Chapter 17 · Dual Nature of Matter and Radiation

17.1 The Photoelectric Effect

Light falling on a clean metal can knock electrons out of it — but only if its frequency is above a threshold, however bright it is, and the fastest electrons get faster with frequency, not with brightness. Einstein explained it with one equation, $h\nu=\phi_0+K_{\max}$: light arrives in packets, photons, of energy $h\nu$ and momentum $h/\lambda$.

An automatic door that opens when you break a beam, the light meter in a camera, the "night-vision" tube that turns a few stray photons into a visible image, and the detectors that count single flashes of light in a hospital PET scanner all rely on the same fact: light can knock electrons out of a material. That fact, discovered almost by accident at the end of the nineteenth century, turned out to be one of the most important clues in the history of physics. Every detail of it contradicted the wave theory of light, which had just triumphed with Maxwell's electromagnetic waves and Young's interference fringes.

The way out, proposed by Einstein in 1905, was startling: light is a wave when it travels and interferes, but it gives and takes energy in indivisible packets — photons — each of energy $h\nu$. This is the dual nature of radiation. In this section we meet the work function that holds electrons inside a metal, follow the experiments of Hertz and Lenard, set out the experimental laws of the photoelectric effect and see why the wave picture cannot explain them, derive Einstein's photoelectric equation and the straight-line graph of stopping potential against frequency, and finish with the photon itself — its energy, its momentum, and how many of them a lamp or a laser sends out each second. In NEET this section is a dependable source of quick marks: the stopping potential or threshold wavelength worked out with $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$, what a change of intensity or of frequency does (and does not do), photocurrent–voltage curves and the $V_0$–$\nu$ graph to be read, the number of photons a source emits, and statements about the photoelectric effect to be judged true or false.

Electron emission and the discovery of the photoelectric effect

A metal contains a huge number of free electrons — roughly one or two per atom — that wander through the crystal lattice and carry electric current. They do not normally leave the metal, because at the surface they meet an energy barrier: once an electron starts to leave, the positive ions it leaves behind pull it back. To get an electron out, we must supply it with at least a certain minimum energy.

📘 Definition 17.1 — Work function

The work function $\phi_0$ of a metal is the minimum energy that must be given to an electron to remove it from the surface of the metal (so that it is just free, with no kinetic energy left over).

It depends on the metal and on the condition of its surface (cleanliness, oxide layers). It is usually quoted in electron volts: $1\ \text{eV}=1.6\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}$, the energy an electron gains in falling through a potential difference of $1\ \text{V}$ (Section 11.3).

Some typical values: caesium $2.14\ \text{eV}$, potassium $2.30\ \text{eV}$, sodium $2.75\ \text{eV}$, calcium $3.20\ \text{eV}$, zinc $4.30\ \text{eV}$, copper $4.65\ \text{eV}$, nickel $5.15\ \text{eV}$, platinum $5.65\ \text{eV}$. The alkali metals (caesium, potassium, sodium) have the smallest work functions — their single outer electron is loosely held.

The energy to free an electron can be supplied in three ways. In thermionic emission, heating the metal (as in the filament of an old radio valve or an X-ray tube) gives some electrons enough thermal energy to escape. In field emission, a very strong electric field (about $10^8\ \text{V/m}$) pulls electrons out of a sharp metal point. In photoelectric emission, the energy comes from light (or other electromagnetic radiation) falling on the surface.

Hertz's observation (1887). While producing and detecting electromagnetic waves with spark gaps, Heinrich Hertz noticed that a spark jumped across a detector gap more easily when the gap was lit by ultraviolet light from the main spark. Shielding the gap with glass, which absorbs ultraviolet, made sparking harder. Something about ultraviolet light helped charges leave the metal electrodes — but Hertz did not pursue it.

Hallwachs and Lenard (1888–1902). Wilhelm Hallwachs showed that a clean, negatively charged zinc plate lost its charge when ultraviolet light fell on it, while a positively charged plate did not; an uncharged plate became positive. So the light was driving negative charges out of the metal. Philipp Lenard put two electrodes in an evacuated glass tube with a quartz window (quartz lets ultraviolet through) and found that when ultraviolet light fell on the negative plate, a current flowed round the circuit, though the plates were separated by vacuum. The current stopped the instant the light was cut off. By deflecting the emitted particles in electric and magnetic fields, Lenard showed that they had the same charge-to-mass ratio as the electrons J. J. Thomson had just discovered. He also found that some metals (zinc, cadmium, magnesium) respond only to ultraviolet, while the alkali metals respond even to visible light.

📘 Definition 17.2 — Photoelectric effect

The photoelectric effect is the emission of electrons from the surface of a material (usually a metal) when electromagnetic radiation of suitable frequency falls on it. The emitted electrons are called photoelectrons, and the current they carry in a circuit is the photocurrent.

✏️ Example 1 — Work function and threshold of potassium
The work function of potassium is $2.30\ \text{eV}$. (a) Express it in joules. (b) Find the lowest frequency of light that can release electrons from potassium, and the corresponding wavelength. (c) Will red light of wavelength $600\ \text{nm}$ release electrons? Will blue light of $450\ \text{nm}$? Take $h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$ and $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$.
(a) $\phi_0=2.30\times1.6\times10^{-19}=3.68\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}$.
(b) A photon must bring at least $\phi_0$ (we justify this in Law 17.2): $\nu_0=\dfrac{\phi_0}{h}=\dfrac{3.68\times10^{-19}}{6.63\times10^{-34}}=5.55\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$, and $\lambda_0=\dfrac{hc}{\phi_0}=\dfrac{1240}{2.30}=539\ \text{nm}$ (green light).
(c) Photon energies: $\dfrac{1240}{600}=2.07\ \text{eV}\lt2.30\ \text{eV}$ — no emission, however bright the red light. $\dfrac{1240}{450}=2.76\ \text{eV}\gt2.30\ \text{eV}$ — electrons are emitted.
⏱ Shortcut Compare wavelengths directly: emission happens only for $\lambda\lt\lambda_0=539\ \text{nm}$. $600\gt539$ (no), $450\lt539$ (yes).

The work function of zinc is $4.30\ \text{eV}$ and that of caesium is $2.14\ \text{eV}$. Which statement is correct?

Experimental laws of photoelectric emission

The standard apparatus is an evacuated glass tube with a quartz window. Inside are a photosensitive plate $C$ (the emitter, or cathode) and a collector plate $A$ (the anode). A battery with a potential divider and a reversing switch lets us set the potential $V$ of the collector relative to the emitter to any value, positive or negative; a sensitive microammeter reads the photocurrent. Monochromatic light, whose frequency $\nu$ and intensity (power per unit area) can be changed separately, falls on the emitter. Three experiments tell the whole story.

