17.4 Aldehydes and Ketones: Named Reactions and Tests; Carboxylic Acids
Aldehydes are oxidised easily and ketones are not — the basis of the Tollens' and Fehling's tests. Both can be reduced to alcohols or right down to $\mathrm{CH_{2}}$, their α-hydrogens are acidic enough to drive aldol condensations, and carboxylic acids owe their acidity to a resonance-stabilised anion.
Rub a warm test tube that contains glucose solution and Tollens' reagent, and its inside turns into a mirror; a drop of an aldehyde turns blue Fehling's solution brick-red; a few drops of propanone warmed with iodine and alkali give a yellow, antiseptic-smelling solid. These colour changes are how chemists told aldehydes from ketones long before spectroscopy — and they are still among the most-asked facts in JEE Main organic chemistry. Behind each one is a single structural difference: an aldehyde has a hydrogen on its carbonyl carbon, a ketone does not.
Section 17.3 dealt with additions to the $\mathrm{C{=}O}$ group. Here we look at what happens around it: oxidation and reduction, the acidity of the hydrogen atoms on the next carbon (the α-hydrogens) and the reactions this acidity makes possible — the aldol condensation, and, for aldehydes that have no α-hydrogen, the Cannizzaro reaction — then the haloform reaction and the tests that tell aldehydes and ketones apart. We finish with carboxylic acids, the oxidation products of aldehydes, and the factors that decide how strong an acid they are. You will need nucleophilic addition from Section 17.3, the electronic effects of Section 14.3 and $K_{a}$, $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ from Section 6.3.
Oxidation and reduction of aldehydes and ketones
To oxidise a carbonyl compound to a carboxylic acid without breaking the carbon chain, the oxidant must replace an H on the carbonyl carbon by OH. Aldehydes have that hydrogen; ketones do not. So aldehydes are oxidised even by mild oxidising agents and are good reducing agents, while ketones are oxidised only by strong oxidants under vigorous conditions, with cleavage of a $\mathrm{C{-}C}$ bond next to the carbonyl group (a mixture of acids with fewer carbon atoms results).
Tollens' reagent is ammoniacal silver nitrate: silver nitrate solution treated with aqueous ammonia until the brown precipitate of $\mathrm{Ag_{2}O}$ just redissolves, giving the complex ion $\mathrm{[Ag(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}}$. It is prepared fresh and used warm.
Fehling's solution is made just before use by mixing equal volumes of Fehling A (aqueous copper(II) sulphate) and Fehling B (alkaline sodium potassium tartrate, Rochelle salt). The tartrate keeps $\mathrm{Cu^{2+}}$ in solution as a deep-blue complex in the alkali. (Benedict's solution is similar, with citrate in place of tartrate.)
Tollens' test. Aldehydes (aliphatic and aromatic) are oxidised to the carboxylate ion, and silver ions are reduced to metallic silver, deposited as a silver mirror (or a grey-black precipitate):
$$\mathrm{RCHO+2[Ag(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}+3OH^{-}\rightarrow RCOO^{-}+2Ag+2H_{2}O+4NH_{3}}$$Fehling's test. On warming, aliphatic aldehydes reduce the copper(II) complex to a red-brown precipitate of copper(I) oxide:
$$\mathrm{RCHO+2Cu^{2+}+5OH^{-}\rightarrow RCOO^{-}+Cu_{2}O+3H_{2}O}$$Scope. Ketones give neither test. Aromatic aldehydes (benzaldehyde) give Tollens' but not Fehling's test. Methanoic acid, $\mathrm{HCOOH}$, which contains an aldehyde-like $\mathrm{H{-}C{=}O}$ unit, gives both. Methanal reduces 4 mol of $\mathrm{Ag^{+}}$ per mole, because the methanoate first formed is itself oxidised (to carbonate).
Strong oxidants. Acidified $\mathrm{KMnO_{4}}$ or $\mathrm{K_{2}Cr_{2}O_{7}}$, and even air, oxidise aldehydes to carboxylic acids: $\mathrm{RCHO+[O]\rightarrow RCOOH}$. Ketones need hot concentrated oxidants and break into smaller acids.
