15.4 Aromatic Hydrocarbons
Benzene, $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}}$, is as unsaturated as a triene on paper, yet it substitutes instead of adding. Naming benzene derivatives, the structure of benzene (Kekulé, resonance, delocalised π cloud, equal bonds), aromaticity and Hückel's $(4n+2)$ rule, the σ-complex mechanism of electrophilic substitution, halogenation, nitration, sulphonation, Friedel–Crafts alkylation and acylation, and the directing influence of substituents.
In 1825 Michael Faraday collected an oily liquid from the gas that lit London's streets. Its formula, $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}}$, has eight hydrogens fewer than hexane — the unsaturation of three double bonds and a ring — so it ought to decolourise bromine water at once, like hexa-1,3,5-triene. It does not. Benzene ignores bromine water and cold permanganate; with bromine and an iron catalyst it swaps a hydrogen for a bromine and keeps its ring intact. Hydrogenating it releases about $150\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$ less heat than three double bonds should. Something about the ring of six makes it unusually stable.
That something is aromaticity. In this section we name benzene derivatives, explain the structure of benzene by resonance and by its delocalised π electrons, state Hückel's $(4n+2)$ rule for deciding which rings are aromatic, and then study the reaction that defines aromatic chemistry — electrophilic substitution — with its mechanism, its main examples (halogenation, nitration, sulphonation, Friedel–Crafts alkylation and acylation) and the rules by which a group already on the ring decides where the next one goes. We use resonance and the inductive effect (Chapter 14), the carbocation stabilities of Section 14.3 and the cyclic trimerisation of ethyne from Section 15.3.
Nomenclature and the structure of benzene
Aromatic hydrocarbons, or arenes, are hydrocarbons containing one or more benzene-like rings that show aromatic character (Definition 15.11). Benzenoid arenes contain benzene rings: benzene, toluene (methylbenzene), the xylenes (dimethylbenzenes), naphthalene $\mathrm{C_{10}H_{8}}$ (two fused rings), anthracene $\mathrm{C_{14}H_{10}}$ (three). Aromatic compounds without a benzene ring, such as the tropylium ion $\mathrm{C_{7}H_{7}^{+}}$ or pyridine, are called non-benzenoid.
The group $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}{-}}$ is phenyl (Ph); $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}{-}}$ is benzyl; a general aryl group is written Ar.
Naming benzene derivatives. A single substituent is named as a prefix to benzene (chlorobenzene, nitrobenzene, ethylbenzene), except that several compounds keep accepted names that IUPAC uses as parent names: toluene $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH_{3}}$, phenol $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}OH}$, aniline $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}NH_{2}}$, anisole $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}OCH_{3}}$, benzaldehyde, benzoic acid, acetophenone $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}COCH_{3}}$, styrene $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH{=}CH_{2}}$. For two substituents the relative positions 1,2-, 1,3- and 1,4- are also called ortho (o-), meta (m-) and para (p-). In IUPAC names, ring positions are numbered to give the lowest set of locants; if a parent name such as toluene or phenol is used, its group is C1; otherwise, on a tie, the substituent cited first in alphabetical order gets the lower number.
| Compound | IUPAC name | Common name |
|---|---|---|
| $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{4}(CH_{3})_{2}}$, 1,2 | 1,2-dimethylbenzene | o-xylene |
| $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{4}Cl_{2}}$, 1,3 | 1,3-dichlorobenzene | m-dichlorobenzene |
| $\mathrm{CH_{3}C_{6}H_{4}NO_{2}}$, 1,4 | 1-methyl-4-nitrobenzene (4-nitrotoluene) | p-nitrotoluene |
| $\mathrm{BrC_{6}H_{4}Cl}$, 1,2 | 1-bromo-2-chlorobenzene | o-bromochlorobenzene |
| $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{3}(CH_{3})_{3}}$, 1,3,5 | 1,3,5-trimethylbenzene | mesitylene |
| $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH(CH_{3})_{2}}$ | (propan-2-yl)benzene | isopropylbenzene, cumene |
Because all six positions of benzene are equivalent, the number of structural isomers depends only on the pattern of substituents:
- $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}X}$: $1$ · $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{4}X_{2}}$ or $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{4}XY}$: $3$ (o, m, p)
- $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{3}X_{3}}$: $3$ (1,2,3; 1,2,4; 1,3,5) · $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{3}X_{2}Y}$: $6$ · $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{3}XYZ}$: $10$
- $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{2}X_{4}}$: $3$ (as for $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{4}X_{2}}$ — count the H atoms instead)
Aromatic isomers of $\mathrm{C_{8}H_{10}}$: $4$ (ethylbenzene and the three xylenes); of $\mathrm{C_{9}H_{12}}$: $8$ (propylbenzene, isopropylbenzene, three ethyltoluenes, three trimethylbenzenes).