1. Effect of intensity. Keep the frequency fixed (above a certain value) and the collector positive. The photocurrent is directly proportional to the intensity of the light. More light means more electrons emitted per second.

2. Effect of the collector potential. Keep frequency and intensity fixed and vary $V$. As $V$ is made more positive, the current rises and then levels off: once every emitted electron is being collected, no further increase in $V$ can increase the current. If $V$ is made negative, the collector repels the electrons. Only those that leave with enough kinetic energy to climb the potential hill reach it, and the current falls. At a particular negative potential $-V_0$ the current becomes zero: even the fastest electrons are turned back.

📘 Definition 17.3 — Saturation current and stopping potential

The saturation current is the largest photocurrent for a given light beam, reached when the collector is positive enough to collect every emitted electron. If $n$ electrons are emitted per second, $I_\text{sat}=ne$.

The stopping potential (cut-off potential) $V_0$ is the magnitude of the negative collector potential at which the photocurrent just becomes zero. It measures the maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons:

$$K_{\max}=\tfrac12mv_{\max}^2=eV_0 .$$

When the experiment is repeated with a brighter beam of the same frequency, the saturation current is larger, but the current falls to zero at the same stopping potential $V_0$. The curves for different intensities meet on the voltage axis. So the maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons does not depend on the intensity.

3. Effect of frequency. Keep the intensity fixed and repeat with light of different frequencies. The higher the frequency, the larger the stopping potential: the fastest electrons come out faster. Plotting $V_0$ against $\nu$ gives a straight line, and it meets the frequency axis at a definite frequency $\nu_0$. Below $\nu_0$ there is no photoelectric emission at all, however intense the light and however long it shines.

📘 Definition 17.4 — Threshold frequency and threshold wavelength

The threshold frequency $\nu_0$ of a metal is the minimum frequency of incident radiation that can cause photoelectric emission from it. The corresponding threshold wavelength $\lambda_0=c/\nu_0$ is the maximum wavelength that can cause emission. Both are properties of the metal (they differ from metal to metal).

📐 Result 17.1 — Laws of photoelectric emission
  1. For a given metal there is a threshold frequency $\nu_0$; light of frequency $\nu\lt\nu_0$ emits no electrons, whatever its intensity.
  2. For $\nu\gt\nu_0$, the photocurrent (number of electrons emitted per second) is proportional to the intensity of the light.
  3. The maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons, $K_{\max}=eV_0$, is independent of the intensity; it increases linearly with the frequency of the light.
  4. Emission is instantaneous: electrons appear within about $10^{-9}\ \text{s}$ of the light being switched on, even when the light is extremely faint.

Why the wave theory fails. In the wave picture, light is a continuous electromagnetic wave whose energy is spread uniformly over the wavefront and is proportional to the intensity (the square of the amplitude); the frequency is irrelevant to the energy delivered. Then: (i) a bright enough beam of any frequency should eventually shake electrons loose — so there should be no threshold frequency; (ii) a more intense wave should shake the electrons harder and give them more kinetic energy — so $K_{\max}$ should grow with intensity; (iii) in very faint light, an electron, which can only soak up energy falling on a region about the size of an atom, would need a long time to collect enough — so there should be a measurable time lag. All three predictions are wrong (Example 3). The wave picture explains the travel of light — interference and diffraction (Section 16.4) — but not the way light hands its energy to an electron.

✏️ Example 2 — Reading a photocell experiment
In a photocell, monochromatic light gives a saturation current of $3.2\ \mu\text{A}$ and a stopping potential of $1.5\ \text{V}$. (a) How many electrons leave the emitter per second? (b) Find the maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons in eV and in J, and their maximum speed ($m_e=9.1\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}$). (c) The intensity of the light is doubled, its frequency unchanged. State the new saturation current and stopping potential. (d) With the original light, what is the largest kinetic energy with which an electron reaches the collector when the collector is at $+2.0\ \text{V}$? At $-1.0\ \text{V}$?
(a) $n=\dfrac{I_\text{sat}}{e}=\dfrac{3.2\times10^{-6}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}=2.0\times10^{13}$ electrons per second.
(b) $K_{\max}=eV_0=1.5\ \text{eV}=1.5\times1.6\times10^{-19}=2.4\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}$. $v_{\max}=\sqrt{\dfrac{2K_{\max}}{m_e}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{4.8\times10^{-19}}{9.1\times10^{-31}}}=7.26\times10^{5}\ \text{m/s}$.
(c) Twice as many electrons per second: $I_\text{sat}=6.4\ \mu\text{A}$. The frequency is unchanged, so $V_0$ stays $1.5\ \text{V}$.
(d) Between emitter and collector an electron gains $e\times(\text{collector potential})$. At $+2.0\ \text{V}$: $1.5+2.0=3.5\ \text{eV}$. At $-1.0\ \text{V}$: $1.5-1.0=0.5\ \text{eV}$ (only electrons that left with more than $1.0\ \text{eV}$ arrive at all).
Check $v_{\max}$ is a few hundred km/s — far below the speed of light, so $\tfrac12mv^2$ is fine.
✏️ Example 3 — How long would a wave take?
Faint light of intensity $1.0\ \text{W/m}^2$ falls on sodium (work function $2.75\ \text{eV}$). Treat the light as a classical wave, and suppose an electron can absorb all the energy falling on a circle of radius $0.10\ \text{nm}$ (about the size of an atom). Estimate how long the electron would need to gather enough energy to escape, and compare with experiment.
Area $A=\pi r^2=\pi(1.0\times10^{-10})^2=3.14\times10^{-20}\ \text{m}^2$.
Power Power collected $=IA=1.0\times3.14\times10^{-20}=3.14\times10^{-20}\ \text{W}$.
Time Energy needed $2.75\times1.6\times10^{-19}=4.40\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}$, so $t=\dfrac{4.40\times10^{-19}}{3.14\times10^{-20}}=14\ \text{s}$.
Compare Experiment: electrons appear within $10^{-9}\ \text{s}$, and in still fainter light the first electrons still appear at once (only fewer of them). Energy is not delivered as a thin continuous trickle but in lumps, each big enough to free an electron immediately.

In Interactive 1 choose sodium, wavelength $400\ \text{nm}$ and intensity $50\%$. The stopping potential reads $0.35\ \text{V}$. Predict what happens when you raise the intensity to $100\%$.

