14.3 Bond Fission, Reactive Intermediates, Electronic Effects and Reaction Types
Every organic reaction breaks some bonds and makes others. Which bond breaks, which way the electrons go and how stable the resulting carbocation, carbanion or free radical is are all decided by four electronic effects — inductive, electromeric, resonance and hyperconjugation — and the same effects rank acids and bases.
Bromomethane reacts with hydroxide ion in one smooth step, but 2-bromo-2-methylpropane first falls apart into an ion and only then reacts. Chlorine attacks methane only when light is shone on the mixture. Chloroethanoic acid is about seventy-five times stronger than ethanoic acid, phenol is a million times more acidic than ethanol, and aniline is a million times weaker as a base than methylamine. These look like unrelated facts to memorise. They are not: each one follows from where the electrons are in the molecule and how they can move.
In this section we build the toolkit that the whole of organic chemistry in JEE Main rests on. First, the two ways a covalent bond can break, the three short-lived species that result — free radicals, carbocations and carbanions — and the two kinds of reagent, electrophiles and nucleophiles. Then the four electronic effects that push electron density around a molecule: the inductive effect along σ bonds, the electromeric effect in π bonds under attack, the resonance (mesomeric) effect through conjugated systems and hyperconjugation from neighbouring $\mathrm{C{-}H}$ bonds. We use them to rank intermediates, acids and amines, and finish with the four basic types of organic reaction drawn with curved arrows. You will need hybridisation and resonance from Section 3.3 and $K_{a}$, $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ from Section 6.3.
Bond fission, reactive intermediates and reagents
A covalent bond is a shared pair of electrons. When it breaks, the pair can be divided in only two ways: one electron to each atom, or both electrons to one atom. Chemists track these movements with curved arrows. A full-headed arrow moves a pair of electrons; a half-headed ("fish-hook") arrow moves a single electron. An arrow always starts at the electrons — a bond or a lone pair — never at an atom's nucleus or a positive charge.
Homolytic fission (homolysis): a covalent bond breaks so that each of the two atoms keeps one of the shared electrons, $\mathrm{A{:}B\rightarrow A^{\bullet}+B^{\bullet}}$. It gives two neutral species with an unpaired electron (free radicals). It is favoured by heat or ultraviolet light, by non-polar bonds between similar atoms ($\mathrm{Cl{-}Cl}$, $\mathrm{O{-}O}$ in peroxides, $\mathrm{C{-}C}$ at high temperature) and by the gas phase or non-polar solvents.
Heterolytic fission (heterolysis): the bond breaks so that both shared electrons go to one atom, $\mathrm{A{:}B\rightarrow A^{+}+{:}B^{-}}$, normally the more electronegative one. It gives a pair of ions. It is favoured by polar bonds and by polar solvents that stabilise the ions by solvation.
When the bond broken is to carbon, the carbon-containing fragment is one of three reactive intermediates. They live for a tiny fraction of a second and are rarely isolated, but their stability decides how fast a reaction goes and which product wins — a more stable intermediate forms through a lower-energy transition state.
- A free radical is a species with an unpaired electron; a carbon free radical such as $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{\bullet}}$ has 7 valence electrons on carbon. It is formed by homolysis, is neutral and very reactive because it seeks an electron to pair with.
- A carbocation is a species with a positively charged carbon carrying only three bonds and six valence electrons, e.g. $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{+}}$. It is formed when the carbon loses the bonding pair in heterolysis.
- A carbanion is a species with a negatively charged carbon carrying three bonds and a lone pair, i.e. eight valence electrons, e.g. $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{-}}$, $\mathrm{HC{\equiv}C^{-}}$. It is formed when the carbon keeps the bonding pair in heterolysis.
Carbocations, carbanions and radicals are classified like alkyl halides by the number of carbons on the reactive carbon: methyl (none), primary $1^{\circ}$ (one), secondary $2^{\circ}$ (two), tertiary $3^{\circ}$ (three).
Their shapes follow from VSEPR and hybridisation. In a carbocation the carbon has three electron domains, so it is $sp^{2}$ hybridised and trigonal planar (bond angles $120^{\circ}$); the unhybridised $p$ orbital, perpendicular to the plane, is empty. A carbanion has four domains (three bonds and a lone pair): $sp^{3}$, pyramidal, isoelectronic with $\mathrm{NH_{3}}$. A simple alkyl radical is best described as $sp^{2}$ and planar (or very nearly so) with the odd electron in the $p$ orbital.
An empty or half-filled orbital on carbon is "electron-hungry". Anything that pushes electron density towards it — alkyl groups by their inductive effect and hyperconjugation, or a neighbouring π bond or lone pair by resonance — spreads out the positive charge or the electron deficiency and stabilises the species. A carbanion already has too many electrons on carbon, so the same groups destabilise it; it is stabilised instead by groups that pull electrons away. We explain each effect in the next two subsections; the results are collected here for reference.