Kekulé's structure and its problem. In 1865 August Kekulé proposed a six-membered ring of carbon atoms with alternating single and double bonds, one H on each carbon. It explains the formula and the fact that benzene gives only one monosubstitution product. But it predicts two different 1,2-dibromobenzenes — one with the two Br atoms across a double bond, one across a single bond — and only one is known. Kekulé suggested the double bonds oscillate rapidly between the two positions. Neither the two-isomer problem nor benzene's resistance to addition is really explained by alternating bonds.
Resonance. Benzene is the resonance hybrid of the two Kekulé structures, which differ only in the placing of the π electrons. Neither structure exists; each C–C bond is a "one-and-a-half" bond. X-ray diffraction confirms it: all six C–C bonds are $139\ \mathrm{pm}$ — between C–C ($154\ \mathrm{pm}$) and C=C ($134\ \mathrm{pm}$) — and the ring is a regular hexagon. The hybrid is drawn as a hexagon with a circle.
The orbital picture. Each carbon is $sp^{2}$ hybridised, forming σ bonds to two neighbouring carbons and one hydrogen at $120^{\circ}$; the whole molecule, all twelve atoms, is flat. Each carbon keeps one $p$ orbital perpendicular to the ring, holding one electron. Each $p$ orbital overlaps equally with both neighbours, so the six π electrons are not localised in three double bonds but spread over the whole ring as two doughnut-shaped clouds, above and below the plane. In molecular-orbital language, the six $p$ orbitals combine into six π molecular orbitals: three bonding and three antibonding. The six π electrons exactly fill the three bonding orbitals — a closed shell with no electrons in non-bonding or antibonding levels — which is the source of the extra stability.
Resonance energy. Adding $\mathrm{H_{2}}$ to cyclohexene releases $120\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$. A ring with three localised double bonds ("cyclohexatriene") should release $3\times120=360\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$; benzene actually releases only $208\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$. Benzene is therefore about $150\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$ more stable than any single Kekulé structure: this is its resonance (delocalisation) energy. Reactions that destroy the π sextet (additions) give up this energy, so benzene prefers reactions that keep it (substitutions).
Where benzene comes from. Benzene and its homologues are obtained from coal tar and from petroleum (catalytic reforming). In the laboratory: (i) cyclic trimerisation of ethyne through a red-hot iron tube ($\mathrm{3C_{2}H_{2}\rightarrow C_{6}H_{6}}$, Section 15.3); (ii) heating sodium benzoate with soda lime (decarboxylation), $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}COONa+NaOH\xrightarrow{CaO,\ \Delta}C_{6}H_{6}+Na_{2}CO_{3}}$; (iii) heating phenol with zinc dust, $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}OH+Zn\rightarrow C_{6}H_{6}+ZnO}$.
All C–C bonds in benzene are $139\ \mathrm{pm}$ long. The best explanation is that
Aromaticity and Hückel's rule
Benzene's special stability is shared by many other rings — some neutral, some ions, some containing nitrogen, oxygen or sulphur. What they have in common was found by Erich Hückel in 1931 from molecular-orbital theory: in a flat, fully conjugated ring the π molecular orbitals come as one lowest level followed by degenerate pairs, so a closed shell (every bonding level full, nothing half-filled) needs $2,6,10,14,\dots$ π electrons.
A molecule or ion is aromatic if it has all four features: (1) it is cyclic; (2) the ring is planar (or nearly so); (3) it is fully conjugated — every ring atom has a $p$ orbital perpendicular to the ring (no $sp^{3}$ ring atom); (4) the ring holds $(4n+2)$ π electrons, $n=0,1,2,\dots$ (Hückel's rule). Aromatic compounds are unusually stable and react by substitution rather than addition.
A cyclic, planar, fully conjugated system with $4n$ π electrons is antiaromatic — less stable than the open-chain analogue (e.g. cyclobutadiene, which exists only fleetingly). A ring that fails (1), (2) or (3) is non-aromatic: it behaves like an ordinary alkene.