At $400\ \text{nm}$ the readouts show $h\nu=3.10\ \text{eV}$, $K_{\max}=3.10-2.75=0.35\ \text{eV}$ and $V_0=0.35\ \text{V}$. At $100\%$ the saturation current goes from $4.0\ \mu\text{A}$ to $8.0\ \mu\text{A}$, but the curve still meets the axis at $-0.35\ \text{V}$: twice as many photons, each with the same energy. Now drag the wavelength to $300\ \text{nm}$: $h\nu=4.13\ \text{eV}$ and $V_0$ jumps to $1.38\ \text{V}$ — frequency, not intensity, sets the stopping potential. Above $451\ \text{nm}$ sodium emits nothing at any intensity.
Interactive 1 — Photocell Lab: Current Against Collector Potential

Light falls on the emitter (left plate) of a photocell. Choose the metal, the wavelength and the intensity, and set the potential of the collector (right plate). Press Play to watch the photoelectrons: with the collector negative, the slower ones turn back. The graph is the photocurrent $I$ against the collector potential $V$; the dot is your setting and the dashed line marks $-V_0$.

400 nm50%+1.00 V
photon energy $h\nu$—
$K_{\max}$—
stopping potential $V_0$—
current at $V$—

Two photocurrent–collector potential curves are drawn for the same emitter. Curve P has a larger saturation current than curve Q, but both meet the voltage axis at the same point. Which is true?

Einstein's photoelectric equation

In 1900 Max Planck had found that he could explain the spectrum of radiation from hot bodies only by assuming that the walls of the hot body exchange energy with the radiation in whole multiples of $h\nu$, where $h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$ is a new constant of nature, now called Planck's constant. In 1905 Einstein went much further: radiation itself is made of separate quanta of energy $h\nu$. A beam of light of frequency $\nu$ is a stream of these quanta — later named photons. A brighter beam of the same colour carries more photons per second, not bigger ones.

In the photoelectric effect one photon gives all its energy to one electron, in a single event; there is no gradual build-up. Part of the energy, at least $\phi_0$, is used to get the electron out of the metal; whatever is left becomes its kinetic energy. Electrons that start below the surface lose some extra energy on their way out, so they emerge slower. The fastest electrons are those that needed only the minimum, $\phi_0$.

📐 Law 17.2 — Einstein's photoelectric equation

When radiation of frequency $\nu$ falls on a metal of work function $\phi_0$, the maximum kinetic energy of the emitted photoelectrons is

$$K_{\max}=h\nu-\phi_0,$$

which, with $K_{\max}=eV_0$ and $\phi_0=h\nu_0$, may also be written

$$eV_0=h\nu-\phi_0=h(\nu-\nu_0).$$

Emission occurs only if $h\nu\ge\phi_0$, i.e. $\nu\ge\nu_0=\phi_0/h$ or $\lambda\le\lambda_0=hc/\phi_0$. In terms of wavelength, $K_{\max}=hc\left(\dfrac1\lambda-\dfrac1{\lambda_0}\right)$. A useful number: $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$, so a photon of wavelength $\lambda$ (in nm) has energy $1240/\lambda$ eV.

Every law of Result 17.1 now follows at once. (1) If $h\nu\lt\phi_0$, no single photon can free an electron, and a photon cannot "wait" for a second one — so there is a threshold, whatever the intensity. (2) The intensity fixes the number of photons arriving per second, hence the number of electrons emitted per second, hence the current. (3) $K_{\max}=h\nu-\phi_0$ depends on $\nu$ and the metal, not on how many photons arrive. (4) Each event is a single collision-like absorption, so emission starts at once.

📐 Result 17.3 — The stopping potential against frequency

Dividing Einstein's equation by $e$,

$$V_0=\frac{h}{e}\,\nu-\frac{\phi_0}{e}.$$

The graph of $V_0$ against $\nu$ is a straight line of slope $h/e$ — the same for every metal ($4.14\times10^{-15}\ \text{V s}$) — meeting the $\nu$-axis at the threshold frequency $\nu_0$ and, if extended backwards, the $V_0$-axis at $-\phi_0/e$. Lines for different metals are parallel. (A graph of $K_{\max}$ against $\nu$ has slope $h$ and intercept $-\phi_0$.)

Einstein's equation was a bold prediction, and many physicists — including Robert Millikan — expected it to fail. Between 1906 and 1916 Millikan measured stopping potentials for sodium and other metals at many frequencies with great care. He found a straight line exactly as predicted, and its slope gave a value of $h$ that agreed with Planck's to within about $0.5\%$. Einstein received the 1921 Nobel Prize for this law, and Millikan the 1923 prize partly for confirming it.

🧭 Problem-solving strategy — Photoelectric calculations
  1. Work in electron volts: photon energy $E=\dfrac{1240}{\lambda(\text{nm})}\ \text{eV}$, and then $K_{\max}$ in eV is numerically equal to $V_0$ in volts.
  2. Check the threshold first: if $h\nu\lt\phi_0$ (or $\lambda\gt\lambda_0$) there is no emission, and $K_{\max}$, $V_0$ and the current are all zero.
  3. Intensity questions: intensity changes the number of photons (and the current), never $K_{\max}$ or $V_0$.
  4. Two sets of data on the same metal: write Einstein's equation twice and subtract — $\phi_0$ cancels, and $h$ (or a ratio) comes out.
  5. Convert to joules only at the end, for speeds ($v=\sqrt{2K/m}$) or SI answers.
✏️ Example 4 — Measuring Planck's constant
A metal surface is lit first with light of frequency $6.0\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$, giving a stopping potential of $0.49\ \text{V}$, and then with light of frequency $8.0\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$, giving $1.32\ \text{V}$. Using $e=1.6\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}$, find (a) Planck's constant, (b) the work function of the metal in eV, (c) its threshold frequency.
Find Planck's constant from these two measurements:
(a) $eV_1=h\nu_1-\phi_0$ and $eV_2=h\nu_2-\phi_0$. Subtracting, $h=\dfrac{e(V_2-V_1)}{\nu_2-\nu_1}=\dfrac{1.6\times10^{-19}\times0.83}{2.0\times10^{14}}=6.64\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$.
(b) $\phi_0=h\nu_1-eV_1$. In eV: $\dfrac{h\nu_1}{e}=\dfrac{6.64\times10^{-34}\times6.0\times10^{14}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}=2.49\ \text{eV}$, so $\phi_0=2.49-0.49=2.00\ \text{eV}$.
(c) $\nu_0=\dfrac{\phi_0}{h}=\dfrac{2.00\times1.6\times10^{-19}}{6.64\times10^{-34}}=4.82\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$.
Check With these values the second measurement gives $\dfrac{6.64\times10^{-34}\times8.0\times10^{14}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}-2.00=3.32-2.00=1.32\ \text{V}$ ✓. This is Millikan's method: the slope of the $V_0$–$\nu$ line is $h/e$.
✏️ Example 5 — Two wavelengths, one metal
Light of wavelength $250\ \text{nm}$ and then light of wavelength $400\ \text{nm}$ falls on the same metal. The maximum speed of the photoelectrons in the first case is twice that in the second. Find (a) the work function of the metal, (b) the stopping potential in each case, (c) the threshold wavelength. Use $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$.
Find the work function before you open the solution:
Energies $E_1=\dfrac{1240}{250}=4.96\ \text{eV}$, $E_2=\dfrac{1240}{400}=3.10\ \text{eV}$.
(a) $v_1=2v_2\Rightarrow K_1=4K_2$: $4.96-\phi_0=4(3.10-\phi_0)$, so $3\phi_0=12.40-4.96=7.44$ and $\phi_0=2.48\ \text{eV}$.
(b) $V_{0,1}=4.96-2.48=2.48\ \text{V}$; $V_{0,2}=3.10-2.48=0.62\ \text{V}$ (and indeed $2.48=4\times0.62$ ✓).
(c) $\lambda_0=\dfrac{1240}{2.48}=500\ \text{nm}$.
⏱ Shortcut Speeds compare as $\sqrt{K}$: a speed ratio $k$ means a kinetic-energy (and stopping-potential) ratio $k^2$. Never set $hc/\lambda_1-\phi_0=2(hc/\lambda_2-\phi_0)$ for a speed ratio of 2.

