Chapter 17 · Dual Nature of Matter and Radiation

17.2 Matter Waves

If waves of light can behave like particles, particles of matter can behave like waves. De Broglie's relation $\lambda=h/p$ gives every moving electron, proton or neutron a wavelength — for an electron accelerated through $V$ volts, $\lambda=1.227/\sqrt V$ nm, about the spacing of atoms in a crystal.

An electron microscope can show the individual columns of atoms in a crystal and the shapes of viruses far too small for any light microscope. It does so by using a beam of electrons instead of a beam of light — not because electrons are small, but because a fast electron behaves like a wave of extremely short wavelength. Neutrons from a nuclear reactor are used in the same way to find where the atoms sit in new materials, from battery electrodes to proteins. Neither technique would be possible if particles were only particles.

In Section 17.1 we saw that light, long known to be a wave, also arrives as particles — photons of energy $h\nu$ and momentum $h/\lambda$. In 1924 Louis de Broglie turned the argument round: if waves can behave like particles, perhaps particles can behave like waves. In this section we state his relation $\lambda=h/p$ and see why it is invisible for cricket balls but decisive for electrons. We find the wavelength of electrons, protons and alpha particles accelerated through a potential difference, and of neutrons and gas atoms at a given temperature, and we compare particles with photons of the same energy or the same wavelength — the comparisons NEET loves to test. NEET questions on this section are short ratio problems — the wavelength of an electron accelerated through $V$ (often in ångströms), a proton against an alpha particle at the same voltage or the same energy, how $\lambda$ changes when the energy or the temperature changes, and a particle compared with a photon — and nearly all of them take under a minute once you have spotted which quantity the two particles share.

The de Broglie hypothesis

De Broglie's reasoning was one of symmetry. Nature uses two descriptions for radiation: a wave (frequency $\nu$, wavelength $\lambda$) and a particle (energy $E$, momentum $p$), linked by Planck's constant through $E=h\nu$ and $p=h/\lambda$. Matter had always been described only as particles. De Broglie proposed that the same two links hold for every material particle: a particle with momentum $p$ has associated with it a wave of wavelength $h/p$. He used the idea to explain why the electron in a hydrogen atom can only occupy certain orbits (Chapter 18) — and three years later electron waves were seen directly, diffracting from crystals exactly as X-rays do.

📐 Law 17.5 — The de Broglie relation

A material particle of mass $m$ moving with speed $v$ (and momentum $p=mv$) behaves, in diffraction and interference, like a wave of wavelength

$$\lambda=\frac{h}{p}=\frac{h}{mv}.$$

In terms of the kinetic energy $K=\dfrac{p^2}{2m}$ (valid for $v\ll c$): $\ \lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}}$. The same relation $\lambda=h/p$ holds for photons, with $p=E/c$.

📘 Definition 17.6 — Matter wave

The wave associated with a moving material particle is called a matter wave (or de Broglie wave); its wavelength $\lambda=h/p$ is the de Broglie wavelength of the particle. The idea that radiation and matter both show wave properties in some experiments and particle properties in others is called wave–particle duality.

Some features of matter waves to keep clear:

Why we never notice it for everyday objects. Wave effects such as diffraction are noticeable only when the wavelength is comparable with the size of an obstacle or gap. Planck's constant is so small ($6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$) that for any object we can see, $\lambda=h/mv$ is unimaginably tiny — far smaller than an atomic nucleus. For an electron, whose mass is only $9.1\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}$, the wavelength becomes comparable with the spacing of atoms in a solid, and the wave behaviour is unmistakable.

✏️ Example 1 — A cricket ball and an electron
Find the de Broglie wavelength of (a) a cricket ball of mass $0.16\ \text{kg}$ bowled at $40\ \text{m/s}$, (b) an electron moving at $2.0\times10^6\ \text{m/s}$. Compare each with a typical atomic spacing of $0.2\ \text{nm}$. ($h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $m_e=9.1\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}$.)
(a) $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{mv}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{0.16\times40}=1.04\times10^{-34}\ \text{m}$ — about $10^{-24}$ of an atomic spacing, and $10^{-19}$ of the size of a nucleus. No gap or obstacle could ever diffract it.
(b) $\lambda=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{9.1\times10^{-31}\times2.0\times10^6}=3.64\times10^{-10}\ \text{m}=0.364\ \text{nm}$ — about twice the atomic spacing, so a crystal acts as a diffraction grating for these electrons.
Check Units: $\dfrac{\text{J s}}{\text{kg m/s}}=\dfrac{\text{kg m}^2\text{s}^{-1}}{\text{kg m s}^{-1}}=\text{m}$ ✓.

An electron and a proton have the same de Broglie wavelength. Then they have the same

Charged particles accelerated through a potential difference

In practice, electrons for diffraction or microscopy are produced by an electron gun: they leave a hot filament almost at rest and are accelerated through a potential difference $V$. A particle of charge $q$ gains kinetic energy $K=qV$ (the work done on it by the field, Section 11.3), so its momentum is $p=\sqrt{2mK}=\sqrt{2mqV}$.

📐 Result 17.6 — Wavelength after acceleration through $V$

A particle of mass $m$ and charge $q$, starting from rest and accelerated through a potential difference $V$ (non-relativistic, $qV\ll mc^2$), has de Broglie wavelength

$$\lambda=\frac{h}{\sqrt{2mqV}}\ \propto\ \frac{1}{\sqrt{mqV}}.$$

Putting in the constants ($h=6.626\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $m_e=9.109\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}$, $e=1.602\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}$):

  • electron: $\ \lambda=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt V}\ \text{nm}$ (with $V$ in volts);
  • proton: $\ \lambda=\dfrac{0.0286}{\sqrt V}\ \text{nm}$;
  • alpha particle ($q=2e$, $m\approx4m_p$): $\ \lambda=\dfrac{0.0101}{\sqrt V}\ \text{nm}$.