A planar, cyclic, fully conjugated system is aromatic when its number of π electrons is
$$N_{\pi}=4n+2\qquad(n=0,1,2,\dots):\ 2,\ 6,\ 10,\ 14,\ \dots$$and antiaromatic when $N_{\pi}=4n$ ($4,8,\dots$). Rules for counting $N_{\pi}$: each C=C in the ring gives $2$; a ring carbanion ($\mathrm{\ddot{C}^{-}}$) gives $2$ (its lone pair is in the $p$ orbital); a ring carbocation gives $0$ (empty $p$ orbital) but keeps conjugation; a ring heteroatom gives $2$ if its lone pair has to be in the $p$ orbital (pyrrole N–H, furan O, thiophene S) and $0$ extra if it already has a π bond and its lone pair lies in the ring plane (pyridine N). An $sp^{3}$ ring atom ($\mathrm{CH_{2}}$) breaks the conjugation.
| Species | Ring | $N_{\pi}$ | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| benzene, pyridine | 6 | 6 ($n=1$) | aromatic |
| cyclopentadienyl anion $\mathrm{C_{5}H_{5}^{-}}$; pyrrole, furan, thiophene | 5 | 6 | aromatic |
| tropylium (cycloheptatrienyl) cation $\mathrm{C_{7}H_{7}^{+}}$ | 7 | 6 | aromatic |
| cyclopropenyl cation $\mathrm{C_{3}H_{3}^{+}}$ | 3 | 2 ($n=0$) | aromatic |
| naphthalene; cyclooctatetraene dianion $\mathrm{C_{8}H_{8}^{2-}}$ | 10 / 8 | 10 ($n=2$) | aromatic |
| cyclobutadiene; cyclopentadienyl cation $\mathrm{C_{5}H_{5}^{+}}$ | 4 / 5 | 4 | antiaromatic |
| cyclopentadiene; cycloheptatriene | 5 / 7 | (4 / 6) | non-aromatic ($sp^{3}$ $\mathrm{CH_{2}}$) |
| cyclooctatetraene $\mathrm{C_{8}H_{8}}$ | 8 | 8 | non-aromatic (tub-shaped, not planar) |
Two consequences show the rule at work. Cyclopentadiene ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}\approx16$) is about as acidic as water — astonishing for a hydrocarbon — because its conjugate base, $\mathrm{C_{5}H_{5}^{-}}$, is aromatic. And cyclooctatetraene avoids being antiaromatic by puckering into a tub, so it behaves as an ordinary polyene that adds bromine readily; with two extra electrons ($\mathrm{C_{8}H_{8}^{2-}}$, $10$ π electrons) it becomes planar and aromatic.
- Ring? Look for one closed loop of atoms (for fused rings, the outer periphery).
- Every ring atom $sp^{2}$ (or $sp$)? A $\mathrm{CH_{2}}$ or other $sp^{3}$ atom in the ring → non-aromatic. A carbocation or carbanion centre counts as $sp^{2}$.
- Planar? Small rings are; large ($\ge8$) neutral $4n$ rings usually pucker.
- Count π electrons (Rule 15.22) — don't count a lone pair that lies in the ring plane.
- $4n+2$ → aromatic; $4n$ (and planar, conjugated) → antiaromatic.
In the Hückel explorer choose the cyclopentadienyl cation, $\mathrm{C_{5}H_{5}^{+}}$. What will the Frost diagram and the readouts show?
Pyrrole ($\mathrm{C_{4}H_{4}NH}$) is aromatic, but pyrrole is a much weaker base than pyridine. Why?
Electrophilic aromatic substitution
The delocalised π cloud makes benzene electron-rich, so it is attacked by electrophiles. But where an alkene would add the electrophile and a nucleophile, benzene loses a proton instead and gets its aromatic sextet back. Overall, an $\mathrm{H}$ on the ring is replaced by an $\mathrm{E}$: electrophilic aromatic substitution (EAS).
- Generation of the electrophile $\mathrm{E^{+}}$ from the reagent, usually with a catalyst (a Lewis acid such as $\mathrm{FeCl_{3}}$ or $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$, or concentrated $\mathrm{H_{2}SO_{4}}$).
- Formation of the σ-complex (slow, rate-determining): two π electrons of the ring form a σ bond to $\mathrm{E}$. The attacked carbon becomes $sp^{3}$, aromaticity is lost, and the positive charge is delocalised over the remaining five carbons — mainly on the carbons ortho and para to the $sp^{3}$ carbon (three resonance structures). This carbocation is called the arenium ion or σ-complex (Wheland intermediate).
- Loss of a proton (fast): a base ($\mathrm{HSO_{4}^{-}}$, $\mathrm{FeCl_{4}^{-}}$, $\mathrm{AlCl_{4}^{-}}$) removes $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ from the $sp^{3}$ carbon; the C–H electron pair returns to the ring, restoring the aromatic sextet. The catalyst is regenerated.
The σ-complex is a true intermediate (an energy minimum between two transition states). Losing $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ (substitution) rather than adding a nucleophile (addition) is favoured because it regains about $150\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$ of resonance energy.