In Interactive 2 set the frequency to $10\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$. Which of the four metals emit electrons, and what is the stopping potential for sodium?

At $\nu=10\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$ the readout shows $h\nu=4.14\ \text{eV}$. Sodium (threshold $6.64\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$) gives $V_0=4.14-2.75=1.39\ \text{V}$; potassium $1.84\ \text{V}$; caesium $2.00\ \text{V}$. Zinc needs $\nu_0=10.4\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$, so at this frequency it gives nothing. All the lines have the same slope, $h/e=4.14\times10^{-15}\ \text{V s}$, and their dashed extensions meet the $V_0$-axis at $-\phi_0/e$. ($4.14\ \text{V}$ forgets to subtract the work function; intensity plays no part in this graph.)
Interactive 2 — Millikan's Graph: Stopping Potential Against Frequency

The four straight lines are $V_0=(h/e)\nu-\phi_0/e$ for caesium, potassium, sodium and zinc; each is solid above its threshold and dashed below it, down to its intercept $-\phi_0/e$. Move the frequency slider (or press Play to sweep it) and read off the stopping potential for the chosen metal. The highlighted triangle shows the common slope $h/e$.

10.0 × 10¹⁴ Hz
photon energy $h\nu$—
threshold $\nu_0$—
stopping potential $V_0$—
slope $h/e$—

For a given metal, a graph of the maximum kinetic energy $K_{\max}$ of the photoelectrons (vertical) against the frequency $\nu$ of the light (horizontal) is

Photons: the particle nature of light

Einstein's quanta behave in every way like particles that carry energy and momentum. Later experiments confirmed it directly: in 1923 Arthur Compton found that X-rays scattered by electrons come out with a longer wavelength, exactly as if each X-ray photon had bounced off an electron like a billiard ball, sharing its energy and momentum. Today single photons are routinely counted by photomultipliers and camera sensors.

📘 Definition 17.5 — Photon

A photon is a quantum of electromagnetic radiation: an elementary packet of energy and momentum. For radiation of frequency $\nu$ and wavelength $\lambda$ (in vacuum), each photon has

$$E=h\nu=\frac{hc}{\lambda},\qquad p=\frac{E}{c}=\frac{h}{\lambda}=\frac{h\nu}{c}.$$

Photons travel at speed $c$ in vacuum, have zero rest mass, are electrically neutral (so electric and magnetic fields do not deflect them), and can be created (emitted) and destroyed (absorbed) — their number is not conserved. In a collision with an electron, the total energy and the total momentum are conserved.

Note that $p=E/c$ for a photon, not $p=\sqrt{2mE}$: that formula is for slow particles with mass. The energy of a beam is shared out among its photons, so the photon picture gives a direct link between the power of a source and the number of photons it emits.

📐 Result 17.4 — Photon flux and the force exerted by light

A source emitting monochromatic radiation of power $P$ and wavelength $\lambda$ sends out

$$N=\frac{P}{h\nu}=\frac{P\lambda}{hc}\quad\text{photons per second.}$$

A beam of intensity $I$ (W/m²) carries a photon flux $\Phi=\dfrac{I}{h\nu}$ photons per square metre per second. For a point source radiating equally in all directions, at distance $r$: $I=\dfrac{P}{4\pi r^2}$.

A beam of power $P$ falling normally on a surface delivers momentum $N\times\dfrac{h}{\lambda}=\dfrac{P}{c}$ per second, so it exerts a force

$$F=\frac{P}{c}\ \ \text{(perfect absorber)},\qquad F=\frac{2P}{c}\ \ \text{(perfect reflector)},$$

since a reflected photon's momentum is reversed (change $2h/\lambda$). The corresponding pressures are $I/c$ and $2I/c$.

In a photocell, not every photon releases an electron: the fraction that do is the quantum efficiency $\eta$ (often a few per cent for a metal surface). Then the saturation current is $I_\text{sat}=\eta Ne$. This gives the fifth trap of the photoelectric effect: if the power of a beam is fixed and its frequency is raised, each photon carries more energy, so there are fewer photons per second and the saturation current falls, even though $V_0$ rises.

The dual nature of radiation. Light shows interference and diffraction — it spreads, adds and cancels like a wave — and it also hands over energy and momentum in lumps like a stream of particles. Neither picture alone describes everything. The wave picture tells us where light is likely to arrive (the intensity pattern); the photon picture tells us how it arrives (one quantum at a time). In a double-slit experiment with very faint light, single photons land one by one at seemingly random points, yet after many thousands of them the familiar fringes build up. The two descriptions are complementary; in Section 17.2 we see that the same is true of electrons and other particles.

