Chapter 13 · Purification and Characterisation of Organic Compounds

13.1 Methods of Purification

A compound made in a flask or taken from a leaf is never pure at first. Sublimation, crystallisation, four kinds of distillation, differential extraction and chromatography each exploit one physical difference between the compound and its impurities, and a sharp melting point or a single spot with a fixed $R_{f}$ tells us when the job is done.

Every organic compound starts life dirty. A reaction mixture holds the product, unused starting materials, side products, solvent and catalyst; a plant extract holds dozens of pigments, oils and sugars at once. Before a chemist can find the formula of a new compound, measure its properties or sell it as a medicine, it has to be separated from everything else and shown to be pure. A paracetamol tablet that contains a fraction of a per cent of the wrong compound can fail its quality test; a dye with a trace of a by-product can change colour in sunlight.

No single technique purifies everything. Each method in this section exploits one physical difference between the compound and its impurities: the ability to pass straight from solid to vapour (sublimation), a difference in solubility (crystallisation), in volatility (the four kinds of distillation), in how the compound shares itself between two immiscible solvents (differential extraction) or in how strongly it clings to a surface (chromatography). We learn the principle behind each, when to use it and the simple calculations JEE Main asks about it — recovery on crystallisation, the composition of a steam distillate, the efficiency of repeated extraction and $R_{f}$ values. Section 13.2 then analyses the purified compound to find which elements it contains and in what proportions.

Purity; sublimation and crystallisation

How do we know that a compound is pure? Chemical analysis cannot tell us — an impure sample still contains carbon and hydrogen. Instead we use physical constants that a pure substance has and a mixture lacks.

📘 Definition 13.1 — Criteria of purity

A pure compound contains only one kind of molecule. In practice it is recognised by

  • a sharp melting point (a solid melts completely within about $1$ K) that does not change on further purification;
  • a constant boiling point (a liquid distils completely at one temperature at a given pressure);
  • a single spot in thin-layer or paper chromatography, whatever the solvent used.

An impure solid melts at a lower temperature and over a range: a dissolved impurity lowers the melting point just as a solute lowers the freezing point of a solvent.

A melting point also helps to identify a compound. If an unknown solid melts at $395$ K, it may be benzoic acid — but other compounds melt there too. Mix it with an authentic sample of benzoic acid and measure the mixed melting point: if the two are the same compound, the mixture still melts sharply at $395$ K; if they are different, each acts as an impurity in the other and the mixture melts lower and over a range.

📘 Definition 13.2 — Sublimation

Sublimation is the direct change of a solid into vapour on heating, without melting; on cooling the vapour turns directly back into solid. A solid sublimes when its vapour pressure reaches the surrounding pressure below its melting point.

It purifies a sublimable compound — such as naphthalene, camphor, anthracene or benzoic acid — from non-sublimable impurities (sand, common salt, sugar, most other organic solids). The mixture is heated gently in a dish covered by an inverted funnel; the pure solid collects on the cool funnel walls.

For most compounds, however, the method of choice is crystallisation. It relies on the fact that the solubility of a solid usually rises steeply with temperature — and that a small amount of impurity, dissolved in a large volume of solvent, does not reach saturation and so stays in solution.

📘 Definition 13.3 — Crystallisation and the mother liquor

Crystallisation purifies a solid by dissolving it in the minimum volume of a suitable hot solvent, filtering the hot solution to remove insoluble impurities, and letting it cool so that the pure compound separates as crystals. The crystals are filtered off and washed with a little cold solvent. The solution left behind, which holds the soluble impurities and some of the compound, is the mother liquor.

A suitable solvent (water, ethanol, acetone, hexane, ethyl ethanoate…) dissolves the compound sparingly when cold and well when hot, dissolves the impurities either very well (they stay in the mother liquor) or not at all (they are filtered off hot), does not react with the compound, and is easily removed from the crystals.

📐 Principle 13.1 — Recovery on crystallisation

Let the solubility of the compound be $s_{\text{hot}}$ at the high temperature and $s_{\text{cold}}$ at the low temperature (in g per 100 mL of solvent). If the compound is dissolved in the minimum volume of hot solvent and cooled, the fraction that crystallises out is

$$\text{fraction recovered}=1-\frac{s_{\text{cold}}}{s_{\text{hot}}} .$$

Any extra solvent keeps an extra $s_{\text{cold}}$ grams per 100 mL in solution, so the recovery falls. Impurities stay dissolved as long as their mass is below what the cold solvent can hold. The method assumes the impurities do not change the compound's solubility and do not crystallise with it.

Three refinements matter. A coloured impurity is removed by boiling the hot solution briefly with a little activated charcoal, which adsorbs it, and filtering hot. If one crystallisation does not give a sharp melting point it is repeated — each time the impurity fraction falls. And when two solids in a mixture differ in solubility, fractional crystallisation separates them: on cooling, the less soluble one crystallises first and is filtered off; the more soluble one crystallises later from the concentrated mother liquor. (The same idea separates sugars and salts on an industrial scale.)

✏️ Example 1 — How much benzoic acid comes back?
A crude sample of benzoic acid weighs $10.0$ g, of which $0.50$ g is a water-soluble impurity. Take the solubility of benzoic acid in water as $6.0$ g per 100 mL near $368$ K and $0.30$ g per 100 mL at $293$ K. (a) What is the minimum volume of hot water needed? (b) How much pure benzoic acid crystallises on cooling to $293$ K, and what percentage of the benzoic acid is recovered? (c) What happens to the recovery if $200$ mL of water is used instead?
(a) Benzoic acid present $=10.0-0.50=9.5$ g. Volume needed $=\dfrac{9.5}{6.0}\times100=158$ mL (about $160$ mL).
(b) At $293$ K, $158$ mL holds $158\times\dfrac{0.30}{100}=0.475$ g. Crystals $=9.5-0.475=9.0$ g (more precisely $9.025$ g), i.e. $\dfrac{9.025}{9.5}=95.0\%$ recovery — exactly $1-\dfrac{0.30}{6.0}=0.95$.
(c) $200$ mL keeps $0.60$ g dissolved: crystals $=8.9$ g, recovery $93.7\%$. Using more solvent than necessary always costs product.
Check The $0.50$ g of impurity stays in the mother liquor provided its own solubility in $158$ mL of cold water exceeds $0.50$ g — that is why a small, soluble impurity is left behind while the main compound crystallises.