With the rounded constants used in this course ($h=6.63\times10^{-34}$, $m_e=9.1\times10^{-31}$, $e=1.6\times10^{-19}$) the electron's number comes out $1.229\approx1.23$ — either is fine.

Derivation of the electron formula. With $q=e$ and $m=m_e$, the denominator is $\sqrt{2m_ee}\,\sqrt V$, where (in SI units)

$$2m_ee=2\times9.109\times10^{-31}\times1.602\times10^{-19}$$ $$=2.918\times10^{-49},$$

so $\sqrt{2m_ee}=5.40\times10^{-25}$ and

$$\lambda=\frac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{5.40\times10^{-25}\sqrt V}\ \text{m}$$ $$=\frac{1.227\times10^{-9}}{\sqrt V}\ \text{m}.$$

So electrons accelerated through about $100\ \text{V}$ have wavelengths of about $0.12\ \text{nm}$ — just right for diffraction by the rows of atoms in a crystal, like X-rays. Electrons accelerated through tens of kilovolts, as in an electron microscope, have wavelengths of a few picometres, about $10^5$ times shorter than visible light, which is why such microscopes can resolve far finer detail. (At $100\ \text{kV}$ and above, relativity changes the numbers; NEET problems stay in the non-relativistic range.)

Two comparisons follow from $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt{mqV}$ and come up again and again:

✏️ Example 2 — Electrons for a diffraction experiment
(a) Find the de Broglie wavelength of electrons accelerated from rest through $150\ \text{V}$, first with the formula $\lambda=1.227/\sqrt V\ \text{nm}$ and then directly from $\lambda=h/p$. (b) Through what potential difference must electrons be accelerated to have a wavelength of $0.050\ \text{nm}$?
(a) $\lambda=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt{150}}=\dfrac{1.227}{12.25}=0.100\ \text{nm}$.
Directly $K=150\ \text{eV}=2.40\times10^{-17}\ \text{J}$; $p=\sqrt{2m_eK}=\sqrt{2\times9.1\times10^{-31}\times2.40\times10^{-17}}=6.61\times10^{-24}\ \text{kg m/s}$; $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{p}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{6.61\times10^{-24}}=1.00\times10^{-10}\ \text{m}$ ✓.
(b) $\sqrt V=\dfrac{1.227}{0.050}=24.5$, so $V=602\ \text{V}$.
⏱ Shortcut $\lambda\sqrt V$ is constant: halving $\lambda$ from $0.100$ to $0.050\ \text{nm}$ needs four times the voltage, $4\times150=600\ \text{V}$.
✏️ Example 3 — Proton against alpha particle
A proton and an alpha particle are each accelerated from rest through the same potential difference. (a) Find the ratio of their de Broglie wavelengths $\lambda_p/\lambda_\alpha$. (b) Find the proton's wavelength if the potential difference is $100\ \text{V}$. (c) For the two to have the same wavelength, what must be the ratio of the accelerating voltages $V_p/V_\alpha$? Take $m_\alpha=4m_p$, $q_\alpha=2e$, $m_p=1.67\times10^{-27}\ \text{kg}$.
Find $\lambda_p/\lambda_\alpha$ in (a) before you open the solution:
(a) $\dfrac{\lambda_p}{\lambda_\alpha}=\sqrt{\dfrac{m_\alpha q_\alpha}{m_pq_p}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{4m_p\times2e}{m_p\times e}}=\sqrt8=2.83$.
(b) $\lambda_p=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2m_peV}}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{\sqrt{2\times1.67\times10^{-27}\times1.6\times10^{-19}\times100}}=2.87\times10^{-12}\ \text{m}=2.87\ \text{pm}$ (or $0.0286/\sqrt{100}\ \text{nm}$).
(c) Equal $\lambda$ needs equal $mqV$: $\dfrac{V_p}{V_\alpha}=\dfrac{m_\alpha q_\alpha}{m_pq_p}=8$.
⏱ Shortcut Same $V$: compare $\sqrt{mq}$. Same $K$: compare $\sqrt m$ (ratio $2$). Same speed: compare $m$ (ratio $4$). Decide which quantity is shared before writing any formula.
🚀 Beyond NEET — the Davisson–Germer experiment

The Davisson–Germer experiment is not in the current NMC NEET (UG) syllabus or the CBSE Class 12 syllabus; it is described here, qualitatively, because it is the experiment that first showed electron waves. Nothing in this box is needed for the exercises, the Exam corner or the quiz.

In 1927 Clinton Davisson and Lester Germer fired a narrow beam of electrons, accelerated through a few tens of volts, at a single crystal of nickel and measured how many electrons bounced off in each direction with a movable detector. Instead of a smooth spread, they found a sharp peak in one direction — for $54\ \text{V}$ electrons, at about $50^\circ$ to the incident beam. This is exactly what happens when X-rays are diffracted by the regular rows of atoms in a crystal: the waves scattered from different rows reinforce only in particular directions. The wavelength worked out from the nickel atom spacing and the angle of the peak ($0.165\ \text{nm}$) agreed with the de Broglie value $1.227/\sqrt{54}=0.167\ \text{nm}$. Changing the voltage moved the peak just as $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt V$ predicts. In the same year G. P. Thomson passed faster electrons through thin metal foils and photographed diffraction rings like those of X-rays. Davisson and Thomson shared the 1937 Nobel Prize.

In Interactive 1 choose the electron and set $V=100\ \text{V}$: the wavelength reads $0.123\ \text{nm}$. Predict the wavelength when you raise the voltage to $400\ \text{V}$.