✏️ Example 6 — Counting the photons in a laser beam
A blue laser of power $2.0\ \text{mW}$ emits light of wavelength $450\ \text{nm}$. Find (a) the energy of each photon in J and in eV, (b) the number of photons emitted per second, (c) the momentum of each photon and the force the beam exerts on a black screen that absorbs it completely. (d) The beam falls on a caesium emitter ($\phi_0=2.14\ \text{eV}$). Find the stopping potential and, if $1.0\%$ of the photons release an electron, the saturation current. Take $h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $c=3.0\times10^8\ \text{m/s}$.
Find the number of photons emitted per second:
(a) $E=\dfrac{hc}{\lambda}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}\times3.0\times10^{8}}{450\times10^{-9}}=4.42\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}=2.76\ \text{eV}$.
(b) $N=\dfrac{P}{E}=\dfrac{2.0\times10^{-3}}{4.42\times10^{-19}}=4.52\times10^{15}$ photons per second.
(c) $p=\dfrac{h}{\lambda}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{450\times10^{-9}}=1.47\times10^{-27}\ \text{kg m/s}$. Force on an absorber $F=\dfrac{P}{c}=\dfrac{2.0\times10^{-3}}{3.0\times10^{8}}=6.7\times10^{-12}\ \text{N}$ (check: $Np=4.52\times10^{15}\times1.47\times10^{-27}=6.7\times10^{-12}$ ✓).
(d) $V_0=2.76-2.14=0.62\ \text{V}$. $I_\text{sat}=\eta Ne=0.010\times4.52\times10^{15}\times1.6\times10^{-19}=7.2\times10^{-6}\ \text{A}=7.2\ \mu\text{A}$.
⏱ Shortcut $N=\dfrac{P\lambda}{hc}$, and with $\lambda$ in nm and $P$ in W: $N\approx5.0\times10^{15}\times P\lambda$ ($5.03\times10^{15}\times2.0\times10^{-3}\times450=4.5\times10^{15}$).
✏️ Example 7 — NEET-style: decide before you calculate
(a) Photons of energy $4.0\ \text{eV}$ fall on a metal of work function $2.0\ \text{eV}$. The intensity of the light is then doubled and its wavelength halved. The new stopping potential is (A) $2.0\ \text{V}$ (B) $4.0\ \text{V}$ (C) $6.0\ \text{V}$ (D) $12.0\ \text{V}$.
(b) Lamp A radiates $40\ \text{W}$ of light of wavelength $600\ \text{nm}$ and lamp B radiates $20\ \text{W}$ of light of wavelength $400\ \text{nm}$. The ratio of the numbers of photons they emit per second, $N_A:N_B$, is (A) $1:3$ (B) $2:1$ (C) $3:1$ (D) $4:3$.
(a) What matters The intensity changes only the number of photons, never $V_0$ — so ignore it. Halving the wavelength doubles the photon energy: $h\nu=8.0\ \text{eV}$ (Definition 17.5).
(a) Einstein $eV_0=h\nu-\phi_0=8.0-2.0=6.0\ \text{eV}$, so $V_0=6.0\ \text{V}$ (it was $2.0\ \text{V}$ before).
Answer (a) (C). (A) is the old value — as if nothing that matters had changed; (B) simply doubles the old $V_0$; (D) doubles the photon energy and then doubles again for the intensity.
(b) Photon count $N=\dfrac{P\lambda}{hc}\propto P\lambda$ (Result 17.4): $\dfrac{N_A}{N_B}=\dfrac{40\times600}{20\times400}=\dfrac{24\,000}{8000}=3$.
Answer (b) (C) $3:1$.
⏱ Shortcut (a) Doubling the frequency always more than doubles $V_0$ (the work function is paid only once), so the answer must exceed $2\times2.0=4.0\ \text{V}$ — only (C) and (D) survive, and intensity never counts. (b) Lamp A has twice the power and cheaper (longer-wavelength) photons, so $N_A$ is more than twice $N_B$: only (C) qualifies, with no constants needed.
⚠️ NEET traps

1. What intensity changes, and what it does not. At a fixed frequency, a brighter beam means more photons per second: more photoelectrons and a larger saturation current. It never changes $K_{\max}$, $V_0$, the threshold or the work function. Below the threshold no intensity and no waiting time helps — "a very bright red lamp will eventually eject electrons" is always false.

2. "Same intensity" in graph statements. When photocurrent–voltage curves for different frequencies are drawn "at the same intensity", the intensity means the same number of photons per second, so the curves share one saturation current and differ only in where they meet the voltage axis (higher frequency, larger $V_0$). If a question instead fixes the power in watts, higher-frequency photons carry more energy each, there are fewer of them, and the saturation current is smaller. Read which one is fixed.

3. Doubling is not doubling. $K_{\max}=h\nu-\phi_0$ is a straight line that does not pass through the origin: doubling $\nu$ more than doubles $K_{\max}$ and $V_0$. And $v_{\max}\propto\sqrt{K_{\max}}$ — a speed ratio of $2$ means an energy ratio of $4$.

4. eV, nm and Å. $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}=12\,400\ \text{eV Å}$. A stopping potential is in volts, $K_{\max}$ in electron volts, and the two numbers are equal. Options often differ only by a power of ten (nm against Å, mW against W), so check the unit of every option before you choose.

5. Maximum, not every. Einstein's equation gives the largest kinetic energy. Photoelectrons leave with every energy from zero up to $K_{\max}$, so a statement that "all photoelectrons have the same kinetic energy" is false.

6. Reading the two graphs. $V_0$ against $\nu$: slope $h/e$ for every metal (parallel lines), $\nu$-intercept $\nu_0$, extended intercept $-\phi_0/e$. $K_{\max}$ against $\nu$: slope $h$, intercept $-\phi_0$. In current–voltage curves, the height is set by the intensity and the foot on the negative axis by the frequency.

7. Photon facts. A photon has zero rest mass but momentum $h/\lambda$; it is uncharged, so fields do not deflect it; emission is instantaneous (within about $10^{-9}\ \text{s}$). A perfect reflector feels the force $2P/c$, a perfect absorber $P/c$.

A red lamp ($650\ \text{nm}$) and a violet lamp ($400\ \text{nm}$) each emit $10\ \text{W}$ of light. Which statement is correct?

Exercises

Take $h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $c=3.0\times10^8\ \text{m/s}$, $e=1.6\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}$, $m_e=9.1\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}$ and $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$ unless told otherwise.

