12.2 Isomerism in Coordination Compounds
Same formula, different compound: ligands can swap places with counter ions, water or the other complex ion, a ligand can turn round, two ligands can sit next to each other or opposite, and some complexes come as left- and right-handed mirror images. Learn to recognise every kind and to count the isomers of any octahedral or square planar complex.
Two compounds of formula $\mathrm{[PtCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]}$ are known. One, cisplatin, is among the most widely used anticancer drugs: it slips into the DNA of a dividing cell and binds two neighbouring guanine bases, kinking the helix. The other, transplatin, has the same atoms and the same bonds and is almost useless as a drug. The only difference is the arrangement of the ligands: in cisplatin the two chlorides are side by side, in transplatin they are opposite. In the same way, $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{4}]Cl}$ exists as a violet and a green solid, and $\mathrm{CrCl_{3}\cdot 6H_{2}O}$ as a violet, a light-green and a dark-green one.
Compounds with the same formula but different structures are isomers. Werner used isomer counts to prove that six-coordinate complexes are octahedral, and in 1911 he separated a cobalt complex into two mirror-image forms that rotate polarised light in opposite directions — showing that optical activity does not need carbon. In this section we meet the four kinds of structural isomerism and the two kinds of stereoisomerism (geometrical and optical), and build a reliable method for counting the isomers of $\mathrm{[MA_{4}B_{2}]}$, $\mathrm{[MA_{3}B_{3}]}$, $\mathrm{[M(AA)_{2}B_{2}]}$, $\mathrm{[M(AA)_{3}]}$ and the other types that JEE Main asks about. The vocabulary of ligands, coordination number and naming is from Section 12.1.
Structural isomerism
Isomers are compounds with the same molecular formula but different arrangements of atoms, and therefore different properties.
- Structural isomers differ in which atoms are bonded to which: different ligands in the coordination sphere, or the same ligand bonded through a different atom.
- Stereoisomers have the same ligands bonded through the same atoms, but arranged differently in space: geometrical and optical isomers.
- Ionisation isomerism: a counter ion and a ligand exchange places, so the isomers give different ions in solution. $\mathrm{[CoBr(NH_{3})_{5}]SO_{4}}$ and $\mathrm{[Co(NH_{3})_{5}(SO_{4})]Br}$. Needs a counter ion that can itself act as a ligand.
- Solvate (hydrate) isomerism: the special case where water (the solvent) is a ligand in one isomer and water of crystallisation in the other. $\mathrm{[Cr(H_{2}O)_{6}]Cl_{3}}$ (violet), $\mathrm{[CrCl(H_{2}O)_{5}]Cl_{2}\cdot H_{2}O}$ (light green), $\mathrm{[CrCl_{2}(H_{2}O)_{4}]Cl\cdot 2H_{2}O}$ (dark green).
- Linkage isomerism: an ambidentate ligand binds through different donor atoms. $\mathrm{[Co(NO_{2})(NH_{3})_{5}]Cl_{2}}$ (yellow, Co–N) and $\mathrm{[Co(ONO)(NH_{3})_{5}]Cl_{2}}$ (red, Co–O); likewise $\mathrm{M{-}SCN}$ / $\mathrm{M{-}NCS}$.
- Coordination isomerism: in a compound where both cation and anion are complex, ligands are distributed differently between the two metals. $\mathrm{[Co(NH_{3})_{6}][Cr(CN)_{6}]}$ and $\mathrm{[Cr(NH_{3})_{6}][Co(CN)_{6}]}$.
Because structural isomers release different ions, or contain different ligands, they differ in chemical behaviour: precipitation tests (silver nitrate for free halide, barium chloride for free sulphate), molar conductivity, the amount of water lost over a drying agent, and colour. Linkage isomers differ in colour and in their infrared spectra (an N-bonded and an O-bonded nitrite vibrate differently); the O-bonded red form of the cobalt complex slowly turns into the more stable yellow N-bonded form.
$\mathrm{[CrCl(H_{2}O)_{5}]Cl_{2}\cdot H_{2}O}$ and $\mathrm{[CrCl_{2}(H_{2}O)_{4}]Cl\cdot 2H_{2}O}$ are
Geometrical isomerism: cis/trans and fac/mer
Geometrical isomerism appears when identical ligands can occupy positions that are either adjacent (at $90^{\circ}$) or opposite (at $180^{\circ}$) to each other. That requires a geometry in which some positions are neighbours and some are opposite — square planar or octahedral.
Geometrical isomers are stereoisomers that differ in the relative positions of the ligands around the central atom. Two identical ligands on adjacent positions ($90^{\circ}$ apart) are cis; on opposite positions ($180^{\circ}$) they are trans.