In each test equation the aldehyde carbon goes from oxidation state $+1$ (in $\mathrm{RCHO}$) to $+3$ (in $\mathrm{RCOO^{-}}$): two electrons are given up, so two $\mathrm{Ag^{+}}$ or two $\mathrm{Cu^{2+}}$ ions are reduced. For methanal, the carbon goes from $0$ to $+4$ (in $\mathrm{CO_{3}^{2-}}$), four electrons in all:
$$\mathrm{HCHO+4[Ag(NH_{3})_{2}]^{+}+6OH^{-}\rightarrow CO_{3}^{2-}+4Ag+4H_{2}O+8NH_{3}}$$Reduction
To an alcohol. Sodium borohydride, $\mathrm{NaBH_{4}}$ (in water or ethanol), lithium aluminium hydride, $\mathrm{LiAlH_{4}}$ (in dry ether, then water), or $\mathrm{H_{2}}$ over Ni, Pt or Pd. Aldehydes give $1^{\circ}$ alcohols, ketones $2^{\circ}$ alcohols. The hydride reagents deliver $\mathrm{H^{-}}$ to the carbonyl carbon (a nucleophilic addition) and leave an isolated $\mathrm{C{=}C}$ untouched; catalytic hydrogenation reduces $\mathrm{C{=}C}$ as well.
$$\mathrm{RCHO\xrightarrow{NaBH_{4}}RCH_{2}OH}\qquad \mathrm{R_{2}CO\xrightarrow{NaBH_{4}}R_{2}CHOH}$$To a hydrocarbon ($\mathrm{C{=}O\rightarrow CH_{2}}$).
- Clemmensen reduction — zinc amalgam and concentrated hydrochloric acid, heat: $\mathrm{R_{2}C{=}O\xrightarrow{Zn{-}Hg,\ conc.\ HCl}R_{2}CH_{2}+H_{2}O}$. For compounds stable to acid.
- Wolff–Kishner reduction — hydrazine forms the hydrazone, which is heated with KOH (or sodium ethoxide) in a high-boiling solvent such as ethane-1,2-diol, losing nitrogen: $\mathrm{R_{2}C{=}O\xrightarrow{NH_{2}NH_{2}}R_{2}C{=}NNH_{2}\xrightarrow[\text{heat}]{\text{KOH, glycol}}R_{2}CH_{2}+N_{2}}$. For compounds stable to base.
Which compound reduces Tollens' reagent but not Fehling's solution?
Acidity of α-hydrogens: the aldol condensation
The α-carbon of an aldehyde or ketone is the carbon directly bonded to the carbonyl carbon; hydrogens on it are α-hydrogens. A base can remove an α-hydrogen as a proton, giving an enolate ion, whose negative charge is shared by resonance between the α-carbon and the oxygen: $\mathrm{{}^{-}CH_{2}{-}CH{=}O\leftrightarrow CH_{2}{=}CH{-}O^{-}}$.
An ordinary $\mathrm{C{-}H}$ bond is hardly acidic at all ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ of ethane ≈ 50). An α-hydrogen is about $10^{30}$ times more acidic — $\mathrm{p}K_{a}\approx17$ for ethanal and $\approx19$ for propanone — for two reasons: the electron-withdrawing $\mathrm{C{=}O}$ group polarises the $\mathrm{C{-}H}$ bond ($-I$), and, much more important, the anion left behind is stabilised by resonance that puts most of the negative charge on the electronegative oxygen. Even so, an α-hydrogen is a weaker acid than water ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ 15.7), so in dilute NaOH only a small fraction of the carbonyl compound is present as enolate at any moment — but that is enough for it to react. Only hydrogens on the α-carbon are acidic: the aldehydic H, and H on β- or γ-carbons, are not.
In the aldol reaction, two molecules of an aldehyde or ketone that has at least one α-hydrogen combine in the presence of dilute alkali (e.g. 10 % NaOH) to give a β-hydroxy aldehyde (an aldol) or a β-hydroxy ketone (a ketol). On warming (or with acid) the product loses water between the α-carbon and the β-OH to give an α,β-unsaturated carbonyl compound; the overall change is called aldol condensation.
$$\mathrm{2CH_{3}CHO\xrightarrow{\text{dil. NaOH}}CH_{3}CH(OH)CH_{2}CHO\xrightarrow[-\mathrm{H_{2}O}]{\text{heat}}CH_{3}CH{=}CHCHO}$$ $$\mathrm{2CH_{3}COCH_{3}\rightleftharpoons(CH_{3})_{2}C(OH)CH_{2}COCH_{3}\xrightarrow[-\mathrm{H_{2}O}]{\text{heat}}(CH_{3})_{2}C{=}CHCOCH_{3}}$$(3-hydroxybutanal → but-2-enal; 4-hydroxy-4-methylpentan-2-one → 4-methylpent-3-en-2-one). Dehydration is easy because the new $\mathrm{C{=}C}$ is conjugated with $\mathrm{C{=}O}$.