I
Photon energy and work function.
  • 1 Find the energy of a photon of wavelength $500\ \text{nm}$ in joules and in electron volts.
  • 2 A photon has energy $3.0\ \text{eV}$. Find its frequency and its wavelength in nm.
  • 3 The work function of tungsten is $4.5\ \text{eV}$. Find its threshold wavelength in nm.
  • 4 The threshold frequency of a metal is $1.2\times10^{15}\ \text{Hz}$. Find its work function in eV.
  • 5 Light of wavelength $400\ \text{nm}$ falls in turn on caesium ($2.14\ \text{eV}$), sodium ($2.75\ \text{eV}$), zinc ($4.30\ \text{eV}$) and copper ($4.65\ \text{eV}$). Which of them emit photoelectrons?
  • 6 Find the momentum of a photon of wavelength $500\ \text{nm}$.
  • 7 Why are caesium and potassium, rather than copper or zinc, used in photocells meant to respond to visible light?
  • 8 Find the energy in eV of a photon from an FM radio station broadcasting at $100\ \text{MHz}$, and explain why radio waves, however strong, cause no photoelectric emission.
1 $E=\dfrac{hc}{\lambda}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}\times3.0\times10^8}{500\times10^{-9}}=3.98\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}=2.49\ \text{eV}$ (with $hc=1240$: $2.48\ \text{eV}$).
2 $\nu=\dfrac{E}{h}=\dfrac{3.0\times1.6\times10^{-19}}{6.63\times10^{-34}}=7.24\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$; $\lambda=\dfrac{c}{\nu}=4.14\times10^{-7}\ \text{m}=414\ \text{nm}$ (or $1240/3.0=413\ \text{nm}$).
3 $\lambda_0=\dfrac{1240}{4.5}=276\ \text{nm}$ (ultraviolet).
4 $\phi_0=h\nu_0=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}\times1.2\times10^{15}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}=4.97\ \text{eV}$.
5 Photon energy $1240/400=3.10\ \text{eV}$. This exceeds $2.14$ and $2.75\ \text{eV}$ but not $4.30$ or $4.65\ \text{eV}$: caesium and sodium emit; zinc and copper do not.
6 $p=\dfrac{h}{\lambda}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{5.0\times10^{-7}}=1.33\times10^{-27}\ \text{kg m/s}$.
7 Their work functions ($2.1$–$2.3\ \text{eV}$) are below the photon energies of visible light ($1.8$–$3.1\ \text{eV}$), so visible light ($\lambda$ up to about $540$–$580\ \text{nm}$) releases electrons. Copper and zinc ($\phi_0\gt4\ \text{eV}$) respond only to ultraviolet.
8 $E=\dfrac{h\nu}{e}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}\times1.0\times10^{8}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}=4.1\times10^{-7}\ \text{eV}$ — about ten million times too small to free an electron. Strong radio waves only mean more of these tiny photons; each electron still absorbs one at a time.
II
Saturation current and stopping potential.
  • 1 The stopping potential for a photocell is $1.8\ \text{V}$. Find the maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons in eV and in J, and their maximum speed.
  • 2 The saturation current in a photocell is $4.8\ \mu\text{A}$. How many electrons leave the emitter each second?
  • 3 The intensity of the light in parts 1–2 is tripled, its frequency unchanged. Give the new saturation current and stopping potential.
  • 4 Sketch the photocurrent against collector potential for (a) two intensities at the same frequency, (b) two frequencies at the same photon flux. Explain the differences.
  • 5 The fastest photoelectrons from a surface move at $6.0\times10^5\ \text{m/s}$. Find the stopping potential.
  • 6 In the photocell of part 1, the collector is at $+2.0\ \text{V}$. Find the largest kinetic energy (in eV) with which electrons reach it.
  • 7 Give two observations of the photoelectric effect that the wave theory of light cannot explain, and say what the wave theory predicts for each.
  • 8 In the photocell of part 1, the collector is at $-1.0\ \text{V}$. Find the largest kinetic energy (in eV) with which electrons reach it.
1 $K_{\max}=1.8\ \text{eV}=2.88\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}$; $v=\sqrt{\dfrac{2\times2.88\times10^{-19}}{9.1\times10^{-31}}}=7.96\times10^{5}\ \text{m/s}$.
2 $n=\dfrac{4.8\times10^{-6}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}=3.0\times10^{13}\ \text{s}^{-1}$.
3 $I_\text{sat}=3\times4.8=14.4\ \mu\text{A}$; $V_0$ unchanged at $1.8\ \text{V}$.
4 (a) Same stopping potential, different saturation currents (higher for higher intensity). (b) Same saturation current (same number of photons, so the same number of electrons) but the higher frequency gives the larger stopping potential — its curve meets the axis further to the left.
5 $V_0=\dfrac{mv^2}{2e}=\dfrac{9.1\times10^{-31}\times(6.0\times10^5)^2}{2\times1.6\times10^{-19}}=1.02\ \text{V}$.
6 The electron gains $2.0\ \text{eV}$ on the way: $1.8+2.0=3.8\ \text{eV}$.
7 (i) A threshold frequency: the wave theory predicts emission at any frequency if the light is intense enough. (ii) $K_{\max}$ independent of intensity: it predicts more energetic electrons in brighter light. (iii) No time lag: it predicts a delay of seconds or more in faint light (Example 3).
8 It loses $1.0\ \text{eV}$: $1.8-1.0=0.8\ \text{eV}$.
III
Einstein's photoelectric equation.
  • 1 Light of wavelength $300\ \text{nm}$ falls on sodium ($\phi_0=2.75\ \text{eV}$). Find the stopping potential.
  • 2 A metal has threshold wavelength $600\ \text{nm}$. Find the maximum kinetic energy (in eV) of photoelectrons released by light of wavelength $400\ \text{nm}$.
  • 3 Light of wavelength $250\ \text{nm}$ gives a stopping potential of $2.0\ \text{V}$. Find the work function and the threshold wavelength.
  • 4 A $V_0$–$\nu$ graph for a metal cuts the frequency axis at $5.0\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$. Find the work function in eV and the stopping potential for light of frequency $8.0\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$.
  • 5 Photons of energy $3.0\ \text{eV}$ release electrons with $K_{\max}=1.0\ \text{eV}$ from a metal. Find $K_{\max}$ (in eV) when photons of twice the frequency are used.
  • 6 Metals A ($\phi_0=2.0\ \text{eV}$) and B ($\phi_0=3.0\ \text{eV}$) are lit by the same ultraviolet light. Compare their stopping potentials, and the slopes and intercepts of their $V_0$–$\nu$ graphs.
  • 7 The wavelength of the light on a photocell is reduced from $400\ \text{nm}$ to $300\ \text{nm}$ (emission occurs in both cases). By how much does the stopping potential change? Does the answer depend on the metal?
1 $E=\dfrac{1240}{300}=4.13\ \text{eV}$; $V_0=4.13-2.75=1.38\ \text{V}$.
2 $K_{\max}=1240\left(\dfrac1{400}-\dfrac1{600}\right)=3.10-2.07=1.03\ \text{eV}$.
3 $\phi_0=\dfrac{1240}{250}-2.0=4.96-2.0=2.96\ \text{eV}$; $\lambda_0=\dfrac{1240}{2.96}=419\ \text{nm}$.
4 $\phi_0=h\nu_0=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}\times5.0\times10^{14}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}=2.07\ \text{eV}$. $V_0=\dfrac{h}{e}(\nu-\nu_0)=4.14\times10^{-15}\times3.0\times10^{14}=1.24\ \text{V}$.
5 $\phi_0=3.0-1.0=2.0\ \text{eV}$. At twice the frequency $h\nu=6.0\ \text{eV}$, so $K_{\max}=6.0-2.0=4.0\ \text{eV}$ — four times as much, not twice.
6 $V_{0,A}-V_{0,B}=1.0\ \text{V}$ ($A$ larger) for any frequency above both thresholds. The graphs are parallel (slope $h/e$ for both); B's line is shifted to the right, its $\nu$-intercept is higher ($7.2\times10^{14}$ against $4.8\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$) and its $V_0$-intercept is $-3.0\ \text{V}$ against $-2.0\ \text{V}$.
7 $\Delta V_0=1240\left(\dfrac1{300}-\dfrac1{400}\right)=4.13-3.10=1.03\ \text{V}$ (increase). It does not depend on the metal: $\phi_0$ cancels in the difference.
IV
Photons, photon flux and harder problems.
  • 1 A $100\ \text{W}$ sodium lamp radiates all its power as yellow light of wavelength $589\ \text{nm}$. How many photons does it emit per second?
  • 2 Assuming the lamp of part 1 radiates equally in all directions, find the photon flux (photons per m² per second) at a distance of $2.0\ \text{m}$.
  • 3 A $5.0\ \text{mW}$ laser beam falls normally on a perfectly reflecting mirror. Find the force on the mirror.
  • 4 Find the force exerted by a $10\ \text{W}$ beam that is completely absorbed by a surface it strikes normally.
  • 5 A $1.0\ \text{mW}$ beam of wavelength $400\ \text{nm}$ falls on the caesium emitter of a photocell with a quantum efficiency of $2.0\%$. Find the saturation current in $\mu\text{A}$.
  • 6 Find the wavelength and the momentum of a gamma-ray photon of energy $1.0\ \text{MeV}$.
  • 7 Sunlight of intensity $2.0\ \text{W/m}^2$ (take a single wavelength $500\ \text{nm}$) falls normally on a black card of area $5.0\ \text{cm}^2$. Find the force on the card and the number of photons striking it per second.
  • 8 Name one phenomenon that shows the wave nature of light and one that shows its particle nature, and explain in a sentence each why it supports that picture.
1 $N=\dfrac{P\lambda}{hc}=\dfrac{100\times589\times10^{-9}}{6.63\times10^{-34}\times3.0\times10^8}=2.96\times10^{20}\ \text{s}^{-1}$.
2 $\Phi=\dfrac{N}{4\pi r^2}=\dfrac{2.96\times10^{20}}{4\pi\times4.0}=5.89\times10^{18}\ \text{m}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$.
3 $F=\dfrac{2P}{c}=\dfrac{2\times5.0\times10^{-3}}{3.0\times10^8}=3.33\times10^{-11}\ \text{N}$.
4 $F=\dfrac{P}{c}=\dfrac{10}{3.0\times10^8}=3.3\times10^{-8}\ \text{N}$ — light pushes, but very gently.
5 $N=\dfrac{P\lambda}{hc}=\dfrac{1.0\times10^{-3}\times400\times10^{-9}}{1.989\times10^{-25}}=2.01\times10^{15}\ \text{s}^{-1}$ (and $3.10\ \text{eV}\gt2.14\ \text{eV}$, so emission occurs). $I=\eta Ne=0.020\times2.01\times10^{15}\times1.6\times10^{-19}=6.4\times10^{-6}\ \text{A}=6.4\ \mu\text{A}$.
6 $E=1.0\times10^6\times1.6\times10^{-19}=1.6\times10^{-13}\ \text{J}$; $\lambda=\dfrac{hc}{E}=1.24\times10^{-12}\ \text{m}$; $p=\dfrac{E}{c}=5.33\times10^{-22}\ \text{kg m/s}$.
7 Power on the card $P=IA=2.0\times5.0\times10^{-4}=1.0\times10^{-3}\ \text{W}$. $F=\dfrac{P}{c}=3.3\times10^{-12}\ \text{N}$. $N=\dfrac{P}{hc/\lambda}=\dfrac{1.0\times10^{-3}}{3.98\times10^{-19}}=2.5\times10^{15}\ \text{s}^{-1}$.
8 Wave: interference in Young's double-slit experiment — bright and dark fringes need waves from the two slits to add and cancel. Particle: the photoelectric effect — the threshold frequency and the instant emission show energy delivered in packets $h\nu$, one per electron. (Compton scattering, with photons carrying momentum $h/\lambda$, is another particle example.)
🎯 Exam corner NEET · MCQ