For three identical ligands in an octahedron: if they occupy the three corners of one triangular face (all three mutually cis, every B–M–B angle $90^{\circ}$) the isomer is facial (fac); if they lie on a meridian — a half-circle around the metal, so that two of them are trans — the isomer is meridional (mer).
- Tetrahedral (CN 4): every position is adjacent to every other ($109.5^{\circ}$ apart), so there are no geometrical isomers.
- Square planar (CN 4): $\mathrm{[MA_{2}B_{2}]}$ and $\mathrm{[MA_{2}BC]}$ have 2 (cis, trans); $\mathrm{[MABCD]}$ has 3 (B, C or D trans to A); $\mathrm{[M(AB)_{2}]}$ has 2; $\mathrm{[MA_{3}B]}$ and $\mathrm{[M(AA)B_{2}]}$ have none.
- Octahedral (CN 6): $\mathrm{[MA_{5}B]}$ none; $\mathrm{[MA_{4}B_{2}]}$ 2 (cis, trans); $\mathrm{[MA_{3}B_{3}]}$ 2 (fac, mer); $\mathrm{[M(AA)_{2}B_{2}]}$ 2 (cis, trans); $\mathrm{[MA_{2}B_{2}C_{2}]}$ 5; $\mathrm{[M(AA)_{3}]}$ none.
In an octahedron every position has four cis neighbours and one trans partner, so any two positions are either cis or trans — there is no third possibility. That is why $\mathrm{[MA_{4}B_{2}]}$ has exactly two isomers.
Werner's proof of the octahedron. If six ligands sat at the corners of a flat hexagon, $\mathrm{[MA_{4}B_{2}]}$ would have three isomers (B's at positions 1,2; 1,3; 1,4 of the ring); a trigonal prism also gives three. The octahedron gives only two. Werner made dozens of $\mathrm{[MA_{4}B_{2}]}$ complexes and never found a third isomer — strong evidence for the octahedron, later confirmed by X-ray crystallography.
How many geometrical isomers does the octahedral complex $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(H_{2}O)_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$ ($\mathrm{MA_{2}B_{2}C_{2}}$) have?
Which complex shows no geometrical isomerism?
Optical isomerism
Hold your right hand up to a mirror: the image is a left hand. No turning of your right hand makes it fit into a left glove. Objects like this, which are not superimposable on their mirror images, are called chiral (Greek cheir, hand). Some complexes are chiral too.
A molecule or ion is chiral if it cannot be superimposed on its mirror image by any rotation. The two mirror-image forms are enantiomers (optical isomers). Enantiomers have identical physical and chemical properties except two: they rotate the plane of plane-polarised light by equal angles in opposite directions — the dextrorotatory ($d$, $+$, clockwise as seen by the observer) and laevorotatory ($l$, $-$) forms — and they react differently with other chiral substances.
Such substances are optically active. An equimolar mixture of the two enantiomers, a racemic mixture, shows no net rotation.
A complex is achiral (optically inactive) if it has a plane of symmetry — a mirror plane through the metal that reflects every ligand onto an identical one — or a centre of symmetry (every ligand has an identical one directly opposite it through the metal). If it has neither, it is chiral. For JEE Main:
- Square planar complexes are achiral: the plane of the molecule itself is a mirror plane (unless the ligands themselves are chiral).
- Tetrahedral complexes are chiral only with four different ligands or two unsymmetrical chelates — rare and seldom isolated.
- Octahedral: chirality needs chelating ligands or several different ligands arranged cis. $\mathrm{[M(AA)_{3}]}$ and cis-$\mathrm{[M(AA)_{2}B_{2}]}$ are chiral; trans-$\mathrm{[M(AA)_{2}B_{2}]}$ is achiral: the plane containing the metal and the four donor atoms of the two chelates reflects one B onto the other. The all-cis form of $\mathrm{[MA_{2}B_{2}C_{2}]}$ is chiral; $\mathrm{[MA_{4}B_{2}]}$ and $\mathrm{[MA_{3}B_{3}]}$ never are.
Can the mirror image of $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ be turned so that it fits exactly onto the original — for the cis isomer, and for the trans isomer?
Which of these is optically active?
Counting isomers systematically
JEE Main questions often ask "how many isomers", and the answer depends on exactly which kind is asked for: geometrical isomers (mirror-image pairs counted once), stereoisomers (geometrical plus optical, each enantiomer counted), or all isomers including structural ones. A careful, systematic count avoids both missing an isomer and counting one twice.