An unknown white solid melts sharply at $395$ K. A $1:1$ mixture of it with pure benzoic acid (m.p. $395$ K) melts over the range $375$–$385$ K. What can you conclude?

Distillation: simple, fractional, reduced pressure and steam

Liquids are purified by distillation. A liquid boils when its vapour pressure equals the external pressure (Section 5.2); its vapour is led into a condenser, and the pure liquid — the distillate — is collected. Non-volatile impurities stay behind in the flask. How the method is set up depends on how different the boiling points are and on whether the compound survives being heated to its boiling point.

📘 Definition 13.4 — The four kinds of distillation
  • Simple distillation separates a volatile liquid from a non-volatile solid, or two liquids whose boiling points differ widely (by roughly $40$ K or more) — e.g. chloroform (b.p. $334$ K) from aniline (b.p. $457$ K). The lower-boiling liquid distils first.
  • Fractional distillation separates miscible liquids with close boiling points, using a fractionating column between flask and condenser. The column gives the rising vapour a large surface on which it repeatedly condenses and re-vaporises; each step enriches the vapour in the more volatile liquid. Used to separate crude petroleum into fractions and acetone from methanol in the wood-distillation industry.
  • Distillation under reduced pressure (vacuum distillation) lowers the external pressure with a pump, so the liquid boils at a lower temperature. Used for liquids that decompose at or below their normal boiling point — e.g. recovering glycerol from the spent lye of the soap industry.
  • Steam distillation passes steam through a mixture containing a compound that is volatile in steam and immiscible with water; the compound and water distil together below $373$ K. Used for aniline, nitrobenzene, essential oils (clove, eucalyptus) and $o$-nitrophenol.

Why a fractionating column works. For two miscible liquids obeying Raoult's law, the vapour above a boiling mixture is richer in the more volatile component than the liquid is. If $p_{A}^{\circ}$ and $p_{B}^{\circ}$ are the vapour pressures of the pure liquids and $x_{A}$ the mole fraction of $A$ in the liquid, the mole fraction of $A$ in the vapour is

$$y_{A}=\frac{x_{A}\,p_{A}^{\circ}}{x_{A}\,p_{A}^{\circ}+(1-x_{A})\,p_{B}^{\circ}} .$$

Condense that vapour and boil it again, and it is enriched again. A column packed with glass beads or fitted with plates performs this condense-and-boil cycle many times on its way up; each ideal cycle is called a theoretical plate. (A mixture that forms an azeotrope cannot be separated beyond the azeotropic composition in this way.)

Why reduced pressure works. Vapour pressure rises steeply with temperature, so lowering the external pressure from $760$ mmHg to, say, $20$ mmHg can lower the boiling point by $100$ K or more. Glycerol (normal b.p. about $563$ K, where it decomposes) distils without decomposition at a few mmHg.

📐 Principle 13.2 — Steam distillation of an immiscible liquid

Two immiscible liquids each exert their full vapour pressure, independent of the amount of the other (neither dilutes the other). The mixture therefore boils when

$$p_{\text{org}}^{\circ}(T)+p_{\text{water}}^{\circ}(T)=P_{\text{ext}},$$

which happens below the boiling point of either liquid — below $373$ K at $P_{\text{ext}}=760$ mmHg. The moles in the vapour are in the ratio of the partial pressures, so the distillate contains the two liquids in the mass ratio

$$\frac{m_{\text{org}}}{m_{\text{water}}}=\frac{p_{\text{org}}^{\circ}\,M_{\text{org}}}{p_{\text{water}}^{\circ}\,M_{\text{water}}}\qquad(M_{\text{water}}=18\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}).$$

Conditions: the compound must be immiscible with water, not react with steam, and have an appreciable vapour pressure (roughly $10$–$15$ mmHg or more) near $373$ K.

The mass ratio explains why steam distillation is so useful: although the organic liquid's vapour pressure is small, its molar mass is large compared with water's $18$, so a useful mass of it comes over with the water. The distillate separates into two layers, which are parted in a separating funnel. Steam distillation also separates $o$-nitrophenol from $p$-nitrophenol: the ortho isomer has an intramolecular hydrogen bond, is not associated with its neighbours and is steam-volatile; the para isomer is held by intermolecular hydrogen bonds (and to water) and stays behind.