At $400\ \text{V}$ the readouts show $K=400\ \text{eV}$, $p=1.08\times10^{-23}\ \text{kg m/s}$ and $\lambda=0.0614\ \text{nm}$: four times the voltage gives twice the momentum and half the wavelength, because $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt V$ ($0.0307\ \text{nm}$ would need $\lambda\propto1/V$). Now switch to the proton at $100\ \text{V}$: $\lambda=0.00287\ \text{nm}$, $\sqrt{1835}\approx43$ times shorter than the electron's — and the alpha particle is shorter again by $2\sqrt2$.
Interactive 1 — Matter Waves: Wavelength Against Accelerating Voltage

A particle is accelerated from rest through $V$. The top panel draws its de Broglie wave to scale beside a row of atoms $0.20\ \text{nm}$ apart, as in a crystal. The bottom panel plots $\lambda$ against $V$ on logarithmic scales for the electron, proton and alpha particle — three parallel lines of slope $-\tfrac12$. Press Play to sweep the voltage upward and watch the wave shorten.

100 V
kinetic energy $K=qV$—
momentum $p$—
wavelength $\lambda$—
$\lambda$ ÷ atom spacing—

The de Broglie wavelength of an electron accelerated from rest through $V$ is $\lambda$. If the accelerating voltage is made $9V$, the wavelength becomes

Thermal neutrons, and particles compared with photons

Neutrons are uncharged, so they cannot be accelerated by a potential difference. The neutrons used for diffraction come out of a nuclear reactor and are slowed down by repeated collisions with the nuclei of a moderator (water or graphite) until they share its thermal motion, like the molecules of a gas. Kinetic theory (Section 9.1) tells us that particles in thermal equilibrium at absolute temperature $T$ have average kinetic energy $\tfrac32k_BT$, where $k_B=1.38\times10^{-23}\ \text{J/K}$ is Boltzmann's constant.

📘 Definition 17.7 — Thermal neutron

A thermal neutron is a neutron in thermal equilibrium with matter at ordinary temperatures (about $300\ \text{K}$), with kinetic energy of the order of $k_BT\approx0.025$–$0.04\ \text{eV}$. Its de Broglie wavelength, about $0.1$–$0.2\ \text{nm}$, is comparable with the spacing of atoms in solids, so thermal neutrons are diffracted by crystals.

📐 Result 17.7 — Wavelength of particles at temperature $T$

A particle of mass $m$ with the average thermal kinetic energy $K=\tfrac32k_BT$ has de Broglie wavelength

$$\lambda=\frac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}}=\frac{h}{\sqrt{3mk_BT}}\ \propto\ \frac1{\sqrt{mT}}.$$

This applies to thermal neutrons and to the atoms or molecules of a gas. (If a problem says the energy is $k_BT$, use $\lambda=h/\sqrt{2mk_BT}$ instead — read the statement.)

For a thermal neutron at $300\ \text{K}$ this gives $0.146\ \text{nm}$ (Example 4). Neutrons have two advantages over X-rays for studying materials: they are scattered by nuclei rather than by electrons, so they "see" light atoms such as hydrogen and lithium that X-rays barely notice; and, having a magnetic moment, they reveal the magnetic order in a solid.

Particles against photons. A photon and a material particle obey the same relation $\lambda=h/p$, but their energy–momentum relations differ: for a photon $E=pc$, for a slow particle $K=p^2/2m$. This makes all the difference when we compare them.

📐 Result 17.8 — A particle and a photon compared

For a photon and a non-relativistic particle of mass $m$:

  • Same wavelength $\lambda$ ⇒ same momentum $p=h/\lambda$. The energies are $E_\text{ph}=pc=\dfrac{hc}{\lambda}$ and $K=\dfrac{p^2}{2m}=\dfrac{h^2}{2m\lambda^2}$, so $\ \dfrac{E_\text{ph}}{K}=\dfrac{2mc\lambda}{h}=\dfrac{2c}{v}\gg1$: the photon has far more energy.
  • Same energy $E$ ⇒ $\lambda_\text{ph}=\dfrac{hc}{E}$ and $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mE}}$, so $\ \dfrac{\lambda_\text{ph}}{\lambda}=\sqrt{\dfrac{2mc^2}{E}}\gg1$ when $E\ll mc^2$: the particle has the much shorter wavelength.

For an electron $m_ec^2\approx0.511\ \text{MeV}$, so at $100\ \text{eV}$ the photon's wavelength is about $100$ times the electron's. Also, for a photon $\lambda\propto1/E$, while for a particle $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt K$.