- Classify the formula as a type: replace the ligands by letters ($\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$ is $\mathrm{M(AA)B_{2}C_{2}}$). Check the geometry (CN 4 tetrahedral, CN 4 square planar or CN 6).
- Place chelates first: each didentate ligand must span two cis positions.
- Describe each arrangement by cis/trans relations between identical ligands (and fac/mer for triples). Two arrangements with the same description are usually the same isomer — but check, as in $\mathrm{MA_{2}B_{2}C_{2}}$, where "all cis" turns out to be a mirror-image pair.
- Test each geometrical isomer for chirality: look for a mirror plane. Count each chiral isomer twice.
- Add structural isomers only if asked: linkage (each ambidentate ligand doubles the choices, but check symmetry), ionisation, hydrate.
| Type (octahedral) | Example | Geometrical | Stereoisomers |
|---|---|---|---|
| $\mathrm{MA_{5}B}$ | $\mathrm{[CoCl(NH_{3})_{5}]^{2+}}$ | 1 | 1 |
| $\mathrm{MA_{4}B_{2}}$ | $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{4}]^{+}}$ | 2 | 2 |
| $\mathrm{MA_{3}B_{3}}$ | $\mathrm{[CoCl_{3}(NH_{3})_{3}]}$ | 2 | 2 |
| $\mathrm{MA_{4}BC}$ | $\mathrm{[CoBrCl(NH_{3})_{4}]^{+}}$ | 2 | 2 |
| $\mathrm{MA_{3}B_{2}C}$ | $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(H_{2}O)(NH_{3})_{3}]^{+}}$ | 3 | 3 |
| $\mathrm{MA_{2}B_{2}C_{2}}$ | $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(H_{2}O)_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$ | 5 | 6 |
| $\mathrm{MA_{2}B_{2}CD}$ | $\mathrm{[PtBrCl_{2}I(NH_{3})_{2}]}$ | 6 | 8 |
| $\mathrm{M(AA)_{3}}$ | $\mathrm{[Co(en)_{3}]^{3+}}$ | 1 | 2 |
| $\mathrm{M(AA)_{2}B_{2}}$ | $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ | 2 | 3 |
| $\mathrm{M(AA)_{2}BC}$ | $\mathrm{[CoCl(en)_{2}(NH_{3})]^{2+}}$ | 2 | 3 |
| $\mathrm{M(AA)B_{2}C_{2}}$ | $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$ | 3 | 4 |
| $\mathrm{M(AB)_{3}}$ | $\mathrm{[Cr(gly)_{3}]}$ | 2 (fac, mer) | 4 |
Square planar: $\mathrm{MA_{3}B}$ 1; $\mathrm{MA_{2}B_{2}}$ 2; $\mathrm{MA_{2}BC}$ 2; $\mathrm{MABCD}$ 3; $\mathrm{M(AB)_{2}}$ 2 — all achiral. Tetrahedral: no geometrical isomers.
1. "Geometrical" versus "stereo" versus "total". $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ has 2 geometrical isomers but 3 stereoisomers; $\mathrm{[MA_{2}B_{2}C_{2}]}$ has 5 geometrical but 6 stereoisomers. Read the question twice.
2. Tetrahedral complexes have no geometrical isomers, and square planar complexes are not optically active. Decide the geometry before counting ($\mathrm{[NiCl_{4}]^{2-}}$ tetrahedral, $\mathrm{[PtCl_{4}]^{2-}}$ square planar).
3. Only cis-$\mathrm{[M(AA)_{2}B_{2}]}$ is chiral; the trans form has a mirror plane. Both fac and mer $\mathrm{MA_{3}B_{3}}$ are achiral — but both fac and mer $\mathrm{[M(AB)_{3}]}$ (unsymmetrical chelates such as gly) are chiral.
4. A chelate can never span trans positions. en and ox are too short; they always occupy two cis positions.
5. Structural isomerism needs the right ligand. Linkage needs an ambidentate ligand ($\mathrm{NO_{2}^{-}}$, $\mathrm{SCN^{-}}$, $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$); ionisation needs a counter ion different from the ligands that could enter the sphere; hydrate isomers differ in the number of water molecules inside the sphere, not in the total water.
The total number of stereoisomers of $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ is
Exercises
en = ethane-1,2-diamine, ox = oxalate, gly = glycinate, py = pyridine. Molar masses: Ag $107.9$, Br $79.9$, Cl $35.5$, Cr $52.0$, H $1.0$, O $16.0\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}$. Assume octahedral geometry for CN 6.
- 1 What type of isomerism is shown by $\mathrm{[CoCl(NH_{3})_{5}]SO_{4}}$ and $\mathrm{[Co(NH_{3})_{5}(SO_{4})]Cl}$? Give a test that distinguishes them.