Carbocations (alkyl groups donate electrons by $+I$ and hyperconjugation):
$$\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{+}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{+}\gt CH_{3}CH_{2}^{+}\gt CH_{3}^{+}}\qquad(3^{\circ}\gt2^{\circ}\gt1^{\circ}\gt\text{methyl})$$Free radicals (same reasons, smaller differences):
$$\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{\bullet}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{\bullet}\gt CH_{3}CH_{2}^{\bullet}\gt CH_{3}^{\bullet}}$$Carbanions (alkyl groups push more electrons on to an already negative carbon) — the reverse order:
$$\mathrm{CH_{3}^{-}\gt CH_{3}CH_{2}^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{3}C^{-}}$$All three intermediates are strongly stabilised by resonance when the reactive carbon is next to a π bond or a benzene ring (allyl $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CH{-}CH_{2}^{+/\bullet/-}}$, benzyl $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}^{+/\bullet/-}}$). A carbanion is also stabilised by $-I$ groups and by greater $s$ character of the carbon holding the lone pair: $\mathrm{HC{\equiv}C^{-}}$ ($sp$, 50 % $s$) $\gt$ $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CH^{-}}$ ($sp^{2}$) $\gt$ $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}^{-}}$ ($sp^{3}$).
The reagents that attack organic molecules fall into two families according to what they do with electrons. A reagent that is short of electrons looks for an electron-rich site; one that has a spare pair looks for an electron-poor site.
An electrophile ("electron-loving", $\mathrm{E^{+}}$ or E) is a reagent that accepts an electron pair from the substrate to form a new bond. It attacks electron-rich sites (π bonds, lone pairs, negative carbons). Examples: positive ions $\mathrm{H^{+}}$, $\mathrm{NO_{2}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{Br^{+}}$, $\mathrm{Cl^{+}}$, carbocations $\mathrm{R^{+}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}CO^{+}}$; neutral molecules with an incomplete octet or an empty orbital, $\mathrm{BF_{3}}$, $\mathrm{BH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$, $\mathrm{FeCl_{3}}$; and molecules with a strongly δ+ atom, $\mathrm{SO_{3}}$ (at S), the carbonyl carbon of $\mathrm{{>}C{=}O}$.
A nucleophile ("nucleus-loving", $\mathrm{Nu^{-}}$ or Nu:) is a reagent that donates an electron pair to the substrate to form a new bond. It attacks electron-poor sites (δ+ carbon, carbocations). Examples: anions $\mathrm{OH^{-}}$, $\mathrm{RO^{-}}$, $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$, $\mathrm{I^{-}}$, $\mathrm{Br^{-}}$, $\mathrm{HS^{-}}$, carbanions $\mathrm{R^{-}}$; neutral molecules with a lone pair, $\mathrm{H_{2}O}$, $\mathrm{ROH}$, $\mathrm{NH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{RNH_{2}}$, $\mathrm{R_{3}N}$. Every nucleophile is a Lewis base and every electrophile a Lewis acid.
Two points cause frequent errors. A neutral molecule can be either kind: $\mathrm{NH_{3}}$ (lone pair) is a nucleophile, $\mathrm{BF_{3}}$ (empty $p$ orbital on boron) an electrophile. And a positive charge does not automatically make an electrophile: $\mathrm{NH_{4}^{+}}$ has neither an empty orbital nor a lone pair on nitrogen; it can only hand over $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ (a Brønsted acid), never accept a pair. A free radical, with one unpaired electron, is neither; it reacts by pairing electrons one at a time (homolytic, free-radical reactions).
(b) Sort into electrophiles and nucleophiles: $\mathrm{H_{2}O}$, $\mathrm{BH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{NO_{2}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}O^{-}}$, $\mathrm{NH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{Cl^{+}}$, $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$, $\mathrm{FeCl_{3}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{+}}$. How many are electrophiles?
Which species is trigonal planar with an empty $p$ orbital on carbon?
Inductive and electromeric effects
In a bond between atoms of different electronegativity the shared pair lies closer to the more electronegative atom. In chloroethane, Cl pulls the $\mathrm{C{-}Cl}$ pair towards itself, leaving C-1 slightly positive. C-1 in turn pulls a little on the $\mathrm{C{-}C}$ bond pair, so C-2 also becomes slightly positive, but less so. The polarisation is relayed along the σ framework like a weakening echo.
The inductive effect is the permanent displacement of σ-bond electrons along a carbon chain caused by an atom or group of different electronegativity. It is a ground-state (always present) effect; it involves σ electrons only, which shift but never leave their bonds; and it dies away rapidly with distance, becoming negligible after about three bonds.
- $-I$ effect (electron-withdrawing, relative to H): $\mathrm{{-}NR_{3}^{+}\gt{-}NO_{2}\gt{-}CN\gt{-}COOH\gt{-}F\gt{-}Cl\gt{-}Br\gt{-}I\gt{-}OH,\ {-}OR\gt{-}C_{6}H_{5}}$ (and $\mathrm{{-}CH{=}CH_{2}}$, whose $sp^{2}$ carbon is more electronegative than $sp^{3}$ carbon).
- $+I$ effect (electron-releasing): $\mathrm{{-}O^{-}\gt{-}COO^{-}\gt{-}C(CH_{3})_{3}\gt{-}CH(CH_{3})_{2}\gt{-}CH_{2}CH_{3}\gt{-}CH_{3}}$. Alkyl groups release electrons; the more branched, the stronger.