🧭 Problem-solving strategy — de Broglie wavelengths
  1. Identify what is given: speed ($\lambda=h/mv$), kinetic energy ($\lambda=h/\sqrt{2mK}$), accelerating voltage ($\lambda=h/\sqrt{2mqV}$, or $1.227/\sqrt V\ \text{nm}$ for electrons only) or temperature ($\lambda=h/\sqrt{3mk_BT}$).
  2. For a photon, never use $\sqrt{2mK}$: $p=E/c$ and $\lambda=hc/E$.
  3. Convert eV to J ($\times1.6\times10^{-19}$) before using SI formulas; give $\lambda$ in nm or pm.
  4. For ratios, write $\lambda$ as a power law ($\lambda\propto1/\sqrt{mqV}$, $\propto1/\sqrt{mK}$, $\propto1/\sqrt{mT}$, $\propto1/mv$) and let the constants cancel.
  5. Small changes: $\lambda\propto K^{-1/2}$, so a change by a factor $k$ in $K$ changes $\lambda$ by $1/\sqrt k$ (e.g. $K\times1.21\Rightarrow\lambda\div1.1$, a $9.1\%$ decrease).
✏️ Example 4 — A thermal neutron
Neutrons leaving a reactor moderator are in thermal equilibrium at $27^\circ\text{C}$. (a) Find their average kinetic energy in J and eV. (b) Find their de Broglie wavelength. (c) Find the wavelength of an electron with the same kinetic energy. Take $m_n=1.67\times10^{-27}\ \text{kg}$, $k_B=1.38\times10^{-23}\ \text{J/K}$.
(a) $T=300\ \text{K}$: $K=\tfrac32k_BT=1.5\times1.38\times10^{-23}\times300=6.21\times10^{-21}\ \text{J}=0.0388\ \text{eV}$.
(b) $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2m_nK}}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{\sqrt{2\times1.67\times10^{-27}\times6.21\times10^{-21}}}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{4.55\times10^{-24}}=1.46\times10^{-10}\ \text{m}=0.146\ \text{nm}$.
(c) Same $K$: $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt m$, so $\lambda_e=0.146\times\sqrt{\dfrac{1.67\times10^{-27}}{9.1\times10^{-31}}}=0.146\times42.8=6.24\ \text{nm}$.
Check $0.146\ \text{nm}$ is comparable with atomic spacings — which is why reactors are used as neutron-diffraction sources.
✏️ Example 5 — An X-ray photon and an electron of the same wavelength
An X-ray photon and an electron each have a wavelength of $0.20\ \text{nm}$. Find (a) the momentum of each, (b) the energy of the photon, (c) the kinetic energy of the electron, (d) the ratio of the two energies. Use $h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$, $m_e=9.1\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}$.
Find the kinetic energy of the electron in eV:
(a) Same wavelength, same momentum: $p=\dfrac{h}{\lambda}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{2.0\times10^{-10}}=3.32\times10^{-24}\ \text{kg m/s}$ for both.
(b) $E_\text{ph}=\dfrac{hc}{\lambda}=\dfrac{1240}{0.20}=6200\ \text{eV}=6.2\ \text{keV}$.
(c) $K=\dfrac{p^2}{2m_e}=\dfrac{(3.32\times10^{-24})^2}{2\times9.1\times10^{-31}}=6.04\times10^{-18}\ \text{J}=37.7\ \text{eV}$ (check: $\left(1.227/0.20\right)^2=37.6\ \text{V}$ ✓).
(d) $\dfrac{E_\text{ph}}{K}=\dfrac{2m_ec\lambda}{h}=\dfrac{2\times9.1\times10^{-31}\times3.0\times10^8\times2.0\times10^{-10}}{6.63\times10^{-34}}=165$ (and $6200/37.7\approx164$, the same within rounding).
⏱ Shortcut Same $\lambda$ ⇒ same $p$. The photon's energy is $pc$, the electron's $p^2/2m=pv/2$ — smaller by the factor $2c/v$.
✏️ Example 6 — The wavelength of photoelectrons
Ultraviolet light of wavelength $200\ \text{nm}$ falls on a metal of work function $4.7\ \text{eV}$. (a) Find the shortest de Broglie wavelength of the emitted photoelectrons. (b) Find it again when the light's wavelength is reduced to $155\ \text{nm}$. (c) By what percentage must the kinetic energy of an electron be increased to reduce its de Broglie wavelength by $10\%$? Use $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$ and $\lambda=1.227/\sqrt{K(\text{eV})}\ \text{nm}$ for electrons.
Find the shortest wavelength in (a):
(a) $K_{\max}=\dfrac{1240}{200}-4.7=6.2-4.7=1.5\ \text{eV}$. The fastest electrons have the shortest wavelength: $\lambda_{\min}=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt{1.5}}=1.00\ \text{nm}$.
(b) $K_{\max}=\dfrac{1240}{155}-4.7=8.0-4.7=3.3\ \text{eV}$; $\lambda_{\min}=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt{3.3}}=0.675\ \text{nm}$.
(c) $\lambda\propto K^{-1/2}$. For $\lambda'=0.90\lambda$: $K'=\dfrac{K}{0.81}=1.235K$ — an increase of $23.5\%$.
Check In (b) the photon energy rose by $29\%$ but $K_{\max}$ more than doubled (the work function is fixed), so $\lambda$ fell by the factor $\sqrt{3.3/1.5}=1.48$.

In Interactive 2 set the energy to $100\ \text{eV}$. About how many times longer is the photon's wavelength than the electron's?

At $100\ \text{eV}$ the readouts show $\lambda_\text{photon}=12.4\ \text{nm}$, $\lambda_\text{electron}=0.123\ \text{nm}$ and $\lambda_\text{neutron}=2.87\ \text{pm}$, a ratio $\lambda_\text{ph}/\lambda_e=101=\sqrt{2m_ec^2/E}$. Slide the energy up: the photon marker moves twice as fast across the logarithmic scale as the particle markers ($\lambda\propto1/E$ against $1/\sqrt E$), so the ratio shrinks. ($1800$ is roughly $m_p/m_e$, which compares a neutron with an electron at the same speed.)
Interactive 2 — Photon, Electron, Neutron: Same Energy, Different Wavelengths

Give a photon, an electron and a neutron the same energy $E$ and compare their wavelengths on a logarithmic scale running from $10^{-13}\ \text{m}$ to $1\ \text{mm}$. The shaded bands mark visible light and the spacing of atoms in crystals. Press Play to sweep the energy from $0.01\ \text{eV}$ to $10\ \text{keV}$ (all particles non-relativistic).

100 eV
photon $hc/E$—
electron $h/\sqrt{2m_eE}$—
neutron $h/\sqrt{2m_nE}$—
$\lambda_\text{photon}/\lambda_\text{electron}$—
✏️ Example 7 — NEET-style: find what is shared, then scale
(a) A proton and an alpha particle have equal de Broglie wavelengths. The ratio of their kinetic energies, $K_p:K_\alpha$, is (A) $1:4$ (B) $4:1$ (C) $1:1$ (D) $2:1$.
(b) Helium atoms in a gas at $127^\circ\text{C}$ have (average) de Broglie wavelength $\lambda$. The temperature at which their wavelength becomes $\lambda/2$ is (A) $254^\circ\text{C}$ (B) $508^\circ\text{C}$ (C) $1600^\circ\text{C}$ (D) $1327^\circ\text{C}$.
(a) Shared Equal wavelengths mean equal momenta, $p=h/\lambda$ (Law 17.5). Then $K=\dfrac{p^2}{2m}\propto\dfrac1m$.
Answer (a) (B): $\dfrac{K_p}{K_\alpha}=\dfrac{m_\alpha}{m_p}=4$. (A) inverts the ratio; (D) uses $\sqrt m$, which belongs to the "same kinetic energy" comparison of wavelengths; the charge does not enter at all.
(b) Scaling $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{3mk_BT}}\propto\dfrac1{\sqrt T}$ with $T$ in kelvin (Result 17.7). Halving $\lambda$ needs $4T$: $T=127+273=400\ \text{K}$ becomes $1600\ \text{K}$, i.e. $1600-273=1327^\circ\text{C}$.
Answer (b) (D) $1327^\circ\text{C}$.
⏱ Shortcut (a) Same $\lambda$ ⇒ same $p$ ⇒ the lighter particle has the larger energy — only (B) says so. (b) Every option built on $^\circ\text{C}$ is a trap: (A) doubles and (B) quadruples $127^\circ\text{C}$, and (C) is the right temperature left in kelvin. Convert to kelvin, scale, convert back.
⚠️ NEET traps

