Chapter 2 · Atomic Structure

2.3 Dual Nature, Uncertainty and the Quantum Mechanical Model

A moving electron behaves as a wave with $\lambda=h/mv$, and its position and momentum can never both be sharp: $\Delta x\,\Delta p\ge h/4\pi$. From these two ideas grows the quantum-mechanical atom, where an orbital is a one-electron wave function $\psi$ and $\psi^{2}$ tells us where the electron is likely to be found.

The Bohr model of Section 2.2 was a triumph and a puzzle at the same time. It gave the lines of the hydrogen spectrum to four significant figures, yet it could not explain the spectrum of helium, the splitting of lines in a magnetic field, or why atoms join into molecules with definite shapes. Worse, it simply assumed that the angular momentum of the electron is a whole number times $h/2\pi$ and that an electron in a fixed orbit does not radiate. Nobody could say why.

The answer came in the 1920s from two surprising ideas. Louis de Broglie proposed that matter, like light, has a wave character — an electron is not just a tiny ball but also a wave whose wavelength depends on its momentum. Werner Heisenberg then showed that, because of this double nature, the position and the momentum of an electron can never both be known exactly, so a sharp Bohr orbit cannot exist. Erwin Schrödinger turned the wave idea into an equation, whose solutions — wave functions or orbitals — are the modern picture of the atom. In this section we build the three ideas in turn and finish with the wave functions of the 1s and 2s orbitals and the radial nodes where the wave function changes sign. The quantum numbers that label the orbitals, and the rules for filling them, follow in Section 2.4.

Matter waves: the de Broglie relation

In Section 2.1 we met the dual behaviour of light: it spreads and interferes like a wave, but in the photoelectric effect it delivers energy in packets (photons) like a stream of particles. A photon of wavelength $\lambda$ carries energy $E=h\nu=hc/\lambda$ and, since $E=pc$ for a particle of light, momentum $p=h/\lambda$. In 1924 de Broglie asked the reverse question: if waves can behave like particles, can particles behave like waves? He suggested that the same link between momentum and wavelength holds for every moving body.

📘 Definition 2.5 — Matter wave and de Broglie wavelength

A material particle of mass $m$ moving with speed $v$ (momentum $p=mv$) has an associated wave, called a matter wave. Its wavelength, the de Broglie wavelength, is the wavelength a photon of the same momentum would have. The matter wave is not an electromagnetic wave: it is not emitted by the particle, needs no charge and travels with the particle itself.

📐 Law 2.8 — The de Broglie relation

For a particle of mass $m$ moving with speed $v$ much smaller than the speed of light,

$$\lambda=\frac{h}{p}=\frac{h}{mv},\qquad h=6.626\times10^{-34}\ \mathrm{J\,s}.$$

Since the kinetic energy is $K=\tfrac12mv^{2}=\dfrac{p^{2}}{2m}$, the same relation can be written

$$\lambda=\frac{h}{\sqrt{2mK}} .$$

A particle of charge $q$ accelerated from rest through a potential difference $V$ gains $K=qV$, so $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mqV}}$. For an electron ($m_{e}=9.11\times10^{-31}\ \mathrm{kg}$, $q=e=1.602\times10^{-19}\ \mathrm{C}$) this gives the working formula

$$\lambda=\frac{1.226}{\sqrt{V}}\ \mathrm{nm}\qquad(V\ \text{in volts}).$$

The relation is useful only while $v\ll c$ (for electrons, accelerating voltages up to a few kilovolts); at higher speeds the momentum must be calculated relativistically.

Two things follow at once. First, $\lambda\propto 1/p$: the heavier or faster the body, the shorter its wave. Second, the wave character matters only when $\lambda$ is comparable with the size of something the wave meets — a slit, a gap between atoms, an orbit. For everyday objects $\lambda$ is absurdly small, which is why we never see a cricket ball diffract.

✏️ Example 1 — A cricket ball and an electron
(a) Find the de Broglie wavelength of a cricket ball of mass $0.16\ \mathrm{kg}$ bowled at $40\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ (about $144\ \mathrm{km\,h^{-1}}$). (b) Find the de Broglie wavelength of an electron moving at $2.19\times10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$, the speed Bohr's model gives for the first orbit of hydrogen. (c) Compare each with a sensible length scale. Use $h=6.626\times10^{-34}\ \mathrm{J\,s}$, $m_{e}=9.11\times10^{-31}\ \mathrm{kg}$.
(a) $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{mv}=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{0.16\times40}=1.04\times10^{-34}\ \mathrm{m}$.
(b) $\lambda=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{(9.11\times10^{-31})(2.19\times10^{6})}=3.32\times10^{-10}\ \mathrm{m}=332\ \mathrm{pm}$.
(c) The ball's wavelength is about $10^{-19}$ times the diameter of a proton — no aperture could ever reveal it. The electron's wavelength is a few times the size of an atom ($\sim100\ \mathrm{pm}$), so in an atom its wave nature dominates.
Check The circumference of Bohr's first orbit is $2\pi a_{0}=2\pi(52.9\ \mathrm{pm})=332\ \mathrm{pm}$ — exactly one electron wavelength. This is no coincidence, as Example 3 shows.

Experimental proof. In 1927 Davisson and Germer fired a beam of electrons accelerated through $54\ \mathrm{V}$ at a nickel crystal and found strong reflection only in certain directions — a diffraction pattern, exactly like X-rays reflected from the same crystal. The spacing of atoms in the crystal acts as a grating, and the measured wavelength agreed with $h/mv$. G. P. Thomson obtained electron diffraction rings through thin metal foils in the same year. Today the electron microscope uses the short wavelength of fast electrons to image objects far smaller than visible light can resolve.