🧭 Problem-solving strategy — Choosing a purification method
  1. Solid or liquid? For a solid, ask first whether it sublimes and the impurity does not (sublimation); otherwise crystallise, and use fractional crystallisation for two solids of different solubility.
  2. Liquid: how far apart are the boiling points? Widely different, or a non-volatile impurity → simple distillation. Close → fractional distillation.
  3. Does it decompose near its boiling point? → distillation under reduced pressure.
  4. Is it steam-volatile and immiscible with water (and the impurities non-volatile)? → steam distillation, which also works for some solids such as $o$-nitrophenol.
  5. Is it dissolved in water? → differential extraction into an immiscible organic solvent. Small amounts, many similar components, or a purity check? → chromatography.
✏️ Example 2 — Matching mixtures to methods
Name the best method to separate or purify: (a) naphthalene contaminated with common salt; (b) ethanol (b.p. $351$ K) from water (b.p. $373$ K), as far as possible; (c) glycerol from spent lye; (d) aniline from a reaction mixture containing non-volatile tarry by-products; (e) a mixture of $o$- and $p$-nitrophenol; (f) diethyl ether (b.p. $308$ K) from a solution of a non-volatile oil.
(a) Sublimation: naphthalene sublimes, sodium chloride does not.
(b) Fractional distillation: miscible liquids $22$ K apart. It can enrich the ethanol only up to the azeotrope (about $95.6\%$ ethanol by mass), not to pure ethanol.
(c) Distillation under reduced pressure: glycerol decomposes at its normal boiling point.
(d) Steam distillation: aniline is steam-volatile and almost immiscible with water; the tar stays in the flask.
(e) Steam distillation: the $o$-isomer (intramolecular H-bond) distils with steam; the $p$-isomer does not.
(f) Simple distillation: a volatile liquid from a non-volatile solute (heated on a water bath — ether is very flammable).
✏️ Example 3 — JEE level: plates in a fractionating column
Liquids $A$ and $B$ form an ideal solution. At the temperature of the column take $p_{A}^{\circ}=600$ mmHg and $p_{B}^{\circ}=200$ mmHg (treat these as constant). An equimolar liquid is distilled. (a) Find the mole fraction of $A$ in the first vapour. (b) How many theoretical plates (vaporise–condense cycles) are needed before the vapour contains at least $95$ mol% of $A$?
(a) $y_{A}=\dfrac{0.5\times600}{0.5\times600+0.5\times200}=\dfrac{300}{400}=0.75$.
Plate 2 The vapour condenses to a liquid with $x_{A}=0.75$: $y_{A}=\dfrac{450}{450+50}=0.90$.
Plate 3 $x_{A}=0.90$: $y_{A}=\dfrac{540}{540+20}=0.964\ge0.95$. So three plates are needed.
⏱ Shortcut In terms of the ratio $r=\dfrac{y_{A}}{y_{B}}$, each plate multiplies $\dfrac{x_{A}}{x_{B}}$ by $\alpha=\dfrac{p_{A}^{\circ}}{p_{B}^{\circ}}=3$: ratios $3, 9, 27$; we need $r\ge19$ (i.e. $y_{A}\ge0.95$), first reached at $27=3^{3}$. The closer the boiling points (the nearer $\alpha$ is to 1), the more plates are needed — which is why close-boiling liquids need a long column.
✏️ Example 4 — JEE level: what comes over in steam distillation
A mixture of aniline ($M=93\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}$) and water is steam-distilled at $760$ mmHg. It boils at $371.5$ K, where the vapour pressure of water is $717$ mmHg. (a) What is the vapour pressure of aniline at this temperature? (b) What mass of aniline distils over with every $100$ g of water? (c) What is the percentage by mass of aniline in the distillate?
Find the mass of aniline per $100$ g of water in (b):
(a) Immiscible liquids: $p_{\text{aniline}}^{\circ}=760-717=43$ mmHg.
(b) $\dfrac{m_{\text{aniline}}}{m_{\text{water}}}=\dfrac{43\times93}{717\times18}=\dfrac{3999}{12\,906}=0.310$; so $31.0$ g of aniline per $100$ g of water.
(c) $\dfrac{31.0}{131.0}\times100=23.7\%$ aniline by mass.
Insight Aniline's vapour pressure is only $\tfrac{43}{760}=5.7\%$ of the total, yet it makes up almost a quarter of the distillate by mass, because each aniline molecule is $93/18\approx5.2$ times heavier than a water molecule. And it distils at $371.5$ K, $85$ K below its own boiling point of $457$ K.

Nitrobenzene boils at about $484$ K ($211\ ^{\circ}\mathrm{C}$). At what temperature does a nitrobenzene–water mixture boil during steam distillation at $760$ mmHg?

Choose nitrobenzene, mode with steam, pressure $760$ mmHg. The readouts show: liquid alone boils at $210.6\ ^{\circ}\mathrm{C}$, water alone at $100.0\ ^{\circ}\mathrm{C}$, but the mixture boils at $99.2\ ^{\circ}\mathrm{C}$, where the two vapour pressures ($20.6$ and $739.4$ mmHg) add up to $760$. The distillate holds $19.0$ g of nitrobenzene per $100$ g of water. Because the vapour pressures add, the mixture always boils below the lower of the two boiling points.
Interactive 1 — Boiling Under Reduced Pressure and With Steam

The graph shows the vapour pressure of water (blue) and of an organic liquid (red) against temperature; the green line is the external pressure. A liquid boils where its curve meets the green line. In with steam mode the purple curve adds the two vapour pressures (immiscible liquids) and the mixture boils where it meets the line. Lower the pressure to see vacuum distillation; press Play to heat the flask.

760 mmHg
liquid alone boils at—
water boils at—
mixture with steam boils at—
organic per 100 g water—

During steam distillation of an organic liquid at $1$ atm, the mixture boils

Differential extraction

Many organic compounds are made or found in water — a reaction run in aqueous solution, a drug in urine, caffeine in tea. To get them out we shake the aqueous solution with an organic solvent that does not mix with water (diethyl ether, chloroform, benzene, ethyl ethanoate) and in which the compound is more soluble. The compound distributes itself between the two layers; the layers are separated in a separating funnel, and the solvent is distilled off to leave the compound.

📘 Definition 13.5 — Distribution coefficient

When a solute is shaken with two immiscible solvents and equilibrium is reached, the distribution coefficient (partition coefficient) is

$$K_{D}=\frac{C_{\text{org}}}{C_{\text{aq}}},$$

the ratio of its concentrations in the organic and the aqueous layer. $K_{D}$ has no units (both concentrations in the same units, e.g. g per mL).

📐 Law 13.3 — The distribution law

At a constant temperature, a solute that has the same molecular form in both solvents (no association, dissociation or reaction in either) distributes itself between two immiscible solvents so that the ratio of its concentrations, $K_{D}=C_{\text{org}}/C_{\text{aq}}$, is constant, whatever the total amount of solute — provided the solutions are dilute.

