Chapter 13 ยท Introduction

Chapter 13 โ€” Purification and Characterisation of Organic Compounds

Before an organic compound can be studied it must be made pure, and before it can be named its formula must be known. Sublimation, crystallisation, distillation, extraction and chromatography each exploit one physical difference; Lassaigne's test finds N, S, P and the halogens; and weighing the products of combustion and digestion turns a sample into percentages and a formula.

A pharmaceutical plant in Hyderabad makes paracetamol by the tonne. Before a single batch is pressed into tablets, a chemist recrystallises a sample, checks that it melts sharply at the right temperature, runs it on a thin-layer chromatography plate to make sure it gives one spot and only one, and sends a few milligrams for combustion analysis to confirm that the carbon, hydrogen and nitrogen percentages match $\mathrm{C_{8}H_{9}NO_{2}}$. In a university laboratory a research student extracts the bitter principle from neem leaves with an organic solvent, separates it from a dozen other leaf compounds on a silica column, and then has to answer the first question anyone asks about a new compound: what elements does it contain, and in what ratio? A forensic laboratory matches a seized powder with a known drug by the distance its spot travels on a plate. All three use the same two toolkits โ€” one for purifying an organic compound and one for finding out what is in it.

The first half of the chapter is about purification. A pure compound has a sharp melting point or a constant boiling point, and every method of purification exploits one physical difference between the compound and its impurities: sublimation (volatility of a solid), crystallisation (solubility that changes with temperature), the four kinds of distillation โ€” simple, fractional, under reduced pressure and in steam โ€” (boiling point and vapour pressure), differential extraction (the distribution coefficient $K_D$ between two immiscible solvents), and chromatography (different distribution between a stationary and a mobile phase, measured by $R_f$). The second half is analysis. Lassaigne's test fuses the compound with sodium so that covalent N, S and halogens become ions that simple colour tests can find. Then the quantitative methods โ€” Liebig's combustion for carbon and hydrogen, Dumas and Kjeldahl for nitrogen, Carius for halogens and sulphur, and the precipitation of phosphorus โ€” turn weighed products into percentages, and the percentages into empirical and molecular formulae. JEE Main asks steady numerical questions on these percentages almost every year.

Criteria of purityโ†’Sublimation & crystallisationโ†’Four distillationsโ†’$K_D$ and extractionโ†’Chromatography, $R_f$โ†’Lassaigne's testโ†’C, H by combustionโ†’N by Dumas & Kjeldahlโ†’X, S, Pโ†’Molecular formula
๐ŸŽฏ By the end of this chapter you canโ€ฆ
  • judge purity by melting and boiling points and choose the right method โ€” sublimation, crystallisation, simple, fractional, reduced-pressure or steam distillation, extraction or chromatography โ€” for a given mixture;
  • find the recovery on crystallisation and explain why steam distillation boils below $373\ \mathrm{K}$, using $p^\circ_\text{org}+p^\circ_\text{water}=P_\text{ext}$ to find the mass ratio of the distillate;
  • use the distribution law and $w_n=w_0\left(\tfrac{V}{V+K_Dv}\right)^n$ to compare one large extraction with several small ones;
  • read a TLC plate or a column: calculate $R_f$, relate it to polarity and adsorption, and predict the order of elution;
  • describe Lassaigne's test and identify N, S, N + S together, the halogens and P from the colours and precipitates, with the equations that produce them;
  • calculate $\%\mathrm{C}$ and $\%\mathrm{H}$ from a combustion, $\%\mathrm{N}$ by Dumas (with the aqueous-tension correction) and by Kjeldahl (including back-titration), and $\%\mathrm{X}$, $\%\mathrm{S}$ and $\%\mathrm{P}$ from the weighed precipitates;
  • go from analysis data and a molar mass (or vapour density) to the empirical and molecular formula;
  • solve JEE Main MCQ and numerical-answer problems on purification and analysis.

$0.30\ \mathrm{g}$ of ethanoic acid, $\mathrm{CH_{3}COOH}$, is burnt completely in the combustion train. By how much does the mass of the potash (KOH) bulbs increase?