✏️ Example 2 — Electrons through 54 volts
An electron is accelerated from rest through $54\ \mathrm{V}$, as in the Davisson–Germer experiment. (a) Find its speed. (b) Find its de Broglie wavelength. (c) A proton ($m_{p}=1.673\times10^{-27}\ \mathrm{kg}$) is accelerated from rest through the same voltage. Find its wavelength. Use $e=1.602\times10^{-19}\ \mathrm{C}$, $m_{e}=9.11\times10^{-31}\ \mathrm{kg}$, $h=6.626\times10^{-34}\ \mathrm{J\,s}$.
Find the electron's wavelength in picometres before you open the solution:
(a) $\tfrac12m_{e}v^{2}=eV$: $v=\sqrt{\dfrac{2(1.602\times10^{-19})(54)}{9.11\times10^{-31}}}=4.36\times10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ (1.5 % of $c$, so no relativity needed).
(b) $\lambda=\dfrac{1.226}{\sqrt{54}}\ \mathrm{nm}=0.167\ \mathrm{nm}=167\ \mathrm{pm}$. (Check: $h/m_{e}v=6.626\times10^{-34}/(9.11\times10^{-31}\times4.36\times10^{6})=1.67\times10^{-10}\ \mathrm{m}$ ✓.)
(c) Same charge and same $V$ give the same kinetic energy, so $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt{m}$: $\lambda_{p}=167\ \mathrm{pm}\times\sqrt{\dfrac{9.11\times10^{-31}}{1.673\times10^{-27}}}=167\times0.0233=3.89\ \mathrm{pm}$.
Insight $167\ \mathrm{pm}$ is comparable with the $215\ \mathrm{pm}$ spacing of atoms in nickel — that is why the crystal diffracts the beam so well. The proton's much shorter wave would need a far finer "grating".

Why Bohr's orbits are quantised. Imagine the electron wave running round a circular orbit. After one lap it meets itself. If the circumference holds a whole number of wavelengths, crests fall on crests and a steady standing wave forms; if not, each lap is out of step with the last and the wave cancels itself out. So only orbits with

$$2\pi r=n\lambda=n\,\frac{h}{mv}\quad\Longrightarrow\quad mvr=n\,\frac{h}{2\pi},\qquad n=1,2,3,\dots$$

can exist. This is exactly Bohr's quantisation of angular momentum — now a consequence of the wave nature of the electron, not an assumption. Combining it with the Bohr results $r_{n}=52.9\,\dfrac{n^{2}}{Z}\ \mathrm{pm}$ and $v_{n}=2.188\times10^{6}\,\dfrac{Z}{n}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ (often rounded to $2.18$ or $2.19\times10^{6}$) gives $\lambda_{n}=\dfrac{2\pi r_{n}}{n}=332\,\dfrac{n}{Z}\ \mathrm{pm}$.

✏️ Example 3 — Electron waves in Bohr orbits (JEE level)
(a) Show that the number of de Broglie wavelengths that fit round the $n$th Bohr orbit is $n$. (b) Find the de Broglie wavelength of the electron in the $n=3$ orbit of $\mathrm{Li^{2+}}$. Which orbit of the hydrogen atom has an electron of the same wavelength? (c) Find the ratio of the electron's wavelength in the $n=2$ orbit of hydrogen to that in the $n=1$ orbit of $\mathrm{He^{+}}$.
(a) Number of waves $=\dfrac{2\pi r}{\lambda}=\dfrac{2\pi r\,mv}{h}=\dfrac{2\pi}{h}\left(n\dfrac{h}{2\pi}\right)=n$, using Bohr's condition $mvr=nh/2\pi$.
(b) $r_{3}=52.9\times\dfrac{9}{3}=158.7\ \mathrm{pm}$, so $\lambda=\dfrac{2\pi(158.7)}{3}=332\ \mathrm{pm}$. Since $\lambda_{n}\propto n/Z$ and $3/3=1/1$, the hydrogen electron in its first orbit has the same wavelength (Example 1).
(c) $\dfrac{\lambda(\mathrm{H},\,n=2)}{\lambda(\mathrm{He^{+}},\,n=1)}=\dfrac{2/1}{1/2}=4$.
⏱ Shortcut Learn $\lambda_{n}\propto\dfrac{n}{Z}$ (because $r\propto n^{2}/Z$ and the orbit holds $n$ waves; equivalently $v\propto Z/n$). Any ratio question is then one line.

In the hydrogen atom ($Z=1$, $n=1$) exactly one electron wavelength of $332\ \mathrm{pm}$ fits round the orbit. For the electron in the $n=2$ orbit of $\mathrm{He^{+}}$ ($Z=2$), what will Interactive 1 show?

Set $n=2$, nucleus $\mathrm{He^{+}}$ and the trial-wavelength slider at 100 %. The readouts show $r=106\ \mathrm{pm}$, $v=2.19\times10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$, $\lambda=332\ \mathrm{pm}$ and $2\pi r/\lambda=2.00$. The speed is the same as in hydrogen's first orbit ($v\propto Z/n$), so the wavelength is the same; the orbit is twice as long, so it holds two waves. "Each $664\ \mathrm{pm}$" is hydrogen's $n=2$ orbit, where the speed is halved.
Interactive 1 — Electron Waves on a Bohr Orbit

Choose the orbit $n$ and the nucleus. The electron's de Broglie wave $\lambda=h/m_{e}v$ is wrapped round the orbit (left) and unrolled along one circumference (top right); the bars show how $\lambda$ changes with $n$. Move the trial wavelength slider away from 100 % to see what happens to a wave that does not fit: the second lap (red) falls out of step with the first and the wave cannot settle. Press Play to make the standing wave vibrate.

3100 %
orbit radius $r_{n}$—
speed $v_{n}$—
$\lambda=h/m_{e}v$—
waves per lap $2\pi r/\lambda$—

An electron and a proton are moving with the same kinetic energy. Which has the longer de Broglie wavelength?

The Heisenberg uncertainty principle

A wave is spread out by its very nature. A single, perfectly regular wave train of wavelength $\lambda$ — and so of perfectly known momentum $h/\lambda$ — goes on for ever: it has no position at all. To build a wave that is concentrated in a small region (a wave packet) you must add together many waves of slightly different wavelengths, which cancel each other outside the region. The narrower the packet, the wider the spread of wavelengths needed, and so the wider the spread of momenta. Position and momentum are therefore not independent: sharpening one blurs the other.

📘 Definition 2.6 — Uncertainty in position and momentum

If many identical measurements of the position $x$ of a particle are made, the results are spread about their average; the size of this spread is the uncertainty in position $\Delta x$. The uncertainty in momentum $\Delta p_{x}$ (along the same direction) and the uncertainty in velocity $\Delta v_{x}=\Delta p_{x}/m$ are defined in the same way. An uncertainty is a property of the state of the particle, not a mistake in the measuring instrument.

📐 Law 2.9 — Heisenberg uncertainty principle

It is impossible to determine simultaneously, with unlimited precision, both the position and the momentum of a microscopic particle along the same direction. The product of the uncertainties obeys

$$\Delta x\cdot\Delta p_{x}\ \ge\ \frac{h}{4\pi},\qquad\text{equivalently}\qquad \Delta x\cdot\Delta v_{x}\ \ge\ \frac{h}{4\pi m}.$$

The limit applies to a coordinate and the momentum along that same axis ($x$ with $p_{x}$); there is no such limit for $x$ and $p_{y}$. The smallest possible uncertainties correspond to the equality sign. ($h/4\pi=5.27\times10^{-35}\ \mathrm{J\,s}$.)