(Ethanoic acid, which forms dimers in benzene, does not obey this simple form of the law.)

Now the key calculation. Suppose $w_{0}$ grams of solute are dissolved in $V$ mL of water and shaken with $v$ mL of organic solvent. If $w_{1}$ grams remain in the water, then $\dfrac{(w_{0}-w_{1})/v}{w_{1}/V}=K_{D}$, which gives $w_{1}=w_{0}\dfrac{V}{V+K_{D}v}$. Each fresh portion of solvent removes the same fraction again.

📐 Result 13.4 — Repeated extraction

After $n$ extractions, each with a fresh $v$ mL of organic solvent, the mass of solute left in $V$ mL of water is

$$w_{n}=w_{0}\left(\frac{V}{V+K_{D}\,v}\right)^{n},\qquad \text{mass extracted}=w_{0}-w_{n}.$$

For the same total volume of solvent, several small portions extract more than one large portion. (The law assumes ideal behaviour of each layer and that equilibrium is reached at every shake.)

If the compound is an acid or a base, chemistry can make the extraction far more selective: shaking an ether solution of benzoic acid and naphthalene with aqueous sodium hydrogencarbonate converts the acid into its water-soluble sodium salt, which moves into the water; naphthalene stays in the ether. Acidifying the aqueous layer then precipitates the benzoic acid.

✏️ Example 5 — JEE level: one big shake or three small ones?
$1.00$ g of an organic compound is dissolved in $100$ mL of water. Its distribution coefficient between ether and water is $K_{D}=4.0$. Compare the mass extracted (a) by one extraction with $60$ mL of ether and (b) by three successive extractions with $20$ mL each. (c) How many successive $20$-mL extractions are needed to remove at least $95\%$ of the compound?
Find the mass extracted by the three $20$-mL portions in (b):
(a) $w_{1}=1.00\times\dfrac{100}{100+4.0\times60}=\dfrac{100}{340}=0.294$ g left; extracted $0.706$ g ($70.6\%$).
(b) Each $20$-mL portion leaves $\dfrac{100}{100+80}=\dfrac59$ of what was there: $w_{3}=1.00\times\left(\dfrac59\right)^{3}=0.171$ g left; extracted $0.829$ g ($82.9\%$).
(c) Need $\left(\dfrac59\right)^{n}\le0.05$: $n\ge\dfrac{\ln0.05}{\ln(5/9)}=\dfrac{-3.00}{-0.588}=5.10$, so $n=6$ extractions (five leave $5.3\%$, six leave $2.9\%$).
Check The same $60$ mL of ether removes $0.829$ g in three portions against $0.706$ g in one: dividing the solvent wins, as Result 13.4 says.

A solute has $K_{D}=C_{\text{org}}/C_{\text{aq}}=4$. A solution of it in $50$ mL of water is shaken once with $50$ mL of the organic solvent. What fraction of the solute stays in the water?

Chromatography

When the components of a mixture are very similar, or present only in milligrams, the methods so far fail. Chromatography (from the Greek chroma, colour — it was first used to separate plant pigments) succeeds because it repeats a tiny difference in "stickiness" thousands of times as a solvent carries the mixture past a solid surface.

📘 Definition 13.6 — Chromatography; stationary and mobile phases

Chromatography separates the components of a mixture by their different distribution between a stationary phase (a solid, or a liquid held on a solid support, that stays in place) and a mobile phase (a liquid or gas that moves through or over it). A component that is held more strongly by the stationary phase moves more slowly.

  • Adsorption chromatography: the stationary phase is a solid adsorbent, usually silica gel or alumina; components differ in how strongly they are adsorbed on its surface. Two forms: column chromatography and thin-layer chromatography (TLC).
  • Partition chromatography: the stationary phase is a liquid; components differ in how they partition (distribute) between it and the mobile liquid. In paper chromatography the stationary phase is the water held in the cellulose fibres of special chromatography paper.

Column chromatography. A glass tube with a tap is packed with alumina or silica gel; the mixture is put on top in a little solvent, and more solvent (the eluent) is run through. The least strongly adsorbed component travels fastest and comes out (elutes) first; the bands are collected as separate fractions. On polar adsorbents such as silica, non-polar compounds (hydrocarbons) elute first, then esters and ketones, then alcohols, and carboxylic acids last. A more polar eluent competes better for the surface and moves every component faster.

Thin-layer chromatography. A thin layer (about $0.2$ mm) of silica gel or alumina is spread on a glass or plastic plate. A small spot of the mixture is placed on a baseline about $1$–$2$ cm above the lower edge, and the plate stands in a closed jar with solvent below the baseline. The solvent rises by capillary action, carrying the components up different distances. Coloured spots are seen directly; colourless ones are revealed under ultraviolet light (on a fluorescent plate), by placing the plate in a jar of iodine crystals (brown spots), or by spraying a reagent — ninhydrin gives purple spots with amino acids.

📘 Definition 13.7 — Retardation factor $R_{f}$

In TLC or paper chromatography the retardation factor of a component is

$$R_{f}=\frac{\text{distance moved by the centre of the spot from the baseline}}{\text{distance moved by the solvent front from the baseline}} .$$

$R_{f}$ has no units and lies between $0$ (stays on the baseline) and $1$ (moves with the solvent front). For a given stationary phase, solvent and temperature it is characteristic of the compound.

baseline solvent front solvent A B d_A d_B d_s R_f(A) = d_A / d_s R_f(B) = d_B / d_s A is held more strongly (more polar on silica)

Applications. Chromatography (i) separates and purifies mixtures — column chromatography for grams, preparative TLC for milligrams; (ii) tests purity — a pure compound gives one spot in several solvents; (iii) identifies a compound by running it beside authentic samples on the same plate (same $R_{f}$ in two or more solvents); (iv) follows a reaction — the starting-material spot fades as the product spot grows; and (v) analyses tiny samples: dyes in inks and foods, amino acids from a protein, pigments in leaves, drugs in body fluids.

