a prong of a tuning fork with a little wax increases its frequency.
(iii) A string fixed at both ends can vibrate at every whole-number multiple of its fundamental frequency.
(iv) The open ends of an organ pipe are displacement nodes.
(v) A wave reflected from a rigid boundary undergoes a phase change of $\pi$.
(A) Two (B) Three (C) Four (D) Five

Check each (i) โœ“ โ€” $\nu_\text{beat}=|\nu_1-\nu_2|$ (Result 10.26). (ii) โœ— โ€” the extra mass makes the prong vibrate more slowly; wax lowers the frequency. (iii) โœ“ โ€” $\nu_n=n\nu_1$, $n=1,2,3,\dots$ (Result 10.24). (iv) โœ— โ€” the air moves most at an open end: it is a displacement antinode (and a pressure node). (v) โœ“ โ€” the reflected wave is inverted (Result 10.22).
Answer (B) three statements: (i), (iii) and (v).
โฑ Shortcut Remember the pairs: wax down, filing up; closed end node, open end antinode; rigid end inverts, free end does not.
๐Ÿ”ฌ Researchโ€“Teaching NexusResearch-tutored ยท optional, about 60 minutes

Research question. Is the end correction of an open pipe really about $0.3$ times its diameter, and does it matter for the notes a pipe plays?

Why it matters. Organ builders, flute and bansuri makers and the designers of bass-reflex loudspeaker ports all tune air columns. A pipe sounds flat compared with $v/4L$ because the vibrating air extends beyond its end, and in a short, wide pipe the error is large. The same end correction limits the accuracy of the resonance-tube measurement of the speed of sound โ€” one of the experiments in the NEET list of experimental skills (Chapter 20).

What to do.

  1. Collect three or four plastic pipes of different internal diameters ($1$โ€“$5\ \text{cm}$), each about $50\ \text{cm}$ long, and a tall bucket or measuring cylinder of water.
  2. Use a phone tone-generator app at a fixed frequency (say $500\ \text{Hz}$) held just above the pipe. Lower the pipe into the water until the sound is loudest (first resonance), and measure the air column $l_1$; raise it to find the second resonance $l_2$.
  3. For each pipe find $\lambda=2(l_2-l_1)$, $v=\nu\lambda$ and $e=\tfrac12(l_2-3l_1)$. Measure the air temperature and compare $v$ with $332\sqrt{T/273}\ \text{m/s}$.
  4. Plot $e$ against the diameter $d$. Is it a straight line through the origin, and what is its slope?
  5. Repeat one pipe at two other frequencies to see whether $e$ depends on frequency.

Tools: Plastic pipes, vernier callipers or a ruler for the diameters, metre scale, bucket of water, smartphone with tone-generator (and a sound-level meter app, if available, to find the loudest point).

Hand in: A table of $d$, $l_1$, $l_2$, $\lambda$, $v$ and $e$ for every pipe; the graph of $e$ against $d$ with its slope; a paragraph comparing your slope with $0.3$ and explaining why using $l_2-l_1$ gives a better $v$ than $4l_1$.

Going further. Theory for a pipe with a wide flange at its mouth gives a larger correction (about $0.82r$) than for an unflanged pipe ($0.61r$). Fit a cardboard collar round the top of one pipe and see whether $e$ increases.

Instructor note: expect $e/d$ between about $0.25$ and $0.35$; the loudest point is broad, so ask students to approach it from both sides and average. Phone speakers are not point sources โ€” holding the phone a few centimetres above the mouth and keeping that height fixed matters more than the exact frequency. The speed of sound usually comes out within $1$โ€“$2\%$ of the value from the temperature.

๐Ÿงช Self-check quiz

0/5 correct

Q1. In a standing wave, the distance between two consecutive nodes is $20\ \text{cm}$. The wavelength of the waves that form it is

Q2. A pipe closed at one end can produce

Q3. A tuning fork X gives $4$ beats per second with a fork of $256\ \text{Hz}$. When a prong of X is loaded with a little wax, the beats fall to $2$ per second. The frequency of X before loading was

Q4. A string fixed at both ends vibrates in four loops. The numbers of nodes (counting both ends) and of antinodes are

Q5. The fundamental frequency of an open pipe is $300\ \text{Hz}$. If one end of the pipe is closed, its fundamental frequency becomes (end corrections neglected)