Why the measurement itself disturbs. To "see" where an electron is, we must bounce light off it. To locate it within $\Delta x$ we need light of wavelength no longer than about $\Delta x$; but a photon of wavelength $\lambda$ carries momentum $h/\lambda$, and some unknown part of that momentum is handed to the electron in the collision. The sharper we try to see (shorter $\lambda$), the harder we kick the electron and the less we know about its momentum afterwards. This thought experiment makes the principle plausible, but the principle is deeper: it follows from the wave nature of matter, and it holds whatever measuring method is used.

Significance. For a body of everyday mass the limit is far below anything we could measure, so classical mechanics works perfectly for cricket balls and planets. For an electron in an atom it is decisive. Confine an electron to a region the size of an atom ($\Delta x\approx100\ \mathrm{pm}$) and its speed is uncertain by about $6\times10^{5}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ — a quarter of its Bohr speed. A sharp orbit, which would need an exact radius and an exact velocity at every moment, is therefore impossible. All we can ever speak of is the probability of finding the electron in a region of space. That is the starting point of the quantum-mechanical model.

✏️ Example 4 — An electron in an atom and a ball on a table
(a) An electron is confined to a region of width $100\ \mathrm{pm}$. Find the minimum uncertainty in its speed and compare it with the speed $2.19\times10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ of Bohr's first orbit. (b) A $10\ \mathrm{g}$ ball is located to within $1.0\ \mu\mathrm{m}$. Find the minimum uncertainty in its speed. Use $h=6.626\times10^{-34}\ \mathrm{J\,s}$, $m_{e}=9.11\times10^{-31}\ \mathrm{kg}$.
Find the electron's minimum uncertainty in speed (in $\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$; you may type 5.0e5-style numbers) first:
(a) $\Delta v=\dfrac{h}{4\pi m_{e}\Delta x}=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{4\pi(9.11\times10^{-31})(1.00\times10^{-10})}=5.79\times10^{5}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$.
Compare $\dfrac{5.79\times10^{5}}{2.19\times10^{6}}=0.26$: the speed is uncertain by about 26 % of its Bohr value — no sharp orbit can be drawn.
(b) $\Delta v=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{4\pi(0.010)(1.0\times10^{-6})}=5.3\times10^{-27}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ — utterly negligible.
Check The ratio of the two answers is $\dfrac{m_{\text{ball}}\,\Delta x_{\text{ball}}}{m_{e}\,\Delta x_{e}}=\dfrac{(0.010)(10^{-6})}{(9.11\times10^{-31})(10^{-10})}=1.1\times10^{32}$ ✓. The principle "switches on" only for tiny masses in tiny regions.
✏️ Example 5 — Working the inequality both ways (JEE level)
(a) The speed of an electron moving at $2.0\times10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ is known to within $1.0\ \%$. What is the least uncertainty in its position? (b) Repeat for a proton ($m_{p}=1.673\times10^{-27}\ \mathrm{kg}$) with the same speed and the same percentage uncertainty. (c) For a particle of mass $m$, the uncertainties in position and momentum are numerically equal (in SI units). Find an expression for the minimum uncertainty in its velocity.
(a) $\Delta v=0.010\times2.0\times10^{6}=2.0\times10^{4}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$; $\ \Delta x=\dfrac{h}{4\pi m_{e}\Delta v}=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{4\pi(9.11\times10^{-31})(2.0\times10^{4})}=2.9\times10^{-9}\ \mathrm{m}=2.9\ \mathrm{nm}$ — about thirty atomic diameters.
(b) $\Delta x\propto1/m$ for equal $\Delta v$: $\Delta x_{p}=\dfrac{2.9\times10^{-9}}{1836}=1.6\times10^{-12}\ \mathrm{m}=1.6\ \mathrm{pm}$.
(c) With $\Delta x=\Delta p$: $(\Delta p)^{2}=\dfrac{h}{4\pi}$, so $\Delta p=\sqrt{\dfrac{h}{4\pi}}=\dfrac12\sqrt{\dfrac{h}{\pi}}$ and $\Delta v=\dfrac{\Delta p}{m}=\dfrac{1}{2m}\sqrt{\dfrac{h}{\pi}}$.
Check Units in (c): $\sqrt{\mathrm{J\,s}}/\mathrm{kg}$ is not $\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ — the expression only makes sense because "numerically equal in SI units" hides a unit. JEE asks it as an algebra exercise; for an electron it gives a speed above $c$, a sign that such a state is not physical.

The position of an electron along $x$ is measured twice as precisely as before ($\Delta x$ halved). The least possible uncertainty in its momentum along $x$

The quantum-mechanical model of the atom

If an electron is a wave and has no sharp path, what is the right way to describe it in an atom? In 1926 Schrödinger wrote down the equation that a matter wave must obey. For an electron moving in the electric field of a nucleus it takes the compact form

$$\hat{H}\,\psi=E\,\psi ,$$

where $\psi$ (psi) is the wave function of the electron, a number assigned to every point of space; $E$ is the total energy; and $\hat{H}$, the Hamiltonian, is a mathematical operator that combines the kinetic energy of the wave with the potential energy $-Ze^{2}/4\pi\varepsilon_{0}r$ of attraction to the nucleus. JEE Main does not ask you to solve it. What matters is what the solutions are like.

Think of a guitar string clamped at both ends. It can vibrate only in patterns that fit between the clamps — the fundamental, the second harmonic, and so on — so only certain frequencies are allowed. In the same way, an electron bound to a nucleus can settle only into wave patterns that fade away far from the atom; the Schrödinger equation has acceptable solutions only for certain values of $E$. Quantisation of energy is not an extra rule: it comes out of the equation automatically. For the hydrogen atom these allowed energies turn out to be exactly Bohr's $E_{n}=-2.18\times10^{-18}\,Z^{2}/n^{2}\ \mathrm{J}$, which is why the Bohr model got the spectrum right even though its picture of the atom was wrong.

📘 Definition 2.7 — Wave function and atomic orbital

A wave function $\psi(r,\theta,\phi)$ is an acceptable solution of the Schrödinger equation for an electron in an atom; $r$ is the distance from the nucleus and $\theta$, $\phi$ give the direction. It may be positive, negative or zero at different points, and it has no direct physical meaning on its own.