The inductive effect matters most in acid strength. An acid $\mathrm{HA}$ is strong if its conjugate base $\mathrm{A^{-}}$ is stable. A $-I$ group near the $\mathrm{{-}COO^{-}}$ group pulls some of the negative charge towards itself, spreading it over more atoms; a spread-out charge is a stable charge, so the equilibrium $\mathrm{HA\rightleftharpoons H^{+}+A^{-}}$ lies further to the right. A $+I$ group does the opposite: it pushes more negative charge on to the carboxylate and makes the acid weaker.
For acids of the same type (e.g. carboxylic acids), in aqueous solution at the same temperature:
- A $-I$ substituent increases the acid strength (lowers $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$); a $+I$ substituent decreases it.
- The stronger the $-I$ effect, the stronger the acid: $\mathrm{FCH_{2}COOH\ (2.59)\gt ClCH_{2}COOH\ (2.86)\gt BrCH_{2}COOH\ (2.90)\gt ICH_{2}COOH\ (3.18)\gt CH_{3}COOH\ (4.74)}$ ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values in brackets).
- More $-I$ groups, stronger acid: $\mathrm{Cl_{3}CCOOH\ (0.65)\gt Cl_{2}CHCOOH\ (1.29)\gt ClCH_{2}COOH\ (2.86)}$.
- The nearer the group to $\mathrm{{-}COOH}$, the larger the effect; each extra bond passes on only about 40 % of it: 2-chlorobutanoic (2.86) $\gt$ 3-chlorobutanoic (4.05) $\gt$ 4-chlorobutanoic (4.52) $\gt$ butanoic acid (4.82).
- Alkyl groups ($+I$) weaken acids: $\mathrm{HCOOH\ (3.74)\gt CH_{3}COOH\ (4.74)\gt CH_{3}CH_{2}COOH\ (4.87)}$.
Quantitatively, $\mathrm{p}K_{a}=-\log K_{a}$, so an acid whose $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ is lower by $\Delta$ has a $K_{a}$ larger by a factor $10^{\Delta}$.
With Cl on C-2 of butanoic acid, $K_{a}$ is about 76 times that of butanoic acid in the model below. Move the Cl to C-4. Roughly how many times stronger than butanoic acid is the acid now?
The inductive effect is permanent. A second effect appears only at the moment a reagent attacks a multiple bond, and vanishes if the reagent is taken away.
The electromeric effect ($E$ effect) is the complete transfer of the shared π electron pair of a multiple bond ($\mathrm{C{=}C}$, $\mathrm{C{=}O}$, $\mathrm{C{\equiv}N}$ …) to one of the two atoms, caused by the demand of an attacking reagent. It is a temporary effect: it operates only in the presence of the reagent and is reversed when the reagent is removed.
- $+E$ effect: the π pair moves to the atom to which the attacking reagent (an electrophile) becomes attached — e.g. $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ adding to an alkene.
- $-E$ effect: the π pair moves away from the atom to which the attacking reagent (a nucleophile) becomes attached — e.g. $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$ adding to the carbon of $\mathrm{{>}C{=}O}$; the pair goes to O.
When the inductive and electromeric effects act in opposite directions, the electromeric effect dominates while the reagent is present.
Which of these acids is the strongest?
Resonance (mesomeric) effect and hyperconjugation
In Section 3.3 we met resonance as a way of describing molecules such as $\mathrm{O_{3}}$ and $\mathrm{CO_{3}^{2-}}$ that no single Lewis structure fits. In organic chemistry resonance does much more: it lets a group with a lone pair or a π bond feed electrons into a neighbouring π system, or drain them from it, over long distances. Writing the right resonance structures is therefore a working skill, and the rules must be followed exactly.
- Only electrons move, never atoms: the positions of all nuclei are the same in every structure. Curved arrows move π pairs and lone pairs (never σ bonds) into an adjacent bond or atom.
- Every structure has the same number of paired and unpaired electrons and the same total charge. No second-period atom (C, N, O) may exceed an octet.
- Resonance needs conjugation: the interacting $p$ orbitals must be on adjacent atoms and parallel, so the atoms involved must lie in (nearly) one plane. A π bond, lone pair, empty $p$ orbital or odd electron next to a π bond can be delocalised; one separated by an $sp^{3}$ carbon cannot.
- Contributors are not equally important. More important are those with (a) more covalent bonds, (b) complete octets on all atoms, (c) less separation of opposite charges, (d) negative charge on the more electronegative atom and positive on the less, (e) no like charges on adjacent atoms.
- The real species, the resonance hybrid, is more stable than any contributor; the energy difference from the most stable contributor is the resonance energy (about $150\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$ for benzene). It is larger when there are more important structures, and largest when they are equivalent.
When a substituent's lone pair or π bond is conjugated with the rest of the molecule, it shifts π electron density permanently. This is the resonance effect, also called the mesomeric effect, and unlike the inductive effect it is transmitted along a conjugated chain or round a benzene ring without dying away.
The resonance effect or mesomeric effect ($R$ or $M$ effect) is the permanent polarisation of a conjugated system produced by the interaction of a substituent's lone pair or π electrons with the π electrons of the system.