The new bond always joins the α-carbon of the donor (the molecule that formed the enolate) to the carbonyl carbon of the acceptor. So the product has the $\mathrm{OH}$ on the carbon that was the acceptor's $\mathrm{C{=}O}$, and the donor's $\mathrm{C{=}O}$ survives two carbons away (β).
Crossed aldol reactions
When two different carbonyl compounds react, each one that has α-hydrogens can be a donor, and each can be an acceptor. With two compounds that both have α-hydrogens, four products are possible (two self and two crossed), which is useless for synthesis. The reaction is useful when one partner has no α-hydrogen (methanal, benzaldehyde, 2,2-dimethylpropanal) and can only accept. Benzaldehyde with a ketone or aldehyde that has α-H gives an α,β-unsaturated product conjugated with the ring — the Claisen–Schmidt reaction:
$$\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CHO+CH_{3}COCH_{3}\xrightarrow[\text{heat}]{\text{dil. NaOH}}C_{6}H_{5}CH{=}CHCOCH_{3}+H_{2}O}$$ $$\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CHO+CH_{3}CHO\xrightarrow[\text{heat}]{\text{dil. NaOH}}C_{6}H_{5}CH{=}CHCHO+H_{2}O}$$(4-phenylbut-3-en-2-one; 3-phenylprop-2-enal, cinnamaldehyde).
For a mixture of different carbonyl compounds, each having at most one kind of α-carbon, with dilute alkali:
$$\text{number of aldol products}=D\times A$$where $D$ = number of compounds with α-hydrogens (possible donors) and $A$ = number of compounds present (all can accept). Structural isomers only are counted; stereoisomers are ignored. Two enolisable compounds give $2\times2=4$; one enolisable + one non-enolisable give $1\times2=2$ (one self, one crossed); two non-enolisable compounds give no aldol product (with concentrated alkali, aldehydes of this kind undergo the Cannizzaro reaction instead).
Ethanal and propanal are mixed with dilute NaOH. How many different aldol products (β-hydroxy aldehydes, ignoring stereoisomers) can form?
Which compound does not undergo a self-aldol reaction with dilute NaOH?
Cannizzaro and haloform reactions; telling aldehydes from ketones
Aldehydes with no α-hydrogen, heated with concentrated alkali (about 50 % NaOH or KOH), undergo self oxidation–reduction (disproportionation): one molecule is oxidised to the carboxylate salt and another is reduced to the alcohol.
$$\mathrm{2HCHO+NaOH(conc.)\rightarrow HCOONa+CH_{3}OH}$$ $$\mathrm{2C_{6}H_{5}CHO+NaOH(conc.)\rightarrow C_{6}H_{5}COONa+C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}OH}$$In a crossed Cannizzaro reaction between methanal and another aldehyde without α-H, methanal is the one oxidised (to methanoate) and the other aldehyde is reduced to its alcohol: $\mathrm{HCHO+C_{6}H_{5}CHO+NaOH\rightarrow HCOONa+C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}OH}$.
The mechanism explains both conditions. Hydroxide adds to the carbonyl carbon (a nucleophilic addition). The resulting anion, pushed by the negative oxygen, can expel a hydride ion directly on to the carbonyl carbon of a second aldehyde molecule. An aldehyde with α-hydrogens never gets this far: the base removes an α-hydrogen instead and an aldol reaction takes over. Methanal is oxidised in the crossed reaction because, being the most reactive carbonyl compound, it adds hydroxide most readily and so becomes the hydride donor.