An atomic orbital is a one-electron wave function of an atom: the wave function that describes one electron moving in the field of the nucleus (and, in many-electron atoms, in the average field of the other electrons). Each orbital has a definite energy and is labelled by three quantum numbers $n$, $l$, $m_{l}$ that come out of the solution (Section 2.4).

📘 Definition 2.8 — Probability density

The square of the wave function, $\psi^{2}$ (strictly $|\psi|^{2}$), at a point is the probability density of the electron there: the probability of finding the electron in a very small volume $\delta V$ around that point is

$$P=\psi^{2}\,\delta V .$$

So $\psi^{2}$ has units of $(\text{volume})^{-1}$; the total probability over all space is $1$. Where $\psi^{2}$ is large the electron is often found; where $\psi=0$ it is never found.

A picture of $\psi^{2}$ is often drawn as a cloud of dots, thick where the probability density is high and thin where it is low — an electron cloud. Each dot can be thought of as the result of one position measurement; after very many measurements the dots outline the orbital.

📐 Result 2.10 — Features of the quantum-mechanical model of the atom
  • The energy of an electron in an atom is quantised: only the energies of the allowed wave functions are possible.
  • Quantised levels exist because electrons have wave properties and are confined by the attraction of the nucleus.
  • The exact position and the exact momentum of an electron cannot be known together (Law 2.9). The path of an electron cannot be traced; we can only give the probability of finding it at a point, $\psi^{2}\,\delta V$.
  • Each allowed state of an electron is an atomic orbital $\psi$. An atom has many orbitals; an electron occupies one of them, and one orbital can hold at most two electrons (Section 2.4).
  • $\psi$ itself has no physical meaning, but its square $\psi^{2}$ is the probability density, and $\psi$ contains all the information about the electron — its energy and its angular momentum can be worked out from it.
  • For hydrogen and hydrogen-like ions ($\mathrm{He^{+}}$, $\mathrm{Li^{2+}}$…) the energy depends only on $n$; in many-electron atoms it depends on both $n$ and $l$.
Bohr orbitQuantum-mechanical orbital
What it isa definite circular path round the nucleusa wave function $\psi$; a region where the electron is likely to be found
Position and velocityboth exact at every instantnever both exact (uncertainty principle)
Shapea flat circlethree-dimensional; spherical for s, other shapes for p, d
Quantisationassumed ($mvr=nh/2\pi$)comes out of the Schrödinger equation
Number per levelone orbit for each $n$$n^{2}$ orbitals for each $n$
Many-electron atomsfailsworks (with approximations)

Which statement about an atomic orbital is correct?

Wave functions of the 1s and 2s orbitals; radial nodes

For s orbitals the wave function depends only on the distance $r$ from the nucleus, not on direction — that is why s orbitals are spherical. For a hydrogen-like atom of nuclear charge $Z$ the solutions are (with $a_{0}=52.9\ \mathrm{pm}$, the Bohr radius):

📐 Result 2.11 — The 1s and 2s wave functions of a hydrogen-like atom
$$\psi_{1s}=\frac{1}{\sqrt{\pi}}\left(\frac{Z}{a_{0}}\right)^{3/2}e^{-Zr/a_{0}}$$ $$\psi_{2s}=\frac{1}{4\sqrt{2\pi}}\left(\frac{Z}{a_{0}}\right)^{3/2}\left(2-\frac{Zr}{a_{0}}\right)e^{-Zr/2a_{0}}$$
  • 1s: $\psi$ is positive everywhere and greatest at the nucleus; it falls off smoothly (exponentially) with $r$ and never quite reaches zero. $\psi^{2}$ is also greatest at $r=0$ and decreases steadily.
  • 2s: $\psi$ is positive near the nucleus, falls to zero at $r=2a_{0}/Z$, becomes negative, reaches a minimum (at $r=4a_{0}/Z$) and then rises back towards zero. $\psi^{2}$ is greatest at the nucleus, is zero at $r=2a_{0}/Z$, and has a second, much smaller maximum further out.
  • The 2s orbital is larger than 1s: most of its electron density lies further from the nucleus, so a 2s electron is less tightly bound.
📘 Definition 2.9 — Radial node

A radial node is a spherical surface, at a fixed distance from the nucleus, on which the wave function is zero. Crossing a radial node, $\psi$ changes sign; on it the probability density $\psi^{2}$ is zero, so the electron is never found there. For an s orbital the number of radial nodes is $n-1$: none for 1s, one for 2s, two for 3s. (The general rule, $n-l-1$ radial nodes, is given in Section 2.4.)

To find a radial node, set the polynomial factor of $\psi$ equal to zero; the exponential factor is never zero. For 2s, $2-Zr/a_{0}=0$ gives $r=2a_{0}/Z$: $105.8\ \mathrm{pm}$ for hydrogen, $52.9\ \mathrm{pm}$ for $\mathrm{He^{+}}$. The 3s wave function has the factor $\left(27-18\sigma+2\sigma^{2}\right)$ with $\sigma=Zr/a_{0}$, and so two radial nodes. A wave that passes through zero and changes sign is just what a standing wave does; the more nodes, the more "wiggles", and the higher the energy — exactly as the higher harmonics of a string carry more energy.

It may seem strange that the electron is never found at the node and yet is found on both sides of it. There is no paradox: the electron is a wave, not a ball rolling from one side to the other. A vibrating string also has points that never move, while the string on both sides of them does.

For the hydrogen atom the 2s node is at $105.8\ \mathrm{pm}$. Where is the radial node of the 2s orbital of $\mathrm{He^{+}}$?

Choose 2s and $\mathrm{He^{+}}$ ($Z=2$). The node readout shows "1 radial node: 52.9 pm", and the dashed node circle in the dot picture shrinks to half its hydrogen size. The node sits at $r=2a_{0}/Z$: doubling the nuclear charge pulls the whole wave function in by a factor of 2 but does not change its shape, so the number of nodes ($n-1=1$) stays the same. $26.5\ \mathrm{pm}$ would be $a_{0}/Z$, a slip in the factor 2.
Interactive 2 — ψ and ψ² for the 1s, 2s and 3s Orbitals

Choose an s orbital and the nucleus. The left graphs show $\psi$ (top) and $\psi^{2}$ (bottom) against $r$, in units of their values for the 1s orbital at the nucleus. On the right is a slice through the atom: dot density follows $\psi^{2}$, and the colour shows the sign of $\psi$ (blue $+$, red $-$). Dashed purple lines and circles are radial nodes. The outer parts of 2s and 3s are faint, so use the vertical zoom (it magnifies the $\psi^{2}$ graph and boosts the dot shading) to see them. Move $r$ or press Play to sweep outwards.