✏️ Example 6 — JEE level: reading a TLC plate
A mixture of two compounds $P$ and $Q$ is run on a silica-gel TLC plate. The baseline is drawn $1.0$ cm above the lower edge. Measured from the lower edge, the solvent front is at $9.0$ cm, spot $P$ at $3.4$ cm and spot $Q$ at $7.4$ cm. (a) Find the $R_{f}$ values. (b) Which compound is more polar? (c) If the mixture is separated on a silica-gel column with the same solvent, which comes out first? (d) An authentic sample of $Q$ run beside the mixture gives a spot at the same height. Does this prove the identity of $Q$?
Find $R_{f}$ of $P$ before you open the solution:
(a) From the baseline: solvent $9.0-1.0=8.0$ cm, $P$: $2.4$ cm, $Q$: $6.4$ cm. $R_{f}(P)=\dfrac{2.4}{8.0}=0.30$; $\ R_{f}(Q)=\dfrac{6.4}{8.0}=0.80$.
(b) $P$ moves less, so it is held more strongly by the polar silica: $P$ is the more polar compound.
(c) $Q$, the less strongly adsorbed compound, elutes first; $P$ later.
(d) It is good evidence, not proof: two different compounds can share an $R_{f}$ in one solvent. Agreement in two or three different solvents, or a sharp mixed melting point, makes the identification convincing.
Check Measuring from the edge would give $\tfrac{3.4}{9.0}=0.38$ for $P$ — a common slip.

With $20\%$ ethyl ethanoate in hexane as eluent, the polar compound $C$ hardly leaves the baseline. What happens when the eluent is changed to $50\%$ ethyl ethanoate?

Set the slider to $20\%$: $R_{f}=0.79$ (A), $0.33$ (B), $0.10$ (C). At $50\%$: $0.92$, $0.62$, $0.27$. A more polar eluent competes better for the polar silica surface, so every compound spends more time in the mobile phase and every $R_{f}$ rises — but the most polar compound is still held most strongly, so the order does not change. The column on the right shows the same thing as elution order: $A$ comes out first.
Interactive 2 — TLC Plate and Column

Three compounds on silica gel: $A$ (a hydrocarbon, non-polar), $B$ (a ketone) and $C$ (an alcohol, most polar). The left lanes hold each pure compound, the right lane the mixture. Choose the percentage of polar ethyl ethanoate in hexane and press Play to develop the plate: the solvent front rises and each spot travels the fraction $R_{f}$ of the solvent's distance. The column on the right is run with the same eluent; the band nearest the bottom elutes first.

20%
$R_{f}$ of A—
$R_{f}$ of B—
$R_{f}$ of C—
elution order (column)—
⚠️ JEE Main traps

1. Steam distillation temperature. The mixture boils below $373$ K (at $1$ atm), not between the two boiling points: immiscible liquids add their full vapour pressures. And the mass ratio uses $p^{\circ}M$, not $p^{\circ}$ alone.

2. Which method for which mixture. Glycerol from spent lye → reduced pressure; aniline, nitrobenzene, essential oils, $o$-nitrophenol → steam; close-boiling miscible liquids, crude oil → fractional; camphor, naphthalene → sublimation; two solids of different solubility → fractional crystallisation.

3. $R_{f}$ distances. Measure both distances from the baseline to the centre of the spot and to the solvent front. $R_{f}$ can never exceed 1. A larger $R_{f}$ means weaker adsorption (less polar on silica/alumina) — and in a column that compound elutes first.

4. Paper chromatography is partition, not adsorption. Its stationary phase is the water held in the paper, not the cellulose itself; TLC and column chromatography are adsorption methods.

5. Extraction arithmetic. $K_{D}$ is a ratio of concentrations, so the volumes enter: fraction left $=V/(V+K_{D}v)$ per extraction, raised to the power $n$. Several small portions beat one large portion of the same total volume.

A mixture of a hydrocarbon, a ketone and an alcohol is separated on a column of silica gel using hexane–ethyl ethanoate. The order in which they come out of the column is

Exercises

Pressures are in mmHg ($760$ mmHg $=1$ atm). $M(\mathrm{H_{2}O})=18\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}$. $K_{D}$ is always $C_{\text{org}}/C_{\text{aq}}$.