Choose ethanoic acid and a sample of $0.30\ \mathrm{g}$. The sample is $0.005\ \mathrm{mol}$, its two carbons give $0.010\ \mathrm{mol}$ of $\mathrm{CO_{2}}$, and the KOH bulbs gain $0.440\ \mathrm{g}$; the calcium chloride tube, which comes first and takes the water, gains $0.180\ \mathrm{g}$ ($0.18\ \mathrm{g}$ is the water, not the $\mathrm{CO_{2}}$). The readouts give $\%\mathrm{C}=40.0$, $\%\mathrm{H}=6.7$, $\%\mathrm{O}=53.3$ and the empirical formula $\mathrm{CH_{2}O}$ (Result 13.6). Now switch to glucose at $0.30\ \mathrm{g}$: the gains โ€” and the percentages โ€” are exactly the same. Combustion gives only the empirical formula; the molar mass ($60$ against $180\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}$) is needed to fix the molecular formula.
Teaser โ€” The Combustion Train: From a Sample to a Formula

A weighed sample is burnt in dry oxygen over hot copper(II) oxide. Its hydrogen becomes water, caught by the weighed U-tube of anhydrous calcium chloride; its carbon becomes $\mathrm{CO_{2}}$, caught by the potash bulbs that follow. Choose a compound and a sample mass and press Play; the bars grow as the sample burns. (C = 12, H = 1, O = 16.)

0.30 g
KOH bulbs gain ($\mathrm{CO_{2}}$)โ€”
$\mathrm{CaCl_{2}}$ tube gain ($\mathrm{H_{2}O}$)โ€”
% C ยท % H ยท % Oโ€”
empirical formulaโ€”

Sections in this chapter

๐ŸŽฏ Chapter mixed test JEE Main ยท MCQJEE Main ยท Numerical

Eight problems drawn from both sections and shuffled, as in the real paper; one needs both sections at once. Answer each one and press Submit (NTA marking: $+4$ correct, $-1$ wrong, $0$ unanswered), or press โฑ Take as a timed test for the real-exam experience: $8$ questions at the JEE Main pace of $2.4$ minutes each, with the NTA question palette. In every numerical, turn the weighed product into the mass of the element first. (Atomic masses: H 1, C 12, N 14, O 16, S 32, Br 80, Ag 108, Ba 137.)

E1. JEE Main ยท MCQ The sodium fusion extract of an organic compound gives a violet colour with sodium nitroprusside. Another portion, boiled with dilute nitric acid and then treated with silver nitrate, gives a yellow precipitate that does not dissolve in concentrated ammonia. The compound contains (A) sulphur and iodine (B) sulphur and bromine (C) nitrogen and iodine (D) nitrogen, sulphur and chlorine

Sulphur Violet with nitroprusside is the test for sulphide: $\mathrm{S^{2-}(aq)+[Fe(CN)_{5}NO]^{2-}(aq)\rightarrow[Fe(CN)_{5}NOS]^{4-}(aq)}$ (Result 13.5).
Halogen Boiling with nitric acid removes any $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$ and $\mathrm{S^{2-}}$, so the precipitate is a silver halide. White and soluble in ammonia = AgCl; pale yellow, sparingly soluble = AgBr; yellow and insoluble = AgI.
Answer (A) sulphur and iodine.
โฑ Shortcut Nothing in the data tests for nitrogen (no Prussian blue was looked for), so (C) and (D) are guesses; the colour and the ammonia test separate (A) from (B).

E2. JEE Main ยท Numerical Bromobenzene ($M=157\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}$) is steam-distilled at an external pressure of $760\ \mathrm{mmHg}$. At the boiling temperature of the mixture the vapour pressure of water is $640\ \mathrm{mmHg}$. Find the mass of bromobenzene, in grams, that distils over together with $36\ \mathrm{g}$ of water. Give the answer to the nearest integer.