Compounds containing the methyl ketone group $\mathrm{CH_{3}CO{-}}$ (methyl ketones and ethanal), or a group oxidised to it under the conditions, $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH(OH){-}}$ (ethanol and secondary alcohols $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH(OH)R}$), react with a halogen in alkali (sodium hypohalite, $\mathrm{NaOX}$) to give the haloform $\mathrm{CHX_{3}}$ and the salt of an acid with one carbon fewer:
$$\mathrm{RCOCH_{3}+3I_{2}+4NaOH\rightarrow CHI_{3}+RCOONa+3NaI+3H_{2}O}$$With iodine the product, iodoform ($\mathrm{CHI_{3}}$, $M=394$), is a yellow precipitate with a characteristic smell: the iodoform test. The three α-hydrogens of the methyl group are replaced one after another by halogen (each substitution makes the next H more acidic), then hydroxide attacks the carbonyl carbon and $\mathrm{{}^{-}CX_{3}}$ leaves.
An alcohol first has to be oxidised by the hypoiodite to the methyl carbonyl compound, which costs one more mole of $\mathrm{I_{2}}$ (and two of NaOH):
$$\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}OH+4I_{2}+6NaOH\rightarrow CHI_{3}+HCOONa+5NaI+5H_{2}O}$$Methanol, propan-1-ol, propanal, pentan-3-one and methanal give no iodoform. Ethanoic acid and its esters do not either: in them the $\mathrm{CH_{3}CO}$ unit is joined to OH or OR, whose lone pairs reduce the acidity of the methyl hydrogens.
Tests that distinguish aldehydes and ketones
| Test | Aldehydes | Ketones | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2,4-DNP | yellow–red precipitate | yellow–red precipitate | shows a $\mathrm{C{=}O}$ group; does not distinguish |
| Tollens' reagent, warm | silver mirror | no change | aromatic aldehydes also positive; also $\mathrm{HCOOH}$ |
| Fehling's solution, warm | red-brown $\mathrm{Cu_{2}O}$ (aliphatic only) | no change | benzaldehyde negative |
| Schiff's reagent (decolorised rosaniline) | pink–magenta colour restored | usually no colour | quick test for aldehydes |
| $\mathrm{I_{2}}$ + NaOH (iodoform) | only ethanal | methyl ketones $\mathrm{CH_{3}COR}$ | tells $\mathrm{CH_{3}CO{-}}$ from other carbonyls |
| $\mathrm{NaHCO_{3}}$ solution | no change | no change | carboxylic acids effervesce ($\mathrm{CO_{2}}$) |
Methanal and benzaldehyde are heated together with concentrated NaOH. The main products are
Carboxylic acids: acidic strength
Oxidising an aldehyde gives a carboxylic acid, $\mathrm{RCOOH}$. The carboxyl group contains a $\mathrm{C{=}O}$, yet carboxylic acids do not give the typical carbonyl reactions (no 2,4-DNP precipitate, no bisulphite or cyanohydrin): a lone pair of the $\mathrm{{-}OH}$ oxygen is delocalised into the $\mathrm{C{=}O}$ group, which makes the carbon much less electrophilic. Their most important property for JEE Main is their acidity.
Anything that stabilises the carboxylate ion $\mathrm{RCOO^{-}}$ relative to the acid (by spreading its negative charge) increases $K_{a}$ and lowers $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$.
- Resonance in the anion. Two equivalent structures put the charge on two oxygens. This is why carboxylic acids ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}\approx 4$–5) are far stronger than alcohols ($\approx 16$), whose alkoxide charge stays on one O, and than phenols ($\approx 10$), whose phenoxide spreads the charge on to less electronegative ring carbons in non-equivalent structures.
- Inductive effect of substituents. Electron-withdrawing ($-I$) groups increase acidity: $\mathrm{NO_{2}\gt CN\gt F\gt Cl\gt Br\gt I}$. Electron-releasing ($+I$) alkyl groups decrease it: $\mathrm{HCOOH\gt CH_{3}COOH\gt CH_{3}CH_{2}COOH}$.
- Number of groups. Effects add: $\mathrm{Cl_{3}CCOOH\gt Cl_{2}CHCOOH\gt ClCH_{2}COOH\gt CH_{3}COOH}$.
- Distance. The inductive effect fades rapidly along the chain: 2-chlorobutanoic $\gt$ 3-chlorobutanoic $\gt$ 4-chlorobutanoic $\gt$ butanoic acid.