- 2 Write an ionisation isomer of $\mathrm{[PtBr_{2}(NH_{3})_{4}]Cl_{2}}$. How many moles of $\mathrm{AgCl}$ does one mole of the original compound give with excess $\mathrm{AgNO_{3}}$?
- 3 How many moles of $\mathrm{AgCl}$ does one mole of the dark-green isomer of $\mathrm{CrCl_{3}\cdot 6H_{2}O}$ give?
- 4 How many moles of water does one mole of the same dark-green isomer lose over concentrated sulphuric acid?
- 5 Which of $\mathrm{NH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{SCN^{-}}$, en, $\mathrm{NO_{2}^{-}}$, $\mathrm{H_{2}O}$, $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$ can give rise to linkage isomerism? Write the linkage isomer of $\mathrm{[Co(NH_{3})_{5}(SCN)]^{2+}}$ (S-bonded).
- 6 Write a coordination isomer of $\mathrm{[Co(NH_{3})_{6}][Cr(C_{2}O_{4})_{3}]}$.
- 7 How many ions does one formula unit of $\mathrm{[Co(NH_{3})_{6}][Cr(CN)_{6}]}$ give in water?
- 8 What mass of $\mathrm{AgBr}$ is precipitated from $0.010\ \mathrm{mol}$ of $\mathrm{[Co(NH_{3})_{5}(SO_{4})]Br}$ by excess silver nitrate?
- 1 Draw the geometrical isomers of $\mathrm{[PtCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]}$. Which one has a dipole moment?
- 2 Explain why $\mathrm{[PtCl(NH_{3})_{3}]^{+}}$ has no geometrical isomers.
- 3 How many geometrical isomers does square planar $\mathrm{[PtBrCl(NH_{3})(py)]}$ have?
- 4 Explain why $\mathrm{[ZnCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]}$ (tetrahedral) shows no geometrical isomerism while $\mathrm{[PtCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]}$ does.
- 5 How many geometrical isomers does $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{4}]^{+}}$ have? Give the Cl–Co–Cl angle in each.
- 6 In fac-$\mathrm{[Co(NO_{2})_{3}(NH_{3})_{3}]}$, how many of the $\mathrm{O_{2}N{-}Co{-}NO_{2}}$ angles are $90^{\circ}$? How does mer differ?
- 7 Square planar $\mathrm{[Pt(gly)_{2}]}$: name the isomers and say which atoms are trans to each other in each.
- 8 If six ligands were arranged at the corners of a regular planar hexagon, how many isomers would $\mathrm{[MA_{4}B_{2}]}$ have?
- 1 Why is $\mathrm{[Co(en)_{3}]^{3+}}$ optically active although all six donor atoms are identical?
- 2 Is trans-$\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ optically active? Identify its symmetry element.
- 3 How many stereoisomers does $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ have in all?
- 4 How many optically active forms does $\mathrm{[Cr(C_{2}O_{4})_{3}]^{3-}}$ have?
- 5 How many stereoisomers does $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$ have?
- 6 How many stereoisomers does $\mathrm{[Cr(gly)_{3}]}$ have?
- 7 How many of the stereoisomers of $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(H_{2}O)_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$ are optically active?
- 8 A student claims that $\mathrm{[PtCl(Br)(NH_{3})(py)]}$ (square planar, four different ligands) must be optically active "because it has four different groups, like a chiral carbon". Explain the error.
- 1 How many isomers (geometrical and linkage) are possible for square planar $\mathrm{[PtCl(NO_{2})(NH_{3})_{2}]}$?
- 2 How many geometrical isomers has $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(H_{2}O)(NH_{3})_{3}]^{+}}$?
- 3 How many stereoisomers has $\mathrm{[PtBrCl_{2}I(NH_{3})_{2}]}$ (octahedral Pt(IV))?
- 4 How many of the following are chiral: cis-$\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$, trans-$\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$, $\mathrm{[Co(en)_{3}]^{3+}}$, fac-$\mathrm{[CoCl_{3}(NH_{3})_{3}]}$, $\mathrm{[PtCl_{2}(en)]}$, mer-$\mathrm{[Cr(gly)_{3}]}$?
- 5 The cis and trans isomers of $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{4}]Cl}$ have the same molar conductivity and give the same amount of $\mathrm{AgCl}$. Suggest two physical properties that distinguish them.
- 6 How many isomers (geometrical and linkage) are possible for square planar $\mathrm{[Pt(SCN)_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]}$?
- 7 How many isomers would $\mathrm{[MA_{3}B_{3}]}$ have if the six ligands were at the corners of a regular planar hexagon?