Pressures Immiscible liquids each exert their full vapour pressure (Principle 13.2): $p^\circ_\text{org}=760-640=120\ \mathrm{mmHg}$.
Mole ratio In the vapour, and so in the distillate, $\dfrac{n_\text{org}}{n_\text{water}}=\dfrac{120}{640}$. With $36\ \mathrm{g}=2\ \mathrm{mol}$ of water, $n_\text{org}=2\times\tfrac{120}{640}=0.375\ \mathrm{mol}$.
Answer $0.375\times157=58.9\ \mathrm{g}$, i.e. $59$.
โฑ Shortcut $\dfrac{m_\text{org}}{m_\text{water}}=\dfrac{p^\circ_\text{org}M_\text{org}}{p^\circ_\text{water}M_\text{water}}=\dfrac{120\times157}{640\times18}=1.64$. Using the pressure ratio alone ($0.19\times36=6.75$) forgets that bromobenzene molecules are almost nine times heavier than water molecules.

E3. JEE Main ยท Numerical In a Carius determination of sulphur, $0.320\ \mathrm{g}$ of an organic compound gave $0.466\ \mathrm{g}$ of barium sulphate. Find the percentage of sulphur in the compound. Give the answer to the nearest integer.

Mass of S $M(\mathrm{BaSO_{4}})=137+32+64=233$, so $m(\mathrm{S})=\dfrac{32}{233}\times0.466=0.064\ \mathrm{g}$ (Result 13.8).
Percentage $\%\mathrm{S}=\dfrac{0.064}{0.320}\times100$.
Answer $20\ \%$, i.e. $20$.
โฑ Shortcut $0.466\ \mathrm{g}$ is exactly $0.002\ \mathrm{mol}$ of $\mathrm{BaSO_{4}}$, so $0.002\ \mathrm{mol}$ S $=0.064\ \mathrm{g}$.

E4. JEE Main ยท MCQ Two compounds X and Y are run on a silica-gel TLC plate with the same solvent; X has $R_f=0.8$ and Y has $R_f=0.3$. Which statement is correct? (A) Y is the less polar compound. (B) On a silica-gel column eluted with the same solvent, X comes out first. (C) If the plate were developed until the solvent front had moved twice as far, the $R_f$ of X would double. (D) X is held more strongly by the stationary phase.

Meaning of $R_f$ A large $R_f$ means the compound spends most of its time in the mobile phase: it is adsorbed less strongly by the polar silica, so it is the less polar of the two (Definitions 13.6, 13.7). That rules out (A) and (D).
Column and plate The same partition decides a column: the less strongly held compound X moves faster and is eluted first. $R_f$ is a ratio of two distances that grow together, so it does not change with the length of the run, which rules out (C).
Answer (B).

E5. JEE Main ยท Numerical A compound contains only carbon, hydrogen and nitrogen. $0.186\ \mathrm{g}$ of it gives $0.528\ \mathrm{g}$ of $\mathrm{CO_{2}}$ and $0.126\ \mathrm{g}$ of $\mathrm{H_{2}O}$ on complete combustion, and its vapour density is $46.5$. Find the total number of atoms in one molecule of the compound. Give the answer to the nearest integer.

C and H $m(\mathrm{C})=\tfrac{12}{44}\times0.528=0.144\ \mathrm{g}$ ($0.012\ \mathrm{mol}$); $m(\mathrm{H})=\tfrac{2}{18}\times0.126=0.014\ \mathrm{g}$ ($0.014\ \mathrm{mol}$) (Result 13.6).
N by difference $m(\mathrm{N})=0.186-0.144-0.014=0.028\ \mathrm{g}=0.002\ \mathrm{mol}$. Ratio $\mathrm{C:H:N}=0.012:0.014:0.002=6:7:1$, empirical formula $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{7}N}$ (mass $93$).
Molecular formula $M=2\times46.5=93$, so the molecular formula is $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{7}N}$ (aniline).
Answer $6+7+1=14$ atoms, i.e. $14$.
โฑ Shortcut $0.186\ \mathrm{g}$ of a compound of $M=93$ is $0.002\ \mathrm{mol}$; $0.012\ \mathrm{mol}$ $\mathrm{CO_{2}}$ means 6 C, $0.007\ \mathrm{mol}$ $\mathrm{H_{2}O}$ means 7 H, and $93-72-7=14$ means one N.