- Aromatic acids. Benzoic acid ($4.20$) is stronger than ethanoic acid ($4.74$): the $sp^{2}$ ring carbon is more electronegative than an $sp^{3}$ carbon. Electron-withdrawing groups on the ring (especially at para, by $-R$ as well as $-I$) increase acidity; electron-releasing groups ($\mathrm{CH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{OCH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{OH}$, $\mathrm{NH_{2}}$ at para) decrease it. Almost any ortho substituent increases the acidity of benzoic acid, whatever its electronic nature (the ortho effect: steric push twists the COOH out of the ring plane, cutting its conjugation with the ring).
| Acid | $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ | Acid | $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ |
|---|---|---|---|
| $\mathrm{Cl_{3}CCOOH}$ | 0.65 | $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}COOH}$ | 4.20 |
| $\mathrm{Cl_{2}CHCOOH}$ | 1.29 | 4-nitrobenzoic acid | 3.44 |
| $\mathrm{FCH_{2}COOH}$ | 2.59 | 4-methylbenzoic acid | 4.37 |
| $\mathrm{ClCH_{2}COOH}$ | 2.86 | 4-methoxybenzoic acid | 4.47 |
| $\mathrm{BrCH_{2}COOH}$ | 2.90 | 2-nitrobenzoic acid | 2.17 |
| $\mathrm{HCOOH}$ | 3.74 | phenol | 10.0 |
| $\mathrm{CH_{3}COOH}$ | 4.74 | 4-nitrophenol | 7.15 |
| $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}COOH}$ | 4.87 | ethanol | 15.9 |
Reaction with sodium hydrogencarbonate. Carbonic acid has $\mathrm{p}K_{a1}=6.35$. An acid stronger than this (lower $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$) converts $\mathrm{HCO_{3}^{-}}$ into $\mathrm{H_{2}CO_{3}}$, which releases $\mathrm{CO_{2}}$: $\mathrm{RCOOH+NaHCO_{3}\rightarrow RCOONa+H_{2}O+CO_{2}\uparrow}$. Carboxylic acids effervesce; ordinary phenols ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}\approx10$) and alcohols do not. Overall order of acidity: $\mathrm{RCOOH\gt H_{2}CO_{3}\gt C_{6}H_{5}OH\gt H_{2}O\gt ROH}$.
One chlorine atom replaces a hydrogen on the methyl group of ethanoic acid. Roughly how many times larger does $K_{a}$ become?
1. Fehling's and benzaldehyde. Aromatic aldehydes give Tollens' test but not Fehling's. Methanoic acid gives both; ketones give neither. Methanal deposits 4 Ag per molecule, not 2.
2. Counting α-hydrogens wrongly. The aldehydic H and ring H are not α-H; count both sides of a ketone ($\mathrm{CH_{3}COCH_{2}CH_{3}}$ has 5). No α-H → no aldol, and with concentrated alkali → Cannizzaro.
3. Crossed Cannizzaro. Methanal is always the one oxidised (to methanoate); the partner gives the alcohol. Dilute alkali does not cause Cannizzaro; concentrated alkali with an enolisable aldehyde gives aldol-type products.
4. Iodoform scope. Positive: ethanal, ethanol, methyl ketones, $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH(OH)R}$. Negative: methanol, methanal, propanal, propan-1-ol, pentan-3-one, ethanoic acid and esters. Moles of $\mathrm{I_{2}}$: 3 for a methyl carbonyl, 4 for an alcohol.
5. Acid strength. F gives a stronger acid than Cl (larger $-I$), but $\mathrm{Cl_{2}CHCOOH}\gt\mathrm{FCH_{2}COOH}$ (two groups). Benzoic acid is stronger than ethanoic acid; any ortho substituent strengthens benzoic acid; phenol does not react with $\mathrm{NaHCO_{3}}$.
Which order of acid strength is correct?
Exercises
Use $\mathrm{C}=12$, $\mathrm{H}=1$, $\mathrm{O}=16$, $\mathrm{Ag}=108$, $\mathrm{CHI_{3}}=394\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}$, molar volume of a gas at STP $22.4\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}}$, and the $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ table in this section.