- $+R$ ($+M$) effect: the group donates electrons into the conjugated system (it has a lone pair on the atom joined to the system): $\mathrm{{-}O^{-}}$, $\mathrm{{-}NH_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}NHR}$, $\mathrm{{-}NR_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}OH}$, $\mathrm{{-}OR}$, $\mathrm{{-}NHCOR}$, $\mathrm{{-}OCOR}$, $\mathrm{{-}F}$, $\mathrm{{-}Cl}$, $\mathrm{{-}Br}$, $\mathrm{{-}I}$. Electron density rises at alternate positions of the system — in a benzene ring, at the ortho and para carbons.
- $-R$ ($-M$) effect: the group withdraws π electrons (it has a π bond to a more electronegative atom): $\mathrm{{-}NO_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}CN}$, $\mathrm{{-}CHO}$, $\mathrm{{-}COR}$, $\mathrm{{-}COOH}$, $\mathrm{{-}COOR}$, $\mathrm{{-}CONH_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}SO_{3}H}$. Electron density falls at the ortho and para carbons of a ring.
Many groups show both effects. For $\mathrm{{-}OH}$, $\mathrm{{-}OR}$, $\mathrm{{-}NH_{2}}$ the $+M$ effect outweighs their $-I$ effect; for the halogens the $-I$ effect outweighs the $+M$ effect (poor overlap of the large 3p, 4p, 5p orbitals with carbon's 2p, and high electronegativity).
A consequence you can measure: in chloroethene and chlorobenzene the $\mathrm{C{-}Cl}$ bond has partial double-bond character (the contributor with $\mathrm{C{=}Cl^{+}}$), so it is shorter (about $169\ \mathrm{pm}$ against $178\ \mathrm{pm}$ in chloroethane) and harder to break.
The third delocalising effect looks surprising at first, because it involves σ electrons. Look at the ethyl cation $\mathrm{CH_{3}{-}CH_{2}^{+}}$. The $\mathrm{C{-}C}$ σ bond can rotate, so at any moment one $\mathrm{C{-}H}$ bond of the $\mathrm{CH_{3}}$ group lies parallel to the empty $p$ orbital of the positive carbon. The two orbitals then overlap sideways a little, and the $\mathrm{C{-}H}$ bonding pair spreads partly into the empty orbital. The positive charge is shared, and the cation is stabilised.
Hyperconjugation is the delocalisation of the σ electrons of a $\mathrm{C{-}H}$ bond on an $sp^{3}$ carbon into an adjacent empty or partly filled $p$ orbital, or into an adjacent π bond. The carbon must be directly attached to the unsaturated or electron-deficient carbon (an α-carbon), and its hydrogens are the α-hydrogens.
- It is a permanent, ground-state effect, also called no-bond resonance (the Baker–Nathan effect), because in the contributing structures the hydrogen appears as $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ with no bond to carbon (the H does not actually leave).
- It operates in carbocations (empty $p$), free radicals (half-filled $p$) and alkenes and alkylbenzenes (π bond). It does not stabilise carbanions.
- Number of hyperconjugative structures = number of α-hydrogens. Hydrogens on the charged (or $sp^{2}$) carbon itself, and hydrogens further away, do not count.
Other things being similar, the more α-hydrogens, the more hyperconjugative structures and the more stable the species.
- Carbocations: $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{+}}$ (9 α-H) $\gt$ $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{+}}$ (6) $\gt$ $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}^{+}}$ (3) $\gt$ $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{+}}$ (0). The same order and counts hold for the radicals.
- Alkenes: more alkyl groups on the double-bond carbons, more α-H, more stable: $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}C{=}C(CH_{3})_{2}}$ (12) $\gt$ $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}C{=}CHCH_{3}}$ (9) $\gt$ $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH{=}CHCH_{3}}$ (6) $\gt$ $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH{=}CH_{2}}$ (3) $\gt$ $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CH_{2}}$ (0). Enthalpies of hydrogenation confirm it: but-1-ene $-127$, cis-but-2-ene $-120$, trans-but-2-ene $-116\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$ (less heat released = more stable alkene; the trans isomer also avoids crowding of the two methyl groups).
- Hyperconjugation and the $+I$ effect act in the same direction for alkyl groups; together they explain Rule 14.8. When a hyperconjugation count is asked for, count α-H only.
Which carbocation has more hyperconjugative structures: the $2^{\circ}$ isopropyl cation $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{+}}$ or the $1^{\circ}$ cation $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C{-}CH_{2}^{+}}$, which carries more carbon atoms?
How many hyperconjugative structures does the isopropyl cation $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{+}}$ have?
Applications: acidity, basicity and the four types of reaction
The four effects are most often examined through acid and base strength. The guiding idea is always the same: an acid is strong if its conjugate base is stable; a base is strong if its lone pair is available. Anything that spreads out the negative charge of the conjugate base (resonance, $-I$, $-M$) strengthens an acid; anything that ties up or withdraws the lone pair of a base weakens it.