E6. JEE Main ยท MCQ Which pairing of a mixture with its method of separation is incorrect? (A) camphor mixed with sand โ€” sublimation (B) glycerol from spent lye โ€” distillation under reduced pressure (C) sugar mixed with common salt โ€” sublimation (D) aniline from its mixture with water โ€” steam distillation

Check each Camphor sublimes and sand does not (Definition 13.2). Glycerol decomposes near its normal boiling point, so it is distilled at low pressure. Aniline is volatile in steam and immiscible with water (Definition 13.4).
The odd one Neither sugar nor salt sublimes, so sublimation cannot separate them; a difference in solubility (crystallisation from a suitable solvent) is needed.
Answer (C).
โฑ Shortcut Sublimation needs one component that sublimes โ€” think camphor, naphthalene, iodine, benzoic acid, anthracene.

E7. JEE Main ยท Numerical $100\ \mathrm{mL}$ of an aqueous solution contains $1.00\ \mathrm{g}$ of an organic bromo compound. It is shaken once with $50\ \mathrm{mL}$ of ether; the distribution coefficient (ether/water) is $8$. The ether layer is evaporated, and the whole residue, analysed by the Carius method, gives $1.504\ \mathrm{g}$ of silver bromide. Find the percentage of bromine in the compound. Give the answer to the nearest integer.

Extraction (13.1) Mass left in water after one extraction (Result 13.4): $w_1=1.00\times\dfrac{100}{100+8\times50}=0.20\ \mathrm{g}$, so the ether takes up $0.80\ \mathrm{g}$.
Carius (13.2) $m(\mathrm{Br})=\dfrac{80}{188}\times1.504=0.640\ \mathrm{g}$ (Result 13.8).
Answer $\%\mathrm{Br}=\dfrac{0.640}{0.80}\times100=80\ \%$, i.e. $80$.
โฑ Shortcut Dividing by the original $1.00\ \mathrm{g}$ gives $64$ โ€” the trap. The analysed sample is only what the ether extracted.

E8. JEE Main ยท MCQ Which of these nitrogen compounds does not give a Prussian blue colour in Lassaigne's test? (A) hydrazine, $\mathrm{H_{2}N{-}NH_{2}}$ (B) urea, $\mathrm{H_{2}NCONH_{2}}$ (C) aniline, $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}NH_{2}}$ (D) benzamide, $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CONH_{2}}$

What the test detects Sodium converts carbon and nitrogen together into cyanide, $\mathrm{Na+C+N\rightarrow NaCN}$, and the cyanide with iron(II) and iron(III) gives Prussian blue, $\mathrm{Fe_{4}[Fe(CN)_{6}]_{3}}$ (Definition 13.8, Result 13.5).
Hydrazine It has nitrogen but no carbon, so no cyanide can form.
Answer (A).
โฑ Shortcut No carbon โ†’ no $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$ โ†’ no Prussian blue. The same is true of hydroxylamine, $\mathrm{NH_{2}OH}$.
โœ… Before you start
Every calculation in Section 13.2 is the mole concept at work: moles from masses, percentage composition and the empirical and molecular formula (Section 1.2), and balanced equations and stoichiometry (Section 1.3). Kjeldahl's method is an acidโ€“base back-titration, so you need molarity (Section 5.1) and neutralisation (Section 6.3). Fractional and steam distillation rest on vapour pressure and Raoult's law (Section 5.2), and the distribution law is an equilibrium between two phases (Section 6.1). The chromatography and polarity arguments use dipole moments and hydrogen bonding (Section 3.2, Section 3.4). From physics: the combined gas law $\dfrac{p_1V_1}{T_1}=\dfrac{p_2V_2}{T_2}$ and Dalton's law of partial pressures, used to correct a gas volume to STP.