1. Halogenation. Chlorine or bromine alone is not electrophilic enough. A Lewis acid (anhydrous $\mathrm{FeCl_{3}}$, $\mathrm{FeBr_{3}}$ or $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$, or iron filings, which form $\mathrm{FeBr_{3}}$ with bromine) polarises the X–X bond and in effect delivers $\mathrm{X^{+}}$. The reaction is done in the dark, at room temperature:
$$\mathrm{Cl_{2}+FeCl_{3}\rightarrow Cl^{+}+[FeCl_{4}]^{-}}$$ $$\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}+Cl_{2}\xrightarrow{\text{anhyd. }FeCl_{3},\ \text{dark}}C_{6}H_{5}Cl+HCl}$$(In bright sunlight and without a catalyst, chlorine instead adds to benzene by a free-radical route: $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}+3Cl_{2}\xrightarrow{h\nu}C_{6}H_{6}Cl_{6}}$, benzene hexachloride (BHC), whose γ-isomer was used as the insecticide gammexane/lindane. Iodination is reversible and needs an oxidising agent such as $\mathrm{HNO_{3}}$ to remove the HI.)
2. Nitration. A mixture of concentrated nitric and sulphuric acids (the nitrating mixture) at $323$–$333\ \mathrm{K}$ converts benzene into nitrobenzene. Sulphuric acid, the stronger acid, protonates nitric acid, which loses water to give the electrophile, the nitronium ion $\mathrm{NO_{2}^{+}}$ (linear, $\mathrm{O{=}\overset{+}{N}{=}O}$):
$$\mathrm{HNO_{3}+2H_{2}SO_{4}\rightleftharpoons NO_{2}^{+}+H_{3}O^{+}+2HSO_{4}^{-}}$$ $$\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}+HNO_{3}\xrightarrow[323{-}333\ K]{conc.\ H_{2}SO_{4}}C_{6}H_{5}NO_{2}+H_{2}O}$$At higher temperatures the product is nitrated again (to 1,3-dinitrobenzene — meta, see below).
3. Sulphonation. Heating benzene with concentrated sulphuric acid, or better with fuming sulphuric acid (oleum, $\mathrm{H_{2}SO_{4}+SO_{3}}$), gives benzenesulphonic acid. The electrophile is sulphur trioxide (electron-poor S) or its protonated form $\mathrm{HSO_{3}^{+}}$:
$$\mathrm{2H_{2}SO_{4}\rightleftharpoons SO_{3}+H_{3}O^{+}+HSO_{4}^{-}}$$ $$\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}+H_{2}SO_{4}(SO_{3})\xrightarrow{\Delta}C_{6}H_{5}SO_{3}H+H_{2}O}$$Unlike the others, sulphonation is reversible: heating benzenesulphonic acid with dilute acid (steam) removes the $\mathrm{{-}SO_{3}H}$ group again.
4. Friedel–Crafts alkylation. An alkyl halide with anhydrous $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$ alkylates the ring (Charles Friedel and James Crafts, 1877). $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$ pulls the halide off to give a carbocation (or a strongly polarised $\mathrm{R^{\delta+}\cdots Cl\cdots AlCl_{3}^{\delta-}}$ complex):
$$\mathrm{CH_{3}Cl+AlCl_{3}\rightarrow CH_{3}^{+}+[AlCl_{4}]^{-}}$$ $$\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}+CH_{3}Cl\xrightarrow{\text{anhyd. }AlCl_{3}}C_{6}H_{5}CH_{3}+HCl}$$Alkenes with an acid (e.g. propene with HF or $\mathrm{H_{3}PO_{4}}$, or with $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}/HCl}$) also alkylate benzene, through the carbocation formed by protonation; this is how cumene is made industrially.
- Rearrangement. The carbocation can rearrange (1,2-hydride or methyl shift) to a more stable one before it attacks. 1-Chloropropane gives mainly isopropylbenzene (cumene): $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}\overset{+}{C}H_{2}\rightarrow CH_{3}\overset{+}{C}HCH_{3}}$; 1-chloro-2-methylpropane gives tert-butylbenzene. A straight chain of three or more carbons cannot be attached this way.
- Polyalkylation. The alkyl group activates the ring (+I, hyperconjugation), so the product is more reactive than benzene and is alkylated again (di-, trialkylbenzenes). A large excess of benzene is used to favour the monoalkyl product.
- Strongly deactivated rings do not react (nitrobenzene is inert enough to be used as a solvent). Rings carrying $\mathrm{{-}NH_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}NHR}$ or $\mathrm{{-}NR_{2}}$ do not react either: the nitrogen lone pair binds the Lewis acid $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$, and the resulting $\mathrm{{-}\overset{+}{N}H_{2}{-}\overset{-}{Al}Cl_{3}}$ group strongly deactivates the ring.