Carboxylic acids, phenols and alcohols. All three lose $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ from an $\mathrm{O{-}H}$ group, yet their $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values span more than ten units: ethanoic acid $4.74$, phenol $9.89$, water $15.7$, ethanol about $16$. In the carboxylate ion the negative charge is shared equally by two oxygen atoms through two equivalent resonance structures. In the phenoxide ion the charge is delocalised from oxygen into the ring (to the two ortho carbons and the para carbon), but those contributors put the charge on carbon, which is less electronegative than oxygen, so they matter less; phenoxide is stabilised, but not as well as carboxylate. An alkoxide ion $\mathrm{RO^{-}}$ has no resonance at all, and the $+I$ alkyl group pushes even more electron density on to the oxygen. Hence
$$\mathrm{RCOOH\gt C_{6}H_{5}OH\gt H_{2}O\gt ROH}\qquad\text{(acid strength)}.$$Substituents fine-tune these acids. In phenols a $-M$ group at the ortho or para position ($\mathrm{NO_{2}}$) can take the negative charge right on to its own oxygen atoms: 4-nitrophenol ($\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ $7.15$) is far stronger than phenol, while 3-nitrophenol ($8.40$), where only the $-I$ effect works, is in between. Electron-releasing groups weaken phenols: 4-methylphenol $10.26$. Halogens lower $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ because $-I$ wins over $+M$ (4-chlorophenol $9.38$). In benzoic acids the same reasoning holds: 4-nitrobenzoic acid ($3.44$) $\gt$ benzoic acid ($4.19$) $\gt$ 4-methylbenzoic acid ($4.37$) $\gt$ 4-methoxybenzoic acid ($4.47$). Benzoic acid is itself stronger than ethanoic acid because the phenyl ring, with its $sp^{2}$ carbon, is $-I$.
Basicity of amines. An amine accepts $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ with the lone pair on nitrogen, so anything that makes that pair more available, or stabilises the ammonium ion $\mathrm{RNH_{3}^{+}}$, increases basicity. Three factors compete in water: the $+I$ effect of alkyl groups (more alkyl groups, more electron-rich N, stronger base); solvation of the conjugate acid by hydrogen bonding with water ($\mathrm{RNH_{3}^{+}}$ has three $\mathrm{N{-}H}$ to bond with, $\mathrm{R_{3}NH^{+}}$ only one, so the tertiary ion is the least stabilised); and steric hindrance by bulky groups around N. In the gas phase only the inductive effect operates and the order is simply $3^{\circ}\gt2^{\circ}\gt1^{\circ}\gt\mathrm{NH_{3}}$. In water the balance gives (with $\mathrm{p}K_{b}$ values):
| amines | order of basicity in water | $\mathrm{p}K_{b}$ |
|---|---|---|
| methyl | $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}NH\gt CH_{3}NH_{2}\gt(CH_{3})_{3}N\gt NH_{3}}$ | $3.27,\ 3.38,\ 4.22,\ 4.74$ |
| ethyl | $\mathrm{(C_{2}H_{5})_{2}NH\gt(C_{2}H_{5})_{3}N\gt C_{2}H_{5}NH_{2}\gt NH_{3}}$ | $3.00,\ 3.25,\ 3.29,\ 4.74$ |
| aryl | $\mathrm{NH_{3}\gt C_{6}H_{5}NH_{2}}$ | $4.74,\ 9.38$ |
Aniline is a very weak base because its lone pair is delocalised into the benzene ring ($+M$ effect of $\mathrm{{-}NH_{2}}$), and the nitrogen bonded to an $sp^{2}$ carbon is less electron-rich; protonation would destroy that resonance. Ring substituents act as expected: $-M$/$-I$ groups weaken it further (4-nitroaniline, $\mathrm{p}K_{b}$ $13.0$), electron-releasing groups strengthen it (4-methylaniline $8.92$, 4-methoxyaniline $8.66$).
- Reduce the question to one species. For acids compare the conjugate bases $\mathrm{A^{-}}$; for bases compare the availability of the lone pair; for intermediates compare the charged or odd-electron carbon.
- Resonance first. Can the charge (or odd electron, or lone pair) be delocalised through a π bond or ring? Delocalisation on to an electronegative atom (O) is worth most.
- Then hyperconjugation (count α-H) for cations, radicals and alkenes, and inductive effects: type ($\pm I$), number of groups, distance (about 40 % per bond).
- Then special factors: $s$ character for carbanions ($sp\gt sp^{2}\gt sp^{3}$), solvation for amines in water, crowding.
- Check with data you know: $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ 4.74 (ethanoic), 9.89 (phenol), about 16 (ethanol); $\mathrm{p}K_{b}$ 3.3 (aliphatic amines), 4.74 ($\mathrm{NH_{3}}$), 9.4 (aniline). A difference of $\Delta$ units means a factor $10^{\Delta}$ in $K$.
Types of organic reaction. However complicated, almost every organic reaction is one of four kinds, distinguished by what happens to the bonds of the substrate. The curved-arrow pictures below show one example of each; the mechanisms themselves are studied in Units 15–17.
- Substitution: an atom or group of the substrate is replaced by another, $\mathrm{R{-}X+Y\rightarrow R{-}Y+X}$. Named after the attacking reagent: nucleophilic ($\mathrm{CH_{3}Br+OH^{-}\rightarrow CH_{3}OH+Br^{-}}$), electrophilic (nitration of benzene) or free-radical ($\mathrm{CH_{4}+Cl_{2}\xrightarrow{h\nu}CH_{3}Cl+HCl}$).
- Addition: two species combine into one, typical of multiple bonds; a π bond is replaced by two σ bonds. Electrophilic ($\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CH_{2}+HBr\rightarrow CH_{3}CH_{2}Br}$), nucleophilic (HCN adding to $\mathrm{{>}C{=}O}$) or free-radical.