I
Purity, sublimation and crystallisation.
  • 1 A student's sample of a compound whose literature melting point is $395$ K melts over $389$–$393$ K. What does this tell her, and what should she do next?
  • 2 An unknown solid melts sharply at $406$ K. A mixture of it with authentic compound $X$ (m.p. $406$ K) melts sharply at $406$ K; a mixture with authentic $Y$ (m.p. $406$ K) melts at $388$–$398$ K. Identify the unknown and explain.
  • 3 From the list naphthalene, sodium chloride, benzoic acid, camphor, sucrose, how many substances can be purified by sublimation?
  • 4 Compound $Y$ dissolves to $30$ g per 100 mL of ethanol at the boiling point and $4.0$ g per 100 mL at $273$ K. What is the minimum volume of hot ethanol (in mL) needed for $12.0$ g of $Y$, and what percentage of $Y$ is recovered on cooling to $273$ K?
  • 5 In part 4 a student uses $60$ mL of hot ethanol. What percentage of $Y$ does she recover?
  • 6 Solids $P$ and $Q$ dissolve in water to $50$ g and $20$ g per 100 g at $353$ K, and $10$ g and $15$ g per 100 g at $293$ K. A mixture of $30$ g of $P$ and $10$ g of $Q$ is dissolved in $100$ g of water at $353$ K and cooled to $293$ K. What mass of crystals forms, and is it pure?
  • 7 Why is a hot solution filtered through a pre-heated funnel during crystallisation, and why is a pinch of activated charcoal sometimes added before filtering?
  • 8 Why are the crystals washed with a small volume of cold solvent, and why must the solvent not react with the compound?
1 A low, broad melting range means the sample is impure. She should recrystallise it and measure the melting point again, repeating until it is sharp and no longer changes.
2 The unknown is $X$: mixing with $X$ causes no depression (same compound), while $Y$ acts as an impurity and lowers and broadens the melting range.
3 Naphthalene, benzoic acid and camphor sublime; NaCl and sucrose do not: 3.
4 $V=\dfrac{12.0}{30}\times100=40$ mL. Cold, $40$ mL holds $1.6$ g; crystals $10.4$ g, recovery $\dfrac{10.4}{12.0}=86.7\%$ $\left(=1-\tfrac{4.0}{30}\right)$.
5 $60$ mL holds $2.4$ g cold; crystals $9.6$ g; recovery $80.0\%$.
6 At $293$ K the water holds $10$ g of $P$ and up to $15$ g of $Q$. So $30-10=20$ g of $P$ crystallises; all $10$ g of $Q$ stays dissolved. The $20$ g of crystals is pure $P$ (apart from adhering mother liquor) — fractional crystallisation.
7 A cold funnel would cool the saturated solution and crystallise the product in the filter paper along with the insoluble impurities. Charcoal has a huge surface that adsorbs coloured impurities, which are then removed with it.
8 Washing removes mother liquor (with its dissolved impurities) from the crystal surfaces; a small volume of cold solvent dissolves very little product. A solvent that reacted would destroy or change the compound being purified.
II
Distillation.
  • 1 Which method would you use to separate chloroform (b.p. $334$ K) from aniline (b.p. $457$ K)? Which liquid distils first?
  • 2 Liquids $A$ and $B$ form an ideal solution; at the column temperature $p_{A}^{\circ}=450$ and $p_{B}^{\circ}=150$ mmHg. Find the mole fraction of $A$ in the vapour above a liquid with $x_{A}=0.40$.
  • 3 The vapour in part 2 is condensed and re-boiled once (one more theoretical plate). Find the new mole fraction of $A$ in the vapour.
  • 4 Explain why glycerol is distilled under reduced pressure, and why lowering the pressure lowers the boiling point.
  • 5 The vapour pressure of a liquid is $100$ mmHg at $393$ K and $760$ mmHg at $483$ K. At what temperature does it boil when the pressure in the apparatus is reduced to $100$ mmHg? Why is the temperature you would expect at $50$ mmHg lower still?
  • 6 Bromobenzene ($M=157\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}$) is steam-distilled at $760$ mmHg. The mixture boils at $368.5$ K, where water's vapour pressure is $640$ mmHg. Find the mass of bromobenzene (in g) that distils per gram of water.
  • 7 What is the percentage by mass of bromobenzene in the distillate of part 6?
  • 8 How many of the following can be purified by steam distillation: aniline, ethanol, $o$-nitrophenol, glucose, $p$-nitrophenol, nitrobenzene, clove oil?
  • 9 Explain why a mixture of two immiscible liquids boils below the boiling point of either, while a solution of two miscible liquids boils between them (if it is ideal).
1 Simple distillation (boiling points $123$ K apart); chloroform distils first, leaving aniline.
2 $y_{A}=\dfrac{0.40\times450}{0.40\times450+0.60\times150}=\dfrac{180}{270}=0.667$.
3 $x_{A}=0.667$: $y_{A}=\dfrac{0.667\times450}{0.667\times450+0.333\times150}=\dfrac{300}{350}=0.857$.
4 Glycerol decomposes near its normal boiling point. A liquid boils when its vapour pressure equals the external pressure; with a lower external pressure that vapour pressure is reached at a lower temperature, below the decomposition temperature.
5 At $393$ K, where its vapour pressure equals $100$ mmHg. At $50$ mmHg the required vapour pressure is smaller, reached at a still lower temperature, since vapour pressure rises with temperature.
6 $p_{\text{org}}^{\circ}=760-640=120$ mmHg; $\dfrac{m_{\text{org}}}{m_{\text{w}}}=\dfrac{120\times157}{640\times18}=\dfrac{18\,840}{11\,520}=1.64$ g per g of water.
7 $\dfrac{1.635}{2.635}\times100=62.1\%$ — more bromobenzene than water by mass, though its vapour pressure is less than a fifth of water's.
8 Aniline, $o$-nitrophenol, nitrobenzene and clove oil: 4. Ethanol is miscible with water; glucose is non-volatile; $p$-nitrophenol is held by intermolecular hydrogen bonds and is not steam-volatile.
9 Immiscible liquids do not dilute each other, so each exerts its full vapour pressure and the total exceeds either alone — the external pressure is reached at a lower temperature. In an ideal solution each vapour pressure is reduced by its mole fraction (Raoult's law), so the total lies between the two pure values.
III
Differential extraction.
  • 1 $50$ mL of water containing $0.10$ g of iodine is shaken with $10$ mL of tetrachloromethane ($K_{D}=85$). What mass of iodine (in g) passes into the organic layer?
  • 2 At equilibrium, $25$ mL of ether contains $0.30$ g of a solute and $50$ mL of water contains $0.060$ g. Find $K_{D}$.
  • 3 $2.0$ g of $X$ in $100$ mL of water ($K_{D}=3.0$ for benzene/water) is extracted once with $90$ mL of benzene. What mass (in g) is extracted?
  • 4 The same solution is extracted three times with $30$ mL of benzene each. What mass (in g) is extracted in total?
  • 5 What is the least number of successive $30$-mL extractions that removes at least $90\%$ of $X$?
  • 6 State the conditions under which the distribution law holds. Why does the simple law fail for ethanoic acid distributed between water and benzene?
  • 7 An ether solution contains benzoic acid and naphthalene. Explain how shaking it with aqueous sodium hydrogencarbonate separates them, and how the benzoic acid is recovered.
  • 8 When an aqueous solution is shaken with ether the organic layer is on top, but with chloroform it is at the bottom. Why, and why does it matter when you run off the layers?
1 Fraction left $=\dfrac{50}{50+85\times10}=\dfrac{50}{900}=0.0556$; extracted $0.10\times0.944=0.0944$ g.
2 $C_{\text{org}}=\dfrac{0.30}{25}=0.012\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}$, $C_{\text{aq}}=\dfrac{0.060}{50}=0.0012\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}$: $K_{D}=10$.
3 Left $=2.0\times\dfrac{100}{100+270}=0.541$ g; extracted $1.46$ g.
4 Left $=2.0\times\left(\dfrac{100}{190}\right)^{3}=0.292$ g; extracted $1.71$ g — more than in part 3 with the same $90$ mL.
5 $\left(\dfrac{100}{190}\right)^{n}\le0.10$: $n\ge\dfrac{\ln10}{\ln1.9}=3.59$, so $n=4$ (three leave $14.6\%$, four leave $7.7\%$).
6 Constant temperature, immiscible solvents, dilute solutions, and the same molecular form of the solute in both. Ethanoic acid is largely dimerised by hydrogen bonding in benzene but monomeric in water, so the ratio of total concentrations is not constant.
7 The acid reacts: $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}COOH + NaHCO_{3}\rightarrow C_{6}H_{5}COONa + H_{2}O + CO_{2}}$; the ionic salt dissolves in water, naphthalene stays in ether. Separating the layers and adding dilute HCl to the aqueous one precipitates benzoic acid, which is filtered off.
8 Ether ($0.71\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}$) is less dense than water and floats; chloroform ($1.48\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}$) is denser and sinks. The lower layer is run off through the tap, so you must know which layer holds your compound.
IV
Chromatography.
  • 1 On a TLC plate the solvent front has moved $12.0$ cm and a spot $4.2$ cm from the baseline. Find its $R_{f}$.
  • 2 A compound has $R_{f}=0.45$ in a certain solvent. How far from the baseline (in cm) is its spot when the solvent front has travelled $10.0$ cm?
  • 3 Measured from the lower edge of a plate: baseline $1.5$ cm, spot $6.3$ cm, solvent front $13.5$ cm. Find the $R_{f}$.
  • 4 A mixture of a hydrocarbon, an ester and a carboxylic acid is put on a column of alumina and eluted with a solvent of increasing polarity. In what order do they come out? Why?
  • 5 Paper chromatography of a green ink gives a yellow spot ($R_{f}=0.75$) and a blue spot ($R_{f}=0.20$). How far apart (in cm) are the spots when the solvent front is $8.0$ cm from the baseline?
  • 6 Name the stationary and mobile phases in paper chromatography, and three ways of seeing colourless spots on a TLC plate.
  • 7 Why must the baseline be drawn in pencil and placed above the level of the solvent in the jar? Why can an $R_{f}$ value never exceed 1?
  • 8 Two compounds give $R_{f}=0.62$ and $0.66$ on silica with 30% ethyl ethanoate in hexane, and their spots overlap. Suggest how to improve the separation.
1 $R_{f}=\dfrac{4.2}{12.0}=0.35$.
2 $0.45\times10.0=4.5$ cm.
3 $R_{f}=\dfrac{6.3-1.5}{13.5-1.5}=\dfrac{4.8}{12.0}=0.40$.
4 Hydrocarbon, then ester, then carboxylic acid — in order of increasing adsorption on the polar alumina. The acid, held most strongly, needs the most polar eluent to move it.
5 $(0.75-0.20)\times8.0=4.4$ cm.
6 Stationary: water held in the cellulose fibres of the paper; mobile: the solvent mixture that rises up it. Spots: UV light on a fluorescent plate, iodine vapour (brown spots), a spray reagent such as ninhydrin for amino acids.
7 Ink would itself dissolve and run; pencil (graphite) does not. If the spot were below the solvent level it would dissolve into the solvent in the jar instead of being carried up the plate. A compound cannot move faster than the solvent that carries it, so its distance is at most the solvent's: $R_{f}\le1$.
8 Both $R_{f}$ values are high, so the compounds spend most of their time in the mobile phase. A less polar eluent (e.g. 10–15% ethyl ethanoate) lowers both and spreads them apart; a different solvent system, or a longer plate, also helps.
🎯 Exam corner JEE Main · MCQJEE Main · Numerical