- Aryl and vinyl halides cannot be used as the alkylating agent: their C–X bonds (on $sp^{2}$ carbon) do not give carbocations.
5. Friedel–Crafts acylation. An acyl chloride ($\mathrm{RCOCl}$) or acid anhydride with anhydrous $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$ gives an aryl ketone. The electrophile is the acylium ion $\mathrm{R{-}C{\equiv}O^{+}}$, stabilised by resonance ($\mathrm{R{-}\overset{+}{C}{=}O\leftrightarrow R{-}C{\equiv}\overset{+}{O}}$):
$$\mathrm{CH_{3}COCl+AlCl_{3}\rightarrow CH_{3}CO^{+}+[AlCl_{4}]^{-}}$$ $$\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}+CH_{3}COCl\xrightarrow{\text{anhyd. }AlCl_{3}}C_{6}H_{5}COCH_{3}+HCl}$$ $$\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}+(CH_{3}CO)_{2}O\xrightarrow{\text{anhyd. }AlCl_{3}}C_{6}H_{5}COCH_{3}+CH_{3}COOH}$$Acylation is free of both main problems of alkylation: the acylium ion does not rearrange, and the C=O group of the product deactivates the ring, so only one acyl group goes in. (The product ketone binds $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$, so at least one mole of catalyst per mole of ketone is needed.) Acylation followed by reduction of C=O to $\mathrm{CH_{2}}$ (Clemmensen or Wolff–Kishner reduction, Chapter 17) is the standard route to straight-chain alkylbenzenes: benzene $\xrightarrow{\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}COCl/AlCl_{3}}}$ $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}COCH_{2}CH_{3}}$ $\xrightarrow{\mathrm{Zn(Hg)/HCl}}$ propylbenzene.
Other reactions. Under forcing conditions benzene does add: $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}+3H_{2}\xrightarrow{Ni,\ 473\ K}C_{6}H_{12}}$ (cyclohexane). It burns with a very sooty flame (high carbon content): $\mathrm{2C_{6}H_{6}+15O_{2}\rightarrow12CO_{2}+6H_{2}O}$.
| Reaction | Reagent / catalyst | Electrophile | Product from benzene |
|---|---|---|---|
| chlorination / bromination | $\mathrm{Cl_{2}/FeCl_{3}}$; $\mathrm{Br_{2}/FeBr_{3}}$, dark | $\mathrm{Cl^{+}}$, $\mathrm{Br^{+}}$ (complexed) | $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}Cl}$, $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}Br}$ |
| nitration | conc. $\mathrm{HNO_{3}}$ + conc. $\mathrm{H_{2}SO_{4}}$ | $\mathrm{NO_{2}^{+}}$ | $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}NO_{2}}$ |
| sulphonation | oleum ($\mathrm{H_{2}SO_{4}+SO_{3}}$) | $\mathrm{SO_{3}}$ / $\mathrm{HSO_{3}^{+}}$ | $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}SO_{3}H}$ |
| F–C alkylation | $\mathrm{RCl}$ + anhyd. $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$ | $\mathrm{R^{+}}$ | $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}R}$ (may rearrange) |
| F–C acylation | $\mathrm{RCOCl}$ + anhyd. $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$ | $\mathrm{RCO^{+}}$ | $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}COR}$ |
In the nitration of benzene, the role of concentrated sulphuric acid is to
Directive influence of substituents
When a benzene ring already carries a group G, an electrophile can attack ortho, meta or para to it. Experiment shows two clear patterns. Toluene nitrates about 25 times faster than benzene and gives mainly 2- and 4-nitrotoluene; nitrobenzene nitrates millions of times more slowly and gives mainly 1,3-dinitrobenzene. The group decides both the rate and the position.
A substituent is activating if the substituted benzene undergoes electrophilic substitution faster than benzene, and deactivating if slower. It is an ortho/para director if the new group enters mainly at the 2- and 4-positions, and a meta director if it enters mainly at the 3-position.