- Elimination: two atoms or groups are removed from the substrate, usually from adjacent carbons (β-elimination), forming a multiple bond: $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}Br+KOH\xrightarrow{\text{alcohol, heat}}CH_{2}{=}CH_{2}+KBr+H_{2}O}$. It is the reverse of addition.
- Rearrangement: atoms or groups move within a molecule (or intermediate), giving a structural isomer. Common example: a 1,2-shift of H or an alkyl group with its electron pair that converts a carbocation into a more stable one.
The rearrangement is not an idle curiosity. When HCl adds to 3-methylbut-1-ene, $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ first gives the $2^{\circ}$ cation $\mathrm{CH_{3}\overset{+}{C}HCH(CH_{3})_{2}}$; a 1,2-hydride shift turns it into the $3^{\circ}$ cation, and the major product is 2-chloro-2-methylbutane, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}CClCH_{2}CH_{3}}$, whose carbon skeleton differs from what the starting alkene suggests. Whenever a carbocation forms next to a carbon that could carry the charge more stably, expect a shift.
1. Counting the wrong hydrogens. Hyperconjugative structures = α-H only: H on carbons bonded to the charged/$sp^{2}$ carbon. The H on $\mathrm{C^{+}}$ itself, vinylic H ($\mathrm{{=}CH_{2}}$), aromatic H and β-H do not count; $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C{-}}$ attached to the centre contributes 0.
2. Copying the carbocation order for carbanions. Alkyl groups stabilise $\mathrm{R^{+}}$ and $\mathrm{R^{\bullet}}$ but destabilise $\mathrm{R^{-}}$: methyl carbanion $\gt1^{\circ}\gt2^{\circ}\gt3^{\circ}$.
3. Halogens. They are $-I$ and $+M$ with $-I$ dominant: 4-chlorophenol is a stronger acid than phenol, and halogen-substituted acids are stronger than the parent. $\mathrm{FCH_{2}COOH}$ is the strongest monohalogenoethanoic acid even though fluorine's $+M$ is the largest.
4. Assuming tertiary amines are the strongest bases in water. Solvation reverses part of the inductive order: $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}NH\gt CH_{3}NH_{2}\gt(CH_{3})_{3}N}$; only in the gas phase is $3^{\circ}$ the strongest. Aniline is weaker than ammonia.
5. Confusing the effects. Inductive, resonance and hyperconjugation effects are permanent; the electromeric effect is temporary (needs a reagent). Resonance structures are not real forms that interconvert, and a structure that moves an atom (keto/enol) is a tautomer, not a resonance structure.
Which is the strongest base in aqueous solution?
Exercises
Use these $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values (water, 298 K) where needed: ethanoic acid $4.74$, methanoic acid $3.74$, fluoroethanoic $2.59$, chloroethanoic $2.86$, butanoic $4.82$, 2-chlorobutanoic $2.86$, 4-chlorobutanoic $4.52$, phenol $9.89$, 4-nitrophenol $7.15$; $\mathrm{p}K_{b}$: methylamine $3.38$, aniline $9.38$.
- 1 Classify each fission as homolytic or heterolytic and name the carbon species formed: (a) $\mathrm{CH_{3}{-}CH_{3}\xrightarrow{\text{heat}}2\,CH_{3}^{\bullet}}$; (b) $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C{-}Cl\rightarrow(CH_{3})_{3}C^{+}+Cl^{-}}$ (in water); (c) $\mathrm{CH_{3}{-}MgBr}$ reacting as if it were $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{-}}$ and $\mathrm{MgBr^{+}}$.
- 2 For $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{\bullet}}$ and $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{-}}$ give the hybridisation of carbon, the shape and the number of valence electrons around carbon.
- 3 Arrange in order of decreasing stability (a) $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{+}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{+}}$; (b) the corresponding carbanions.
- 4 From $\mathrm{H_{2}O}$, $\mathrm{BF_{3}}$, $\mathrm{NO_{2}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{NH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$, $\mathrm{AlCl_{3}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}O^{-}}$, $\mathrm{SO_{3}}$, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{+}}$, $\mathrm{I^{-}}$: how many are electrophiles? List the nucleophiles.
- 5 Explain why $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{+}}$ behaves as an electrophile and $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{-}}$ as a nucleophile. Why is a free radical neither?
- 6 Di-tert-butyl peroxide, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}CO{-}OC(CH_{3})_{3}}$, is used to start radical reactions. Which bond breaks on heating, by which kind of fission, and how many radicals does one molecule give?
- 7 In each pair, which is more stable? (a) $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}^{\bullet}}$ or $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{\bullet}}$; (b) $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}^{-}}$ or $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{-}}$; (c) $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CHCH_{2}^{+}}$ or $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}CH_{2}^{+}}$; (d) $\mathrm{HC{\equiv}C^{-}}$ or $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}^{-}}$.
- 8 How many of the following have a planar ($sp^{2}$) carbon at the reactive centre: $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{-}}$, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{+}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{\bullet}}$, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{-}}$, $\mathrm{CH_{4}}$?
- 1 Arrange in order of increasing acid strength and explain: $\mathrm{CH_{3}COOH}$, $\mathrm{Cl_{3}CCOOH}$, $\mathrm{ClCH_{2}COOH}$, $\mathrm{Cl_{2}CHCOOH}$.