50 pm
$r$ and $Zr/a_{0}$—
$\psi$ (rel. to $\psi_{1s}(0)$)—
$\psi^{2}$ (rel.)—
radial nodes—
✏️ Example 6 — Locating radial nodes (JEE level)
(a) Locate the radial node of the 2s orbital of hydrogen, and state the sign of $\psi_{2s}$ on each side of it. (b) Locate the 2s node for $\mathrm{Li^{2+}}$. (c) For a hydrogen-like atom the 3s wave function is $\psi_{3s}=k\left(27-18\sigma+2\sigma^{2}\right)e^{-\sigma/3}$, where $\sigma=Zr/a_{0}$ and $k$ is a positive constant. Find the positions of the radial nodes of the 3s orbital of hydrogen in pm ($a_{0}=52.9\ \mathrm{pm}$).
Find the outer radial node of the hydrogen 3s orbital first:
(a) $2-\dfrac{r}{a_{0}}=0$ gives $r=2a_{0}=105.8\ \mathrm{pm}$. Inside ($r\lt2a_{0}$) the factor $2-r/a_{0}$ is positive, so $\psi_{2s}\gt0$; outside it is negative, so $\psi_{2s}\lt0$.
(b) $r=\dfrac{2a_{0}}{Z}=\dfrac{2(52.9)}{3}=35.3\ \mathrm{pm}$.
(c) $2\sigma^{2}-18\sigma+27=0$: $\sigma=\dfrac{18\pm\sqrt{324-216}}{4}=\dfrac{18\pm10.39}{4}$, so $\sigma=1.902$ or $7.098$. With $Z=1$: $r=1.902\times52.9=101\ \mathrm{pm}$ and $r=7.098\times52.9=375\ \mathrm{pm}$.
Check Two nodes for 3s, as $n-1=2$ requires ✓. Between them $\psi_{3s}$ is negative (e.g. at $\sigma=4$: $27-72+32=-13$), outside both it is positive. Set 3s in Interactive 2 to see the two node circles at these radii.
🚀 Beyond JEE Main — the radial probability distribution

The radial probability function is not named in the JEE Main 2026 list; it is shown here because it explains a puzzle about $\psi^{2}$. Nothing in this box is needed for the exercises, the Exam corner or the quiz.

$\psi^{2}_{1s}$ is greatest at the nucleus — yet the electron is most likely to be found about $52.9\ \mathrm{pm}$ from it. The two statements fit together once we ask for the probability of finding the electron anywhere in a thin spherical shell of radius $r$ and thickness $dr$. The shell's volume is $4\pi r^{2}\,dr$, so that probability is $4\pi r^{2}\psi^{2}\,dr$. Near the nucleus $\psi^{2}$ is large but the shells are tiny; far out the shells are huge but $\psi^{2}$ is tiny. The product $4\pi r^{2}\psi^{2}_{1s}$ peaks at exactly $r=a_{0}=52.9\ \mathrm{pm}$ for hydrogen — Bohr's radius reappears as the most probable distance, not as a fixed orbit. For 2s the radial probability has two peaks with a zero between them at the node, the outer peak being the larger.

⚠️ JEE Main traps

1. Using energy instead of momentum. $\lambda=h/p$, not $h/E$. For a particle of kinetic energy $K$, $\lambda=h/\sqrt{2mK}$; for a photon, $\lambda=hc/E$. Mixing the two formulas is the commonest slip. Also, $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt{K}$: four times the kinetic energy halves the wavelength.

2. $h/4\pi$, not $h/2\pi$ or $h$. The uncertainty product is $\Delta x\,\Delta p\ge h/4\pi$. With velocities, divide by the mass: $\Delta x\,\Delta v\ge h/4\pi m$. Use the uncertainty $\Delta v$, not the speed $v$ itself (convert a percentage first).

3. Charge and mass in accelerated-particle ratios. Through the same $V$, $K=qV$, so $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt{mq}$. An α-particle has $q=2e$ and $m\approx4m_{p}$: $\lambda_{p}/\lambda_{\alpha}=\sqrt{8}=2\sqrt2$, not 2.

4. Reading $\psi$ as a probability. $\psi$ can be negative; only $\psi^{2}$ (times a volume) is a probability. At a radial node $\psi=0$ and $\psi^{2}=0$. For s orbitals $\psi^{2}$ is greatest at the nucleus, not at $a_{0}$.

5. Node positions with $Z$. Nodes scale as $1/Z$ ($r=2a_{0}/Z$ for 2s), while their number ($n-1$ for s) does not depend on $Z$. And $1.226/\sqrt{V}$ gives nanometres, not ångströms — $12.26/\sqrt{V}$ is the ångström form.

For the 2s orbital of the hydrogen atom, the probability density $\psi^{2}$ at $r=2a_{0}=105.8\ \mathrm{pm}$ is

Exercises

Use $h=6.626\times10^{-34}\ \mathrm{J\,s}$, $m_{e}=9.11\times10^{-31}\ \mathrm{kg}$, $m_{p}=1.673\times10^{-27}\ \mathrm{kg}$, $e=1.602\times10^{-19}\ \mathrm{C}$, $a_{0}=52.9\ \mathrm{pm}$ and the Bohr speed $v_{n}=2.19\times10^{6}\,Z/n\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ unless a part says otherwise. Speeds are small compared with $c$.