| Class | Groups (strongest first) | Electronic effect |
|---|---|---|
| o/p directing, activating | $\mathrm{{-}NH_{2},\ {-}NHR,\ {-}NR_{2},\ {-}OH,\ {-}OCH_{3},\ {-}NHCOCH_{3},\ {-}CH_{3}}$ and other alkyl, $\mathrm{{-}C_{6}H_{5}}$ | $+M$ (lone pair on the atom next to the ring) outweighs $-I$; alkyl: $+I$ and hyperconjugation |
| o/p directing, deactivating | $\mathrm{{-}F,\ {-}Cl,\ {-}Br,\ {-}I}$ | $-I$ outweighs $+M$ (rate), but $+M$ decides the position |
| meta directing, deactivating | $\mathrm{{-}NO_{2},\ {-}N(CH_{3})_{3}^{+},\ {-}CN,\ {-}SO_{3}H,\ {-}CHO,\ {-}COR,\ {-}COOH,\ {-}COOR,\ {-}CCl_{3}}$ | $-M$ and/or $-I$; the atom next to the ring is $\delta+$ or $+$ and has no lone pair |
Rule of thumb: a group whose first atom carries a lone pair, or an alkyl group, directs ortho/para; a group whose first atom is part of a multiple bond to a more electronegative atom, or carries a positive charge, directs meta. All activating groups are ortho/para directors; all meta directors are deactivating.
Why — the σ-complex decides. The rate-determining step makes the σ-complex, whose positive charge sits on the carbons ortho and para to the point of attack. Compare the three possible σ-complexes for a ring carrying G:
- Ortho or para attack puts the positive charge, in one resonance structure, on the carbon bearing G. If G has a lone pair ($\mathrm{{-}\ddot{O}H}$, $\mathrm{{-}\ddot{N}H_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}\ddot{O}CH_{3}}$, halogen), it can donate it to that carbon: a fourth resonance structure appears in which every atom has an octet. If G is alkyl, that structure is a tertiary carbocation, stabilised by $+I$ and hyperconjugation. Either way, the ortho/para σ-complexes are more stable than the meta one, so ortho/para attack is faster.
- Meta attack never puts the charge on the carbon bearing G (the charge goes to the three carbons ortho/para to the $sp^{3}$ carbon, and C–G is not one of them). For an electron-donor this means "no extra help"; for an electron-withdrawing group it means "no extra harm".
- For $\mathrm{{-}NO_{2}}$ (or $\mathrm{{-}CHO}$, $\mathrm{{-}CN}$, $\mathrm{{-}N(CH_{3})_{3}^{+}}$), ortho/para attack puts the $+$ charge right next to the positively polarised N or C of G — a strongly destabilised structure. Every position is slowed, but ortho and para are slowed most, so the meta product dominates: meta directors are least deactivating at meta.
Electron density view. Resonance of a donor with the ring ($\mathrm{\ddot{N}H_{2}}$, $\mathrm{\ddot{O}H}$) places $\delta-$ on the ortho and para carbons of the starting compound; a withdrawing group ($\mathrm{NO_{2}}$, $\mathrm{CHO}$) places $\delta+$ there, leaving the meta carbons the least electron-poor. Both pictures lead to the same rules.
Halogens — the odd case. Chlorine and bromine are strongly electronegative ($-I$), so they withdraw electron density from the whole ring through the σ bond: chlorobenzene reacts more slowly than benzene. But when the electrophile attacks ortho or para, the halogen's lone pair can stabilise the σ-complex ($+M$): so they direct ortho/para. Rate is decided by $-I$, orientation by $+M$.
Ortho or para? There are two ortho positions and one para, but para usually wins for bulky groups or bulky electrophiles (steric hindrance at ortho): nitration of toluene gives about $58\%$ ortho and $38\%$ para; of tert-butylbenzene, mainly para. When a ring carries two groups, the more strongly activating group controls the position, and substitution between two groups that are meta to each other is rare (crowding).
In the directing-effect explorer choose –NO₂ and ortho attack. In how many of the σ-complex structures is the positive charge on the ring carbon that carries the nitro group?
Toxicity and carcinogenicity. Benzene and many polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons are toxic. Long exposure to benzene vapour damages the bone marrow and can cause leukaemia, which is why its use as a solvent is now strictly limited and toluene is used instead. Hydrocarbons with four or more fused benzene rings — such as 1,2-benzanthracene, 3-methylcholanthrene and benzo[a]pyrene — are carcinogenic. They form in the incomplete combustion of organic matter (tobacco smoke, coal tar, vehicle exhaust, charred food). In the body they are oxidised to reactive epoxides that bind to DNA and cause mutations.
1. Counting π electrons. Pyridine's N lone pair is not in the sextet; pyrrole's and furan's (one pair) are. A ring $\mathrm{CH_{2}}$ (cyclopentadiene, cycloheptatriene) kills aromaticity; the ions $\mathrm{C_{5}H_{5}^{-}}$ and $\mathrm{C_{7}H_{7}^{+}}$ are aromatic. Cyclooctatetraene is non-aromatic (tub), not antiaromatic.