- 2 How many times larger is $K_{a}$ of fluoroethanoic acid than that of ethanoic acid?
- 3 Arrange $\mathrm{FCH_{2}COOH}$, $\mathrm{ICH_{2}COOH}$, $\mathrm{BrCH_{2}COOH}$, $\mathrm{ClCH_{2}COOH}$ in order of decreasing acid strength. What property of the halogen decides the order?
- 4 Find the ratio $K_{a}$(2-chlorobutanoic acid) : $K_{a}$(4-chlorobutanoic acid).
- 5 Methanoic acid is stronger than ethanoic acid. Explain, and find the ratio of their $K_{a}$ values.
- 6 How many of these groups show a $-I$ effect: $\mathrm{{-}NO_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}CH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{{-}OH}$, $\mathrm{{-}C(CH_{3})_{3}}$, $\mathrm{{-}CN}$, $\mathrm{{-}F}$, $\mathrm{{-}C_{2}H_{5}}$, $\mathrm{{-}COOH}$?
- 7 State whether the $+E$ or $-E$ effect operates when (a) $\mathrm{H^{+}}$ attacks ethene; (b) $\mathrm{CN^{-}}$ attacks propanone. Why is the electromeric effect called temporary?
- 8 In 1-nitropropane, $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}CH_{2}NO_{2}}$, arrange C-1, C-2 and C-3 by the size of their partial positive charge. Using the 40 % rule, roughly what fraction of the δ+ on C-1 reaches C-3?
- 1 Which pairs are resonance structures of the same species? (a) $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CH{-}\overset{+}{C}H_{2}}$ and $\mathrm{\overset{+}{C}H_{2}{-}CH{=}CH_{2}}$; (b) $\mathrm{CH_{3}COCH_{3}}$ and $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}C(OH)CH_{3}}$; (c) $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CH{-}\ddot{O}CH_{3}}$ and $\mathrm{{}^{-}CH_{2}{-}CH{=}\overset{+}{O}CH_{3}}$.
- 2 How many resonance structures (including the one shown) can be written for the pentadienyl cation $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CH{-}CH{=}CH{-}CH_{2}^{+}}$? On which carbons is the positive charge found?
- 3 How many of these groups show a $+M$ effect: $\mathrm{{-}OH}$, $\mathrm{{-}NO_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}NH_{2}}$, $\mathrm{{-}CHO}$, $\mathrm{{-}Cl}$, $\mathrm{{-}CN}$, $\mathrm{{-}OCH_{3}}$, $\mathrm{{-}COOH}$?
- 4 Find the number of hyperconjugative structures of the 2-methylbutan-2-yl cation, $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}\overset{+}{C}CH_{2}CH_{3}}$.
- 5 Arrange propene, but-1-ene, 2-methylbut-2-ene and 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene in order of stability using α-H counts. How many α-H does 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene have?
- 6 How many more hyperconjugative structures does the tert-butyl cation have than the ethyl cation?
- 7 Arrange in order of stability: $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{4{-}CH_{3}OC_{6}H_{4}CH_{2}^{+}}$, $\mathrm{4{-}O_{2}NC_{6}H_{4}CH_{2}^{+}}$. Name the effect responsible in each substituted cation.
- 8 The $\mathrm{C{-}Cl}$ bond in chloroethene is shorter and less reactive than in chloroethane. Explain with resonance structures.
- 9 The enthalpies of hydrogenation of but-1-ene and trans-but-2-ene are $-127$ and $-116\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$ (both give butane). By how many $\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}$ is trans-but-2-ene more stable? Relate this to the α-H counts.
- 1 Arrange in order of increasing acid strength: ethanol, water, phenol, ethanoic acid, 4-nitrophenol. Give one reason for each step.
- 2 How many times stronger an acid is 4-nitrophenol than phenol?
- 3 Arrange (a) the methylamines and ammonia, (b) the ethylamines and ammonia in order of basicity in water. Why do the two orders differ from the gas-phase order?
- 4 Find the ratio $K_{b}$(methylamine) : $K_{b}$(aniline) and explain why aniline is so weak a base.
- 5 Classify each reaction as substitution, addition, elimination or rearrangement: (a) $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}Br+OH^{-}(aq)\rightarrow CH_{3}CH_{2}OH+Br^{-}}$; (b) $\mathrm{CH_{2}{=}CH_{2}+Br_{2}\rightarrow BrCH_{2}CH_{2}Br}$; (c) $\mathrm{CH_{3}CH_{2}OH\xrightarrow{\text{conc. H}_{2}\text{SO}_{4},\ 443\ \text{K}}CH_{2}{=}CH_{2}+H_{2}O}$; (d) $\mathrm{CH_{4}+Cl_{2}\xrightarrow{h\nu}CH_{3}Cl+HCl}$; (e) $\mathrm{NH_{4}CNO\xrightarrow{\text{heat}}NH_{2}CONH_{2}}$; (f) $\mathrm{CH_{3}CHO+HCN\rightarrow CH_{3}CH(OH)CN}$. How many are additions?
- 6 The 3-methylbutan-2-yl cation rearranges by a 1,2-hydride shift. Draw the new cation and give the number of α-H before and after the shift (state the "after" value).