1. Square roots. $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt V$ and $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt K$, not $1/V$ or $1/K$: four times the voltage or the energy halves the wavelength; nine times divides it by three. Only at fixed mass is $\lambda\propto1/v$.

2. The electron formula and its units. $\lambda=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt V}\ \text{nm}=\dfrac{12.27}{\sqrt V}\ \text{Å}$ is for electrons only. NEET options often give the same digits in nm and in Å — a factor of ten apart — so fix the unit before you choose. For a proton or an alpha particle use $h/\sqrt{2mqV}$, with $q_\alpha=2e$ and $m_\alpha=4m_p$.

3. Read what is shared. Same speed: $\lambda\propto1/m$. Same kinetic energy: $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt m$. Same accelerating voltage: $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt{mq}$. Same momentum: the same $\lambda$, whatever the particle.

4. Photon or particle? For a photon $\lambda=hc/E$ and $p=E/c$; $h/\sqrt{2mK}$ is only for particles with mass moving slowly. Equal wavelengths mean equal momenta, never equal energies.

5. Temperature. $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt T$ with $T$ in kelvin; use the energy $\tfrac32k_BT$ unless the question says $k_BT$.

6. Statement traps. Matter waves are not electromagnetic waves and need no charge — neutrons and whole atoms have them. The wavelength does not depend on the charge for a given momentum. Everyday objects have wavelengths too; they are just far too small to show diffraction.

A photon and an electron have the same energy, $50\ \text{eV}$. Which has the longer wavelength?

Exercises

Take $h=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{J s}$, $e=1.6\times10^{-19}\ \text{C}$, $c=3.0\times10^8\ \text{m/s}$, $m_e=9.1\times10^{-31}\ \text{kg}$, $m_p=m_n=1.67\times10^{-27}\ \text{kg}$, $m_\alpha=4m_p$, $k_B=1.38\times10^{-23}\ \text{J/K}$, $hc=1240\ \text{eV nm}$, and $\lambda=1.227/\sqrt V\ \text{nm}$ for electrons, unless told otherwise. All particles are non-relativistic.