2. Friedel–Crafts alkylation rearranges. 1-Chloropropane gives mainly cumene; 1-chloro-2-methylpropane gives tert-butylbenzene. For a straight chain use acylation + reduction.
3. Halogens are o/p directors but deactivating. Do not put chlorobenzene above benzene in a reactivity order; do not call Cl a meta director.
4. Aniline (and amines) fail Friedel–Crafts; nitrobenzene is too deactivated. Order of steps in a synthesis decides meta versus ortho/para.
5. Chlorine and benzene: $\mathrm{FeCl_{3}}$, dark → substitution ($\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}Cl}$); sunlight, no catalyst → addition ($\mathrm{C_{6}H_{6}Cl_{6}}$, 3 mol $\mathrm{Cl_{2}}$).
Chlorobenzene undergoes nitration more slowly than benzene, yet gives mainly ortho and para products. This is because chlorine
Exercises
Atomic masses: H 1, C 12, N 14, O 16, S 32, Cl 35.5, Br 80. Molar volume at STP $22.7\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}}$.
- 1 Give IUPAC names: (a) m-xylene, (b) p-nitrotoluene, (c) o-chlorotoluene.
- 2 Draw 1-bromo-3-chloro-5-iodobenzene and 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene.
- 3 How many isomeric dichlorobenzenes are there?
- 4 How many isomeric trichlorobenzenes are there? Name them.
- 5 How many structural isomers have the formula $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{3}(CH_{3})ClBr}$ (three different substituents on one ring)?
- 6 How many aromatic isomers have the formula $\mathrm{C_{8}H_{10}}$?
- 7 How many σ bonds are there in a benzene molecule? How many π bonds (in one Kekulé structure)?
- 8 Give two experimental facts that a single Kekulé structure cannot explain, and explain them.
- 1 How many π electrons does the tropylium ion $\mathrm{C_{7}H_{7}^{+}}$ have? Is it aromatic?
- 2 Classify the cyclopropenyl cation and the cyclopropenyl anion.
- 3 How many π electrons does naphthalene have? Is it aromatic?
- 4 For the cyclooctatetraene dianion, find the value of $n$ in $4n+2$.
- 5 Explain why the nitrogen of pyridine is basic but that of pyrrole is not.
- 6 How many of the following are aromatic: benzene, cyclopentadiene, cyclopentadienyl anion, tropylium ion, cyclobutadiene, furan, cyclooctatetraene, thiophene?
- 7 Cyclopentadiene ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}\approx16$) is about $10^{34}$ times more acidic than cyclopentane ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}\approx50$). Explain.
- 8 Why does cyclooctatetraene decolourise bromine water while benzene does not?
- 1 Write the equation for the formation of the nitronium ion in the nitrating mixture.
- 2 $15.6\ \mathrm{g}$ of benzene is nitrated with an $80\%$ yield. What mass of nitrobenzene is obtained?
- 3 Give the main product of benzene with 1-chloropropane and anhydrous $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$, and explain.
- 4 What forms from benzene and 2-chloro-2-methylpropane / $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$? Would 1-chloro-2-methylpropane give a different product?
- 5 Give the product of benzene with ethanoyl chloride / $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$ and explain why a second acyl group does not enter.
- 6 How many moles of $\mathrm{Cl_{2}}$ add to one mole of benzene in bright sunlight? Name the product.
- 7 How many moles of $\mathrm{H_{2}}$ are needed to hydrogenate one mole of styrene ($\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH{=}CH_{2}}$) completely?
- 8 $7.80\ \mathrm{g}$ of benzene is completely converted into toluene with $\mathrm{CH_{3}Cl/AlCl_{3}}$. What volume of HCl (at STP) is released?
- 9 Why can chlorobenzene not be used to make diphenyl ($\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}{-}C_{6}H_{5}}$) by a Friedel–Crafts reaction with benzene?
- 1 Classify as o/p or meta directors, activating or deactivating: $\mathrm{{-}OH}$, $\mathrm{{-}CHO}$, $\mathrm{{-}Cl}$, $\mathrm{{-}CH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{{-}NO_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}NHCOCH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{{-}CN}$, $\mathrm{{-}OCH_{3}}$.
- 2 How many of the groups in part 1 are ortho/para directors?
- 3 Arrange in order of decreasing reactivity towards bromination: benzene, phenol, nitrobenzene, toluene, chlorobenzene.
- 4 Give the main product(s) of nitrating (a) bromobenzene, (b) benzoic acid, (c) acetanilide ($\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}NHCOCH_{3}}$).
- 5 How many different ring-monochloro derivatives of toluene are possible?