- 1 How many of these reduce Tollens' reagent: ethanal, propanone, benzaldehyde, methanoic acid, butan-2-one?
- 2 How many of these reduce Fehling's solution: ethanal, benzaldehyde, propanone, methanal?
- 3 What mass of silver is deposited by $0.88\ \mathrm{g}$ of ethanal with excess Tollens' reagent?
- 4 What mass of silver is deposited by $0.15\ \mathrm{g}$ of methanal with excess Tollens' reagent?
- 5 Give the product of propanone with (a) $\mathrm{NaBH_{4}}$; (b) $\mathrm{Zn{-}Hg}$/conc. HCl; (c) $\mathrm{NH_{2}NH_{2}}$, then KOH in ethane-1,2-diol, heat.
- 6 Write the equation for the Fehling's test with ethanal and give the oxidation states of copper before and after.
- 7 $12.0\ \mathrm{g}$ of 1-phenylethan-1-one undergoes complete Wolff–Kishner reduction. What volume of nitrogen (at STP) is released?
- 8 Why are ketones not oxidised by Tollens' reagent, while strong hot oxidants give a mixture of acids with fewer carbon atoms?
- 1 How many α-hydrogens are there in butan-2-one? In pentan-3-one? In 2,2-dimethylpropanal?
- 2 How many of these undergo a self-aldol reaction with dilute NaOH: methanal, ethanal, 2,2-dimethylpropanal, benzaldehyde, propanone?
- 3 Give the aldol product of propanal and its molar mass.
- 4 How many aldol products can form from a mixture of ethanal and propanone with dilute NaOH?
- 5 Benzaldehyde and ethanal are warmed with dilute NaOH. Give the main condensation product and its molar mass.
- 6 Benzaldehyde (2 mol) and propanone (1 mol) are warmed with dilute NaOH. Give the product.
- 7 Explain why the α-hydrogens of propanone ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}\approx19$) are far more acidic than the hydrogens of ethane ($\approx50$).
- 8 Why does the ketol from propanone lose water so easily on warming, and what is the product?
- 1 Write the Cannizzaro reaction of benzaldehyde. Which molecule is oxidised and which reduced?
- 2 Methanal and 2,2-dimethylpropanal are heated with concentrated NaOH. Give the main products and explain which aldehyde is oxidised.
- 3 What mass of phenylmethanol can be obtained from $21.2\ \mathrm{g}$ of benzaldehyde by the Cannizzaro reaction (complete reaction)?
- 4 How many of these give the iodoform test: ethanol, methanol, propan-2-ol, propan-1-ol, butan-2-one, pentan-3-one, ethanal, propanal, 1-phenylethan-1-one, ethanoic acid?
- 5 How many moles of $\mathrm{I_{2}}$ react with one mole of propanone in the iodoform reaction? How many moles of NaOH?
- 6 What mass of iodoform is formed from $2.9\ \mathrm{g}$ of propanone?
- 7 Give one test to distinguish each pair: (a) propanal and propanone; (b) pentan-2-one and pentan-3-one; (c) benzaldehyde and ethanal; (d) ethanoic acid and phenol.
- 8 A compound $\mathrm{C_{3}H_{6}O}$ gives the iodoform test and does not reduce Tollens' reagent. Identify it.
- 1 Arrange in increasing acid strength: $\mathrm{Cl_{3}CCOOH}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}COOH}$, $\mathrm{Cl_{2}CHCOOH}$, $\mathrm{ClCH_{2}COOH}$.
- 2 Arrange in decreasing acid strength: $\mathrm{ICH_{2}COOH}$, $\mathrm{FCH_{2}COOH}$, $\mathrm{BrCH_{2}COOH}$, $\mathrm{ClCH_{2}COOH}$.
- 3 Arrange in decreasing acid strength: butanoic acid, 2-chlorobutanoic, 3-chlorobutanoic, 4-chlorobutanoic acid. Explain.
- 4 How many times larger is $K_{a}$ of chloroethanoic acid than that of ethanoic acid?
- 5 Arrange in decreasing acid strength: benzoic acid, 4-nitrobenzoic acid, 4-methoxybenzoic acid, 4-methylbenzoic acid.
- 6 Arrange in decreasing acid strength: ethanol, phenol, ethanoic acid, water, 4-nitrophenol.