E1. NEET · MCQ The threshold wavelength of a metal is $310\ \text{nm}$. When ultraviolet light of wavelength $200\ \text{nm}$ falls on it, the stopping potential is ($hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$) (A) $2.2\ \text{V}$ (B) $6.2\ \text{V}$ (C) $4.0\ \text{V}$ (D) $1.1\ \text{V}$

Energies $\phi_0=\dfrac{1240}{310}=4.0\ \text{eV}$; $h\nu=\dfrac{1240}{200}=6.2\ \text{eV}$.
Einstein $eV_0=h\nu-\phi_0=6.2-4.0=2.2\ \text{eV}$ (Law 17.2), so $V_0=2.2\ \text{V}$.
Answer (A) $2.2\ \text{V}$.
⏱ Shortcut $V_0$ must be smaller than the photon energy in volts, $6.2$ — so (B) is out. (C) is the work function itself, and (D) halves the right answer for no reason.

E2. NEET · MCQ Statement I: When the intensity of the light falling on a photosensitive surface is doubled, its frequency unchanged, the maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons is doubled. Statement II: Above the threshold frequency, the number of photoelectrons emitted per second is proportional to the intensity of the incident light. In the light of these statements, choose the correct option. (A) Both Statement I and Statement II are correct (B) Both Statement I and Statement II are incorrect (C) Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect (D) Statement I is incorrect but Statement II is correct

Statement I $K_{\max}=h\nu-\phi_0$ contains no intensity: doubling the intensity at the same frequency doubles the number of photons, each with the same energy. Incorrect.
Statement II One photon frees at most one electron, so the emission rate follows the photon rate, i.e. the intensity (Result 17.1, law 2). Correct.
Answer (D).
⏱ Shortcut Intensity → how many; frequency → how fast. Any statement linking intensity to energy is false.

E3. NEET · MCQ Assertion (A): For a given metal, the stopping potential increases when the wavelength of the incident light is decreased (emission occurring in both cases). Reason (R): The maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons is directly proportional to the frequency of the incident light. Choose the correct option. (A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A (B) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A (C) A is true but R is false (D) A is false but R is true

Assertion A shorter wavelength means a higher frequency and more energetic photons, so $eV_0=hc/\lambda-\phi_0$ rises. True.
Reason $K_{\max}=h\nu-\phi_0$ increases linearly with $\nu$, but it is not proportional to $\nu$: it is zero at $\nu_0$, not at $\nu=0$ (Result 17.3). False.
Answer (C).
⏱ Shortcut "Directly proportional" means a straight line through the origin. The $K_{\max}$–$\nu$ line cuts the axis at $\nu_0$, so the word "proportional" alone makes R false.