- 6 How many ring-monobromo derivatives can 1,2,4-trimethylbenzene give? And mesitylene?
- 7 The $\mathrm{{-}N(CH_{3})_{3}^{+}}$ group has no π bond, yet it is a strong meta director. Explain.
- 8 Starting from benzene, outline syntheses of (a) 3-nitroacetophenone, (b) 4-nitrotoluene.
E1. JEE Main · MCQ Which of the following is aromatic? (A) cyclopenta-1,3-diene (B) cycloocta-1,3,5,7-tetraene (C) cyclopropenyl cation (D) cyclobuta-1,3-diene
E2. JEE Main · Numerical How many structural isomers are possible for a benzene ring carrying two chlorine atoms and one methyl group, $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{3}Cl_{2}CH_{3}}$? Give the answer to the nearest integer.
E3. JEE Main · MCQ Benzene is treated with 1-chloro-2-methylpropane in the presence of anhydrous $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$. The major product is (A) tert-butylbenzene (B) isobutylbenzene (C) sec-butylbenzene (D) butylbenzene
E4. JEE Main · Numerical $39.0\ \mathrm{g}$ of benzene is nitrated with a mixture of concentrated nitric and sulphuric acids; the yield of nitrobenzene is $80\%$. Find the mass of nitrobenzene obtained, in grams ($\mathrm{H}=1$, $\mathrm{C}=12$, $\mathrm{N}=14$, $\mathrm{O}=16$). Give the answer to the nearest integer.
E5. JEE Main · MCQ The correct order of reactivity towards electrophilic substitution is (A) benzene $\gt$ toluene $\gt$ chlorobenzene $\gt$ nitrobenzene (B) toluene $\gt$ chlorobenzene $\gt$ benzene $\gt$ nitrobenzene (C) nitrobenzene $\gt$ chlorobenzene $\gt$ benzene $\gt$ toluene (D) toluene $\gt$ benzene $\gt$ chlorobenzene $\gt$ nitrobenzene
E6. JEE Main · Numerical How many of the following substituents are ortho/para directors in electrophilic aromatic substitution: $\mathrm{{-}NH_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}SO_{3}H}$, $\mathrm{{-}Br}$, $\mathrm{{-}C_{2}H_{5}}$, $\mathrm{{-}COCH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{{-}NO_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}OC_{2}H_{5}}$, $\mathrm{{-}CN}$? Give the answer to the nearest integer.
Research question. How much benzene do people in a city actually breathe, where does it come from, and how does it compare with the limits set to protect against leukaemia?
Why it matters. Benzene is a known human carcinogen with no completely safe level. Petrol contains up to about $1\%$ benzene by volume; it escapes at fuel stations and in exhaust, and it is also present in tobacco smoke. India's National Ambient Air Quality Standards set an annual average limit of $5\ \mu\mathrm{g\,m^{-3}}$ for benzene, the same value as the European Union's limit.
What to do.
- Find published monitoring data (a pollution-control board, a city air-quality report, or a peer-reviewed study) giving benzene concentrations near a busy road, near a fuel station and in a residential area.
- Convert the values to ppb by volume: at $298\ \mathrm{K}$ and $1\ \mathrm{atm}$, $1\ \mathrm{ppb}$ of benzene is $\dfrac{78}{24.5}\approx3.2\ \mu\mathrm{g\,m^{-3}}$.
- An adult breathes about $20\ \mathrm{m^{3}}$ of air a day. Estimate the daily intake (in µg) in each place, and compare with the intake of a smoker (find a value for the benzene delivered per cigarette).
- Explain, using what you know about aromatic rings, why benzene is very stable in air yet harmful once oxidised in the liver (look up "benzene oxide" and its metabolites).
- List two engineering measures that reduce exposure (vapour recovery at fuel pumps, limits on benzene in petrol) and find when they were introduced in one country.
Tools: Published air-quality data and reports, a spreadsheet.
Hand in: A table of concentrations (µg m⁻³ and ppb) and daily intakes; a bar chart comparing the places and a smoker; one paragraph of recommendations.
Going further. Toluene has largely replaced benzene as an industrial solvent. Its side chain gives the liver an easier route (oxidation of $\mathrm{CH_{3}}$ to benzoic acid, which is excreted). Why does that make it much less carcinogenic?
🧪 Self-check quiz
Q1. The carbon–carbon bond length in benzene is
Q2. A planar, cyclic, fully conjugated species is aromatic if its number of π electrons is
Q3. The electrophile in the nitration of benzene is
Q4. Which group is a meta director?
Q5. Friedel–Crafts methylation of benzene gives some dimethylbenzenes as well as toluene because