I
The de Broglie relation.
  • 1 Find the de Broglie wavelength of a $50\ \text{g}$ ball moving at $20\ \text{m/s}$.
  • 2 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in nm, of an electron moving at $1.0\times10^6\ \text{m/s}$.
  • 3 Find the speed of an electron whose de Broglie wavelength is $0.50\ \text{nm}$.
  • 4 Find the momentum of any particle whose de Broglie wavelength is $0.10\ \text{nm}$.
  • 5 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in pm, of a proton moving at $2.0\times10^5\ \text{m/s}$.
  • 6 An electron and a proton move with the same speed. Find the ratio $\lambda_e/\lambda_p$.
  • 7 Explain why we never observe the diffraction of a moving car, although it has a de Broglie wavelength.
  • 8 An electron and a proton have the same kinetic energy. Find the ratio $\lambda_e/\lambda_p$.
1 $\lambda=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{0.050\times20}=6.63\times10^{-34}\ \text{m}$.
2 $\lambda=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{9.1\times10^{-31}\times1.0\times10^6}=7.29\times10^{-10}\ \text{m}=0.729\ \text{nm}$.
3 $v=\dfrac{h}{m\lambda}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{9.1\times10^{-31}\times5.0\times10^{-10}}=1.46\times10^{6}\ \text{m/s}$.
4 $p=\dfrac{h}{\lambda}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{1.0\times10^{-10}}=6.63\times10^{-24}\ \text{kg m/s}$, whatever the particle.
5 $\lambda=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{1.67\times10^{-27}\times2.0\times10^5}=1.99\times10^{-12}\ \text{m}=1.99\ \text{pm}$.
6 Same speed: $\lambda\propto1/m$, so $\dfrac{\lambda_e}{\lambda_p}=\dfrac{m_p}{m_e}=\dfrac{1.67\times10^{-27}}{9.1\times10^{-31}}=1835$.
7 A $1000\ \text{kg}$ car at $20\ \text{m/s}$ has $\lambda=3\times10^{-38}\ \text{m}$. Diffraction is noticeable only for gaps or obstacles comparable with $\lambda$, and nothing remotely that small exists (a nucleus is $10^{-15}\ \text{m}$).
8 Same $K$: $\dfrac{\lambda_e}{\lambda_p}=\sqrt{\dfrac{m_p}{m_e}}=\sqrt{1835}=42.8$.
II
Charged particles accelerated through a potential difference.
  • 1 Find the de Broglie wavelength of electrons accelerated through $100\ \text{V}$.
  • 2 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in pm, of electrons accelerated through $10\ \text{kV}$ in an electron microscope.
  • 3 Through what potential difference must electrons be accelerated to have a de Broglie wavelength of $0.10\ \text{nm}$?
  • 4 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in pm, of a proton accelerated through $1.0\ \text{kV}$.
  • 5 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in pm, of an alpha particle accelerated through $1.0\ \text{kV}$.
  • 6 A deuteron ($m=2m_p$, $q=e$) and an alpha particle are accelerated through the same potential difference. Find $\lambda_d/\lambda_\alpha$.
  • 7 The accelerating voltage of an electron gun is quadrupled. What happens to the speed, the momentum and the de Broglie wavelength of the electrons?
  • 8 Explain why an electron microscope can resolve much finer detail than an optical microscope.
1 $\lambda=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt{100}}=0.123\ \text{nm}$.
2 $\lambda=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt{10\,000}}=0.01227\ \text{nm}=12.3\ \text{pm}$.
3 $V=\left(\dfrac{1.227}{0.10}\right)^2=151\ \text{V}$.
4 $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2m_peV}}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{\sqrt{2\times1.67\times10^{-27}\times1.6\times10^{-19}\times1000}}=9.07\times10^{-13}\ \text{m}=0.907\ \text{pm}$.
5 $\lambda=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{\sqrt{2\times6.68\times10^{-27}\times3.2\times10^{-19}\times1000}}=3.21\times10^{-13}\ \text{m}=0.321\ \text{pm}$ (check: $0.907/2\sqrt2=0.321$ ✓).
6 $\dfrac{\lambda_d}{\lambda_\alpha}=\sqrt{\dfrac{m_\alpha q_\alpha}{m_dq_d}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{4m_p\times2e}{2m_p\times e}}=2$.
7 $K$ is quadrupled, so the speed and the momentum double ($\propto\sqrt V$) and the wavelength halves.
8 The smallest detail a microscope can resolve is of the order of the wavelength it uses. Visible light has $\lambda\approx500\ \text{nm}$; electrons accelerated through tens of kilovolts have $\lambda$ of a few pm — about $10^5$ times shorter (in practice lens defects limit the resolution to about $0.1\ \text{nm}$, still thousands of times better).
III
Thermal particles and comparisons with photons.
  • 1 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in nm, of a thermal neutron at $300\ \text{K}$ (energy $\tfrac32k_BT$).
  • 2 At what temperature would thermal neutrons have a de Broglie wavelength of $0.10\ \text{nm}$?
  • 3 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in nm, of a helium atom ($m=6.68\times10^{-27}\ \text{kg}$) in a gas at $300\ \text{K}$.
  • 4 A photon and an electron each have a wavelength of $0.50\ \text{nm}$. Find the energy of the photon and the kinetic energy of the electron, in eV.
  • 5 A photon and an electron each have energy $1.0\ \text{keV}$. Find the ratio $\lambda_\text{photon}/\lambda_\text{electron}$.
  • 6 Find the de Broglie wavelength of a neutron with kinetic energy $0.025\ \text{eV}$.
  • 7 A photon and a proton have the same de Broglie wavelength. Which, if either, has the greater momentum, and which has the greater energy?
1 $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{3m_nk_BT}}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{\sqrt{3\times1.67\times10^{-27}\times1.38\times10^{-23}\times300}}=1.46\times10^{-10}\ \text{m}=0.146\ \text{nm}$.
2 $T=\dfrac{h^2}{3m_nk_B\lambda^2}=\dfrac{(6.63\times10^{-34})^2}{3\times1.67\times10^{-27}\times1.38\times10^{-23}\times(1.0\times10^{-10})^2}=636\ \text{K}$.
3 $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt m$ at the same $T$: $0.146\times\sqrt{\dfrac{1.67}{6.68}}=0.146\times0.5=0.0728\ \text{nm}$.
4 Photon: $E=\dfrac{1240}{0.50}=2480\ \text{eV}$. Electron: $K=\dfrac{h^2}{2m_e\lambda^2}=\dfrac{(6.63\times10^{-34})^2}{2\times9.1\times10^{-31}\times(5.0\times10^{-10})^2}=9.66\times10^{-19}\ \text{J}=6.04\ \text{eV}$.
5 $\lambda_\text{ph}=\dfrac{1240}{1000}=1.24\ \text{nm}$; $\lambda_e=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt{1000}}=0.0388\ \text{nm}$; ratio $32.0$ $\left(=\sqrt{2m_ec^2/E}=\sqrt{1024}\right)$.
6 $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2m_nK}}=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{\sqrt{2\times1.67\times10^{-27}\times0.025\times1.6\times10^{-19}}}=1.81\times10^{-10}\ \text{m}=0.181\ \text{nm}$.
7 Same $\lambda$ ⇒ same momentum $h/\lambda$. The photon has the greater energy: $pc$ against $p^2/2m=pv/2$, and $c\gg v/2$.
IV
Harder problems.
  • 1 The kinetic energy of an electron is increased by $21\%$. By what percentage does its de Broglie wavelength decrease?
  • 2 Light of wavelength $248\ \text{nm}$ falls on a metal of work function $2.5\ \text{eV}$. Find the shortest de Broglie wavelength of the photoelectrons, in nm.
  • 3 Through what potential difference must an electron be accelerated so that its de Broglie wavelength equals the wavelength of an X-ray photon of energy $4.96\ \text{keV}$?
  • 4 A proton accelerated through $800\ \text{V}$ has a certain de Broglie wavelength. Through what potential difference must an alpha particle be accelerated to have the same wavelength?
  • 5 A dust grain of mass $1.0\ \mu\text{g}$ drifts at $2.0\ \text{mm/s}$. Find its de Broglie wavelength and comment.
  • 6 Show that for a non-relativistic particle $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}}$, and use it to say how $\lambda$ changes when (a) the speed is doubled, (b) the kinetic energy is doubled, (c) the momentum is doubled.
  • 7 An electron and a photon both have wavelength $0.10\ \text{nm}$. Find the ratio of the photon's energy to the electron's kinetic energy.
1 $\lambda'=\dfrac{\lambda}{\sqrt{1.21}}=\dfrac{\lambda}{1.1}=0.909\lambda$: a decrease of $9.09\%$ (not $10.5\%$, which would be half of $21\%$ — the binomial estimate is only good for small changes).
2 $K_{\max}=\dfrac{1240}{248}-2.5=5.0-2.5=2.5\ \text{eV}$; $\lambda_{\min}=\dfrac{1.227}{\sqrt{2.5}}=0.776\ \text{nm}$.
3 Photon: $\lambda=\dfrac{1240}{4960}=0.250\ \text{nm}$. Electron: $V=\left(\dfrac{1.227}{0.250}\right)^2=24.1\ \text{V}$.
4 Equal $\lambda$ needs equal $mqV$: $V_\alpha=V_p\dfrac{m_pq_p}{m_\alpha q_\alpha}=\dfrac{800}{8}=100\ \text{V}$.
5 $\lambda=\dfrac{6.63\times10^{-34}}{1.0\times10^{-9}\times2.0\times10^{-3}}=3.3\times10^{-22}\ \text{m}$ — millions of times smaller than a nucleus: even a microscopic grain shows no wave behaviour.
6 $K=\dfrac{p^2}{2m}\Rightarrow p=\sqrt{2mK}$ and $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{p}=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}}$. (a) $p$ doubles: $\lambda$ halves. (b) $p$ grows by $\sqrt2$: $\lambda\to\lambda/\sqrt2$. (c) $\lambda$ halves (and $K$ is quadrupled).
7 $\dfrac{E_\text{ph}}{K}=\dfrac{2m_ec\lambda}{h}=\dfrac{2\times9.1\times10^{-31}\times3.0\times10^8\times1.0\times10^{-10}}{6.63\times10^{-34}}=82.4$ (check: $12\,400\ \text{eV}$ against $151\ \text{eV}$ ✓).
🎯 Exam corner NEET · MCQ