I
The de Broglie relation.
  • 1 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in pm, of an electron moving at $1.0\times10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$.
  • 2 Find the de Broglie wavelength of a $1500\ \mathrm{kg}$ car moving at $20\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$. Why can its wave nature never be observed?
  • 3 At what speed must an electron move to have a de Broglie wavelength of $0.50\ \mathrm{nm}$?
  • 4 An electron is accelerated from rest through $600\ \mathrm{V}$. Find its de Broglie wavelength in pm.
  • 5 Find the kinetic energy, in electronvolts, of an electron whose de Broglie wavelength is $1.0\ \mathrm{nm}$ ($1\ \mathrm{eV}=1.602\times10^{-19}\ \mathrm{J}$).
  • 6 A proton and an electron have the same kinetic energy. Find the ratio $\lambda_{p}/\lambda_{e}$ of their de Broglie wavelengths.
  • 7 A proton and an electron move with the same speed. Find $\lambda_{e}/\lambda_{p}$.
  • 8 The kinetic energy of a particle is made nine times as large. By what factor does its de Broglie wavelength change?
  • 9 A proton and an α-particle ($m_{\alpha}=6.64\times10^{-27}\ \mathrm{kg}$, charge $2e$) are each accelerated from rest through the same potential difference. Find $\lambda_{p}/\lambda_{\alpha}$.
1 $\lambda=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{(9.11\times10^{-31})(1.0\times10^{6})}=7.27\times10^{-10}\ \mathrm{m}=727\ \mathrm{pm}$.
2 $\lambda=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{1500\times20}=2.2\times10^{-38}\ \mathrm{m}$ — some $10^{23}$ times smaller than a nucleus; no slit or obstacle is anywhere near that size, so no diffraction can be seen.
3 $v=\dfrac{h}{m_{e}\lambda}=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{(9.11\times10^{-31})(0.50\times10^{-9})}=1.5\times10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$.
4 $\lambda=\dfrac{1.226}{\sqrt{600}}\ \mathrm{nm}=0.0501\ \mathrm{nm}=50.1\ \mathrm{pm}$.
5 $K=\dfrac{h^{2}}{2m_{e}\lambda^{2}}=\dfrac{(6.626\times10^{-34})^{2}}{2(9.11\times10^{-31})(1.0\times10^{-9})^{2}}=2.41\times10^{-19}\ \mathrm{J}=1.50\ \mathrm{eV}$.
6 At equal $K$, $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt{m}$: $\dfrac{\lambda_{p}}{\lambda_{e}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{m_{e}}{m_{p}}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{9.11\times10^{-31}}{1.673\times10^{-27}}}=0.0233$ (about $1:43$).
7 At equal $v$, $\lambda\propto1/m$: $\dfrac{\lambda_{e}}{\lambda_{p}}=\dfrac{m_{p}}{m_{e}}=1836$.
8 $\lambda\propto1/\sqrt{K}$: it becomes $\tfrac13$ of its former value.
9 $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mqV}}$, so $\dfrac{\lambda_{p}}{\lambda_{\alpha}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{m_{\alpha}q_{\alpha}}{m_{p}q_{p}}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{6.64\times10^{-27}\times2}{1.673\times10^{-27}}}=\sqrt{7.94}=2.82$ (close to $2\sqrt2$, taking $m_{\alpha}\approx4m_{p}$).
II
Matter waves in Bohr orbits and the uncertainty principle.
  • 1 How many de Broglie wavelengths fit round the fifth Bohr orbit of a hydrogen-like atom? Does the answer depend on $Z$?
  • 2 Find the de Broglie wavelength, in pm, of the electron in the $n=2$ orbit of hydrogen.
  • 3 Find the de Broglie wavelength of the electron in the $n=1$ orbit of $\mathrm{He^{+}}$.
  • 4 Find the minimum uncertainty in the speed of an electron confined within $1.0\ \mathrm{nm}$.
  • 5 The speed of a $0.15\ \mathrm{kg}$ ball is known to within $0.10\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$. Find the least uncertainty in its position.
  • 6 A proton is confined to a region $1.0\times10^{-14}\ \mathrm{m}$ across (about the size of a nucleus). Find the minimum uncertainty in its speed.
  • 7 Explain, using the uncertainty principle, why the idea of an electron moving in a definite orbit of fixed radius has to be abandoned.
  • 8 An electron and a proton are each located to within the same $\Delta x$. Find the ratio $\Delta v_{e}/\Delta v_{p}$ of their minimum velocity uncertainties.
1 Five: $2\pi r/\lambda=n$ for every Bohr orbit, independent of $Z$.
2 $\lambda_{n}=332\,n/Z\ \mathrm{pm}$: $\lambda=665\ \mathrm{pm}$ (from $2\pi r_{2}/2=2\pi(211.6)/2$).
3 $\lambda=332\times\tfrac12=166\ \mathrm{pm}$ (the orbit is $26.5\ \mathrm{pm}$ in radius and holds one wave).
4 $\Delta v=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{4\pi(9.11\times10^{-31})(1.0\times10^{-9})}=5.79\times10^{4}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$.
5 $\Delta x=\dfrac{h}{4\pi m\Delta v}=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{4\pi(0.15)(0.10)}=3.5\times10^{-33}\ \mathrm{m}$ — immeasurably small.
6 $\Delta v=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{4\pi(1.673\times10^{-27})(1.0\times10^{-14})}=3.15\times10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ — about 1 % of $c$, so protons in nuclei move fast.
7 A definite orbit means knowing the radius (position) exactly and the velocity exactly at each instant. For an electron confined to atomic size, $\Delta x\sim10^{-10}\ \mathrm{m}$ forces $\Delta v\sim10^{5}$–$10^{6}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$, comparable to the speed itself, so neither the path nor the speed can be sharp. Only probabilities can be given.
8 $\Delta v=h/4\pi m\Delta x\propto1/m$: $\dfrac{\Delta v_{e}}{\Delta v_{p}}=\dfrac{m_{p}}{m_{e}}=1836$.
III
The quantum-mechanical model and the 1s and 2s wave functions (use Result 2.11).
  • 1 Give two differences between a Bohr orbit and an atomic orbital.
  • 2 Find the probability of finding the electron of a hydrogen atom (1s) in a tiny volume of $1.0\ \mathrm{pm^{3}}$ at the nucleus. (Treat $\psi$ as constant over this volume.)
  • 3 For hydrogen 1s, find the ratio $\psi^{2}(r=a_{0})/\psi^{2}(r=0)$.
  • 4 For hydrogen 1s, at what distance from the nucleus has $\psi^{2}$ fallen to 1.0 % of its value at the nucleus?
  • 5 Why can $\psi$ not itself be the probability of finding the electron, while $\psi^{2}$ can?
  • 6 According to the quantum-mechanical model, on which quantum number(s) does the energy of an electron depend (a) in a hydrogen atom, (b) in a many-electron atom?
  • 7 For hydrogen, find the ratio $\psi^{2}_{2s}(0)/\psi^{2}_{1s}(0)$ of the probability densities at the nucleus.
  • 8 Find the ratio of $\psi^{2}_{1s}$ at the nucleus for $\mathrm{He^{+}}$ to that for $\mathrm{H}$. What does it say about the size of the $\mathrm{He^{+}}$ ion?
1 Any two of: an orbit is a definite flat path, an orbital a three-dimensional probability region; an orbit gives exact position and velocity, which the uncertainty principle forbids; an orbit's quantisation is assumed, an orbital's comes from the Schrödinger equation; each $n$ has one orbit but $n^{2}$ orbitals.
2 $P=\psi^{2}(0)\,\delta V=\dfrac{1}{\pi a_{0}^{3}}\,\delta V=\dfrac{1.0}{\pi(52.9)^{3}}=2.15\times10^{-6}$ (with $a_{0}$ in pm and $\delta V$ in $\mathrm{pm^{3}}$).
3 $\psi^{2}\propto e^{-2r/a_{0}}$: ratio $=e^{-2}=0.135$.
4 $e^{-2r/a_{0}}=0.010$: $r=\dfrac{a_{0}\ln100}{2}=2.303\,a_{0}=122\ \mathrm{pm}$.
5 $\psi$ can be negative (e.g. 2s beyond its node), and a probability cannot. $\psi^{2}$ is never negative, and its total over all space is 1.
6 (a) $n$ only — e.g. 2s and 2p have the same energy. (b) $n$ and $l$.
7 $\psi_{2s}(0)=\dfrac{2}{4\sqrt{2\pi}}\left(\dfrac{1}{a_{0}}\right)^{3/2}$, so $\psi^{2}_{2s}(0)=\dfrac{1}{8\pi a_{0}^{3}}$; $\psi^{2}_{1s}(0)=\dfrac{1}{\pi a_{0}^{3}}$. Ratio $=\tfrac18=0.125$.
8 $\psi^{2}(0)\propto Z^{3}$: ratio $=8$. The $\mathrm{He^{+}}$ cloud is pulled in to half the size, so the same probability is packed into one-eighth of the volume.
IV
Radial nodes and harder problems.
  • 1 Locate the radial node of the 2s orbital of $\mathrm{He^{+}}$.
  • 2 How many radial nodes does the 4s orbital have? How many spherical surfaces of zero electron density does it contain?
  • 3 Using the 3s wave function of Example 6, find both radial nodes of the 3s orbital of $\mathrm{Li^{2+}}$.
  • 4 A hypothetical s-type wave function of a hydrogen atom is $\psi=k\left(\sigma^{2}-8\sigma+12\right)e^{-\sigma/2}$ with $\sigma=r/a_{0}$. How many radial nodes does it have, and where is the outer one (in pm)?
  • 5 Sketch, without numbers, $\psi_{2s}$ and $\psi^{2}_{2s}$ against $r$, marking the node, and state how the sketches change for $\mathrm{He^{+}}$.
  • 6 At what distance from the nucleus (in pm) is $\psi_{2s}$ of hydrogen most negative? (Differentiate $(2-\sigma)e^{-\sigma/2}$.)
  • 7 (Application) An electron microscope accelerates electrons from rest through $50\ \mathrm{kV}$. Using the non-relativistic formula, estimate their de Broglie wavelength in pm, and compare it with the wavelength of green light ($500\ \mathrm{nm}$).
1 $r=\dfrac{2a_{0}}{Z}=\dfrac{2(52.9)}{2}=52.9\ \mathrm{pm}$.
2 $n-1=3$ radial nodes, i.e. three concentric spheres on which $\psi=0$.
3 $\sigma=1.902$ and $7.098$ as before, now with $r=\sigma a_{0}/3$: $r=33.5\ \mathrm{pm}$ and $125\ \mathrm{pm}$.
4 $\sigma^{2}-8\sigma+12=(\sigma-2)(\sigma-6)=0$: two radial nodes, at $\sigma=2$ and $6$, i.e. $106\ \mathrm{pm}$ and $317\ \mathrm{pm}$. (Two radial nodes in an s function make it "3s-like".)
5 $\psi_{2s}$: starts positive at $r=0$, falls through zero at $2a_{0}$, dips negative, then creeps back to zero. $\psi^{2}_{2s}$: largest at $r=0$, zero at $2a_{0}$, a small second hump, then zero. For $\mathrm{He^{+}}$ both curves have the same shape squeezed to half the distances, with $\psi^{2}(0)$ eight times larger.
6 $\dfrac{d}{d\sigma}\left[(2-\sigma)e^{-\sigma/2}\right]=e^{-\sigma/2}\left[-1-\tfrac12(2-\sigma)\right]=0$ gives $\sigma=4$: $r=4a_{0}=212\ \mathrm{pm}$.
7 $\lambda=\dfrac{1.226}{\sqrt{50\,000}}\ \mathrm{nm}=5.48\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm{nm}=5.48\ \mathrm{pm}$, about $10^{5}$ times shorter than green light — hence the far finer detail. (At $50\ \mathrm{kV}$ the electrons reach $0.4c$, so the true value is a little shorter, about $5.4\ \mathrm{pm}$.)
🎯 Exam corner JEE Main · MCQJEE Main · Numerical