E4. NEET · MCQ Match each feature in List-I with its value in List-II, for a metal of work function $\phi_0$ and threshold frequency $\nu_0$.
List-I: (a) slope of the graph of stopping potential against frequency (b) intercept of that graph on the frequency axis (c) slope of the graph of maximum kinetic energy against frequency (d) intercept of the extended $K_{\max}$–$\nu$ line on the energy axis
List-II: (i) $h$ (ii) $-\phi_0$ (iii) $h/e$ (iv) $\nu_0$
Choose the correct answer: (A) a-i, b-iv, c-iii, d-ii (B) a-iii, b-ii, c-i, d-iv (C) a-iii, b-iv, c-ii, d-i (D) a-iii, b-iv, c-i, d-ii

Graphs $V_0=\dfrac he\nu-\dfrac{\phi_0}{e}$: slope $h/e$ (iii), zero at $\nu=\nu_0$ (iv). $K_{\max}=h\nu-\phi_0$: slope $h$ (i), intercept $-\phi_0$ (ii) (Result 17.3).
Answer (D) a-iii, b-iv, c-i, d-ii.
⏱ Shortcut A frequency-axis intercept must be a frequency, so b-iv — that removes (B). A slope cannot be $-\phi_0$, which removes (C); and the $V_0$ graph, not the $K_{\max}$ graph, has the $1/e$, which removes (A).

E5. NEET · MCQ The graph shows the stopping potential $V_0$ against the frequency $\nu$ of the incident light for two metals P and Q. Light of frequency $8.0\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$ falls on each in turn. The difference between the two stopping potentials, and the work function of Q, are ($h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $e=1.6\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}$) (A) $0.83\ \text{V}$, larger for P; $2.49\ \text{eV}$ (B) $0.83\ \text{V}$, larger for Q; $2.49\ \text{eV}$ (C) $1.66\ \text{V}$, larger for P; $1.66\ \text{eV}$ (D) zero, since the lines are parallel; $2.49\ \text{eV}$
246810123ν (10¹⁴ Hz)V₀ (volt)0PQ

Read the graph P meets the $\nu$-axis at $\nu_{0P}=4.0\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$, Q at $\nu_{0Q}=6.0\times10^{14}\ \text{Hz}$; both lines have slope $h/e=4.14\times10^{-15}\ \text{V s}$ (Result 17.3).
Difference $V_{0P}-V_{0Q}=\dfrac he(\nu_{0Q}-\nu_{0P})=4.14\times10^{-15}\times2.0\times10^{14}=0.83\ \text{V}$, with P larger ($1.66\ \text{V}$ against $0.83\ \text{V}$).
Work function $\phi_Q=h\nu_{0Q}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}\times6.0\times10^{14}}{1.6\times10^{-19}}\ \text{eV}=2.49\ \text{eV}$.
Answer (A).
⏱ Shortcut Parallel lines keep a constant vertical gap, not a zero one — (D) is out. The line further left (lower threshold, smaller work function) is always higher — (B) is out. (C) gives P's values, not Q's.

E6. NEET · MCQ How many of the following statements are correct?
(i) A photon has zero rest mass but carries momentum $h/\lambda$.
(ii) A beam of photons is deflected by a strong electric field.
(iii) The work function of a metal depends on the frequency of the light falling on it.
(iv) For the same power, a violet lamp emits more photons per second than a red lamp.
(v) Photoelectrons appear within about $10^{-9}\ \text{s}$ of switching on the light, even when it is very faint.
(vi) In a collision between a photon and an electron, the total energy and the total momentum are conserved.
(A) Two (B) Three (C) Four (D) Five

Check each (i) ✓ Definition 17.5. (ii) ✗ — photons are uncharged; fields do not deflect them. (iii) ✗ — $\phi_0$ is a property of the metal and its surface. (iv) ✗ — violet photons are more energetic, so fewer of them make up the same power ($N\propto\lambda$). (v) ✓ Result 17.1, law 4. (vi) ✓ as in any collision.
Answer (B) three statements: (i), (v) and (vi).
⏱ Shortcut Statement (iv) is the classic reversal: at equal power, the red source wins on photon numbers because each red photon is cheaper.
🔬 Research–Teaching NexusResearch-tutored · optional, about 45 minutes

Research question. Can you measure Planck's constant with a handful of coloured LEDs and a multimeter, and how close to $6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$ can you get?

Why it matters. Since 2019 the kilogram itself has been defined by fixing the value of $h$, so Planck's constant underpins every mass measurement in the world. Photon energies set the colour of every LED and laser, the band gaps of solar cells, and the threshold of the image sensors in phones and telescopes. An LED is a "photoelectric effect in reverse": an electron falling through an energy step of about $eV$ emits one photon of energy $h\nu$. Measuring the voltage at which an LED just begins to glow, for several colours, gives a straight line whose slope is $h$ — the same idea as Millikan's $V_0$–$\nu$ graph (Result 17.3).

What to do.

  1. Collect four or five LEDs of different colours (red, orange, yellow, green, blue) and look up or measure the peak wavelength of each (a cheap diffraction grating or phone spectrometer app works).
  2. Connect each LED in series with a $1\ \text{k}\Omega$ resistor to a variable supply and a voltmeter across the LED.
  3. In a darkened room, raise the voltage slowly and record the "turn-on" voltage $V$ at which the LED just begins to glow (or extrapolate the straight part of its I–V curve back to zero current).
  4. Plot $eV$ against $\nu=c/\lambda$. Fit a straight line; its slope is your estimate of $h$.
  5. Estimate the uncertainty in $h$ from the scatter of your points and compare with the accepted value.

Tools: LEDs of several colours, resistor, variable DC supply (or a battery and potentiometer), digital multimeter(s), diffraction grating or spectrometer app, spreadsheet for the straight-line fit.

Hand in: A table of $\lambda$, $\nu$ and turn-on voltage for each LED, the graph with its fitted line, your value of $h$ with an uncertainty, and a paragraph comparing your method with Millikan's photoelectric measurement.

Going further. Cool one LED in iced water or warm it in a hairdryer stream and measure its turn-on voltage again. Does $h$ "change"? What does this tell you about the assumptions behind the method?

Instructor note: careful work gives $h$ within about $10$–$20\%$; the main systematic error is the definition of "turn-on" and the width of the LED spectrum. Extrapolating the linear part of the I–V curve is more consistent than judging the first glow by eye. Blue LEDs often give the largest deviation because of their extra internal voltage drop — a good discussion point about why Millikan used a vacuum photocell and a stopping potential, which measure energy more directly.

🧪 Self-check quiz

0/5 correct

Q1. In the photoelectric effect, the maximum kinetic energy of the emitted electrons depends on

Q2. The work function of a metal is $3.1\ \text{eV}$. Its threshold wavelength is closest to ($hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$)

Q3. A monochromatic source of power $3.0\ \text{mW}$ emits light of wavelength $660\ \text{nm}$. The number of photons it emits per second is about ($h=6.6\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $c=3\times10^8\ \text{m/s}$)

Q4. The momentum of a photon of energy $E$ is

Q5. Graphs of stopping potential (vertical) against frequency (horizontal) for two different metals are