- 8 Explain why a chelating en ligand can never occupy two trans positions of an octahedron, and use this to show that trans-$\mathrm{[M(AA)_{2}B_{2}]}$ must have both chelates in one plane.
E1. JEE Main · MCQ Which of the following can exist as a pair of enantiomers? (A) trans-$\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ (B) $\mathrm{[CoCl_{3}(NH_{3})_{3}]}$ (C) cis-$\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ (D) $\mathrm{[PtCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]}$
E2. JEE Main · Numerical The total number of stereoisomers (geometrical and optical) of $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$ is ____. Give the answer to the nearest integer.
E3. JEE Main · MCQ $\mathrm{[CoBr(NH_{3})_{5}]SO_{4}}$ and $\mathrm{[Co(NH_{3})_{5}(SO_{4})]Br}$ are an example of (A) linkage isomerism (B) ionisation isomerism (C) coordination isomerism (D) hydrate isomerism
E4. JEE Main · Numerical The number of geometrical isomers of the octahedral complex $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(H_{2}O)_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$ is ____. Give the answer to the nearest integer.
E5. JEE Main · MCQ Which complex shows neither geometrical nor optical isomerism? (A) $\mathrm{[PtCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]}$ (B) $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{4}]^{+}}$ (C) $\mathrm{[Co(en)_{3}]^{3+}}$ (D) $\mathrm{[ZnCl_{2}(NH_{3})_{2}]}$ (tetrahedral)
E6. JEE Main · Numerical Let $x$ be the number of stereoisomers of $\mathrm{[Co(C_{2}O_{4})_{3}]^{3-}}$, $y$ the number of stereoisomers of $\mathrm{[CoCl_{2}(en)_{2}]^{+}}$ and $z$ the number of geometrical isomers of square planar $\mathrm{[PtBrCl(NH_{3})(py)]}$. Find $x+y+z$. Give the answer to the nearest integer.
Research question. Can you build and count every isomer of a complex with your own hands — and why does the arrangement matter so much for platinum anticancer drugs?
Why it matters. Cisplatin, carboplatin and oxaliplatin are used in hospitals worldwide against testicular, ovarian, lung and colon cancers. All three are square planar platinum(II) complexes with two leaving groups cis to each other; the trans arrangement cannot bind two neighbouring DNA bases. Pharmaceutical chemists must also control chirality: oxaliplatin contains a chiral diamine, and only one form is used in the medicine.
What to do.
- Make octahedral models: a small ball of clay (the metal) and six toothpicks along $\pm x$, $\pm y$, $\pm z$; coloured beads for the ligands, and a bent pipe-cleaner for each chelate (it must join two adjacent tips).
- Build every arrangement you can find of $\mathrm{MA_{4}B_{2}}$, $\mathrm{MA_{3}B_{3}}$, $\mathrm{M(AA)_{2}B_{2}}$ and $\mathrm{MA_{2}B_{2}C_{2}}$. Turn the models to throw out duplicates and record how many distinct ones remain.
- For each model, build its mirror image (swap the beads on $+x$ and $-x$) and try to turn it into the original. Record which are chiral.
- Compare your counts with Result 12.7 and with Interactive 1. Then read a short review article or an encyclopaedia entry on platinum anticancer drugs and summarise in your own words why the cis geometry is essential.
Tools: Modelling clay, toothpicks, coloured beads, pipe-cleaners, a small mirror, this section's interactives.
Hand in: A table of your isomer counts (geometrical and stereo) with photographs or sketches of each isomer, and one paragraph on cisplatin versus transplatin.
Going further. Count the isomers of $\mathrm{MABCDEF}$ (six different ligands). Hint: fix A at the top; the ligand trans to A can be chosen in 5 ways, and the remaining four go round a square. Interactive-style counting gives 15 geometrical isomers, every one chiral — 30 stereoisomers.
🧪 Self-check quiz
Q1. $\mathrm{[Co(NO_{2})(NH_{3})_{5}]Cl_{2}}$ and $\mathrm{[Co(ONO)(NH_{3})_{5}]Cl_{2}}$ are
Q2. The number of stereoisomers of $\mathrm{[Co(en)_{3}]^{3+}}$ is
Q3. Square planar complexes of the type $\mathrm{[MABCD]}$ are not optically active because
Q4. fac and mer isomers are possible for
Q5. Violet $\mathrm{[Cr(H_{2}O)_{6}]Cl_{3}}$ and light-green $\mathrm{[CrCl(H_{2}O)_{5}]Cl_{2}\cdot H_{2}O}$ are best described as