E1. NEET · MCQ An electron starts from rest and is accelerated through a potential difference of $64\ \text{V}$. Its de Broglie wavelength is about (A) $0.192\ \text{Å}$ (B) $1.53\ \text{Å}$ (C) $15.3\ \text{Å}$ (D) $0.153\ \text{Å}$

Formula For an electron $\lambda=\dfrac{12.27}{\sqrt V}\ \text{Å}$ (Result 17.6, with $1\ \text{nm}=10\ \text{Å}$).
Value $\lambda=\dfrac{12.27}{\sqrt{64}}=\dfrac{12.27}{8}=1.53\ \text{Å}$ $(=0.153\ \text{nm})$.
Answer (B) $1.53\ \text{Å}$.
⏱ Shortcut $64$ is a perfect square — divide by $8$, not by $64$ (that gives (A)). (C) and (D) are the right digits in the wrong unit: $0.153$ is the answer in nm, not Å.

E2. NEET · MCQ Statement I: A proton and an alpha particle accelerated from rest through the same potential difference have de Broglie wavelengths in the ratio $\lambda_p:\lambda_\alpha=2\sqrt2:1$. Statement II: A proton and an alpha particle that have the same kinetic energy have de Broglie wavelengths in the ratio $\lambda_p:\lambda_\alpha=2:1$. In the light of these statements, choose the correct option. (A) Both Statement I and Statement II are correct (B) Both Statement I and Statement II are incorrect (C) Statement I is correct but Statement II is incorrect (D) Statement I is incorrect but Statement II is correct

Statement I Same $V$: $\lambda\propto\dfrac1{\sqrt{mq}}$, so $\dfrac{\lambda_p}{\lambda_\alpha}=\sqrt{\dfrac{4m_p\times2e}{m_p\times e}}=\sqrt8=2\sqrt2$ (Result 17.6). Correct.
Statement II Same $K$: $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}}\propto\dfrac1{\sqrt m}$, so the ratio is $\sqrt4=2$. Correct.
Answer (A).
⏱ Shortcut The charge enters only when the energy comes from a voltage ($K=qV$). With the energy given directly, only the mass counts.

E3. NEET · MCQ Assertion (A): An electron and a proton moving with the same speed have the same de Broglie wavelength. Reason (R): The de Broglie wavelength of a particle depends only on its momentum. Choose the correct option. (A) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A (B) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A (C) A is true but R is false (D) A is false but R is true

Reason $\lambda=h/p$ (Law 17.5). True.
Assertion At the same speed the proton has $1835$ times the momentum $mv$, so its wavelength is $1835$ times shorter. False.
Answer (D).
⏱ Shortcut R itself kills A: "depends only on momentum", and equal speeds do not give equal momenta for unequal masses.

E4. NEET · MCQ Match each case in List-I with its wavelength in List-II ($m$ is the particle's mass).
List-I: (a) an electron (charge $e$) accelerated from rest through a potential difference $V$ (b) a particle of kinetic energy $K$ (c) a gas molecule with the average thermal energy $\tfrac32k_BT$ (d) a photon of energy $E$
List-II: (i) $\dfrac{hc}{E}$ (ii) $\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{3mk_BT}}$ (iii) $\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2meV}}$ (iv) $\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}}$
Choose the correct answer: (A) a-iv, b-iii, c-ii, d-i (B) a-iii, b-iv, c-ii, d-i (C) a-iii, b-iv, c-i, d-ii (D) a-iii, b-ii, c-iv, d-i

Match (a) $K=eV$ in $h/\sqrt{2mK}$: iii. (b) iv (Law 17.5). (c) $K=\tfrac32k_BT$: ii (Result 17.7). (d) $p=E/c$: i (Definition 17.5).
Answer (B) a-iii, b-iv, c-ii, d-i.
⏱ Shortcut Only (i) has no mass in it, so it must be the photon: d-i, which removes (C). Only (iii) has $V$ in it, so a-iii, which removes (A); and $k_BT$ belongs to the gas, which removes (D).