E1. JEE Main · MCQ A proton and an α-particle are accelerated from rest through the same potential difference. Taking $m_{\alpha}=4m_{p}$, the ratio $\lambda_{p}:\lambda_{\alpha}$ of their de Broglie wavelengths is (A) $1:2\sqrt2$ (B) $2\sqrt2:1$ (C) $2:1$ (D) $1:2$

Idea $K=qV$, so $\lambda=\dfrac{h}{\sqrt{2mqV}}\propto\dfrac{1}{\sqrt{mq}}$.
Ratio $\dfrac{\lambda_{p}}{\lambda_{\alpha}}=\sqrt{\dfrac{m_{\alpha}q_{\alpha}}{m_{p}q_{p}}}=\sqrt{4\times2}=2\sqrt2$.
Answer (B) $2\sqrt2:1$.
⏱ Shortcut (C) forgets the α-particle's double charge; (A) inverts the ratio — the lighter, less charged proton has the longer wave.

E2. JEE Main · Numerical The minimum uncertainty in the velocity of an electron confined within a region $1.0\ \mathrm{nm}$ wide is $x\times10^{4}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$. Using $h=6.626\times10^{-34}\ \mathrm{J\,s}$ and $m_{e}=9.11\times10^{-31}\ \mathrm{kg}$, find $x$. Give the answer to the nearest integer.

Law $\Delta v=\dfrac{h}{4\pi m_{e}\Delta x}$.
Number $\Delta v=\dfrac{6.626\times10^{-34}}{4\pi(9.11\times10^{-31})(1.0\times10^{-9})}=5.79\times10^{4}\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$, so $x=5.79$.
Answer $6$.
⏱ Shortcut $\dfrac{h}{4\pi m_{e}}=5.79\times10^{-5}\ \mathrm{m^{2}\,s^{-1}}$ — remember it and divide by $\Delta x$. Using $h/2\pi$ by mistake gives 12.