E1. JEE Main · MCQ In the soap industry, glycerol is recovered from spent lye by (A) steam distillation (B) distillation under reduced pressure (C) fractional crystallisation (D) sublimation

Idea Glycerol is a high-boiling liquid that decomposes at its normal boiling point, and it is miscible with water, so steam distillation is ruled out.
Method Lowering the external pressure lowers its boiling point below the decomposition temperature.
Answer (B).

E2. JEE Main · Numerical Nitrobenzene ($M=123\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}$) is steam-distilled at $760$ mmHg. At the boiling temperature of the mixture the vapour pressure of water is $740$ mmHg. Find the mass of nitrobenzene, in grams, that distils over with $1.00$ kg of water. Give the answer to the nearest integer.

Pressures $p_{\text{org}}^{\circ}=760-740=20$ mmHg.
Mass ratio $\dfrac{m_{\text{org}}}{m_{\text{w}}}=\dfrac{20\times123}{740\times18}=\dfrac{2460}{13\,320}=0.1847$; with $1000$ g of water, $m_{\text{org}}=184.7$ g.
Answer $185$.
⏱ Shortcut Mole ratio $=$ pressure ratio $=20/740$; moles of water $=1000/18=55.6$, so moles of nitrobenzene $=1.50$, mass $=1.50\times123=185$ g.