- 7 Show with curved arrows the two steps of the addition of HBr to propene through the more stable carbocation, and name the product.
- 8 Arrange in order of decreasing basicity: aniline, 4-nitroaniline, 4-methoxyaniline, methylamine, ammonia.
E1. JEE Main · MCQ The correct order of stability of the carbanions is (A) $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}C^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{-}\gt CH_{3}^{-}\gt C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}^{-}}$ (B) $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}^{-}\gt CH_{3}^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{3}C^{-}}$ (C) $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{-}\gt C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{3}C^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{-}}$ (D) $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}CH_{2}^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{3}C^{-}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}CH^{-}\gt CH_{3}^{-}}$
E2. JEE Main · Numerical 2-Methylbut-2-ene is protonated by a strong acid. The more stable of the two possible carbocations is formed. How many hyperconjugative structures (involving $\mathrm{C{-}H}$ bonds) does this carbocation have? Give the answer to the nearest integer.
E3. JEE Main · MCQ The correct order of acid strength of (I) phenol, (II) 4-nitrophenol, (III) 4-methylphenol and (IV) ethanol is (A) I $\gt$ II $\gt$ III $\gt$ IV (B) II $\gt$ III $\gt$ I $\gt$ IV (C) IV $\gt$ III $\gt$ I $\gt$ II (D) II $\gt$ I $\gt$ III $\gt$ IV
E4. JEE Main · Numerical The $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values of ethanoic acid and chloroethanoic acid are $4.74$ and $2.86$. The ratio $K_{a}(\mathrm{ClCH_{2}COOH})/K_{a}(\mathrm{CH_{3}COOH})$ is $x$. Find $x$. (Take $10^{0.88}=7.59$.) Give the answer to the nearest integer.
E5. JEE Main · MCQ The correct order of basic strength in aqueous solution is (A) $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{2}NH\gt CH_{3}NH_{2}\gt(CH_{3})_{3}N\gt C_{6}H_{5}NH_{2}}$ (B) $\mathrm{(CH_{3})_{3}N\gt(CH_{3})_{2}NH\gt CH_{3}NH_{2}\gt C_{6}H_{5}NH_{2}}$ (C) $\mathrm{C_{6}H_{5}NH_{2}\gt(CH_{3})_{3}N\gt CH_{3}NH_{2}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}NH}$ (D) $\mathrm{CH_{3}NH_{2}\gt(CH_{3})_{2}NH\gt(CH_{3})_{3}N\gt C_{6}H_{5}NH_{2}}$
E6. JEE Main · Numerical When HCl adds to 3,3-dimethylbut-1-ene, the first-formed carbocation rearranges by a 1,2-methyl shift before chloride attacks. Find the number of α-hydrogen atoms (hyperconjugative structures) in the rearranged carbocation. Give the answer to the nearest integer.
Research question. Can one number per substituent predict the acid strength of a whole family of compounds — and does that number separate the inductive effect from the resonance effect?
Why it matters. Whether a drug molecule is ionised at the pH of the stomach (about 2) or of blood (7.4) decides how well it is absorbed and where it goes in the body. Pharmaceutical chemists, agrochemical designers and environmental chemists predicting how a pollutant moves in groundwater all estimate $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values from substituent effects before a compound is ever made.
What to do.
- From an open data source (e.g. a chemistry data handbook or the PubChem database) collect $\mathrm{p}K_{a}$ values at 298 K for benzoic acid and its 3- and 4-substituted derivatives with $\mathrm{X}=\mathrm{NO_{2}},\ \mathrm{CN},\ \mathrm{Cl},\ \mathrm{Br},\ \mathrm{H},\ \mathrm{CH_{3}},\ \mathrm{OCH_{3}},\ \mathrm{NH_{2}}$, and the same set for phenols.
- For each X compute $\sigma=\mathrm{p}K_{a}(\text{benzoic})-\mathrm{p}K_{a}(\text{X-benzoic})$ separately for the 3- and the 4-position.
- Plot $\mathrm{p}K_{a}(\text{phenol})-\mathrm{p}K_{a}(\text{X-phenol})$ against $\sigma$. Is it a straight line? What is its slope, and what does the slope say about how sensitive phenols are compared with benzoic acids?
- Compare $\sigma$ at the 3- and 4-positions for each X. Which groups change most between the two positions, and how does that fit $\pm I$ (felt at both) versus $\pm M$ (felt mainly at 2- and 4-positions)?
Tools: Spreadsheet with a linear-fit function; an open chemical database; this section's table of $+M$/$-M$ groups.
Hand in: Your data table with sources, the plot with its fitted line, and a paragraph identifying two groups whose 3/4 difference shows a strong resonance effect.
Going further. Where do the 4-nitrophenol and 4-aminophenol points fall relative to your line? Groups that can conjugate directly with the phenoxide oxygen behave as if their resonance effect were enhanced — why might phenols, but not benzoic acids, show this?
🧪 Self-check quiz
Q1. Which statement about the methyl free radical $\mathrm{CH_{3}^{\bullet}}$ is correct?
Q2. Which substituent shows a $-I$ effect and a $+M$ effect, with the $-I$ effect dominating?
Q3. The electromeric effect
Q4. Which of these is a rearrangement reaction?
Q5. Which alkene is the most stable on the basis of hyperconjugation?