E3. JEE Main · MCQ For the 2s orbital of a hydrogen-like ion, which statement is correct? (A) $\psi$ is positive at every distance from the nucleus. (B) $\psi^{2}$ is greatest at the radial node. (C) The number of radial nodes increases with the nuclear charge $Z$. (D) $\psi$ changes sign at $r=2a_{0}/Z$, where $\psi^{2}=0$.

Check each (A) is false: the factor $(2-Zr/a_{0})$ is negative beyond the node. (B) is false: $\psi^{2}=0$ at the node; it is greatest at the nucleus. (C) is false: the number of radial nodes is $n-1=1$ whatever $Z$ is; only the position $2a_{0}/Z$ changes.
(D) $\psi_{2s}\propto(2-Zr/a_{0})$ passes through zero and changes sign at $r=2a_{0}/Z$, so $\psi^{2}=0$ there — a radial node.
Answer (D).

E4. JEE Main · Numerical An electron accelerated from rest through a potential difference of $V$ volts has a de Broglie wavelength of $61.3\ \mathrm{pm}$. Using $\lambda=1.226/\sqrt{V}\ \mathrm{nm}$, find $V$. Give the answer to the nearest integer.

Rearrange $\sqrt{V}=\dfrac{1.226\ \mathrm{nm}}{\lambda}=\dfrac{1.226}{0.0613}=20.0$.
Square $V=20.0^{2}=400\ \mathrm{V}$.
Answer $400$.
⏱ Shortcut Convert the wavelength to nm before dividing ($61.3\ \mathrm{pm}=0.0613\ \mathrm{nm}$); dividing by 61.3 gives a nonsensical $4\times10^{-4}\ \mathrm{V}$.

E5. JEE Main · MCQ The ratio of the de Broglie wavelength of the electron in the second Bohr orbit of hydrogen to that of the electron in the third Bohr orbit of $\mathrm{Li^{2+}}$ is (A) $2:1$ (B) $1:2$ (C) $4:9$ (D) $2:3$

Idea $\lambda_{n}=\dfrac{2\pi r_{n}}{n}$ with $r_{n}\propto\dfrac{n^{2}}{Z}$, so $\lambda_{n}\propto\dfrac{n}{Z}$.
Ratio $\dfrac{2/1}{3/3}=2$.
Answer (A) $2:1$.
⏱ Shortcut (C) is the ratio of $n^{2}$ values (the radii ratio without $Z$); (D) uses $n$ alone. Always carry $Z$.

E6. JEE Main · Numerical The radial node of the 2s orbital of a hydrogen-like ion lies $26.45\ \mathrm{pm}$ from the nucleus. Taking $a_{0}=52.9\ \mathrm{pm}$, find the atomic number $Z$ of the ion. Give the answer to the nearest integer.

Node $\psi_{2s}\propto\left(2-\dfrac{Zr}{a_{0}}\right)$ vanishes at $r=\dfrac{2a_{0}}{Z}$.
Solve $Z=\dfrac{2a_{0}}{r}=\dfrac{2(52.9)}{26.45}=4.00$ — the ion is $\mathrm{Be^{3+}}$.
Answer $4$.
⏱ Shortcut For hydrogen the 2s node is at $2a_{0}=105.8\ \mathrm{pm}$; $105.8/26.45=4$ at once.
🔬 Research–Teaching NexusResearch-tutored · optional, about 45 minutes

Research question. Why can an electron microscope show individual columns of atoms when the best light microscope cannot see anything smaller than about $200\ \mathrm{nm}$ — and how far does the simple formula $\lambda=h/\sqrt{2meV}$ take us before relativity must be added?

Why it matters. Transmission electron microscopes are used worldwide to image viruses and proteins (cryo-electron microscopy won the 2017 Nobel Prize in Chemistry), the defects in steel and battery electrodes, and the layers of computer chips. Their resolving power rests directly on the de Broglie wavelength of the beam.

What to do.

  1. In a spreadsheet, compute $\lambda=h/\sqrt{2m_{e}eV}$ for accelerating voltages of $1$, $10$, $50$, $100$, $200$ and $300\ \mathrm{kV}$.
  2. Find the electron speed from $\tfrac12m_{e}v^{2}=eV$ for each voltage. At which voltage does this "speed" exceed $c$? What does that tell you about the formula?
  3. Repeat with the relativistic momentum $p=\sqrt{2m_{e}eV\left(1+\dfrac{eV}{2m_{e}c^{2}}\right)}$ and tabulate the percentage difference in $\lambda$.
  4. Look up the stated resolution of two commercial electron microscopes and compare with your wavelengths. Why is the resolution much worse than $\lambda$?

Tools: Spreadsheet; manufacturers' or university microscopy-centre web pages for resolutions.

Hand in: Your table (voltage, non-relativistic $\lambda$, relativistic $\lambda$, % difference), a graph of $\lambda$ against $V$ on log scales, and three sentences explaining the gap between wavelength and real resolution.

Going further. Neutron diffraction uses slow ("thermal") neutrons. Estimate the wavelength of a neutron ($1.675\times10^{-27}\ \mathrm{kg}$) moving at $2200\ \mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ and compare it with the spacing of atoms in a crystal. Why are neutrons especially good at locating hydrogen atoms?

Instructor note: non-relativistic values are about $3.88\ \mathrm{pm}$ at $100\ \mathrm{kV}$ and $2.24\ \mathrm{pm}$ at $300\ \mathrm{kV}$; relativistic values are $3.70\ \mathrm{pm}$ and $1.97\ \mathrm{pm}$ (differences of about 5 % and 14 %). The naive speed passes $c$ near $256\ \mathrm{kV}$. Real resolution (about $50$–$100\ \mathrm{pm}$ in aberration-corrected instruments) is limited by lens aberrations, not by $\lambda$. The thermal neutron has $\lambda\approx180\ \mathrm{pm}$.

🧪 Self-check quiz

0/5 correct

Q1. The momentum of a particle is doubled. Its de Broglie wavelength

Q2. Which of the following is a correct statement of the Heisenberg uncertainty principle for a particle of mass $m$?

Q3. The number of radial nodes in a 3s orbital is

Q4. In the quantum-mechanical model, $\psi^{2}$ at a point in an atom represents

Q5. The kinetic energy of an electron is increased four times. Its de Broglie wavelength becomes