E3. JEE Main · MCQ On a TLC plate, the baseline is $2.0$ cm above the lower edge. After development, the solvent front is $9.5$ cm and a spot is $5.0$ cm above the lower edge. The $R_{f}$ of the compound is (A) $0.53$ (B) $0.67$ (C) $0.40$ (D) $0.32$

Distances from the baseline Spot: $5.0-2.0=3.0$ cm; front: $9.5-2.0=7.5$ cm.
Ratio $R_{f}=\dfrac{3.0}{7.5}=0.40$.
Answer (C).
⏱ Shortcut (A) is $5.0/9.5$ — both distances taken from the edge; (B) and (D) mix the two references. Always subtract the baseline first.

E4. JEE Main · Numerical An aqueous solution ($100$ mL) of an organic compound is extracted with two successive $50$-mL portions of an organic solvent. The distribution coefficient (organic/aqueous) is $2.0$. What percentage of the compound is extracted in total? Give the answer to the nearest integer.

Each portion Fraction left $=\dfrac{V}{V+K_{D}v}=\dfrac{100}{100+2.0\times50}=\dfrac12$.
Two portions Left $=\left(\dfrac12\right)^{2}=0.25$; extracted $=0.75$.
Answer $75$.
⏱ Shortcut One $100$-mL portion would leave $\tfrac{100}{300}=\tfrac13$, extracting only $67\%$ — splitting the solvent gains 8 percentage points.

E5. JEE Main · MCQ A mixture of $o$-nitrophenol and $p$-nitrophenol is separated by steam distillation because (A) the $p$-isomer has the lower molar mass (B) the $o$-isomer is more soluble in water (C) the $p$-isomer forms an intramolecular hydrogen bond (D) the $o$-isomer forms an intramolecular hydrogen bond and is steam-volatile

Structure In the ortho isomer the –OH and –$\mathrm{NO_{2}}$ groups are neighbours and form a hydrogen bond within the molecule; the molecules are not associated with each other or strongly with water, so the compound is volatile in steam.
Para The para groups are too far apart; it forms intermolecular hydrogen bonds, has a much lower volatility and remains in the flask.
Answer (D). (A) is false — they are isomers with equal molar masses; (B) and (C) reverse the facts.

E6. JEE Main · Numerical Two liquids $A$ and $B$ form an ideal solution, and at the column temperature $p_{A}^{\circ}=3p_{B}^{\circ}$ (take this ratio as constant). Starting from an equimolar liquid, what is the minimum number of successive vaporisation–condensation steps needed to obtain a vapour containing at least $95$ mol% of $A$?

Idea By Raoult's and Dalton's laws, $\dfrac{y_{A}}{y_{B}}=\dfrac{p_{A}^{\circ}}{p_{B}^{\circ}}\cdot\dfrac{x_{A}}{x_{B}}$: each step multiplies the $A:B$ ratio by $3$.
Steps Ratio $1\rightarrow3\rightarrow9\rightarrow27$. We need $\dfrac{y_{A}}{y_{B}}\ge\dfrac{0.95}{0.05}=19$, first reached after 3 steps ($y_{A}=27/28=0.964$).
Answer $3$.
🔬 Research–Teaching NexusResearch-tutored · optional, about 60 minutes

Research question. Which colouring agents are in a coloured sweet or a felt-tip pen — and do two products with the "same" colour use the same dyes?

Why it matters. Food-safety laboratories in many countries screen confectionery, spices and drinks for permitted and banned dyes; forensic scientists compare inks on questioned documents; pharmaceutical quality-control laboratories run TLC on every batch of a drug to check that no impurity spot appears. All of them rely on $R_{f}$ values measured under fixed conditions.

What to do.

  1. Cut strips of chromatography paper (or coffee-filter paper) and draw a pencil baseline $1.5$ cm from the bottom.
  2. Dissolve the coating of two or three sweets of the same colour in a few drops of water; spot each, and two felt-tip pens of the same colour, on separate strips. Let each spot dry and re-spot two or three times to keep it small but concentrated.
  3. Develop the strips in a covered jar with a little salt water (about 1% NaCl) — then repeat with a 1:1 mixture of water and propan-2-ol (rubbing alcohol). Mark the solvent front as soon as you remove each strip.
  4. Measure every spot and calculate its $R_{f}$ in both solvents. Group spots with matching $R_{f}$ values across products.

Tools: Chromatography or filter paper, pencil, ruler, glass jars with lids, salt, rubbing alcohol, toothpicks for spotting, a phone camera to record the strips.

Hand in: Photographs of the strips, a table of $R_{f}$ values in both solvents, and a short conclusion: how many dyes each product contains, which products share dyes, and why agreement in two solvents is stronger evidence than in one.

Going further. Run the same sample with the spot made larger and larger. At what size do neighbouring spots start to merge? Why do analytical laboratories insist on small, concentrated spots?

Instructor note: food dyes are ionic and very soluble in water, so salt water gives well-spread spots; the alcohol mixture changes their order slightly, which makes a good discussion of why identification needs two solvents. Black and brown inks often separate into three or more colours. Felt-tip $R_{f}$ values typically repeat within about $\pm0.03$ between strips run together but drift more between days (temperature, paper batch) — the reason reference samples are always run on the same plate.

🧪 Self-check quiz

0/5 correct

Q1. Camphor containing a little sand is best purified by

Q2. On a silica-gel TLC plate, compound X has $R_{f}=0.75$ and compound Y has $R_{f}=0.25$ in the same solvent. Which statement is correct?

Q3. A compound can be purified by steam distillation only if it is

Q4. A solute with $K_{D}=C_{\text{org}}/C_{\text{aq}}=2$ is extracted from $100$ mL of water. Which procedure removes the most solute?

Q5. In paper chromatography the stationary phase is