- 7 Estimate the pH of $0.10\ \mathrm{M}$ ethanoic acid ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}=4.74$), assuming slight ionisation.
- 8 How many of these release $\mathrm{CO_{2}}$ from aqueous $\mathrm{NaHCO_{3}}$: ethanoic acid, phenol, 4-nitrophenol, benzoic acid, 2,4,6-trinitrophenol ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}=0.38$)?
- 9 Explain why methanoic acid is stronger than ethanoic acid, and why benzoic acid is stronger than ethanoic acid.
E1. JEE Main · MCQ Which compound gives a positive iodoform test but does not reduce Tollens' reagent? (A) ethanal (B) propanal (C) butan-2-one (D) pentan-3-one
E2. JEE Main · Numerical A mixture of ethanal, propanal and benzaldehyde is treated with dilute aqueous NaOH. How many different aldol addition products (β-hydroxy aldehydes; ignore stereoisomers) are possible? Give the answer to the nearest integer.
E3. JEE Main · MCQ The strongest acid among the following is (A) $\mathrm{Cl_{2}CHCOOH}$ (B) $\mathrm{FCH_{2}COOH}$ (C) $\mathrm{ClCH_{2}COOH}$ (D) $\mathrm{HCOOH}$
E4. JEE Main · Numerical Propan-2-ol is warmed with excess iodine and sodium hydroxide until the reaction is complete. How many moles of $\mathrm{I_{2}}$ are consumed per mole of propan-2-ol? Give the answer to the nearest integer.
E5. JEE Main · MCQ Methanal and benzaldehyde (1 : 1) are heated with concentrated NaOH. The main products are (A) $\mathrm{HCOONa}$ and $\mathrm{CH_{3}OH}$ only (B) $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}COONa}$ and $\mathrm{CH_{3}OH}$ (C) $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH(OH)CH_{2}CHO}$ (D) $\mathrm{HCOONa}$ and $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}OH}$
E6. JEE Main · Numerical $0.30\ \mathrm{g}$ of methanal reacts completely with excess Tollens' reagent. How many millimoles of silver are deposited? ($\mathrm{C}=12$, $\mathrm{H}=1$, $\mathrm{O}=16$.) Give the answer to the nearest integer.
Research question. Can one number per substituent predict how much that substituent changes the strength of an aromatic acid — and does the same number work for other acids?
Why it matters. The $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ of a drug decides how much of it is ionised in the stomach (pH ≈ 2) and in blood (pH 7.4), and so how well it crosses cell membranes. Food preservatives such as benzoic and sorbic acid work mainly in their un-ionised form, which is why they are used in acidic foods. Pharmaceutical and food chemists estimate $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values before a compound is ever made, using exactly this kind of substituent analysis.
What to do.
- Collect measured $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values (water, $298\ \mathrm{K}$) of benzoic acid and of its 3- and 4-substituted derivatives for at least eight substituents ($\mathrm{NO_{2}}$, $\mathrm{CN}$, $\mathrm{Cl}$, $\mathrm{Br}$, $\mathrm{H}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{OCH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{NH_{2}}$ …).
- For each one compute $\sigma=\mathrm{p}K_{a}(\text{benzoic})-\mathrm{p}K_{a}(\text{substituted})$. Positive $\sigma$ means electron-withdrawing.
- Collect $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values of the same 4-substituted phenols (or phenylethanoic acids). Plot their $\Delta\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ against your $\sigma$ values and fit a straight line.
- Interpret the slope: is the phenol more or less sensitive to substituents than benzoic acid? Which points lie off the line, and why?
Tools: A spreadsheet or plotting tool; a chemistry data handbook or an open chemical database for $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values.
Hand in: Your $\sigma$ table, the graph with its line and slope, and a paragraph explaining the outliers in terms of resonance.
Going further. Why are ortho substituents left out of such tables? Look up the $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values of the three nitrobenzoic acids and relate them to the ortho effect.
🧪 Self-check quiz
Q1. The reagent for the Clemmensen reduction is
Q2. Which aldehyde does not undergo the Cannizzaro reaction?
Q3. Which compound gives a yellow precipitate with iodine and sodium hydroxide?
Q4. The correct order of acid strength is
Q5. Which reagent distinguishes benzaldehyde from ethanal?