E5. NEET · MCQ The graph shows the de Broglie wavelength $\lambda$ against $1/\sqrt V$ ($V$ in volts) for two particles P and Q, each accelerated from rest through a potential difference $V$. The particles are two of these: a proton, a deuteron (mass $2m_p$, charge $e$) and an alpha particle (mass $4m_p$, charge $2e$). P and Q are (A) P alpha particle, Q proton (B) P proton, Q deuteron (C) P deuteron, Q alpha particle (D) P proton, Q alpha particle
0.020.040.060.080.101231/√V (V in volt)λ (pm)0PQ

Slopes $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mq}}\cdot\dfrac1{\sqrt V}$, a straight line through the origin of slope $\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mq}}$ (Result 17.6). At $1/\sqrt V=0.10$ the graph gives about $2.9\ \text{pm}$ for P and $1.0\ \text{pm}$ for Q: the slopes are in the ratio about $2.8\approx2\sqrt2$.
Which pair A slope ratio of $2\sqrt2$ needs $mq$ in the ratio $8$: only the proton ($m_pe$) and the alpha particle ($8m_pe$) qualify; the deuteron differs from either by a factor $2$ in $mq$ (slope ratio $\sqrt2\approx1.4$). The steeper line, P, has the smaller $mq$ — the proton. (Check: $0.0286\ \text{nm}\times0.10=2.86\ \text{pm}$ for a proton.)
Answer (D).
⏱ Shortcut Steeper line = lighter, less charged particle, which rules out (A) and (C) at once. Then read the ratio off the graph: about $3$, not about $1.4$, which rules out (B).

E6. NEET · MCQ How many of the following statements are correct?
(i) Matter waves are electromagnetic waves given out by moving charged particles.
(ii) A neutron, being uncharged, has no de Broglie wavelength.
(iii) If the kinetic energy of a free electron is made four times as large, its de Broglie wavelength is halved.
(iv) An electron and a photon with the same wavelength have the same momentum.
(v) An electron and a photon with the same energy of $10\ \text{eV}$ have the same wavelength.
(vi) Moving with the same speed, an alpha particle has a shorter de Broglie wavelength than a proton.
(A) Two (B) Four (C) Three (D) One

Check each (i) ✗ — matter waves are not electromagnetic and need no charge (Definition 17.6). (ii) ✗ — every moving particle has $\lambda=h/p$; thermal neutrons are used precisely for their waves. (iii) ✓ $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt K$. (iv) ✓ $p=h/\lambda$ for both. (v) ✗ — the photon's wavelength is about $320$ times longer (Result 17.8). (vi) ✓ $\lambda\propto1/m$ at equal speeds.
Answer (C) three statements: (iii), (iv) and (vi).
⏱ Shortcut Same wavelength ⇔ same momentum, always; same energy says nothing simple, because a photon's $E=pc$ and a particle's $K=p^2/2m$ differ.
🔬 Research–Teaching NexusResearch-tutored · optional, about 45 minutes

Research question. How fine a detail can a microscope resolve, and how does the answer change when we swap light for electrons accelerated through a chosen voltage?

Why it matters. The structures of the coronavirus spike protein, of new battery materials and of computer-chip transistors only a few nanometres wide were all found with electron beams. Cryo-electron microscopy, which won the 2017 Nobel Prize in Chemistry, now maps proteins atom by atom, and neutron and electron diffraction are used worldwide in materials laboratories. In each case the key number is the de Broglie wavelength $\lambda=h/\sqrt{2meV}$ (Result 17.6), set by the accelerating voltage.

What to do.

  1. Look up the wavelengths of visible light and the typical accelerating voltages of a scanning electron microscope ($1$–$30\ \text{kV}$) and a transmission electron microscope ($100$–$300\ \text{kV}$).
  2. Compute the non-relativistic de Broglie wavelength for each voltage with $\lambda=1.227/\sqrt V\ \text{nm}$ and tabulate it next to the wavelength of green light.
  3. For $100\ \text{kV}$ and $300\ \text{kV}$ also compute the relativistic value, $\lambda=h/\sqrt{2m_eeV\,(1+eV/2m_ec^2)}$, and find the percentage error of the simple formula.
  4. Find published resolution limits for real instruments and compare them with your wavelengths. Why is the real resolution worse than $\lambda$?
  5. Use an online virtual electron-diffraction simulation (or the ring pattern of a graphite sample, if your school has an electron-diffraction tube) to see how the ring radius changes with voltage.

Tools: Spreadsheet, calculator, manufacturers' specification sheets for electron microscopes, an electron-diffraction tube or a free online simulation.

Hand in: A table of voltage, wavelength (non-relativistic and relativistic) and real resolution; a graph of $\lambda$ against $1/\sqrt V$; and a paragraph explaining why electron microscopes can image atoms but light microscopes cannot.

Going further. In an electron-diffraction tube, the ring radius $r$ on the screen is roughly proportional to $\lambda$. Predict how $r$ changes when the voltage is raised from $2\ \text{kV}$ to $4\ \text{kV}$, and test it if you can.

Instructor note: the relativistic correction is about $5\%$ at $100\ \text{kV}$ and about $12$–$14\%$ at $300\ \text{kV}$ — a good illustration of where the school formula $1.227/\sqrt V$ nm stops working. Real resolution is limited by lens aberrations to roughly $0.05$–$0.2\ \text{nm}$, far worse than $\lambda$, but still about a thousand times better than the best light microscope. In the diffraction-tube test, $r\propto1/\sqrt V$ means the rings shrink by a factor $\sqrt2$.

🧪 Self-check quiz

0/5 correct

Q1. The de Broglie wavelength of a particle depends on its

Q2. The de Broglie wavelength of an electron accelerated from rest through $100\ \text{V}$ is about

Q3. An electron, a proton, a neutron and an alpha particle all move with the same speed. Which has the longest de Broglie wavelength?

Q4. For neutrons in thermal equilibrium at absolute temperature $T$, the de Broglie wavelength is proportional to

Q5. An electron, a proton, a deuteron and an alpha particle are each accelerated from rest through the same potential difference. Which has the shortest de Broglie wavelength?